[Burichan] [Futaba] [Nice] [Pony]  -  [WT]  [Home] [Manage]
[Catalog View] :: [Archive] :: [Graveyard] :: [Rules] :: [Quests] :: [Wiki]

[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [Last 100 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Name (optional)
Email (optional, will be displayed)
Subject    (optional, usually best left blank)
Message
File []
Embed (advanced)   Help
Password  (for deleting posts, automatically generated)
  • How to format text
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, MP3, MP4, PNG, SWF, WEBM, ZIP
  • Maximum file size allowed is 25600 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.

File 126230746974.png - (11.38KB , 242x318 , Lunardisc.png )
8407 No. 8407 ID: ed376e

Ok, judging by that infodump in the main quest, it seems like you folks could do with an actual discussion thread!

In relation to said infodump, I'd better clarify a few things. For instance, although the quest does take place in the Exalted setting, and you may pick up on one or two extra details or clues through familiarity with said setting, don't be too trusting in what you already know! For example, the possible magical powers available were mentioned. In Lunar Quest, a lot of the elements of the system have been simplified and folded into each other - for example, the array of Excellencies has been reduced to the Boost system. Similarly, Abilities and specialities have been folded together into Competencies, and Saulanna's method of improving herself bears no relation to the xp/training time mumbojumbo that Exalted uses. And it's not just the game system. Our heroine has no idea what year in the setting it is... so, neither do you. It's different, in summary! This quest should be just as fun for people who aren't familiar with Exalted as it is for people who are.

Keep an open mind, hey?
Expand all images
>>
No. 8408 ID: 426169

Seeing as I'm the first to spot this thread, allow me to say: You totally rock.
>>
No. 8410 ID: aecf60

>>318208
Seconding this because it is a verified fact.
>>
No. 8413 ID: 3dfb34

jukashi: add saulanna as a background character in keychain of creation

exaltedfag: go fanboy allover jukashi
>>
No. 8414 ID: 3dfb34

also cant anyone copypaste that crap and place it in the wiki?
>>
No. 8415 ID: 6faa8c

OMGHIYOUAREAWESOME
>>
No. 8420 ID: 697b23

Wait, is Jukashi the guy who does Keychain of Creation?
>>
No. 8423 ID: 51d0f5

I'm quite down with a dramatic simplification of the system, considering how grossly complicated the original is.

"Okay, so do you guys want to use a Perfect on the third attack of the flurry this turn?"
"Argh I can't even remember what we're fighting about."

>>318220
Yeah.
>>
No. 8425 ID: 697b23

>>318223
Holy shit, how could we possibly be that lucky?!
>>
No. 8428 ID: 3dfb34

arr pe gee links us together. let us bathe in the glory of the internets.

>>318223
i want to see more people stunting. the MA setting of exalted was prety awesome in the meaning that it rewards you for being awesome, in a questthread its like ice cream and chicken pie: why HASNT anyone added these two before?

in a completely related news: i fail engrish.
>>
No. 8429 ID: 6faa8c

>>318223
OH GOD I COULD DIE TOMMOROW AND I WOULD BE A HAPPY MAN.
>>
No. 8430 ID: 6faa8c

Also pattern spiders.
>>
No. 8432 ID: 3dfb34

so, soulanna was once a slave, or something that needed to be shackled. she is a smart, cunning person with a crap strenght and somewhat beauty. by the looks she was either a small servant or pimp material. if she could remember her past it would be easy to know what cities to avoid, all along with possible former clients.

i dont remember abyssal lore completely, but if this isnt the time of tumult, then we should be near a army of demons or some crap like it. the possibility of choosing from 5 chastes is however alluring, since a better specialization would be nice anyway.

the wyld hund should be on its peak due to the scarlet empress still being in charge. i sure hope it is the time of tumult, id rather deal with a abyssal soulmate for the lulz that with 5 experienced dragonblooded copying power rangers while hunting us down, possibly with trinkets and relics whose existance we cant even consider due to lolmemoryloss.

i think im gonna read up on spells next. i liked the idea of making a twilight-equivalent lunar.
>>
No. 8433 ID: fb4013

>>318207
Shifting the infodump to this thread:
>>
No. 8434 ID: 5dd961

Well i like exalted, so imma let ya resume the quest but first exalted had the best settings of all time, and so id like to explain it to you.

we kinda started hard mode. first, lunars are exalted due to great deeds done by the need of them, usually costing sweat, blood and tears, when not limbs and children. we are likely a slave that had to punch trhu dragonblooded (common exalted, they win by numbers) and then survive for a few days in this deathland, with a few children already dead, if not all our friends/mates/whatever from where we used to live before being enslaved.

second, this is a deathland. it is so bad that this is the homeland of ghosts and deathknight, the evil equivalent of solar exalted. if we find a deathknight, it most definitively made this land (with the deaths of countless humans) to please its masters, and he can most likely eat/kill/tame/fuck us all in one. in this land they can recover "motes" (DM called it MP or moon points, but there are 5 types of motes, all wich empower different types of machines/magical stuff). outside of it, they recover by peforming generic evil stuff as we would gain by "stunting" in the name of luna.

third, a lunar exalt excels in physical deeds. while it may be bad to have so much inteligence related powers, luna spellcasters are some of the most dreadful casters in exalted because fo their resilience. we will soon have weird charms like a charm that lets you run faster that what you are chasing, and another that lets you run faster that what is chasing YOU. even the most modest of lunar exalted can undergo trainning much like the werewolves in WoD, wich will give us a mentor to other charms/skills and a snazzy glowing tatto that prevents disfigurement when we change shape in the wyld (a place even more inhospitable that deathlands, more on it later)

lunars are also shapeshifters. we can change to pure raccoon right now (so no furfaggotry), and if we partake in huntings, we can adquire other shapes, by consuming the heart of what we chase. but until we get the tatoos of moonsilver we have the risk of getting "xomified" with bad mutations all over us. this also affects ou minds, so we are likely to go insane. in game terms, we have a limit (wich is a curse from the deathknight's lord) that literally makes us snap and lose control, adquiring a mutation lower the requirement to have a limit break. we can also change shape to other people.
>>
No. 8435 ID: 5dd961

lunars are made to be a pair with solar exalted. some fo them have a natural link to their mate when they exalt, meaning you magically knows where the other one is. the bad news is that some solars have fallen to ebil hands, and are now abysmal exalted, or deathknights. its like emo goth vampires, but 300% more badass. expect tsundere/yandere love if our mate is abysmal.

if this is the time of tumult, we have 3 choices: full moon, no moon and changing moon. full moon are warriors, no moon are spies and the likes, changing moon is a amalgama of 3 types. lunar exalted had to hide in the wyld, wich corrupted their exaltation, rougthly changing moon favors 3 types, social battle, magic and crafting. we will get a definitive type later on with the tatoos, but until then we are directed by the moon type, so we are warriors now.

my suggestion is we go for changing moon. we can craft like hell with these status (we can make incredible stuff like power armor starcraft style, huge guns wich we do have how to yield, and other uncredible trinkets like mind control collars, weapons that can change themselves, etc), the spellcasting should come easy and we already got boobs so that 50% of all social battles won.

another thing. we already have enemies and friends on our tail. the wyld hunt was specialized in hunting lunar exaltations with their dragonblooded for over 1k years, least we get backup we are very dead. any close lunar tribe also realized our exaltation and so will come to hunt us down. in short words, they will force us to be tatooed, and to take a position with them regarding the current situation. the tatoos are good (and some tatoo crafters can make them with extra stuff), but they may be chauvinistic commies that will requires us to work for them, wich isnt always good.
>>
No. 8436 ID: 5dd961

lastly, the wyld is a place of quantum faggotry and cthlutu-style creatures. anything there is eventually xomified, also corrupting its mind and soul.

lunars had to hide there because dragonblooded rioted against their now cursed exalted masters (pehaps rightfully, pehaps not). they succeeded with the lunars retreat to the wyld, all solars where killed and had their exaltation captured but they didnt knew how to keep what the exalted made, so everything falled apart quickly.

then some sideral exalted (the most abstract of all exalted) coached them in weird martial arts, so they may tame gods (yeah, you herd it right, taming GODS) to keep what was left of all solar stuff. wich is like less that 10% of what was made. did i mention they where also cursed? noone rememeber you if you exalted as a sideral. only some essesce 2 beings (literally, anything inhuman) are able to retain memories of them, and that if the sideral so wants to. siderals craft and alter FATES, are able to punch LANGUAGES and trhow WORDS. we will likely face a few of them, but they are glass cannons style and we may just have resistance to them if we get the tatoos.

solars and abyssal excel in specific crafts (some of the best magical items comes from them, any specific task has a charm to peform it better that any other exalted), dragonblooded are natural generals, leading/trainning armies when possible. siderals are logistic support (tho its questionable, they have been failing since ever). lunars used to pair with solars, so they had generic buffs. while a solar may, for example, have a charm to give orders, a lunar would have a charm to magnify persuasion, thus allowing more versatility.

i dont play as a lunar, so i know very little of them ._. i still have all books on them, so if anyone wants a discussion, just make a trhead and let me know
>>
No. 8437 ID: 8b7db1

>>318234
>Well i like exalted, so imma let ya resume the quest but first exalted had the best settings of all time, and so id like to explain it to you.

...was anyone else channeling Kayne West here?
>>
No. 8438 ID: 108e41

>>318234
>>318235
>>318236
Shouldn't this be in /questdis/?

>>318237
Me too.
>>
No. 8439 ID: e75a2f

>>318237
That was the 'joke'
>>
No. 8443 ID: 445c48

>>318232
Saulanna could also have been a criminal.
>>
No. 8451 ID: bf8e75

>>318243
a con artist pehaps, but with nearly no dexterity, thats unlikely.
>>
No. 8452 ID: bf8e75
File 126236750517.png - (31.25KB , 700x700 , saulanon.png )
8452

to boot:
skills
basic natural attack (claws, im assuming biting too)
basic woodwork (is this craft (wood)?)


charms:
BEAST SENSE
MOON CLAWS
FLOWING DEFENSE
WAR FORM
>>
No. 8520 ID: c0f3bf

...Does "unfixed" mean she's not sterile, or...?
>>
No. 8522 ID: ad8569

>>318320
i loled.

lunars need to have their chaste fixed. this is done with the tatooing process, and until then we are vulnerable to the effects of the wyld, along with xomification when we change shape.
>>
No. 8523 ID: 426169

Awww, but it was so much funnier the other way.
>>
No. 8524 ID: 51d0f5

You know, if we get up to permanent limit 5 before getting tattooed, we get bonuses of being a chimera without being 100% crazy. :3c
>>
No. 8525 ID: ad8569

>>318324
we just snap faster that normal!

no. we have too much into mind to risk more limit breaks that the usual.

if we could go for full moon that surely would be a good strategy.
>>
No. 8526 ID: af3e6d

>>318322
>chaste fixed
That typo makes it even funnier in the context of the prior post.
>>
No. 8569 ID: 6419d1

without going into spoilers, the dragon that soulanna found is the ebon dragon. he has some deathknights on his command and they favor eldrad-styled dickery and backstabbing.

so we do NOT greet statues of deathlords that can twist our soul with a few glares.
>>
No. 8571 ID: aecea2

>>318369

The Ebon Dragon is a Yozi, he has nothing to do with deathknights. You're thinking of infernals.
>>
No. 8573 ID: 119b5c

I don't know any of this. Steal the Gem.

Shenanigans now.
>>
No. 8594 ID: 0a59ea

>>318373
the hearthstone doesnt seem to be there, actualy. we may be able to salvage something if we destroy the manse.

>>318371
im almost sure you should have spoilered.
>>
No. 8595 ID: 488063

>>318371
THE EBON NEVERBORN
INFERNABYSSAL SCOURGE

(Yes, I'm familiar with Exalted fluff. I just think this is funnier.)
>>
No. 8638 ID: f21281
File 126275418982.jpg - (87.99KB , 700x700 , saulanna64.jpg )
8638

>>
No. 8675 ID: 4f8e95

manses are naturally hard to destroy, even harder to make and relatively easy to defend. this one is exposed, has no guard and what looks like no traps near it, sure looking like a easy job.

some solar exalted made their manse with stuff that defies the crafties of the dorfs. we wont just break it with explosives, we need magical gurl powa to destroy it. this manse should have magic defending it, meaning a lot of hability to sulk damage.

some of the greatest exalted weapons could literally suck a manse dry, either by using it or by actualy eating it.

if we manage to find a truly wondrous weapon we may damage it. a grand daiklaive is too much for us to use, that leave us with very few choices, a bonestrider would likely dry us before damaging it, a energy cannon could be nice, but in a emoland, 2or 3 shots wot do it.
>>
No. 9108 ID: 04eff9

Hey guys! Just wanted to apologize a tad for leaving this as sporadic as I have, I've had some stuff to do. Maybe I could pay you back a bit by explaining the combat rules, since I didn't get Luna to explain when Saulanna was actually in combat?

Basically: highest INTUITION goes first, attacks are made using AGILITY plus applicable attack competencies, compare that to target's Agility plus relevant defense competencies. Equal or higher hits, so for example the zomby goast and Saulanna both had Agility of 2; Saulanna got a bonus of 1 to dodging from her BEAST SENSES but the goast himself had a bonus for his MINDLESS RAGE, and they cancel out.

So the goast then had Might 3 plus no bonus from his accuracy. Because she is Exalted, though, Saulanna can subtract her Toughness from that number (an ordinary mortal could take half their toughness from it). So because the zomby goast's claws add no damage (just make it "bleeding" damage) she just takes 1 point of health loss (and she doesn't bleed any extra, again for being Exalted). Health points are equal to twice a character's Toughness.

When she took her warform, then, things changed: her Agility increased, so the goast couldn't hit her. She was able to get him though, with a leftover bonus of 1, added to her new Might of 4 plus 1 extra damage from MOON CLAWS minus half the goast's Toughness (3) rounded up since it's a supernatural creature. Or 4 damage.

Simple enough?

The skill numbers used in combat can be enhanced by being cool, using magic or other bonuses such as EMOTIONS, just like everything else.
>>
No. 9109 ID: fd430c

>>318908
>>318908
i was going to comment, but then i got too exited so i stfu'd.

i suppose we will need to alter the character sheet to show numbers :3
>>
No. 9110 ID: 51d0f5

>Simple enough?
Compared to canon exalted, shit yeah.
>>
No. 9754 ID: 57aa53

>>318910
as a update, we got:

INTERMEDIATE MANSE MAKING SKILLS
BASIC KNOWLEDGE ON METAPHYSICS

one is like MAGICAL PLUMBING wich includes wormholes to teleport magic points to us, the other one is how magic behaves, wich includes cool stuff like GAIA is the source of all MAGIC, and she has a lezbo relationship with LUNA (not kidding).

we also have a sidequest! a FREAKING DEMON is in our head, he has been begging for us to let him be, but the truth is, he is smalltime against any exalted.

demons need a considerate amount of skill and strength to possess completely any exalt of any type. this leads to interesting possibilities for saulanna:

-attempting to tame the demons while he is still weak. he MAY have the charm to posses a exalted, if this is true we need to vanquish him before he recovers.
-milk him for information before dismissing him with a call to luna
-attempt to gain the taming charms/spells SOMEHOW (we may already have them, cursed memory loss) and tame him properly. this taming is quite perfect thanks to exaltation and can yield good results long term.
-attempt to join HOT GOAST DUDE and DEMONS to make a being strong enougth to pass the barrier at day.
>>
No. 9763 ID: 30257e

>>319554

Translation: You now have some Occult, with a little understanding of the Art of Geomancy.

In future, though, a lot of competencies won't relate well to the Abilities in Exalted.
>>
No. 10585 ID: 2eac65
File 12660207941.png - (105.51KB , 911x1132 , koc0269.png )
10585

Noticed the cameo in today's comic.

We love you too, Jukashi.
>>
No. 10610 ID: 445c48

>>320385
WAIT SHIT I DIDN'T SEE THAT
>>
No. 12359 ID: 89ff2a

>BEST SENSES

Gord dormit. Gonna have to lay off the booze.
>>
No. 12360 ID: 3b6c92

>>322159
It happens.

Although "BEST SENSES" sound awesome.
>>
No. 12361 ID: 2eac65

Beast senses are the best senses.
>>
No. 12373 ID: f52552

>>322160
I keep reading it Breast Senses.
>>
No. 12379 ID: 1ac39d

let's try playing the music box in front of the manse. those notes seem to make it seem like that will do something.
>>
No. 12460 ID: 3b7755

>>322179
not with 3 possible enemies outside. what if they want the music box that is with HOT GOAST DUDE in the outsi...

god dammit.
>>
No. 15409 ID: 0fc814
File 127347327950.jpg - (36.01KB , 338x450 , barackface.jpg )
15409

>>/quest/175748
>No! Why did we do that? We can't just go around dismembering people!
>>
No. 15410 ID: 1ac39d

>>325209
OHHHHH BURRRRRRRN!!!
>>
No. 15415 ID: 4eb774

we could most likely troll them into giving us the box, but i go for the violent approach on this one.

they kinda knew that we are exalted and how fucking powerful a exalt can be, but then they would live, and that means backup to properly face a exalted.
>>
No. 15770 ID: 2eac65

I want to say I like this quest, but it's hard to get into when the updates are days or weeks apart. It's kind of irritatiing to know that the results of any choice we make won't show up for a week.

While we're waiting between ticks of the clock, what are Saulanaa's long-term goals going to be? It looks like the popular ones so far are "become Luna's consort" and "protect the innocent". I'd personally like to add "explore and learn about the world" to that, since that's one of my favorite things about questing. What are your thoughts?
>>
No. 15774 ID: 700b85

>>325570
Honest discussion of likable quests = doomed effort on this board.

Probably needs moar dongs.
>>
No. 15775 ID: 2eac65

>>325574
Right. We can file that under "long-term plans for Saulanna".

Plan #4: Get More Dongs. It shouldn't be too difficult, since we're an Exalted shapeshifter.
>>
No. 15787 ID: 0fc814

>>325574
>Honest discussion of likable quests = doomed effort on this board.
All it takes is for more people to post their thoughts about it.

After thinking it over, I'm down with letting the mysterious demon thing mess with our minds a little. It's demonstrated that it can teach us things, and we desperately need more skills and information.

We can worry about throwing off its control later, if it proves to be evil.
>>
No. 15801 ID: 2eac65

>>325587
>We can worry about throwing off its control later, if it proves to be evil.
Not if it eats our brain and drives us around like a mechanical doll. This is the sort of thing you want to prevent before it has a chance to happen. Our lack of knowledge is a problem, yes, but it's also the very reason we can't trust people easily, especially with something like that. Shortcuts to power are how evil tempts the unwary.
>>
No. 15802 ID: 0fc814

>>325601
>Not if it eats our brain and drives us around like a mechanical doll.
Saulanna's a Lunar. It'll grow back.
>>
No. 15810 ID: 2eac65

>>325602
You are drastically overestimating the potency of an Exalted, especially a fresh one. We're powerful, but we're still basically human* and we should remember that. Without Charms, our physical attributes are barely above average; our primary advantage is our mind, and if we don't put it to use, we'll be at the mercy of any powerful force who doesn't feel like giving their competition time to grow.

*Apart from the raccoon bits, and they can't regrow brains either.
>>
No. 15827 ID: 0fc814

1) By the time it actually manages to pull stuff like that, we'll have a training montage or two under our belt.

2) Jumping out of a burning building and hoping to catch the fire escape across the alley beats waiting for the best solution to come along.

3) Do we ALWAYS have to pick the very safest, most cautious option worth the most paragon points? I was as hostile as anyone when we first found out this thing was opposed to the Incarna, but I think it'd be cool and interesting if we gave it a chance.
>>
No. 15828 ID: 6d381d

well yeah, to start we should stunt but noone is even trying to do that. then we have to remember that saulanna is not a good warrior, but a thinkerer. im hoping we can get some magic going because the only solid thing i remember of lunar mages is that they "rock really hard"

then we are so effing affraid of trying something that its just not even beginning to work. we shouldnt have JUST kicked its butt, we should have made a speech about how much is missing of us, how we need to protect the music box because its the only HALF lead we have to what we could had BEEN, and what we actualy are in a wondefully horrible world that literally shitted us on a deathland demmanding closure, a deed that no experienced exalted would pull on his own.

i have seen wonders of the first age. the little that there is on lunar is top tier stuff. you guys wanna go all WARSTRIDER/WARHAWK FUCK YEAH? we need that manse turned to serve us.
>>
No. 15829 ID: 1ac39d

>>325628
then why don't you write up the epic speech next time?
>>
No. 15839 ID: 6d381d

>>325629
yeah im trying.

i felt like a ass when i wrote that reply ._.
>>
No. 15840 ID: 2eac65

Epic speeches are for epic moments. Nothing particularly epic has happened to us so far.
>>
No. 15841 ID: 6d381d

um.

we used to be a slave/servant exalted by luna, escaped to a land that requires the death of thousands to be made, found a HOT GOAST DUDE that we are trying to help for god knows what reason, to find a MENANCING MANSE near HOT GOAST DUDE's girlfriend house with a POSSESSED BOOKWORM that is problaby a demon that may or may not dick with un in our own mind, to find out that there is indeed a organization around (problaby led by a experienced DEATHKNIGHT or worse) that may just be looking for us, but are after the only exalted masterpiece we found. then we got possessed and DEMONIC BOOKWORM seems to be willing to help.

you know, this sounds like something coop would say before accidentaly destroying new jersey again.
>>
No. 15844 ID: 1ac39d

>>325641
by pushing all three "DO NOT PUSH" buttons at the same time.
>>
No. 15848 ID: 620bfb

>>325641
Man, now you're making me want MegasQuest.
>>
No. 15853 ID: 2eac65

>>325641
That's pretty average by Exalted standards. "Epic" would be something like conquering a city or meeting our father who we haven't seen in 50 years.

>>325644
And that's why the Solars were dethroned.
>>
No. 15855 ID: 1ac39d

>>325653
yeah, but in Megas using all three together somehow ends up saving the day without blowing up anything good because the downsides cancel out or something.
>>
No. 15861 ID: 620bfb

>>325655
No, it ends up saving the day by causing slightly more damage to the enemy than to the city. Which is a lot.
>>
No. 15865 ID: 6d381d

>>325653
thats actualy not completely accurate.

solars got over their heads up to the point of not caring to their work. they turned agaisnt their people when it suited their wills, stole what they believed that was rightfully theirs, etc, because of the curse that acted like a ultimate personality restriction breaker. i think that a coop solar would be dawn caste with the limit of lazing off instead of blowing everything, because he does not need a reason to blow up new jersey, nor to care to its safety.

what you described sounds like something a abyssal would do anyway.

>>325661
its called "wasteland war". you destroy not only the enemy but also what he may hope to gain from waging war against you.
>>
No. 16000 ID: 1ac39d

GOD DAMMIT GUYS! are we going to kill the guy or not? we need to decide NOW or else salunna will be too paralyzed to take her body back and the book worm will take it.
>>
No. 16001 ID: 1ac39d

>>325800
oops, too late. everyone decide what her personality is now so we don't have that happen again, when we are united she get's more powerful when we bicker she gets confused.
>>
No. 16003 ID: 8bdb6a

ENEMY DEFEATED
TWO UNITS OF MOON ENERGY ACQUIRED
PLOT AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION ACQUIRED

Plus the demon looks like Mew Cai. How can we distrust a face like that?
>>
No. 16009 ID: 2eac65

We will help those who are in need of help, and protect the innocent from those who would hurt and oppress them. We will do what is necessary to stop evildoers, but we will not act merely out of anger or revenge. We will not allow others to come to harm without a good reason.
>>
No. 16013 ID: 1ac39d

>>325809
if death is what is necessary would you condone it? need to figure out the breaking points.
>>
No. 16014 ID: 2eac65

>>325813
It's a matter of necessity. If we can stop evildoers without killing them, we should.
>>
No. 16015 ID: 1ac39d

>>325814
yes i understand that i'm saying that the ONLY way to stop them is death. they cannot be reasoned with and all non-lethal blows are shrugged off.

and who is to say non-lethal would even work? we take a guy down and the next day he comes back with a bunch of dudes, we take all of them down and a week later they have even more dudes with the first guy leading them. we can ether pray they never get enough dudes to over-power us or we can take them out.
>>
No. 16021 ID: b1c12c

>>325803
yeah i mean, so what if he eats souls for fun and kicks. i wonder what he would do once he fiigures out the exaltations were made out of souls.

>>325813
ideally: death is always unecessary. the boss thug could maybe have been turned into a ally, so he could literally fight in our side.

i really have to get my exalted reading going on. i did not realized neither the undead nor the demon could do all of that.
>>
No. 16025 ID: 1ac39d

>>325821
and if the boss thug didn't want to be our ally? let's say the moment we let go he runs off to HIS boss and tells him where we are and then we are swarmed with a small army of ghosts, whos fault is it? ours, for not being extreme enough. just because you want to play nice doesn't mean you can.

i say salunna should be overall nice but if someone outright attacks us, an ally, or gets in the way of our mission they get a full force no mercy kill. you can be kind AND ruthless at the same time, you just need to prioritize.
>>
No. 16026 ID: 2eac65

>>325803
>Plus the demon looks like Mew Cai. How can we distrust a face like that?
1: It doesn't really have a face.
2: It eats people's souls and minds. If we trust it, we might end up an Akuma or worse.

>>325821
Probably not an ally, but with some careful bluffing and manipulation, we might have convinced him that he'd be cursed if he told anyone about us. We don't actually have an ability like that, but he didn't know that.

>i really have to get my exalted reading going on. i did not realized neither the undead nor the demon could do all of that.
This isn't going to work exactly like Exalted. We don't even know how much of the backstory is the same.
>>
No. 16027 ID: 1ac39d

also, Jukashi, only one person wanted her to stop the demon while everyone else was cheering her on, unless length of post increases it's decision power he was clearly out-voted for the response.
>>
No. 16034 ID: 2eac65

>>325827
It probably has more to do with how Saulanna feels.

Our mistake was letting the serpent take control of the situation. We should have made it clear that it wasn't allowed to eat anyone's minds without our permission.

Saulanna's other problem is that she was conflicted about caring for someone she hated. We should help people based on what they need, not whether they like them. The sooner Saulanna understands and accepts this, the better.

Whatever we plan for the future, it's best to hold ourselves to a high standard now. It's much easier for a formerly good person to just stop caring than for a formerly evil person to live with guilt.
>>
No. 16063 ID: b1c12c

>>325825
i suppose the meaning of "ideally" and "maybe" was lost in its purpose.

"if" all of that where to happen a sample, common death is enougth. havin him eaten by a faceless demondragon bookworm thingie is pretty bad in my scale of badness.

>If we trust it, we might end up an Akuma or worse
exalted used to tame demons for fun. maybe we can get to that.

>>325834
we dont have acess to the whole char file but its a safe bet to say that saulanna has a high-ish "compassion" value.

im not sure how jukashi would interpretate, but if we are not saulanna in its whole but rather the player behind the character, he may use the system to put a stop in the orb's usual shenannigans.

also that was most likely the curse, so we know is on the 3rd impact time of tumult.

this also means its possible to claim shenannigans and force control over saulanna because it fits more her character file we got railroaded.
>>
No. 16066 ID: 8704fc
File 127457864214.jpg - (39.03KB , 407x405 , lunardog.jpg )
16066

Aright, I'm gonna explain this a bit. Get some more tutorial stuff in here.

Saulanna is a blank slate. She doesn't know anything. She has no memories. As a result, she has no morality of her own - it takes years of trial and error and culture and tutelage for a person to develop a sense of right and wrong based on their experiences. So, under most circumstances, Saulanna's choice of what player suggestion to follow will be based off an intellectual choice, i.e. what seems like it would work. Because she has no desires of her own (yet), she'll simply try to accomplish what your "consensus" goal seems to be.

Into this, however, comes her EMOTIONS. Emotions are important because, if you guys successfully pull off an EMOTIONAL APPEAL, she'll get a bonus to her actions, particularly in regards mental influence. This can stack with the bonus from cool and/or imaginative actions.

Now, I'll have an idea in my head of what Saulanna's emotional state is like, based on what she's done, what you've told her to do, and the situation at hand. So, for example, she's most recently been fighting ghosts who threatened a friend of hers, dismembered one guy violently, then got mentally violated. I figured her dominant emotion would be Anger, so when you guys made an Emotional Appeal to that anger, she got a bonus. But then another Emotional Appeal was made - to spare the mobster at least some portion of his punishment. This Appeal resonated with earlier motivations - the desire to help our ghost friend with his problems. Saulanna felt two valid EMOTIONS, but they conflicted and she suffered Emotional Confusion.

Which was not necessarily a bad or a good thing. Saulanna's future development is going to be based on prior choices (or lack thereof) and the fact that she didn't deliberately allow her attacker to be eaten will account for something.

In short, Emotions are a way to get bonuses on actions, bonuses that you may well need, but Saulanna will become trickier to control as she becomes more Emotional. If her Emotions get really high...

Well, we'll see what happens.
>>
No. 16067 ID: 3afd1f

>>325866
Should we be trying to do flashy shit to regenerate Moon Power? Or can we regenerate it simply by doing well?
>>
No. 16072 ID: b1c12c

>>325866
tl;dr best RP gets a bonus!
>>
No. 16108 ID: 1ac39d

only problem is that some people don't like being verbose but they could have some good ideas, while someone else could write a few paragraphs of a stupid idea and the stupid one would win because it's longer.
>>
No. 16114 ID: ed8496

>>325908

More clarification: verbosity does not affect what Saulanna thinks is a good idea (i.e. what suggestion I pick). If it's a stupid idea it won't get chosen, because she's got good intelligence herself. It's usually only if you make an emotional appeal, while her Emotions are high, that she can be persuaded to do something stupid; in exactly the way that real people can be made to be idiots by their emotions.

Of course, she might also do something because it's cooler than a smarter but boring option. That's what Luna wants! But amount of words has nothing to do with it. Being creative and imaginative does, but that's not the same thing as a flood of prose.

In fact, if you wrote a "few paragraphs", I might be less likely to choose it because it'd probably be more work to follow up on. Also tl;dr might come into effect.
>>
No. 16123 ID: 1ac39d

>>325914
okay cool.

a nice thing to get would be the ability to store things in Elsewhere, then we can stop worrying about the music box getting jacked.
>>
No. 16403 ID: 2eac65

You okay, Jukashi?
>>
No. 16419 ID: 15f93c

>>326203

He probably is. He does a webcomic as well (called Keychain of Creation), and presumably has an active well-adjusted social life (for a webcomic artist, I mean), so Lunar Quest moves a bit slowly.
>>
No. 16424 ID: 2eac65

I know, I just get worried when I don't hear from people in a while.
>>
No. 16444 ID: 9fb92c

>an active well-adjusted social life

uh

>(for a webcomic artist, I mean)

Ah, yes. That's what I have.

I'm also gearing up for KoC comic 300, so y'know.
>>
No. 16445 ID: 1ac39d

yeah, just don't do any '300' jokes. if i see a spartan i will rage,
>>
No. 16447 ID: 5a2e05

>>326245
Nah, it'll be subtle. The 300th comic will be simple and restricted. Simple characters, simple backgrounds, simple colors. No more than the bare minimum. Just a few lines on a page.

You could say the layout would be quite...

Spartan.
>>
No. 16448 ID: 2eac65

>>326244
Oh, hey, you're back! It's nice to know you're not in any trouble.
>>
No. 16453 ID: d4872d

>>326247
inb4 300 speech bubbles
>>
No. 17751 ID: 2eac65
File 127664192967.jpg - (581.63KB , 1048x828 , Sun and Moon.jpg )
17751

It's been two weeks and now I'm worried again.

Will these cute animals help?
>>
No. 17754 ID: 8bdb6a

>>327551
Well, Jukashi did post a bunch of Lantern Corps pics in the fanart thread somewhat recently. It's not like he disappeared.
>>
No. 17763 ID: 2eac65

>>327554
Yeah, you're right. Maybe I'm just making excuses to be greedy. Or maybe not. Either way, I hope he likes the puppies.
>>
No. 17768 ID: 8bdb6a

I, too, want Lunar Quest to continue. It's very interesting, and I like the writing style, but it's just so darned slow...
>>
No. 17808 ID: d6cb21

What I want to know is if the comic and quest take place in the same universe......
>>
No. 17810 ID: 2eac65

Well, that was quite a lot to handle. The puppies must have worked.

>>327608
We'll see. We've still got a lot of information to gather.
>>
No. 17838 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/194957
>Aww yeah, we totally found the morality system.
Potentially, yes. We don't know what 'titan's will' means. It could be that the more we use our mysterious friend, the more connected we are with the Yozis/Primordials, which are the closest thing to titans in exalted. Or it could mean something completely different. We don't know.

>Do we go all grimdark by devouring more souls and gaining their power, or do we moralfag and struggle to succeed without all the abilities we could get?
>grimdark ... moralfag
Without being rude, I can't take anyone seriously when they say 'moralfag.' At all.
>>
No. 17848 ID: d41f2b

>>327638
moralfaggotry asides, we are the heroes. heroes dont eat souls. they recycle them!

also we lost our shackles!

and i think titan's will is a knack! i dont know from where =c
>>
No. 17849 ID: 8bdb6a

>also we lost our shackles!
Yeah. That was VERY cool.

If only we could find out whether the souls were going to lethe. Killing people is to be avoided either way, unless they've got it coming.

According to the 'accepted' morality of exalted, (as I understand it) ghosts are an aberration in the natural order of things, so sending them back into the reincarnation cycle is okay. Whether you agree or not is a personal value judgement.
>>
No. 17850 ID: f95872

>>327638
>Without being rude, I can't take anyone seriously when they say 'moralfag.' At all.
/b/ the only place you go that it's used?

>>327648
We aren't heroes, we're an Exalt. We can eat souls if we damn well please.
>>
No. 17851 ID: 620bfb

>>327638
I was never expecting to be taken seriously, which is why I went back and added the word grimdark as well. I just thought it was an amusingly retarded spectrum.
>>
No. 17860 ID: 65afa8

>>327650
not quite. abyssals do what they "damm as well please", infernals are psychotic engine of destruction, siderals are coach and managers with alchemicas acting like public servants.

solars are chosen for they have the will to do even better, on that means, they may indeed do whatever they can. anything else is just bad roleplay.

well, except that lunars are specialized in "breeding" and surviving, so we may as well be doing what we "damm as well please" if our captor decide to unite breeding and "surviving".

you are one of those solar players that uses the solar curse as a excuse to do shenanigans. arent you?
>>
No. 17870 ID: 2eac65

It doesn't matter what we're meant to be. We are what we choose to be.
>>
No. 17871 ID: 620bfb

I choose not to decide.
>>
No. 17872 ID: c4c313

>>327660

>> lunars are specialized in "breeding" and surviving

c:
>>
No. 17962 ID: f95872

Okay so basically we are like the whole hinduism thing, we merge with other souls and attain a greater consciousness. This is entirely morally acceptable.
>>
No. 17963 ID: f95872

Also
>>327660
I don't think so. The curse is kind of an always negative thing. I might engage in shenanigans with other justifications though, depending on what you might call "shenanigans".
>>
No. 17968 ID: aeade0

once we get enough will could we change physics? can only imagine how hard the siderealx would freak out. 1+1 suddenly equaling fish would probably fuck all plans up.
>>
No. 17969 ID: 2eac65
File 127692493657.jpg - (100.00KB , 484x468 , Four Suns.jpg )
17969

We've got four daily updates in a row! That's a lot! Please accept these four puppies as tokens of gratitude.
>>
No. 17970 ID: 732129

>>327769
Those aren't puppies. Those are dinner.
>>
No. 17972 ID: 2eac65

>>327770
You want to eat the sun? My, you're an ambitious one! That's the sort of spirit the Exalted have!

I think you'll find it quite a bit harder than you expect, though.
>>
No. 17973 ID: 9b64a5

>>327763
yus, the curse is always a bad thing. but you are not always under the effect of the curse.

its more like every day or so you are drunk and driving, you may get used to it and steer well enought to not crash too many things, or you could get used to being fucked by it and drive to crash just to see how you would get out of the mess.
>>
No. 18071 ID: f95872

>>327773
That's... kind of a bad metaphor. Crashing a car is much more directly bad than than the curse. The curse can often harm you only indirectly. And you can choose not to drink and drive.
>>
No. 18186 ID: 604703

FUCK IM FALLING DOWN ALL THIS EXPOSITION..........
>>
No. 18188 ID: 5a2e05

>>327986
I WARNED YOU ABOUT EXPOSITION BRO!!!!

I TOLD YOU DOG!
>>
No. 18194 ID: 8bdb6a

>>327986
Just be happy you're using a mostly established setting.

Just imagine if you also had to out-and-out explain things like exaltation, incarna, the style of exalted, beastfolk, the world being flat, etc, etc.

On the other hand, I guess those concepts are pretty straightforward.
>>
No. 18202 ID: ff6cf4

>>327994
TOO BAD, HERE IS BAD EXPLANATION FOR YOU.

>>/quest/197346
long story made short:

existance suddenly began. primordials appeared out of nothing, gathering in a place they named creation. they are a bunch of lazy elitist fags so they make these godlings bound to not hurt them while they play a game so great you have a orgasmic seizure just by touching the pieces.

these godlings are awsm, so they kinda want to have fun too. so they looked at humans and saw a way to use them agaisnt the primordials. but alas, they barely manipulate essence, and those that can only suceed after many years, making them old to be a warrior!

then this amazing primordial called autchocon autch-kun machine spirit Autochron showed everyone a exaltation. it was literally a toolkit made of souls that helped a chosen soul to kick butt while chewing bubblegun made out of willpower, magic essence and souls! suddenly he was selling them like water in the desert!

luna and unconquered sun got married 300 exalted each. each divine maiden got 20, totalizing 100 FATE NINJAS and 600 butt-kicking warriors, crafters, diplomats and the most venomous of all, divine lawyers. a era of awesomeness happened as everyone had no restrictions to their power watsoever, charms, motes and souls where exchanged like they where pokemon.

then some dragon discovered they could fuck humans (and airplanes) giving birth to a eartlhy exaltation, the dragonblooded. after everyone got together agaisnt the primordial, a humongous clusterfuck battle happened, many primordials died, many souls got eaten, everyone got cursed but noone noticed it, etc.

and we got where we are. maybe. its definitively after the battle. anyways, right AFTER the battle the godlings went to play the orgasmic seizure game while leaving the exalted to rule themselves while cursed. history repeats itself, the dragonblood with their un-controllable exaltation decides to overtrhow everything and suceeeds, but realizes their exaltations arent fit for research and crafting, the work of the exalted got abandoned or becamed utterly precious to be used. it was darker that dark age, even more so because gods did existed and exalted lawyers kept them on check, and working for creation.

the FATE NINJAS are fuckworried that everything is falling apart and so they decide to teach the dragonblooded a martial art tecnique that can hurt gods. with fear of dying (and possibly meeting the primordials they abandoned) cooperation "happened", but just at the bare minimun to make creation work. civilization didnt quite persisted, even more so because DEATHLORDS EVERYWHERE began killing, maiming and spreadin diseases. only 1/10th of all humans survived. we may be here.

now i didnt explained what happened to the solar and lunar exalted. the solars were either abandoned, betrayed or killed, unliked generally because of the curse. they resided for a long time in a coffing under the sea. lunars couldnt or didnt wanted to help the solars, so they ran to this place that makes cthulu and shoggoths in a fairly constant rate. after some SAN loss, lunars got 3 castes merged in 1. they remained with a constant rebirth rate in creation, some trying to make their own type of dragonblooded, called now beastmen. ruive may be one. the problem is, the FATE NINJAS also considered lunars a thread.

the FATE NINJAS helped organize a set of lies to help hunt down lunars, and later on, solars. in a constant basis, they would warn a group of veteran soldiers where a lunar exalt would appear, and thus where they could go to kill it, moments after it appears. on those days, lunars would dispatch help as well, as long as it wasnt in a city.

then someone decided it was time to have a diahrea in the loom of fate.

the solar exaltations where released by fukken demons, the empress that could use a defense network to literally say WE ARE ONLY ONE EMPIRE, YOUR ARGUMENT IS IRRELEVANT disapeared (rumor is, she likes big black dragon dick) and the hunters of lunars now see a better way to gain power, competing for the trhone. everyone is now in a power run, lunars and solars being rebirthed ALONG with deathlords attacking, abyssals appearing, godlings revolting and FATE NINJAS shitting themselves with so much work that the loom of fate was the least of their concerns.

oh and those solars?

they had stash of weapons from the primordial clusterfuck war spread EVERYWHERE.
>>
No. 18205 ID: 2eac65

>>328002
We know that already.

We're trying to stay in character.
>>
No. 18206 ID: 5f20de

>>327986

The level of exposition is pretty high, but I'm liking it. You're a good storyteller... as can be evidenced from the fact that I went from "We need to get rid of this demon ridin' our asses ASAP" to "Well, um, I guess he's not actually bad per se, and... Oh hell. I JUST WANNA HOLD HIM AND HUG HIM AND CALL HIM WORDSBLOOD."

Well played, sirrah. Well played.

>>328005

...Huh? We're not Saulanna. It's, like, right there at the beginning.

>???? can now hear VOICES OF THE PAST
>???? is now SAULANNA RICANYA ROCKBLOSSOM

We're those crazy durn VOICES OF THE PAST. There was actually a hint to Wordsblood being there as well:

>???? can now hear SOMETHING ELSE(?)
>>
No. 18207 ID: ff6cf4

lastl i forgot. lunars are very resilient, and we should not have trouble becoming a exelent mage. there 2 together are hax.

>>328006
saulanna is tecnically a meritocracy of the orb with the vice-precidency of wordblood, our favorite primordial dragonbookwormdemonthingie.
>>
No. 18209 ID: 407b5b

>>328002

I think you forgot to mention the Fair Folk coming in from outside Creation for 'funtimes with chaos' becasue they thought reality was too boring without some extra Xom.
>>
No. 18211 ID: ff6cf4

>>328009
i did not knew how to add them, nor the specific between wich events that happened.

anyway i was just about to realize. saulanna can somewhat easily learn magic, along with diplomacy required to become apprentice in every type of magic. add some defenses from lunar exaltation, we can master almost all types of magic. we started with a hard one, primordial magic, everything else will be easy from here on.

we can learn FATE MAGIC if we pull every string together, all we need is find a partially friendly FATE NINJA to use soon-to-be-adquired charms and social skills, we can learn solar sorcery from any mage exalt we encounter (guess what payment is =3) and if we get to a reliable dragonblood land we can learn their terrestrial circle sorcery, maybe even pretending to be a dragonblooded.

also pac saulanna. deathlands. free titan's will.

and we wasted one point dragging Gevin HOT GOAST DUDE to inside our head.
>>
No. 18215 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/197371
>>/quest/197348
>>/quest/197347
>>/quest/197339
>>/quest/197294
>>/quest/197288

5copper, there is no god damn reason to make six posts in response to one update.
>>
No. 18217 ID: f9f4d9

wait... what if we eat another exalted soul? would we absorb the exaltation essence as well?
>>
No. 18218 ID: 604703

>>328011
>wasted one point dragging Gevin HOT GOAST DUDE to inside our head

That ability will also facilitate the capture of souls for eating, so I would hardly call it a waste. Unless, of course, you aren't going to eat any more souls. But if Saulanna has enough Titan's Will, she can pretty much do... anything.

If she has enough.
>>
No. 18219 ID: 5a2e05

So I know virtually nothing of the more detailed aspects of the setting and need to know something important. Namely, does eating souls stick them back into some kind of life cycle or does it just get rid of them for good? And is that a bad thing?
>>
No. 18220 ID: ff6cf4
File 127726261872.png - (337.37KB , 650x2047 , skull of regret.png )
18220

>>328018
OHGOD I KNEW IT WE ARE PACWOMAN

>>328015
y u mad bra?

this is me every dammed time i read something i wrote.
>>
No. 18221 ID: ff6cf4

>>328019
it sends them to the biggest wait line in existance in order to be reborn.
>>
No. 18222 ID: f9f4d9

>>328020
what you are supposed to do is delete the old post and combine the old words and the new words into another post. so next time you forget copy paste your post into the field and then start writing the new stuff. after you submit it delete the old one.
>>
No. 18223 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328020
Delete and repost when you mess up, like I do way too often.

>Namely, does eating souls stick them back into some kind of life cycle or does it just get rid of them for good? And is that a bad thing?
From what Wordblood says, neither. He absorbs them and makes them a part of himself. Which is pretty Bad End, I gotta admit.

I vote we just pretend that the soul bits are going into lethe, in an effort to get people to vote for more power-eating, because that is way more fun.

>That ability will also facilitate the capture of souls for eating, so I would hardly call it a waste.
Capturing souls in a mind-palace with a mind-prison in the mind-basement is completely over the top awesome. I'd be in favor of it even if it WASN'T our main route to power.

>Unless, of course, you aren't going to eat any more souls.
It is possible. Tough to judge what /quest/ will go for, but these days there's a pretty strong 'save the day with zero casualties' streak in the posters.
>But if Saulanna has enough Titan's Will, she can pretty much do... anything.
I like the sound of that! It seems like the lunars could use a boost in this game. Speculating from what Gevin said, they were kicking deathlord ass for awhile, then got kinda fucked up and scattered.

Setting ourselves up as a sorcerous overlady, beating back the forces of death and the locust crusade, and then forcing some level of reconciliation between the remains of the titans and the gods, seems like a sufficiently epic goal for a celestial exalt.
>>
No. 18225 ID: f9f4d9

>>328023
still, reincarnation resluts in all your memories being purged from your soul and then being stuck in a new baby body. and so many souls are in line waiting for a new body that we could eat millions of them and a line would still be forming. so yeah eating the souls doesn't result in a worse end for them then normal.
>>
No. 18227 ID: ff6cf4

>>328025
isnt that tecnically a good thing that we do it with the dead? or was just the bodies?
>>
No. 18234 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328025
I think the most rationalization we can do is that turning ourselves into a primordial-fueled powerhouse will let us better oppose the deathlords, and thus we're sacrificing a small number of ghosts to save millions.
>>
No. 18235 ID: f9f4d9

once we get powerful enough we can EAT the deathlords.
>>
No. 18242 ID: e91554

>>328034
i do belive we can eat souls with certain impunity. we should keep that a secret however, and we have to pick those that arent useful for us.

why not consume Gevin HOT GOAST DUDE for 2 of titans will?
>>
No. 18243 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328042
But... fixating unreasonably on the well being of certain mortals while allowing the deaths of many others is a big part of being an exalt.
>>
No. 18245 ID: e973f4

>>328042
Because we like Gevin? :V
>>
No. 18249 ID: 0c4fcd

it was a serious question.

Gevin has no use for us, unless we empower him. thats at least 1 less titan's will. we can get power word or moon power from that, maybe even increase our bust and have 200% more fanservice. admitidely, gevin may help in battles if he steals people body.

he can talk to us about everything he knows but this can also be archieved if we eat his soul.

we may need him to keep contact with ruive. but why we want to do that again? he has been a burden since the beginning. and we are yet to see what the music box does.

we cant ressurect him, in fact, we killed his old body. we cant make him into a useful "something" unless wordblood somehow finds a use like hiding in his head instead of ours, or empowering him with a bonestrider. wich would be cool, but at least 2 months to make the bonestrider unless we get a specific set of charms. again, more titan's will is needed.

we need to look at this approach, because we have a primordial with us. he is somewhat loyal to us but he is in our head, and thus, actualy in debt with us.

saulanna will go to sleep soon, and we will one day wake up without gevin, and wordblood will "swear" he does not know why he runned off in a manner we cannot track him.

are we a instrument of damnation or salvation? is wordblood part of it? can we trust him? should we set a quota of souls to eat in order to ensure his trust or loyalty?

i had a intricated plan to figure out if he was part of the ebon dragon, but it mostly involves asking luna to ask the ebon dragon.
>>
No. 18252 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328049
>we cant ressurect him, in fact, we killed his old body.
What? No.
>>
No. 18253 ID: e973f4

>>328049
It was a serious answer.
>>
No. 18256 ID: 0c4fcd

>>328052
im pretty sure the zombie we faced in the beginning was his.

>>328053
oh :V
>>
No. 18257 ID: d363a2

>>328056
the zombie was a zombie goast, it was a ghost as well. his body is a bunch of bones in the mud in an old river, he died from a tree falling on him.
>>
No. 18260 ID: 0c4fcd

>>328057
oh yeah, his zombie counterpart is yet to rise then.

well, still. ressurection is impossible in exalted.
>>
No. 18265 ID: 3b45b8

>>328060
>enough Titan's Will
>anything

This quest ain't gonna pussy out when it comes to temptation!
>>
No. 18267 ID: 5a2e05

>>328065
You really know how to dangle carrots.
>>
No. 18270 ID: 5d84fb

if we get strong enough we can eat the sticks too.
>>
No. 18273 ID: 3b45b8

>>328067

I can hardly do otherwise with how I've set things up! Theoretically Saulanna could reach a stage where she could wander off beyond the edge of reality and make herself a new world, with whatever rules she wishes.

Of course, this whole Titan's Will thing is just one option. Saulanna can still become powerful as a Lunar does normally (with slight modifications to the process to facilitate the medium of a quest, of course), and follow paths of development in shapeshifting or sorcery or martial arts or whatever, as any Champion of the gods can. Don't think Titan's Will is "the" system for getting stronger in this Quest. I will say, however, that Wordblood's presence and the options he presents are what make Saulanna unique; no other character in the setting will be able to use Words of Power, for example (unless Saulanna/Wordblood teaches or grants such an ability to them). Of course, there are drawbacks to being unique.

I have a few different "end conditions" for the quest thought up; some good ends, some bad ends, and some... debatably good or bad ends. I will probably end up thinking of more before long.
>>
No. 18274 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328065
yeahbut
>>/quest/197529
>>
No. 18278 ID: a594b9

>>328070
Oh god I lol'd.
>>
No. 18292 ID: 0c4fcd

>>328073
so wordblood confirmed for BFF?
>>
No. 18301 ID: 445c48

Personally, I vote eating souls is kosher, so long as we just happen to run into those souls anyways, no slaughtering villages for power but if we're punching people well we may as well, they're probably bad people if we're punching them.

Also voting on powering up Wordblood right now, to make future powerups better.
>>
No. 18320 ID: 43a8f2

>>328101
upgrading wordblood would cost 2 titans will, and we would not be able to get power word until we feed again.

considering we are being hunted, we may get live targets rather that souls to eat. we really should get power word and stop there.
>>
No. 18322 ID: 3b45b8

>>328120

There are other options for powering him up besides just increasing his Soul Force. Giving him increased Ease of Consumption would help him absorb powerful souls with less difficulty, and reduce the "stun" that comes with the absorption; or Efficiency of Consumption would reduce the lightshow that comes with it, and provide an additional measure of Titan's Will each time a soul is absorbed. Both of these would cost only one measure of Titan's Will to improve. There are other things as well.
>>
No. 18324 ID: 8bdb6a

In that case, Efficiency of Consumption sounds like a solid investment.

Power Word: Halt sounds like another. Especially since these have broad applications. That could stop someone chasing us, or stop someone from falling to their death, or stop an arrow in mid flight, or halt the water in a river so we can run across the surface.

Hesitant to suggest these, if only because raw Agility is always just so gosh darned useful in almost any circumstance. (And not just because it's the godstat in White Wolf)
>>
No. 18325 ID: e973f4

>>328124
Yeah Efficiency of Consumption sounds like the best plan, just because assuming we make this soul-eating a habit it'll add up to more "points" to spend on things later.
>>
No. 18328 ID: 5a2e05

Efficiency of Consumption seems to be a smart move. Small cost now for bigger payoff later. It's like making another resource-gatherer in an RTS.

As for the souls thing, I give in to the temptation. As long as we're not going out of our way to devour innocents.
>>
No. 18330 ID: 43a8f2

efficiency + power word sounds like the best course of action. just got to post it in the thread '-'
>>
No. 18332 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328130
Just to be absolutely clear: We need to specify a word of power. We can't just have all of them.
>>
No. 18335 ID: 2eac65

This isn't the appropriate time to be discussing this. We should get to a safe place, check up on our current abilities, sort out our priorities, then decide how to upgrade ourselves in accordance to what we have, what we lack, and what we want.
>>
No. 18336 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328135
Maybe. If we ARE going to get a Word of Power, or more Agility, then we should do it ASAP so it can help us out.
>>
No. 18338 ID: 2eac65

>>328136
That might close off other, more expensive and useful options that we'd have wanted to pick later. We have MP to help us in the short term.
>>
No. 18339 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328138
Well, with that attitude, we'll never pick ANYthing. Every decision closes off other opportunities.
>>
No. 18340 ID: d98958

if we eat enough souls then we can get everything.
>>
No. 18341 ID: 7d7c19

I will add another note to say that, because Wordblood is residing in Saulanna's mindspace, where time flows differently, he can make changes to himself and craft words of power and such instantly. It's only when Titan's Will is used to affect the external world (including Saulanna's body) that it will take time, depending on what it is that's being done.
>>
No. 18342 ID: 2eac65

>>328139
Which is why we shouldn't rush into it by focusing too much on the immediate problem.
>>
No. 18343 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328141
Wait, we do have to pay TW for each Word of Power we learn, right? Or do I misunderstand?

>>328142
Buying an ability to let us get more TW per ghost we eat is hardly rushing into things to solve the immediate problem.
Also, we should indeed consider taking abilities to solve the immediate problem. Unspent points are no use if we die.
>>
No. 18344 ID: 2eac65

>>328143
If we decide eating souls for power is something we actually want to do.

We're not in immediate danger of dying, and the situation looks like one we've got under control. We can afford to delay.
>>
No. 18346 ID: e3202a

>>328143

Each Word of Power made will cost TW, yes. Very strong ones may cost two to three or even more (a two-point example would be Power Word: Protection, which will create protection appropriate to a target danger for Saulanna or for any person or object she specifies); most will probably cost one (such as Burn, or Sleep, or the proposed Halt), and very weak ones might be available for multiples per measure (those would mostly be Power Nouns which create commonplace or minor objects, such as Light or Water).

The effect of individual Power Words will ramp up with the total Soul Force available to Saulanna. The suggested Power Word Halt, at her current level, will cease any motion that is currently imparted to a creature or object. Objects in flight or falling will hang in midair. But it won't stop things from moving in new ways, so an object can just be picked up and a person can just start moving again as they wish (though if they're Halted in midair, they'll only flail around, because gravity's been canceled). As she got more powerful, Halt would become capable of a temporary stasis effect of increasing duration, leading up eventually to permanence at the highest levels.

Words of Power will be vulnerable to magic that protects people from spells and such, including the countermagic of sorcery.
>>
No. 18347 ID: 43a8f2

>>328144
this isnt necessarily true. we are being chased, if we need time to peform upgrades we should do so now.

efficiency and moon power seem to be the way to go now. power word is just too vast to get with few TW.
>>
No. 18349 ID: 2eac65

>>328147
Our pursuers aren't in the immediate area. If we do get in a fight, a physical enhancement won't make much of a difference, and other things won't take any time to apply.

I really want to clear up our priorities before we use up our resources.
>>
No. 18350 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328149
>If we do get in a fight, a physical enhancement won't make much of a difference
That's just your opinion.
>>
No. 18371 ID: 001d41

Whew, I'm beginning to see why other quests don't try these sort of complicated character growth decision shenanigans!
>>
No. 18372 ID: 5a2e05

>>328171
Just count yourself lucky you tossed up a discussion thread. And even then...
>>
No. 18373 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328171
It works more smoothly for less popular quests. Sorry.
>>
No. 18374 ID: 2eac65

>>328171
I don't have a problem with it, except that it's happening at this specific moment in time.
>>
No. 18379 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328174
What, we don't have enough time to think it over?

I can see the argument in keeping a few spare points, but I think that just getting things to benefit us will help more, because you can ALWAYS make the argument for keeping them in reserve. "What if I need them MORE at a later point?"

Also, I bet it'd be possible to let Saulanna store things in her mind other than ghosts and spirits. Like maybe an inventory.
>>
No. 18380 ID: a594b9

Hey can we get like a vote thing going? I haven't been following the discussion but if someone collects up all the ideas of what to use TW on and puts them in poll format then maybe we can actually decide what to do!
>>
No. 18382 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/198792
I'd just like to make it clear that Luna can't remove someone's exaltation if she stops approving of their actions. And that's just assuming that consorting with demons is enough to make Luna pissy at an exalt, which isn't true.

...unless that's different from canon.

But honestly, do you think just spending XP-equivalent will make the gods destroy us? Don't be so paranoid.
>>
No. 18383 ID: 2eac65

>>328179
There is no need to use it right this instant. Our situation isn't that urgent.
>>
No. 18384 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328183
I thought you said the situation was too urgent to spend XP. Now it's not urgent enough to spend XP?

Let's just agree to disagree.
>>
No. 18385 ID: 2eac65

>>328184
I said there were more immediate concerns we should be focusing on, and we can spend our will after gathering enough information to have some clue on what we want to spend it on. I didn't say that we would get killed if we didn't use it immediately on something that might help us.

And don't say that we might as well never use it. That's a false dilemma. I would have no problem talking about what we want to use it for if we had some idea of what we want to do. I just don't want to waste it on a problem we don't even know we need any help with. "Not now" doesn't mean "never".

>>328182
We have reason to keep our involvement with Wordblood a secret. If Luna asks any questions on what we've been up to, we'll want to be able to provide answers that are consistent with what she can see and won't make her suspicious.
>>
No. 18387 ID: c029a6

>>328146
i have been thinking, i belive there is a way to "ressurect" someone, we would need a power word aging, someone able to give birth (maybe we already do!) and a means to emulate domnica's mantle (page 85 of scrolls of exalts).

i think we could use lunar charms to change minor appearance in the baby if needed. im not sure on that part.

>>328182
tecnically luna can send one of her moonsilver clone to kill us. i do think wordblood can pass as a "common akuma" if the need arises, so this shouldnt come to happen.

remember that primordials are a big deal, so much that there is the possibility that luna would call to arms to capture wordblood.

you need a essence 9 charm to "kill" a primordial, noone in the setting after the fall of the solars should/would possess that, maybe not even a deathlord.

>>328185
luna had more that one of her exalt simply defecting to deathlords. some of them serve them willingly. she in fact has absolutely no reason to keep track of us, and the only reason she does such is because jukashi is a cool guy (TM) and didnt wanted to add a DMPC to teach us so early in game.

let it go, luna doesnt care to what we do.
>>
No. 18391 ID: 8bdb6a
File 127750510792.png - (14.34KB , 875x140 , moonsilver_clone_canonicity.png )
18391

>moonsilver clone
wat
>>
No. 18393 ID: c029a6

>>328191
of course its not called clone. its some sort of bullshit charm (like everything high end in exalted) that allowed luna to make 3+ copies of her. its how she greets her exalted. its on glories of the most high, where every god was stated.

unconquered sun simply summoned them.
>>
No. 18397 ID: c029a6

>>/quest/198921
yes the world sucks. but you dont understand WHY. we cant even KILL wordblood properly. if he decides to have a snack on us or use TW on his own, we dont have how to stop him. without knowing what created this, we would simply recreate the tragedy that already happened twice.

shit sucks so bad that you literally cant call for help of heavens office because they literally hate your guts for things that you dont remember, problaby do not want to remember and if you did, would not really object against our death. luna would most likely not act against us directly but there would definitively be proper retaliation against wordblood.

the primordial created their servants that command the exalted. every single one of them is now cursed and cannot act in their own free will. we may just possess the power needed to break those chains, up to the point of actualy forcing equality between all parts. and then again, we can do some more.

solar and lunar exalt have a curse that makes them act "unrestrained" for some time. add power and merit to it and you get a power hungry dude that kills, fucks and steals as he pleases. in the end of the first age, not even solar exalts could tolerate other solar exalts. we can break that curse. its gonna be "fun" to discover it, but we can.

we can do little against abyssals and infernals directly. some of them may be "turned" or conviced but not all would listed, but there are more ordinary ways of turning them to solar or simply riding them of their resonance "curse". we can act against deathlords, but this would require a huge amount of manpower.

autochron detected the curse, he isolated himself in elsewhere because heaven's office was "bothered" by his existance. his exalted are the ones invading the south. if he wakes up we can repair the lunar exaltation (wich we dont know that is broken yet) make new exalts and methodically fight the deathlords. wich we can also free of their prison and oaths of servitude to the dead primordials/yotzi/whatever.

we can visit the mountainfolk, first creation of autocrhon. their tunnels literally connect creation as a whole, even their weakest exalt can make artifact of great wonder. they are a dying breed and, you guessed it, they are under a curse to not act on creation. we dont even need to break the curse to literally ask them for awesome stuff, imagine what they would do once they know alchemicals are on the south and rising.

and heavens office? infernals. you dont want to know.

there is too much that saulanna can do with wordblood. we cannot deny this is a plot device. we must plot for its use, but not to rely or abuse it.
>>
No. 18398 ID: 2eac65

>>328197
I wasn't pushing for any particular course of action, or trying to decide which side was in the wrong. I was only advocating the general worldview of "the strong should help the weak". I didn't even want to make that speech until we found out much more about the setting; that's one of the reasons I was so insistent that we put aside our plans for the future for just a few ticks while we solve our more immediate problems.

We got too far ahead of ourselves, and what happened? We lost control. We're lucky it happened now and all we did was eat a fish. In the future, the consequences could be much worse.
>>
No. 18401 ID: 01e059

>>328198
yes, we need to focus on the here and now at the moment due to having too little power to effect long term plans. most likely salunna's blank slate state is a result of wordblood being in her when she was exalted, resulting in the exalted memories being turned into energy for wordblood to power up.
>>
No. 18402 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328198
If it's not too much trouble, could you try to make fewer posts in the in-character thread? And especially not just make posts replying negatively to other people's suggestions?

Of the last fifty posts in the in-character thread, more than a dozen are yours.
>>
No. 18407 ID: 090a78

the best thing would be to eat the ghost of a lunar. we would learn how to do everything they could do, gain all charms, spells, whatever that they had.
>>
No. 18416 ID: 2eac65

>>328202
I try to say everything I have to say in one post, but I don't always think of everything the first time. Sometimes, I think of reasons why other suggestions wouldn't end well.
>>
No. 18417 ID: 78ef58

>>328216
well stop. no matter how eloquent your write it you cannot change someone opinion.
>>
No. 18418 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328217
Worse, he might convince people that they're not "good" enough to make suggestions, or that they don't want to deal with the hassle of it, which is basically just browbeating them out of participating, which is bad.

Every single possible course of action, including doing nothing, including the most cautious possible course of action, has many things that could go wrong.
>>
No. 18422 ID: 2eac65

>>328217
Some people listen to advice and gain a new perspective on their ideas. That can help them refine their ideas, or choose better ones.

>>328218
Other people get angry and make personal accusations.

Can we please not have an argument here? I didn't want to have the last one, and having another one will just make us all angry.
>>
No. 18476 ID: 5f20de

>>328207

Do lunar ghosts even exist? I thought the whole premise of exaltation was that Luna collected the souls of her dead champions and threw 'em back into worthy mortals.

>>328222

Well. You have shown a slight tendency to be snarky and opinionated when responding to some suggestions.

For example, you say you disapprove of a specific suggestion and explain why. When someone then throws his support behind that suggestion anyway, you >> the post and say "Let's not do this again", because...Why?

Did you think you had concluded the issue by explaining that this wasn't something we should do, in your opinion?

Sir, that is not how /Quest works. Kindly revise your feedback method.

>Serious advice is pretty serious.
>>
No. 18477 ID: 059120

>>328216 >>328222
Try to cut your reasoning out and put it here. Crossboard link it (>>/questdis/328277) if you must. Downvoting a particular action is okay if you've advocated another one, but posting "Guys maybe you should think this through first," in the thread starts really derailing it.
>>
No. 18479 ID: a594b9

>>328222
This is actually the right place to have an argument. Or was that post originally from the quest thread?

At any rate, Quest-Discussions is where we discuss and argue about quests. Quest threads are where we suggest. Posts in /quest/ should be suggestions only. I wish more people followed that rule.
>>
No. 18480 ID: 5727de

>>328276
>Do lunar ghosts even exist?

The Exalted can leave ghosts, at least in theory. For example, the Deathlords, the 13 most powerful ghosts (disregarding the Neverborn), are the ghosts of Solars who died in the Usurpation.
>>
No. 18482 ID: 5f20de

Pyeh, nevermind my derailing.

Since this IS a discussion thread, I have a query for y'all: On what and why SHOULD we spend our Titan's Will on right now (or later), if at all? I'm just trying to see where the consensus is at.

Remember, our current supply is 2 TW, and these are our current options. And remember, PHYSICAL/EXTERNAL changes will take time, whereas SPIRITUAL/INTERNAL changes will not. Both will probably flare up our SOUL FIRE thingy again, unless we buy the Titan's Work that reduces that.

>Wordsblood's Titan's Works
>Efficiency of Consumption

It gives us a dot more of Titan's Will when we munch on delicious [strike]cake[/strike] souls, and turns us into less of a lightshow.

Cost: 1 TW

>Wordsblood's Titan's Works
>Ease of Consumption

Lets us OM NOM NOM stronger souls easier and with less stun feedback.

Cost: 1 TW

>Words of Power: Whatever.

So many uses.

Cost 1-3 TW, depending on power scale.

I'm currently championing getting us "Power Word: Confusion", due to it being useful in dealing with opponents with no sorcery defenses. Should cost 1 TW.

Getting "Power Word: Halt" should be handy as well, so I'd support that. Should also cost 1 TW.

>Soul Force+ Saulanna

We get more Lunar abilities and greater potential for shapeshifting. The strength of her Power Words will increase. We also get 3 moon dots.

Cost: 2 TW

>Soul Force+ Wordsblood

+3 moon dots. Wordsblood becomes able to tell us what powers Saulanna can get and generally performing better (for example, enhancing Gevin with TW becomes easier).

Cost: 2 TW

In lieu of getting Power Words, I'm supporting this, since a stronger Wordsblood can do more stuff, and tell us more about possible Lunar Abilities. I'm pretty sure he's trustworthy enough to boost a bit.

>Enhancing Gevin.

As I understand it, we'll sort of be 'exalting' a ghost with some of our power (i.e. Titan's Will). Not sure quite what the enhancement options are, but be aware that Wordsblood has said he needs to be stronger to do this without risking screwing up.

Cost: ?

>Increasing physical stat: Might, Agility, Toughness, Beauty

What it says. Improves a stat.

[Personal note: Why is Agility so important to boost? I get that we become faster and better able to handle combat, but wouldn't a couple of Power Words or well-written suggestions let us kick ass anyway? Maybe it's just that I'm not really behind the whole 'make her a kick-ass warrior' idea.]

Cost: ?

>Make other permanent physical alterations

The implications of this should be obvious. In before Godzilla Warform wrestling Ebon Dragon suggestion.

Cost: ? (probably scope-dependant)

>Draw forth dormant MOON ABILITIES or increase capacity to SHAPESHIFT.

Rather than increasing soul force to get Moon Abilities and increasing shapeshifting capabilities, Wordsblood can draw them forth or increase them specifically. At his current strength, he'll be drawing 'em out at random, as he can't tell us what these abilities are yet.

[Note: What's the benefit of this? Are there any specific abilities we would want to hunt down and get, in lieu of steadily increasing her SOUL FORCE?]

Cost: ?

And that's all, I think. Anyone spot an option I missed?
>>
No. 18485 ID: 2eac65
File 127758473598.jpg - (123.14KB , 530x530 , Beach_Fruit.jpg )
18485

>>328276
Your advice has been noted.

Squabbles like that are unpleasant for me, too. They make it hard to maintain the endearing cheerfulness I try to project.

Please accept this melon as an apology.
>>
No. 18486 ID: 8bdb6a

>Why is Agility so important to boost? I get that we become faster and better able to handle combat, but wouldn't a couple of Power Words or well-written suggestions let us kick ass anyway? Maybe it's just that I'm not really behind the whole 'make her a kick-ass warrior' idea.
Well, I dig the idea of using our brain instead of our brawn, but I don't feel we can always avoid combat. And even if we are avoiding combat, agility lets you literally avoid combat.
Agility is to-hit and defense, as I understand. When we were trying to beat that ghost, he was just a bit too quick for us. If we had higher agility, we wouldn't have needed to spend an MP on boosting agility. Plus, maybe some day (or potentially tonight!) we'll be fighting an exalt, and boosting our (improved) agility is the only thing we can do to avoid getting killed.
Plus, it has noncombat applications. When we were up against that cliff, our agility was too low to climb it (or am I mistaken?) and we also had an idea to punch it in the precise location to cause a rockslide, but our agility was too low for that, too. Sure, we got up the cliff anyway, but I like having more options.

It's just a really useful stat. I'm not saying we should spend LOTS of TW on it. Just enough to make us more survivable in a pinch, (I cannot overstress the value of survivability) and so we don't always have to spend an MP on every little thing.

PS: I don't think that we can rely on "well written suggestions" for attack/defense. Nothing we tried, short of spending an MP, would let us hit that ghost boss. I also don't think we should go "Oh, we can train that normally later." I mean, when we actually get time to train, I can't imagine that we'll go "oh, well, we could have trained agility, but our agility is too high, so now we wasted our chance and cannot do anything!"

Sorry to be so long winded.
>>
No. 18487 ID: 2eac65

Yes, now's the time to talk about upgrading! I said "when we have a chance to rest", and I'm standing by that.

Enhancing Saulanna's physical stats, I recommend against. We can train for that, and we can do so much more with Titan's Will.

Getting more Moon Magic would be a good idea if we could pick what we get, but we can't, so deciding on that is like not deciding at all.

Boosting Soul Force would give us more raw power. Probably a good idea in the future, but in the short term I think it would be best to get more options. We're supposed to be a tricky one, so we need tricks to work with.

Ease of Consumption implies that we plan on eating souls as a routine matter. I am against it.

Efficiency of Consumption would decrease the number of souls we need to get future upgrades. That is much easier to accept.

Our best options seem to be giving Wordblood access to new Titan's Works or Words of Power. Here are some ideas from me, though I don't know how plausible they are:

Dream Snare
Pulls a living soul out of its body, without killing it. The body appears to be asleep for the duration of the effect. If the soul is released, it returns to the body unharmed.

Dream Palace
Creates an illusionary world inside Saulanna's mind. Helpful for training and conditioning trapped spirits.

Soul Vivisection
Cuts out pieces of a soul without destroying it entirely, allowing us to absorb some memories and Titan's Will while leaving the victim alive. Since one spirit gave us three measures, this should theoretically be possible.

Power Word: "Submit"
Forces the target to cease whatever action they are performing and become receptive to commands. Can quickly end a fight, and aid in certain kinds of social interaction.

Power Word: "Confess"
Forces the target to speak any secrets they're trying to hide. Also usable on objects designed with a hidden purpose, such as secret doors and coded messages, indicating said purpose with glowing runes.

Power Word: "Fail"
Cancels out any efforts made by the target. Attacks miss, spells fizzle, and the like.

Before we can decide what to get next, though, we should know what we've got now. What's our current assortment of Moon Abilities?
>>
No. 18494 ID: 560417

>What's our current assortment of Moon Abilities?

Man, when people asked for combat-related MAs I put them up right away. I was wondering how long it'd take for someone to just ask for the complete list.

Saulanna has:

MOON ABILITIES
Beast Senses
Increases the senses of touch, hearing and smell, and allows Saulanna to sense any immaterial spirits of consequence.

Moon Claws
Saulanna can spring long claws of moonsilver from her hands, which deal high damage and can touch immaterial creatures.

Flowing Defense
Saulanna's body takes on a fluidity that allows it to ease itself around non-magical bludgeoning or cutting attacks, so long as she's aware of them.

Inner Den
Saulanna can store a limited number and size of objects in her Mindspace, increasing as her Soul Force does.

Mask Sneak
So long as her Soul Fire isn't showing, Saulanna can pull a shroud of unnoticeability about herself that will render her invisible to mundane perception, scaling up to thwart magical senses of increasing power as her Soul Force grows.

Black-stripe Thief
Saulanna can ease her way through nonmagical bonds and open nonmagical doors or containers. Scales up to manage magical versions with Soul Force.

SHAPESHIFTING
Human Form
Totem Form
War Form
Captured Form

Captured Forms:
Pale Salmon
>>
No. 18495 ID: 5dedfd

>>328287
2 of these habilities you could find in adamand circle of spells. they are hax.

we should also consider options to affect objects. im not creative at all wich is why i dislike power word now. terrestrial circle sound so appealing now =c

>>328286
there are better means to defend "uselves". exalted have perfect defense charms, these are literally required after some point in game. if agility is the same as dexterity it can become interesting to pick it due to possible craft skills.

id rather increase craft skill instead of beauty or agility. maybe beauty since a first impression is lasting, but we also have charms to help with that.

we also have to find a lunar tribe that can teach us, in a manner that they would accept us. more specificaly, we are lacking tatoos that would protect us from the wyld (and a bit more if we find a god crafter) and trainning with the lunar exaltation. they can even initiate us in the spellcrafting business.
>>
No. 18498 ID: 8bdb6a

>there are better means to defend "uselves". exalted have perfect defense charms
Doesn't the lunar perfect require high agility? Even assuming it works like in canon exalted?

Also, not to be a dick, but people are always 'oh, we'll work through everything without violence' right up until a bad guy attacks, at which point most suggestions turn into 'oh no a baddie kill it kill iiiiiit.'
>>
No. 18501 ID: 2eac65

>>328295
If you're going to plan, plan big. It'll give us something to aim for.

Speaking of "big", how much would it take to give birth to a new titan?

>>328298
Agility is certainly very handy, but I'm against spending Titan's Will on it because it's much harder to get than training time, and we can do so much more with it.

For the same reason, we shouldn't use it to power up Gevin. I'm all for helping him, but there are many other ways we can do that besides giving up a part of ourself.

In a way, it comes down to whether you think eating a soul is something objectionable or not. If it is, then Titan's Will is a difficult resource to get, and we should use it carefully. The less important it is, the less we have to worry.
>>
No. 18502 ID: d4b8e9

>>328301
harder to get in an ethical manor, we could just go up to a random ghost, stuff them into our brain-ventory and have wordblood eat him. BAM at least 3 points of titans will and who knows what else from memories.
>>
No. 18503 ID: 560417

>>328301
A new Titan would take a lot of building up, and a lot of Titan's Will.

>>328302
Most ghosts will only give you 2 measures, maybe even just 1 for the weakest ones.
>>
No. 18511 ID: 57dbd6

>>328303
ah, yes, i was taking the Efficiency of Consumption bonus into account when i said three.
>>
No. 18512 ID: 2eac65

>>328302
Yes, that's what I meant. The more we care about who we eat, the harder it is to get Titan's Will. Inconvenient, yes, but if you compromise your principles to gain power, there's really no point to having it, is there?

>>328303
I figured it wouldn't be easy. It's something to keep in mind for the future, in case we want to make a big change to the nature of the universe.

So how much would we need for those other ideas? It'll be harder to decide if we don't know that.

Speaking of which, it looks like we're good for combat and stealth, but we've got nothing to help social interaction.
>>
No. 18513 ID: 5dedfd

i have read some more on the matter of primordials, and i found a lot of stuff.

a primordial had/have many souls. he is in fact at least 3 circles of several demons, the innermost being the more relevant to what he is. they can indeed spawn souls to serve them based on their will alone and each of them is replaceable, except for a fetish soul that represents the primordial itself, but even then, killing the fetish soul would change the primordial forever instead of killing him. every and each part of it can be summoned, but these demons are really difficult to even consider talking to. they are not only "dead" but cursed, so there is not much they can do. gaia wasnt destroyed or defeated, she simply decided to explore the wyld with too many souls.

by the by. wordblood matches even more the destroyed fetish soul of the ebon dragon, shadow dragon or w/e.

in turn this means epic battles ahead. the deathknight is a scourge and not exactly battle fit. furthermore, of all dead primordials, ebon dragon is the most reasonable. i actualy have reasons to trust wordblood and to prevent his capture.

>>328312
eventually the principle will come out clear. maybe we will even get a exaltation to experiment upon, after all, deathlands and a death manse do means a abyssal is around.

as for social interaction, we have high intuition and we arent ugly. id say all we need is actual etiquette. becoming pretty in a lad that do slave trade isnt exactly ideal.
>>
No. 18517 ID: 2eac65

>>328313
I know you're trying to help, but we're better off without the out-of-character infodumps. It'll be more fun for Saulanna to figure things out in-character.
>>
No. 18519 ID: e973f4

>>328317
That and it says in the first post of this thread that this isn't quite Exalted, so a not insubstantial portion of what 5copper keeps quoting at us is probably incorrect. :/
>>
No. 18521 ID: e973f4

>>328319
Isn't quite canon Exalted, rather. >_>
>>
No. 18813 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/201397
I still prefer choosing a broadly useful power word instead of one that's only useful in specific circumstances. (On the other hand, uses of 'No' could probably get pretty abstract with increasing power.)

That said, if Saulanna can't resist his compelling voice, well... you guys want to solve our problems with talking, right?
>>
No. 18814 ID: 148105

>>328613
if we get enough words, could we make a Power Phrase? like 'burning down the house' causes a building to be instantly incinerated.
>>
No. 18815 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328614
Wouldn't "Burn" or "Fire" work just as well?
>>
No. 18816 ID: 148105

>>328615
i said instant, those would light it up but it will still take a while.
>>
No. 18817 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328616
Why would using more words make it faster?
>>
No. 18818 ID: 148105

>>328617
by being specific. everyone knows that the more unambiguous your target is the better things work.
>>
No. 18820 ID: 2eac65

It's kind of hard to decide what Power Word to get if we don't know how which ones are plausible and how much they cost.
>>
No. 18822 ID: 0d5620

We should take Power Word: Arousal. Or Naked.
>>
No. 18827 ID: 707490

>>328620
i agree with this.

we need to think aterally. id say power word love could get us a ally much faster that power word arousal could get us raped.
>>
No. 18834 ID: 19e705

So, guys? um...

Power Word: Cocks

It seems like a versatile and useful word to know.
>>
No. 18835 ID: 6a5a08

>>328634
Indeed, we could summon a swarm of angry chickens to attack them. Or something.
>>
No. 18838 ID: 2eac65

>>328627
Love could still result in rape. It's an empowering, unpredictable emotion, no good for controlling others or oneself. For controlling people, it's better to either be more subtle, or be more direct with a Power Word like "Obey" or "Submit".

For a mental defense, we could go with Power Word: "Silence", which would also help with stealth.
>>
No. 18845 ID: 445c48

How about two dots in efficiency of consumption? Sure, we don't get any pornography related magic right now, but future souls should yield more Titan's will for more pornography related magic.
>>
No. 18846 ID: d76879

>>328645
not sure we can PUT two into that. looks like a single tier upgrade.
>>
No. 18847 ID: 2eac65

>>328645
That would be a good choice if we're planning to do more soul-eating. But how can we justify something we would find horrifying if done to us?
>>
No. 18848 ID: 6a5a08

>>328647
Easy: We did it before they could do it to us.
>>
No. 18849 ID: 110562

>>328634
why not just say orgy or some shit like it?

>>328647
exalted is a strange world. we can justify it because others eat soul as well. above anything else, the world is a mess and we have the power to set it right.

>>328638
we would still need to say it to him, thus revealing our position.
>>
No. 18850 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328645
Well, let's not go crazy trying for MAXIMUM efficiency, even assuming there's multiple levels.

In my opinion, the name of the game is "good enough." It's never going to be perfect. And, in the meantime, imagine how dumb we'll feel if we put both TW into efficiency and then die before we eat another dude.

Besides. This is a quest, not a corporate financing final exam. Let's try and have SOME fun.
>>
No. 18851 ID: 110562

>>328650
its a safe bet to put one point on it. we should do that before discovering that the undead vampire abyssal deathlord wanna be has ghosts escorting him instead of unedible undead.
>>
No. 18852 ID: 2eac65

>>328649
>exalted is a strange world. we can justify it because others eat soul as well. above anything else, the world is a mess and we have the power to set it right.
If there are so many powerful people in it, why is it so messed up? When a lot of people each strive for a different "greater good", and each one makes sacrifices to pursue their own goals, nobody gets what they want and everyone is left with the consequences. To save everyone, we have to hold ourselves to our own standards.

>we would still need to say it to him, thus revealing our position.
Yeah, Silence won't help us sneak away from our immediate problem; being quiet when you're on fire is a wasted effort. But in the long term, it could be very helpful.

Another option: bribe the possible-vampire with a Word of Power for himself, either as payment for leaving us be, or as a demonstration that cooperating with us would be far more beneficial than, say, drinking our blood and making us a zombie slave.
>>
No. 18854 ID: 914efe

So there I was just thinking I had completely run out of good type-mashup character ideas that I hadn't seen done previously.

Then BAM.

Vampire magician.
>>
No. 18856 ID: 110562

>>328652
> When a lot of people each strive for a different "greater good"
uh, no. there is no greater good. it ended in the first age wich we definitively arent anymore.

in the first age there was fate ninjas, solars and dragonborn working together. everything you needed or wanted was supplied with magic or any magical device equivalent. a example would be dinosaurs that piss heroin, monster mash with gengineered humans/animals, orgies involving enought people to exaust the exalted as a form of adoration and magical stone monoliths set at the very edge of existance, keeping pure chaos from pouring in creation.

then the terrestrial exalted decided they wanted to run the show, beginning the second age. they did not knew how. long story made short, if you are alive by the end of the second age you are very lucky. and the magical wonders that actualy kept the world in one piece were slowly breaking, at least a quarter of creation fell to the chaos, adding to the already huge pieces of deathlands created by the death of the primordials.

>bribe the possible-vampire
thats a huge no. he must not know we have a power word. its like telling him we have a cooperative entity that can reshape existance when requested. you think its bad that we want to eat the souls that deserve it? he will enslave souls to reshape existance at his will.

also its likely he is a death knight. this is not "terribad", but i belive he is a diplomat type and thus not able to fight so effectively. however if he is a experienced abyssal he can wipe the floor with us, power words or not. he may be the most elaborate snack i am yet to find. we should not be able to "eat" him because he has high soul power.

and i fear he may pull a magnifcient bastard on us and the pairings would begin.
>>
No. 18857 ID: 110562

>>328654
when i saw him i immediately thought that he would pull a "what is a exalt, but a miserable pile of motes?"
>>
No. 18858 ID: a594b9

>>328654
It is a good concept!
>>
No. 18864 ID: 2eac65

>>328656
You don't have to tell me about Exalted. I know.

For the sake of asking, how much would the various things we've been suggesting cost?
>>
No. 18873 ID: 2eac65

Also, congratulations on reaching one thousand posts. I think that makes it the largest TGchan topic ever.
>>
No. 18875 ID: a594b9

Holy crap the quest thread has 1000 posts!

I think it's about time we made a new one or split this one or something.
>>
No. 18876 ID: a594b9

>>328673
One of the Golem Quest threads is bigger.
>>
No. 18877 ID: f5efca

>>328675

Only because I've gone and left so much time for people to talk, it's not so great updatewise.

I know where this first chapter will end.
>>
No. 18881 ID: 02b07c

i just noticed that saulanna has her chaste mark showing and its different that the current moon. am i forgetting something here?

also, why is everyone telling her to pretend she is a "common" raccoon? she failed acting in front of a bunch of dumb thugs, she will succeed against a enlightened ghost?
>>
No. 18887 ID: e1a765

>>328681
>chaste mark
:3
>>
No. 18893 ID: 35e55e

Jukashi, will you show us some official colours for Kaan?

I love him already because he seems like a suave bastard of a villain.

You rule.
>>
No. 18899 ID: 601965

>>328687
ohu.jpg

>>328693
he is a ghost. those are his colors.
>>
No. 18900 ID: 35e55e

>>328699
;-; Oh right. Dammit.
>>
No. 18901 ID: 35e55e

>>328699
Actually wait, are you sure he's a ghost?

He has colour on him which none of the ghosts so far have. I mean, Saulanna is black and white with occasional colour so who is to say that Kaan doesn't have a body?
>>
No. 18903 ID: 2eac65

>>328701
Probably not. Our senses told us he was alive. When we met Gevin, there were clear signs he wasn't alive - he wasn't breathing and his body was cold to the touch.
>>
No. 18904 ID: f728d3

>>328699
>>328701

Ghosts are drawn in gray lines.
>>
No. 18908 ID: 8bdb6a

He is obviously an Abyssal.

...or am I missing something?
>>
No. 18911 ID: 601965

>>328708
not a ghost, thus, must be a abyssal.

well, it seems only the BG will/would be colored. a bit counter intuitive but im ok with it.
>>
No. 18914 ID: 35e55e

>>328711
>>328708

Based on this image:
>>/quest/194724
Kaan is definitely an exalted and this figure (derp)

Well. I assume he owns this graveyard of a land. Is that manse his? I know I keep hearing the manse belongs to some dragon-whats-his-face but Wordblood says that she preferred her draconic form as do many supernatural creatures. She and Kaan/manse owner could easily shift into a human form.

>>/quest/199347

The Dragon's Shadow, that was his name.
>"He prizes his own interests and freedom above all else. He is the Shadow of All Things."
>He can be quite charming though.

Charming you say? Like how suave/charming Kaan is being now?

Sorry for the rather large post but I want to get some things straight before I sleep.
And; name-fagging.
>>
No. 18917 ID: 2eac65

>>328708
He does have a black Caste Mark...

...but he also introduced himself by name.
>>
No. 18922 ID: 8bdb6a

>>328717
It's probably his stage name. He is a magician, after all. I can't think of any magician who uses their real name.

...or maybe abyssal names aren't that big of a deal in this version of Exalted. Or he could be an infernal. Or maybe the Yozis and the Neverborn teamed up to corrupt solar essences instead of making two different kinds. Or maybe he's just a Solar who likes skulls a lot. Or something else entirely!

Probably a stage name, though.
>>
No. 18923 ID: 504131

>>328714
of all the big primordials ebon dragon is the only one that literally does not leave the dragon form.

also the manse is in his homenage, thus its possible the undead gentlemen carries the ownership and the heartstone. since its safe to say he is indeed a abyssal that works for the ebon dragon, he is a scourge, master of deception and lies.

>>328722
its possible that is the name his neverborn master gaved him. altho im votin for lies.

peregin kaan is like Pilgrim khan, literally wanderer ruler. yus, google dictionary can get weird results sometimes.

and something i didnt noticed, as a abyssal this puts the quest after the time of tumult.
>>
No. 18925 ID: 8bdb6a

>and something i didnt noticed, as a abyssal this puts the quest after the time of tumult.
The Solars came back before Gevin was born. He said as much. Also that there's a second sun in the sky. (Ligier or equivalent, I guess) Also, Autochthon showed up. Dunno how that went down. Not too important right now.

>>/quest/197433

In the sense that this fits into canon exalted at all, centuries may have passed since the Scarlet Empress disappeared. I'd guess 150 years, but that's just a stab in the dark.

From the sound of things, Dragon's Shadow took over the entire Underworld. There may no longer be a difference between Abyssals and Infernals. They appear to have the same boss, now.

He's probably also taken over huge chunks of Creation, but probably not all of it, since the Gods still exist, and Luna didn't sound very... besieged.
>>
No. 18930 ID: 504131

>Also that there's a second sun in the sky
wow i missed that detail.

>Also, Autochthon showed up. Dunno how that went down.
want info dump? im sure its irrelevant unless we go to the elemental poles or to the south.

>Luna didn't sound very... besieged
haha. damm. i need to tell you one thing.

luna's palace has a door to the underwold behind her trhone room. on it, a huge dining room is set for her and the ebon dragon, supposely named dragon's shadow now.
>>
No. 18971 ID: 8d16ab

>>/quest/201542
>>/quest/202375
Wait, does this mean Kaan is Saulanna's Solar Bond?
>>
No. 19002 ID: 68fbf2

>>328771
no, the fact she got a social attack from a charm does not means she is his lunar mate.

the fact she may remember him is. im hoping she is actualy remembering him due to the gangster ghost's memory.
>>
No. 19003 ID: 3bb7c1

>>328802
like i said, could be just a past life's memory. last person with our exaltation could of just met him once. don't need a bond to remember things like that.
>>
No. 19022 ID: 8d16ab

>>328771
On second thought I suppose there's a slight chance it's memories from before we got tabula rassa'd (since apparently we were held at his house and escaped). Not confident in this though, mainly since the implication of that whole process was that no pre-exaltation character traits survived.

>>328730
I don't actually know the setting enough to get what you're saying here, but it'd be pretty hilarious if we eventually screwed up and Luna found out about Wordblood, and she was just like, "huh. that's neat."

Also, not really strategy related, but... the fact that we're "voices of the past" is kind of interesting, given that all this happens a measurable amount of time since the creation of the known universe. Wonder if we'll ever find out more about that.
>>
No. 19023 ID: 8d16ab

>>328802
>>328803
It's more the "moon power won't help, something inside her wants to obey" part. Even if he spiked his request you'd think we could channel some MP into resisting, unless he had a hook on our moon powers themselves.
>>
No. 19028 ID: f8a708

>>328823
simple, we don't know HOW to channel MP into resisting.
>>
No. 19031 ID: 68fbf2

>>328823
this isnt exactly true. moon power and social attacks interact differently, most likely he can easily control other weak willed beings.

>>328828
if i remember correctly in exalted you spend willpower or something like it. it seems we have none.
>>
No. 19037 ID: 8d16ab

>>328831
Fair enough. To be honest I probably don't know enough about Exalted to make these kinds of arguments in the first place. >_>
>>
No. 19053 ID: 4178ee

"Social" effects in Lunar Quest bear only miniscule relation to how they're done in Exalted.

The use of both Willpower and Virtues has been subsumed into a character's Emotional state, and their broader outlook and goals. "Social combat" is basically about comparing your Dickery/Inspiration/Beauty to the other person's Acuity/Intuition/Beauty, but you increase your chances and decrease their by layering on good arguments, appeals to their key emotions, being seductive/intimidating, bargaining, etc. And magic, if you have it.
>>
No. 19054 ID: 4178ee

>>328853

All depending on the individual in question, of course.
>>
No. 19103 ID: 4178ee

>>328853

Also competencies.

I have to remember not to post about this sort of thing when I'm tired.
>>
No. 19110 ID: 8bdb6a

Is there some special technique for /quest/ to use dickery? Due to the multi-person nature of suggestions, the suggestions will "forget" that a certain falsehood is being maintained. Would Saulanna go against a majority to maintain a facade?
>>
No. 19129 ID: e31d52

>>328910
There needs to be motivation: Look in Golem Quest and you'll see we're very good at appearing to be a mage distance-controlling a golem, rather than the worldly anathema that is a sentient golem.
>>
No. 19130 ID: 9f4050

>>328929
sometimes we are too good. i think a noob or two actually thought we were mage.
>>
No. 19131 ID: 7ff337

>>328910

I try not to have Saulanna do anything she'd think of as stupid. If she uses deceit, she'll try keep it up until she has a reason not to. Her Dickery is not extremely high, though, and the Smoothtalking Competency she picked up is only Average, so a very complex or unbelievable deception may result in a mistake on her part. And there's always a chance of being seen through by a very perceptive character.
>>
No. 19133 ID: 86745d

>>328930
Well we never let up on it, even a little, so unless they were avid followers and not just bandwagonists, I can see them thinking that.... nah.
>>
No. 19238 ID: af4fba

From what I've seen, I'm pretty sure this guy is a Daybreak caste abyssal. They tend to be very good necromancers, and from his introduction that is likely what he is skilled in. Also, they tend to be very focused on knowledge and education. This may work to our favor, considering our connection to Wordblood.

And speaking of Wordblood, if he is a part of Saulanna, doesn't that make her a "proto-primordial"? If primordials have more than one soul, and Saulanna now has TWO souls (seeing as Wordblood is a "part of her"), it stands to reason that she may in time go so far as to BECOME a primordial.

But that's just a theory, so I dont think its very possible.
.....right?
>>
No. 19241 ID: d1b9a6

>>329038

>if Saulanna has enough Titan's Will
>anything
>>
No. 19243 ID: 8bdb6a
File 127843930070.jpg - (11.22KB , 300x222 , 126113542169.jpg )
19243

>>329041
>>
No. 19261 ID: 68fbf2

should i make a infodump on how primordial works?

well i was gonna suggest something but then i realized it would be very close to trolling. plus im completely uncertain if pilgrin king is a plot device or a villain.

we should flee from him. we definitively cannot lie about what or who we are without him noticing. even the spenditure of MP to increase those status would be noticeable to him.

assuming he is a good diplomat and knows strong necromancy, we should have a bit of a advantage running and escaping him. im affraid we already gaved a name so he may have a easy time "affecting" us in the future, but when the soulfire dims to nothing we should just scamper to his back. this may or may not get us killed, but he has something in storage for us, and that is not a good thing.

there is the possibility he contains saulanna's soulmate exaltation. if this is true, it does suck. but there will be cuddling, so im partial to it.
>>
No. 19263 ID: 8d16ab

>>329038
>Saulanna now has TWO souls (seeing as Wordblood is a "part of her")
Or three, depending on how you count the mobling.

On a slightly related topic, does anyone have any ideas as to what's going on with Wordblood? Seems to me that either he accidentally damaged/overexerted himself in his attempt to scramble Kaan's suggestion, or he's "hiding" from the guy the same way he'd "hide" from Luna, or proximity is making him cut up in some way that has to do with whyever we were locked up at Kaan's Manse to begin with. It's worrying, but I get the feeling it's *intended* to be worrying?

We should probably try to find some literature for him to snack on when we have the free time, anyway.
>>
No. 19264 ID: 08aa7e

>>329063
since he is pure soul if he was dead he would of vanished so we know he is still alive, probably needs more energy. maybe we should read a good book, that may get him back up.
>>
No. 19265 ID: 8d16ab

...actually, question: are there even any proper primordials left in the basic setting, other than Gaia? From my limited knowledge of Exalted I only really remember there being Autochthon (who picked up his ball and went somewhere else), the Yozis (who have surrender terms on them that prevent them from doing a lot), and the Neverborn (who are dead). If Wordblood is right about there being other Titanic fragments lying around, there really is something unique and important going on here.
>>
No. 19267 ID: f95872

>>329061
>should i make a infodump on how primordial works?
No
>>
No. 19273 ID: 68fbf2

>>329065
as far as i know you are right, no other primordial exists in creation, at least not a sane one.

>>329063
any primordial is literally kill on sight even for the solar exalted.

for example, autch-kun stole whole cities when he left. if gaia cough hard some mountains crumble on cities and other equally huge disasters.

there is also another oddity, wordblood is in a very "primordial" state in a manner that makes no sense at all.

>>329067
too bad, i checked the old infodumb and its there. >>328313
>>
No. 19274 ID: d560d6

Well, damn, do I regret skipping over "another ??? ??? oh noes amnesia" quest. So much catch-up.

>>/quest/90322
CHESTTUFT ACTIVATE
>>
No. 19280 ID: 8bdb6a

>any primordial is literally kill on sight even for the solar exalted.
Eh, I'm sure we can make it work. Plus, with an exaltation, and a single body, we won't have the same vulnerabilities.
...though, sheesh. Talk about counting your chickens before they hatch. This is something to worry about several threads from now, if we're lucky.
Still, I'm looking forward to it. It seems completely awesome. I hope the majority goes forward with incredibly ambitious plans like that.
>>
No. 19351 ID: 5696f7

>>329065
There's one or two clues in the books that a primordial MAY have escaped and hid in the darkest deepest parts of the underground. It's clearly nothing more than a "hey plot hook idea!" but it's there.

On a side note, if we ever need to persuade Wormblood, we might be able to use the promise that we'll (or we'll get someone to) develop new languages after things are settled and we're in a position of little urgency and significant freedom.
>>
No. 19353 ID: df7322

i say wordblood's trust lvl is at least 8~9 out of ten. he severely injured himself scrambling the command. it may have been all part of a plan to earn our trust though, which is why he isn't a ten yet. still, we can trust him somewhat.
>>
No. 19382 ID: 67c611
File 127855537817.gif - (1.04KB , 16x16 , Lunar_Quest_Favicon.gif )
19382

favicon
>>
No. 19383 ID: 9f36e6

>>329080
i fail at writing small posts =c

also i am pretty sure pilgrin is toying with us.
>>
No. 19385 ID: 8bdb6a

Abyssals are not "combat specialized." That's not really how exalt types work. The different castes do different things. Plus, if you were to make such a judgment call, Lunars would be combat specialized, too.

And, once again: This ISN'T canon exalted. It's different. The rules are different. The universe is different. The situation is different.
>>
No. 19486 ID: 00b231

they are solar mirrors but with the intent to destroy. how is this not combat specialized?

>>/quest/205348
he is a manipulative bastard i will give you that. but until we discover his intent and objectives, he is not a enemy. like i said, some deathlords are outright wrong with their choices for exaltation. i am however perplexed at his unwillingness to strike us physically.

we are still alive for some odd reason, so its safe to say we will either have combat in the next update or we already are a part of his plan in some way.

the only real doubts i have is who is his master, what are his plans and if we are really connected as soulmates.
>>
No. 19493 ID: 00b231

huge post ahead containing the interaction with Pilgrin, feel free to ignore:

he control us to leave the hole to talk to him. we resist but show pacifically anyway. wordblood is exausted. i couldnt facepalm harder at this action.

then we spend a mote point to store the music box. pilgrim does not notices it. he announces himself elegantly with a lot of titles indicating a likely scourge with necromancy spells.

saulanna has the sensation she knew him already. this may be from her adquired memories or the exaltation. i consider this important, since it could means we know what he actualy is. he declared he had enhaced his charm a little and claimed that he expected us to have done that already. he says he offers protection and services to the ghosts and asks us to take human form, a practical excuse was given wich he tooked without complains.

he tries to probe us for our origins. we have a small talk with gevin and wordblood, to then spend a dot of moon power to help wordblood recover (lol, tooked a long time). pilgrim takes notice, but does not complain. wordblood hints that we can use the power word stop to halt these social attacks. THEN we give the tale, a bit extravagant but that explains the lunar exaltation and our appearance. its possible he belives we used the moon power to increase our intuition/charisma to make a beliveable tale.

upon asked the message that we left with the thugs, a generic "oh fuck" is given. we relate that it was mostly a message from someone else to the ruler of these lands. he seems to buy it, but becomes more relaxed. he points out that he never mentioned a runaway slave and gives a sob story of how he cared for the slave because of her memory loss, also mentioning he needed to remember her of that constantly.

upon asked if we knew of where the slave was, he receives a mostly "we dunno" answer, but we inquire of who she was. he politely refuses to tell of her private life and handle us a bouquet of black roses.

we are here now, and the way things are, i would not be surprised if saulanna suddenly had a memory flashback from the bouquet.

id also like to point out that despite the thugs never saw saulanna in human form, she appeared to them shackled and untatooed. i do not know anything that would explain the soul bonfire at all. added that to the huge mouth we have, its pretty safe to say we lost the social duel.
>>
No. 19518 ID: c4c313

>>329293

Yeah, we were pretty much boned after >>/quest/194403

Democracy at work!
>>
No. 19519 ID: 8e2486

>>329318
we didn't do that. the mark and all that was not done, we just gave them a vague threat of leaving or we will kill them next time.

seriously, our biggest issue is what we want her to do. if we ate or killed those ghosts as well we wouldn't of needed to worry about them giving a message to anyone. simply put, but being a pacifist we let someone gain information.
>>
No. 19533 ID: e67770

>>329319
no the craving didnt happened. but the message did.

now he is all like "wow, she IS full of shit" and thinking in how many ways he can pimp us for that music box.
>>
No. 19534 ID: 8e2486

>>329286
whelp looks like you are wrong, this guy is an asshole and deserves to be munched.
>>
No. 19536 ID: 8e2486

>>329333
PS, from now on assume all abyssals are out to get us until proven otherwise.
>>
No. 19537 ID: 076306

Ok, someone suggested to "Use 6 points of power to upgrade all around". Sorry, cannae do. Shapeshifting can be used separately, but in one "action" you can use a moon ability or moon boost one talent.

Saulanna has to become more powerful before she can combine moon abilities together, including the moon boost.

Just getting that info out there.
>>
No. 19543 ID: e67770

yeah i was pretty sure that it could happen, but that we could try to diverge it by gettin in his good side. mostly after he talked about the message i was pretty certain he was a enemy.

>thinking in how many ways he can pimp us for that music box
im not sure, but if we fall unconsious we shoulnt lose the contents of the inner den.
>>
No. 19547 ID: c4c313

He doesn't know we have the music box. I don't even think he knows about the music box! He may know of it and it might be the key to his destruction, but I would not bet on that..

Pilgrin knows, with a very small shadow of a doubt, that we are his escaped prisoner. We basically gave him that information point blank. That's why he's knocking us out (not killing us) and that's why he wants to capture us. No box, nothing like that, just our strange mysterious past, and I wouldn't doubt the blood sucker himself is the one who made us an amnesiac.
>>
No. 19548 ID: c4c313

Frankly I don't think Pilgrin is doing anything particularly evil. This is more our fault than his. He's trying to minimize the damage, not do anything horrible or inhumane yet. That doesn't mean I think he's not evil. Just he hasn't proven himself yet to be so. If he gets us and takes us back to his evil dungeon of forgetty to be tortured, then he'll be evil, but right now I'm laying the blame for this solely on >>/quest/194403

(Well that and Jukashi took one single anon's "quick idea" and had Saulanna decide to do it just because it'd get us in trouble later. =_=)
>>
No. 19549 ID: 42838c

I think it's "Peregrin." Like the falcon.
>>
No. 19550 ID: e67770

>>329347
he knows of the music box. his thugs where stealing it. we saved the dude with the music box. they saw us taking off with it.

>>329348
the plot.

it must go on.

even if it is on rails.
>>
No. 19551 ID: e67770

>>329349
oh. falcon king.

thats not bad.
>>
No. 19553 ID: c4c313

>>329350

His thugs might have mentioned that. But basically they saw Gevin with the box, grabbed it from him on general looting principles, and then started interrogating him on the whereabouts of a girl with long hair in manacles. Pomegranate sure as heck didn't order them to seek out any music box. All they were really after was Saulanna.
>>
No. 19556 ID: 8bdb6a

Well, told you guys he was evil, (also, the sky is blue) but on the other hand, I also figured he'd never use a trick like that. Whoops. Lesson learned.

>>329343
I mean this in the nicest way possible: Please, please stop acting like you know everything. We realize you've read every exalted sourcebook and we're all very, genuinely impressed, but please try to tone it down, if it's not too much trouble.
>>
No. 19577 ID: e67770

>>329356
i should refrain from posting then =c

facing a experienced exalt, even if on social battles, would be too much of a challenge for a new exalt. i really thought he was gonna be some sort of ally.
>>
No. 19580 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329377
>i should refrain from posting then =c
It's not my quest, so I couldn't tell you to stop even if I wanted. I'm just asking that you stop acting like you know everything. We don't know what's changed from canon exalted, so we can't be certain that any single thing is the same.

...that said, you just assumed that he was one of the tiny fraction of Abyssals who aren't hugely evil? In spite of the fact that he was the person who had Saulanna in shackles? That's just boneheaded. Sorry.
>>
No. 19582 ID: 2eac65

Getting to know someone before you decide to kill and eat them on principle is not being stupid. It's being fair. There's a difference between reading subtext and jumping to conclusions.

And how do we know that Abyssals are so horrible? This is different from canon Exalted, as you yourself just said, and even in canon it's not exactly accurate. Nobody was saying not to be cautious, only that he might not be as bad as you're assuming.

You're calling out 5copper for metagaming, but you're doing the same thing, and personally insulting other users because of it. Stop that.
>>
No. 19583 ID: 538af1

more like he is an abyssal as in FROM THE ABYSS.
all i know about exalted is from reading KoC that is it. just the name abyssal tells me he is bad news. i have no idea what they do other then they want to one day kill everything.
>>
No. 19586 ID: e67770

>>329380
well i was mostly hoping that it would be explained because it makes no sense to face a experienced exalt so soon. as far as i know the slave sob story was unrelated to us because he wanted to dissuade us to go with him willingly.

also i didnt wanted to prosecute him for being a nigger equivalent of a abyssal. now that he literally caught us there are reasons to think he is evil. when we discover what he has been doing with us we will have reasons to eat his soul, rip and tear his guts or something like it.

>>329383
you are gonna LOVE when we find a infernal =3
>>
No. 19588 ID: 8bdb6a

>well i was mostly hoping that it would be explained because it makes no sense to face a experienced exalt so soon
Quit assuming so much.
>>
No. 19589 ID: 2eac65

>>329383
That's basically it. One thing to remember about Exalted, though, is that you are what you make of yourself. Exalted aren't categorized by what they want to do, but by what they're designed to do. Abyssals are the most heavily restricted of the Exalted, but even they don't all try to kill the universe; some of them fight against their masters, some use their powers for their own purposes, and some protect the peace in the Underworld without getting involved in the killing. Same with Solars, Lunars, Sidereals, and any other variety: it's not the powers you have that make the difference, it's the things you do with them.

And canonically, the Abyssals don't work for the Ebon Dragon. They work for the Deathlords. There's no telling what difference that makes.
>>
No. 19592 ID: e67770

>>/quest/205884
each one of those bolded words sounds good for power wording.

i was thinking, would the power word not be so versatile it could be used to deny anything?
>>
No. 19599 ID: 42838c

I've been partial to creating a Power Word that would be something like "Ignore," as in, we could cause someone to ignore or overlook something else, most probably us. It seems to me that we could avoid a whole lot of trouble if we could say "IGNORE ME!" and have it actually work.
>>
No. 19600 ID: 2eac65

>>329399
We already have Mask Sneak for stealth. Unfortunately, it doesn't work while our Soul Fire is on, but I expect any other attempts to make people ignore us will run into the same problem.

Maybe Power Word: Snuff to extinguish our Soulfire? But I'd prefer something with a wider variety of uses.

My main goal with Titan's Will is to think of ways to get more of it. Since it comes from sentient beings, that's going to be a troublesome issue. I'll want to save a point for Efficiency of Consumption, in case we ever run into another soul we want to eat, because it'll give us a point back immediately. Here's another idea:

Soul Harvest
Grass that is uprooted can only be eaten once, but when the grass is merely trimmed, it can regrow from its roots again and again. As it is with crops, it is with souls. This ability will let Saulanna shear off parts of a soul without destroying it utterly, reducing the victim's Soul Force by one level, and granting her a single measure of Titan's Will. This is devastating to the victim's mind and identity, but leaves them the means to regrow into a different person.

This will let us gain strength and keep people with power under control, solving two moral dilemmas at once.
>>
No. 19601 ID: 8bdb6a

I am opposed to making words of power that will only matter in the current situation or extremely similar ones.
>>
No. 19603 ID: 940a91

>>329401
i like clense. anything that could be cleaned will be. never will poisons of any kind bother us.

most powerful and probably expensive as fuck would be DIE and single word that ends a life. don't know about you but high lvls of that would let us kill some bullshit things.
>>
No. 19604 ID: 940a91

>>329400
oh and that Soul Harvest thing sounds bullshit lvl of expensive. probably needs like 20 titans will.
>>
No. 19606 ID: c828d1

Just to clear a few points:

Inner Den can only be used to carry solid objects. No gas or liquid, unless they're inside a container.

Eating only part of the soul is possible (with an upgrade), but it is massively crippling, and no-one can recover from it without powerful magic. Even then, they will almost never be able to return to their full spiritual vitality.
>>
No. 19607 ID: 2eac65

So those plans won't work. Still, no harm in wondering.

We can still use Inner Den through our feet, right?
>>
No. 19608 ID: 8bdb6a

>Eating only part of the soul is possible (with an upgrade), but it is massively crippling, and no-one can recover from it without powerful magic. Even then, they will almost never be able to return to their full spiritual vitality.
Ouch! I wonder what that would be good for? (Aside from getting delicious soul meats without technically killing someone)
>>
No. 19609 ID: e17ed5

>>329408
hmmmm, what happens when a partially chomped soul gets in line for reincarnation?
>>
No. 19615 ID: e67770

asides the horrible idea that maybe saulanna is a partial soul eated victim, this was a largely unsurprising update.

i was gonna suggest power word NOT and efficiency, but it seems we should wait even furter. im worried because im not sure we can escape peregin's influence.
>>
No. 19634 ID: 42838c

Well, we might be able to escape his influence if we kill him. And we might actually have a way to do that. I think that creating Power Word: Confusion and using it on Kaan might incapacitate him enough for Saulanna to go back and rip his throat out. Or just run away freely. Take your pick.

But for this to work, we'd need to decide to use Titan's Will and not avoid it or hoard it.

I think it's our best option. Does anyone disagree, or see any flaws in the basic plan? If so, why, or what?
>>
No. 19638 ID: 2eac65

>>329434
I want to save our Titan's Will to get us out of a situation where we'll need to use it. It's true that we shouldn't hoard it, but we also shouldn't use it when we've got other options which are less costly or more likely to work.

It's against Wordblood's nature to destroy information, which means it'll cost a lot to try, and Kaan specializes in using his mind, so he'll probably be able to shake it off. Basically, we're matching our weakness against his strength.

Instead, we should target his weaknesses. I'm guessing he's a physical-tertiary character, and we know where to find a poison that targets Endurance. That would be a much more reliable way to incapacitate him. Failing that, we could attack him physically in some way; we've got ways of boosting our martial strength, though I'm sure he has some of his own.
>>
No. 19640 ID: aabc6d

>Well, we might be able to escape his influence if we kill him.
jeegus x-ist, i was talking about his informants and personnel.

we cant face him head on with confusion, since mental is at least his second highest atribute, its unlikely this could work. then we have to consider he has magic and can attack us better that we can with our feeblesome physical.

saulanna isnt beardbeard, we need magic before heading experienced villains.

>>329438
that is a very restrictive use of TW. we should rest for now, mostly because he just started to use his motes and we are already half way trhu them.

unless someone wants to eat gevin. then we can waste all TW we want and get the motes back
>>
No. 19650 ID: 4a4aa1

Y'know, I think I'll say now that, it being such a contentious subject, I'm gonna need a vote of at least three people before a Power Word is made. Here in the disc thread, preferably, just so the debate doesn't clog up the main thread.
>>
No. 19651 ID: 4a4aa1

Not that I'm calling for a vote or anything.

I'm just saying, for future reference.
>>
No. 19657 ID: 2eac65

The problem is that we don't know how much Titan's Will any of our ideas would take, or how close they'll be to what we expect them to be. Without knowing that, all we can say is "this would be nice to have".
>>
No. 19660 ID: aabc6d

should we poll on the possible words to make a voting soon?

the way things are going we really should consider doing it asap.
>>
No. 19678 ID: 8bdb6a

I vote we spend one TW on AGILITY.

While a word of power is tempting, most of those being suggested will only be useful in very specific circumstances. Possibly too specific to ever actually be useful. Agility isn't particularly flashy, but it's incredibly broad. Almost every situation can be assisted by more Agility. It'd have helped Saulanna dodge that poison cloud, or climb that cliff, or catch that Ghost Boss without having to use Moon Boost. It'd make her better at running away, attacking, defending, and a bunch of other things.

We like to think that she can think or talk her way out of anything, but so far almost every situation has gotten physical in some way.
>>
No. 19680 ID: 4ecd6a

>>329478
id say efficiency and moon power.

we arent really supposed to work physically, i would be quite sad to discover later on we have charms/spells to defend us without agility.
>>
No. 19681 ID: e973f4

>>329478
I really can't argue with this.
>>
No. 19682 ID: 54af1f

>>329478
Yeah, I agree here. Agility is generally useful and efficient.
>>
No. 19683 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329480
>we arent really supposed to work physically, i would be quite sad to discover later on we have charms/spells to defend us without agility.
"What if, some day in the distant future, we no longer need stats?" doesn't seem like very solid logic.
And "we're not supposed to work" just doesn't make any sense.
>>
No. 19684 ID: c00244

>>329478
This seems a solid choice, although personally my inclination would be to improve either Wordblood's or Saulanna's soul force. The logic is similar there- much like agility, doing so would have a broad set of benefits.

Really, though, more important than what we spend it on it simply that we spend it at all. It does us no good sitting around waiting to be used... and while certain objections have been made to devouring souls, I don't really have a problem with it. We could get a lot of power very quickly that way, which is rather the logical course in our current situation. And it's not really any worse than killing people; they just end up "reincarnated" as part of us, instead of reincarnating elsewhere. In the case of ghosts, who are already dead... why not?

Point is, we should gain as much Titan's Will as possible and spend it to improve ourselves as fast as possible, before someone gets us while we're still weak.
>>
No. 19685 ID: 8bdb6a

>Point is, we should gain as much Titan's Will as possible and spend it to improve ourselves as fast as possible
Agreed. We should spend the second TW on Efficiency of Consumption (Even though Soul Force is handy), both so we get more TW later, and so people start focusing on how to get more, instead of arguing over how to spend the current points...
>>
No. 19689 ID: 54af1f

Can people stop posting giant difficult to read suggestions in the game thread? They're making it much more difficult to read and kind of killing my interest here.
>>
No. 19690 ID: d78b61

so we are agreed. efficiency and agility.
>>
No. 19698 ID: a594b9

>>329485
Agreed.
>>
No. 19700 ID: 2eac65

>>329478
Physical changes take time. We can't do that now, and if we do it later, we can train for it normally. Titan's Will can be used for many other things that we can't just get through training.

Here's an analogy: You want to make a meal. You have five dozen eggs and fifteen dollars. You could use the money to buy some scrambled eggs, or you could scramble your own eggs and buy some sausage and orange juice to go with them.

>While a word of power is tempting, most of those being suggested will only be useful in very specific circumstances.
Yes, it's important to have something with general utility. That's what I've been trying to come up with: suggestions that will be useful in many future situations.

>>329484
Killing people isn't something we do casually, either. That's why forcibly reincarnating someone is a big deal.

Think about what Saulanna's seen so far. She's met a god, a demon, several ghosts, and she's heard of an entire civilization of ghosts which seems to be working out fine. Peregrin Kaan is the first "living" human she's seen. Saulanna isn't going to think that, since ghosts are "dead" already, "killing" them again is no big deal. A person's life doesn't end when their body dies, it ends when their soul reincarnates; that is when their identity vanishes and they become a new person. Life as a ghost is just what comes after life as a mortal; it's just as valuable.
>>
No. 19702 ID: d78b61

>>329500
then we will never get any more TW ever because unless wordblood eats someone we get nothing ever. besides, once he get's powerful enough he can just MAKE more souls to make up for the ones he has taken.
>>
No. 19703 ID: e31d52

Power word: Stop is so utilitarian it hurts. Think about it.
>>
No. 19707 ID: 2eac65

>>329502
Not "never". Just not easily. Sometimes, we might have no choice but to kill a soul, and if that happens, absorbing them into ourself is no worse than forcing them to reincarnate. But it's not something to be done lightly. We shouldn't use it up on something we can just as easily get through other methods on the assumption that we can just get more Titan's Will later.
>>
No. 19708 ID: a594b9

>>329503
I bet the more useful and powerful a word is, the more expensive it will be.
>>
No. 19709 ID: e31d52

>>329508
It's more likley that the more useful a use is, the more expensive it will be. Stopping time will be more expensive than stopping poison.
>>
No. 19715 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329500
>Physical changes take time.
I can find no reference to this.

>We can't do that now, and if we do it later, we can train for it normally.
That's your assumption. Training normally could be incredibly difficult and/or time consuming, for all we know.

>Here's an analogy: You want to make a meal. You have five dozen eggs and (etc)...
Maybe we have something better to do that day than cook. Your analogy assumes that time is free. In this case, 'cooking' could take months of precious time.
>>
No. 19716 ID: d78b61

>>329509
two different costs, TW is how much the word costs whill our MP is how strong a use can be.
>>
No. 19717 ID: 54af1f

>>329515
Not to mention the fact that we're currently in a shadowlands being followed around by some kind of horrible abyssal. We need to get our combat stats up now.
>>
No. 19719 ID: 8bdb6a

And, so maybe upgrading Agility takes a nonzero amount of time. We don't know how long. All the more reason to start ASAP instead of waiting until we desperately need it.
>>
No. 19720 ID: 2eac65

>>329512
>Says who? I can find no reference to this.

>>328141
>It's only when Titan's Will is used to affect the external world (including Saulanna's body) that it will take time, depending on what it is that's being done.
Emphasis mine.

>I think you are just making things up and stating them as fact.
Stop that. You've been hostile and condescending, and now you're outright insulting my honesty. I'm only trying to discuss what to spend our upgrades on; I'd really like to avoid any personal hostility.

>Again, that's your assumption. Training normally could be incredibly difficult and/or time consuming, for all we know.
Maybe, maybe not. We know it's possible, and we're already planning to train Gevin to enter the living world.

But Agility isn't really as versatile as you've said. It'll help us fight, or climb a cliff, but it won't help us lift a rock, solve a puzzle, negotiate a contract, write a poem, or find buried treasure. It's only useful in certain types of physical challenges. Which does include our current situation, but putting a point in Agility will only make us slightly more above average; it won't tip the balance of power in our favor as much as a new, cleverly applied ability could.

Maybe we don't have such an option. But maybe we do, and it should be the first thing we look for.
>>
No. 19721 ID: 8bdb6a

>Stop that.
Yeah, I deleted that awhile ago because I thought I was being too rude. Oh well.

>Maybe, maybe not.
Right. We don't know.

>But Agility isn't really as versatile as you've said. It'll help us fight, or climb a cliff, but it won't help us lift a rock, solve a puzzle, negotiate a contract, write a poem, or find buried treasure.
'Cleanse' isn't exactly going to write you a sonnet either. Also, improving a stat by one level means that it'll be two levels higher while Moon Boosted. Score!

But I think the key issue here is that I don't think we can just 'give up' on agility, or put it on a back burner. It is our main line of defense, offense, and escape, and we keep getting attacked!
>>
No. 19724 ID: 2eac65

>>329521
>'Cleanse' isn't exactly going to write you a sonnet either.
But it will help us with poisons, diseases, and magical effects, and we're probably going to encounter the latter quite a lot. That's not much more, but my point is that Agility doesn't have a clear advantage in that area.

>But I think the key issue here is that I don't think we can just 'give up' on agility, or put it on a back burner. It is our main line of defense, offense, and escape, and we keep getting attacked!
That's true. It would be very useful to improve. But in the long term, we have better options than spending Titan's Will, and in the short term it's a bad idea for several reasons:

It could leave us vulnerable while our body changes.
We're already faster.
Peregrin will still outclass us in melee skill.
We may have other options which will make a bigger difference.

The last one is the important one. We can't hope that one extra point of Agility will push the balance in our favor. We need a more decisive edge.
>>
No. 19725 ID: c00244

>>329500
>Life as a ghost is just what comes after life as a mortal; it's just as valuable.
I understand what you're saying here and it may very well hold true in this setting; it would not do so in many in which I have played, but I'll give the benefit of the doubt here. Therefore I shall clarify and/or alter my position somewhat.

Running around devouring villages- of living mortals, ghosts, or whatever- would be inappropriate. However, I'm more than willing to set the bar for how much someone has to annoy us/piss us off/generally act like a dick in order for us to go after them for their delicious soul quite low. We don't have to be nice, or merciful, or cut other people slack. We need power, and if others give us any excuse to take it from them we should damn well jump on it. Killing people- no matter their form- isn't very nice, but Luna didn't charge us to be nice, she charged us to "kick ass in [her] name".
>>
No. 19727 ID: d78b61

>>329525
we give them ONE chance. they step out of line we give them a warning. step out of line again and NOM NOM NOM!
>>
No. 19728 ID: e5b19f

>>329524
>>329490
i disagree with any PW. since there doesnt seem to be a actual choice asides efficiency and [Atribute], id like to propose efficiency and dexterity, or any other physical status that may help us craft. if at all, we should adquire mastery in a martial art style, but this doesnt seem to be a choice now.

>>329525
we kinda already discussed this. even if there is a perfectly normal undead/ghost society there will be those that are simply too criminal/evil to be a part of it. those, we feast upon.
>>
No. 19733 ID: 2eac65

>>329528
There are lots of other options. Like, for instance, this:

World Reading
Allows the user to see the words and numbers that define the world and everything in it. While active, Saulanna can understand the essential nature of any creature, thing, or magical effect she sees.

Basically, a thematically-adapted version of All-Encompassing Sorcerer's sight. This will be much more useful against Kaan than an agility boost, and it's likely to come in very handy in the future.

But I think we're trying to find one answer to two questions: "What do we spend our Titan's Will on?" and "How do we deal with Peregrin Kaan?" The latter has many answers which don't involve spending Titan's Will at all, and I want to focus on those, so we'll be able to answer the former without compromising long-term effectiveness for short-term effectiveness.
>>
No. 19734 ID: d78b61

efficiency is long term regardless of situation.
>>
No. 19737 ID: 2eac65

>>329534
Yes, Efficiency of Consumption is almost certainly a good choice, because we'll get its cost back as soon as we absorb someone else. But we might need that point for something before we find another victim. The upgrade doesn't change the physical world, so it won't take any time to make. We can get it immediately before the consuming process; we lose nothing by delaying.
>>
No. 19840 ID: e973f4

>>328202
>>/quest/207743
Please stop doing this! It is extremely counterproductive towards us forming a consensus on something for you to just say "no," give no reasons, and accuse one of the other suggesters of trying to start a fight. :C
>>
No. 19842 ID: 2eac65

>>329640
I've said multiple times already why upgrading Agility is a bad idea. He seems to be ignoring them. If he had logically explained why it was actually the best option, that would be one thing, but he isn't.
>>
No. 19843 ID: e973f4

>>329642
... which doesn't change the fact that upgrading agility has approximately seven votes for to what appears to be your one against in this thread. :/
>>
No. 19846 ID: 2eac65

>>329643
I gave reasons. Just saying "no" and ignoring them isn't productive either.
>>
No. 19847 ID: d586b6

I still think being an Abyssal minion for a little while sounds fun, as he shows us the ropes.
>>
No. 19850 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329642
>If he had logically explained why it was actually the best option, that would be one thing
I've explained at least four times:
>>/quest/198786
>>328286
>>328298
>>329478
Your response, each time, was "we can just train it up later." However, this has not convinced me, since we need it ASAP, and we can always get more TW later. That is, if we survive. Hoarding it is pointless.

>>329647
>I still think being an Abyssal minion for a little while sounds fun, as he shows us the ropes.
Well, maybe. But... this is the guy who had Saulanna in chains. The guy who was experimenting on her in the first place. The guy who swore his soul to the gods of death and pledged that he would do all in his power to destroy the world. The guy who tricked and attacked us just a minute ago!
Isn't it a little obvious by now that he's an evil liar? I think he'll go "haha, sucker," and put the PC in stronger chains. Or a mind control collar or something.
>>
No. 19851 ID: e973f4

>>329646
Alright, so, looking through the thread, it appears that you and testpattern continued arguing back and forth on this for some time. Not seeing any "I'm ignoring your reasons" in here and I don't know why you're being so defensive.

I was just saying that "my concerns have not been fully addressed" does not change the fact that we have
>>329478 (>>329483 >>329485 >>329515 >>329519 >>329521) one
>>329481 two
>>329482 (>>329517) three
>>329484 (>>329525) four
>>329490 (>>329502) five
>>329498 six
versus
>>329480 (>>329528) one
>>329500 (>>329507 >>329520 >>329524 >>329533) two
against as far as this proposal goes, which in light of >>329450 suggests that we probably have enough people behind it to do it regardless. :V
>>
No. 19852 ID: 54af1f

>>329650
>Your response, each time, was "we can just train it up later." However, this has not convinced me, since we need it ASAP, and we can always get more TW later. That is, if we survive. Hoarding it is pointless.

It doesn't, for instance, help us escape the crazed Daybreak caste who we're now facing.
>>
No. 19853 ID: 2eac65

>>329649
>Your response, each time, was "we can just train it up later."
That is not the only thing I've said.

>However, this has not convinced me, since we need it ASAP,
We don't need it and can't get it now.

>and we can always get more TW later.
Maybe we won't. How do you know we'll run into another situation where it's morally right to eat someone's soul?

We do, however, know we'll have more training time later.

>Hoarding it is pointless.
Not using it for Agility doesn't mean hoarding it. There are many other things we can use it for.

I've said all of this already. This is frustrating.
>>
No. 19854 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329653
>We don't need it...
We obviously do. What do you want, a list of times we've needed more, already?
>Maybe we won't.
Are you seriously saying that you think the game has this XP mechanic for the purpose of never again being used?
>I've said all of this already.
Here's your problem. You think your points prove you right. We HAVE read your points, but we STILL disagree with you. Repeating them again (and again, and again) won't convince us.
Likewise, my points clearly aren't going to convince you.
Just stop jumping down our throats when we make suggestions we disagree with. You are not the boss.
>>
No. 19855 ID: 2eac65

>>329654
Of course you aren't going to convince me if you spend more effort on belittling me than on logical discussion. I'm not trying to force anyone to agree with me without any consideration. I'm trying to discuss the matter.

>We obviously do. What do you want, a list of times we've needed more, already?
And we've solved each situation without it. You're exaggerating its universal applicability, and you haven't addressed any other options or suggestions.

>Are you seriously saying that you think the game has this XP mechanic for the purpose of never again being used?
You keep misrepresenting other people's points. What I said was that we don't know how freely we'll be able to get Titan's Will, and have reasons to be conservative about it.
>>
No. 19856 ID: 8bdb6a

>And we've solved each situation without it.
And at least two of them could've been solved more quickly and cheaply if we had a higher score. And we probably could've had a chance to dodge that latest attack.

Anyhow. I don't want to argue with you anymore. I keep saying we should agree to disagree, but you just keep bringing it up as though you have conclusively proved us wrong and we're just too stupid to see it, which is not the case. I've made my point in detail, and I don't feel like belaboring it over and over and over until someone gets too tired to continue posting. Please, please, just stop jumping down our throats about it. We just want to spend an experience point in a game. :(
>>
No. 19857 ID: 2eac65

>>329656
I never wanted this to be a personal squabble. All I'm trying to do is talk about what we should do so we can make the best decision. That isn't jumping down anyone's throat.
>>
No. 19860 ID: e973f4

>>329657
My problem is that it feels like you're saying "you guys can't do anything unless I approve it," almost. You and Testpattern are reiterating the same arguments over and over again without really getting anywhere in terms of either of you changing your opinions, and it appears that enough people have been convinced by his arguments rather than yours for his plan to have enough support to go through.

What I am more interested in is that you have made multiple references to plans on how to get out of the current situation that don't involve the use of TW. If you could expand on these, it might give you a better apparent position than "don't do this!"
>>
No. 19862 ID: 2eac65

>>329660
I... wasn't trying to give that impression. I'm sorry for that. Really. I don't want to be that arrogant. I'm just very frustrated because I'm trying to debate the issue and it seems like he isn't responding to or even acknowledging my points, or any of the other options I'm thinking of. Even explaining why my reasons are unconvincing would be enough for a healthy debate.

>What I am more interested in is that you have made multiple references to plans on how to get out of the current situation that don't involve the use of TW. If you could expand on these, it might give you a better apparent position than "don't do this!"
Like I said, that's a whole separate issue. And increasing Agility won't really address it, since it takes time and will only slightly tip the balance of power. It seems to me that people are too focused on "boost Agility" as an answer to both questions, while it isn't the optimal answer to either.

As for the current situation, I've shared a few plans in the main thread. My plan to have him disarm himself as a gesture of trust will also help us if we decide to fight him. The overall goals I'm shooting for are to either escape and continue with our goal of finding Ruive, or incapacitate him and interrogate him for information.
>>
No. 19863 ID: e973f4

>>329662
I'm just saying that if you propose an actual alternative in this thread instead of simply opposing the other plan with a decent amount of weight behind it you might have a better shot at winning people over, is all.
>>
No. 19865 ID: e973f4

>>329662
Also
>it seems like he isn't responding to or even acknowledging my points

That is not how your back-and-forth starting from >>329478 reads at all! Both of you consistently address the other's arguments, even if just to say that you disagree with them.
>>
No. 19874 ID: ec8582

Test Pattern: if you could not choose agility, WHAT would you choose?

Typo: i havent seen your suggestion. am i blind?

Jukashi: barge in conversation and make it efficiency and agility anyway

>>329665
yes i see your point, but they do not elaborate on their opinions. its like a very elaborated "yes it is/no its not" argument.

as far as i noticed:
soul power would give us more MP and better effect on the charms. agility helps conflict. moon power seems to be a wildcard since not even wordblood knows what it will come.

i still want moon power + efficiency =c the only power word that truly feels useful is not. cleanse is very difficult to reuse and now its outdated.
>>
No. 19878 ID: e973f4

>>329674
My votes are for agility + efficiency of consumption, as I've said a few times, and based on what I've read in this thread. :V
>>
No. 19879 ID: ec8582

>>329678
nuts. there goes my idea of using it to get martial art.
>>
No. 19883 ID: 2eac65

>>329663
Alternatives to what? Getting more agility, or getting more agility to help our fight? There are two separate issues here, and I've suggested alternative solutions to both.

>>329678
Yes, buy why?
>>
No. 19884 ID: 5f20de

5copper, 2Edition, to put it plainly: In terms of support, TestPattern has more'n you. Unless you can scrounge up some counter-support, well, agility it'll be.

Personally, I wanted Power Word Confusion and/or a Wordsblood spirit upgrade, and I still don't agree we should boost agility. However much TestPattern argues that it's the single most useful thing we can do, I still think we should set Saulanna in a different direction than the typical warmongery ass-kicking one. And there's the matter of how long an agility 'upgrade' will take in real-time.

That said, seems we're outvoted on the matter, so eh.

...Although, would someone be interested in changing their mind and tossing all their weight behind Power Word: Truth? Might be able to use it to see through illusions, and make people be honest with us, which WOULD be useful. Hell, could've made our conversation with Peregrin a tad more interesting if we'd thought of that earlier.
>>
No. 19885 ID: ec8582

>>329684
thats tecnically 3 against agility upgrade. 1 more and jukashi wont peform it until something else pops up.

saulanna wasnt made thinking in battles, her primary status is mind, with social as secondary. im against agility because that would ruin her build in the future, even if we regard other means of trainning. moon power could give us charms related to social and physical battles. saulanna's soul power upgrade would be a generic, safe upgrade to everything.

im chargin in this battle because i know we need more from peregin and the only way we will get it is if he captures us.

also: PW truth may be easily replaced by some moon charms that increases saulanna's persuasiveness. considering she has high intuition, i think PW truth is not a good choice, even now.
>>
No. 19886 ID: e973f4

>>329683
>yes, but why?
>based on what I've read in this thread

(well, with efficiency of consumption in particular it's also because if there's one thing I've learned from playing games with this sort of mechanic extant anywhere it's that upgrading your ability to get more upgrade points almost always pays off.)
>>
No. 19887 ID: 2eac65

>>329684
That's probably because there hasn't been much focus on other ideas. He suggested it and people just went "yeah". Boosting our Agility is a good idea, just not with Titan's Will.

Power Word: Confusion is a bit specific. Its only use would be incapacitating people. As an alternative, something like [b[Forget[/b] or Submit would have other uses.

Instead of Truth, I'd choose Power Word: Confess, to reveal a person or object's hidden secrets. Less likely to be tricked by clever phrasing, and it resonates strongly with Wordblood's language theme. This would be immediately relevant and useful in the future.
>>
No. 19888 ID: 8bdb6a

If everyone who wants something else counts as a subtracted vote, then we'll never have enough, save if the overwhelming majority wants something.
>>
No. 19890 ID: c00244

>>329687
I don't know that "confess" could affect an object. Something like "Reveal" might be more effective for that purpose while still working for social purposes. Alternately, we could attack the problem from another angle by going with "Discern", used upon ourself to increase our perceptions- and discover if others are full of it, any hidden objects or potentially magics, that sort of thing.

I do think that taking one of the words in this line would be of significant benefit to us in both the short and long term.
>>
No. 19891 ID: 5f20de

>>329687

To assume people have given no thought to their pick is rather, if you'll pardon me saying so, presumpteous of you. Maybe they put effort into following this thread and this argument, and made a calculated decision. Just because someone keep their posts short and sweet, doesn't mean there's no thought behind it. And the point still stands: Test's suggestion has numbers, ours do currently not. Clearly this means he has succeeded better in garnering support than either of us.

Look, if you were looking to raise support for your point of view, it probably doesn't help that your vote so far has mostly been "no, we shouldn't use anything yet", something not many seem to agree with. You've also made a ton of possible upgrade suggestions that have muddied the waters on where you stand support-wise. What ARE you currently championing, exactly? If people aren't clear on that, how can you expect them to support you?

>>329685

I'm fairly sure opposition voices do not subtract support voices. Particularly not when no (semi-equally supported) alternative is available and the number of opposition voices are LESS than the number of support voices, both of which seem to be the case here.

>>329690

"Discern" has a nice ring to it.
>>
No. 19892 ID: e973f4

>>329683
An alternative to the latter, clearly spelled out.

>>329687
>he suggested it and people just went "yeah"
Gee, thanks for presuming that everyone who currently supports that plan does so solely because it's the only plan. >:/
>>
No. 19893 ID: 2eac65

>>329691
>To assume people have given no thought to their pick is rather, if you'll pardon me saying so, presumpteous of you.
You're right. I apologize for that.

>What ARE you currently championing, exactly?
I'm not too certain about any of my ideas. I'm hoping other people will give their thoughts on them.

>>329690
>I don't know that "confess" could affect an object.
The way I imagine it, it would create glowing runes in the air that indicated any hidden purpose or feature of the object. And if used on a person, it would force them to reveal anything they're trying to keep hidden, through outright lies, omission or clever phrasing.

>Discern
I think that's too broad in scope to be plausible.

Alternatively, instead of taking a Power Word to reveal hidden secrets, we could learn World Reading, as I described here: >>329533 That has the advantage of being a persistent effect rather than a one-time thing, but it's also limited in scope and won't help us with our current dilemmma. Then again, there are things it can show us that a Power Word can't.
>>
No. 19899 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329691
>Just because someone keep their posts short and sweet, doesn't mean there's no thought behind it.
A thousand times this. I try to keep my suggestions as short as possible. That doesn't mean I don't put thought into them.

>>329693
>I'm not too certain about any of my ideas.
Just choose the one you think is the best.
>>
No. 19900 ID: a594b9

>>329693
Keep in mind that the more useful, powerful and far-reaching a Power Word is, the more expensive it will be to either make, cast, or both. We're not getting any free lunches here.
>>
No. 19903 ID: 74f2e9

>>329699
i just remembered, wordblood suggested the word "stop" when he recovered from his struggle to resist peregin's command.
>>
No. 19908 ID: bc4f88

blimey

Ok, first a little reminder, since I'm sure Wordblood mentioned this, that an upgrade to Agility or to any physical Talent (or to Beauty) will take a little time. A matter of seconds, but considering that time is spent rewriting Saulanna's control over her body, you would expect a brief period of incapacitation.

This process, too, can be upgraded.

Now, Saulanna would be aware of this, and she probably isn't going to do it with Peregrin in front of her. But, since the majority seems in favour, she will have an Agility improvement when she next has opportunity, and she will instruct an upgrade to Efficiency of Consumption immediately.

That is, with the update.
>>
No. 19909 ID: 5f20de

>>329708

Fair enough. And I guess that uses up our TW supply.

Which means no more arguing! Huzzah!
>>
No. 19910 ID: bc4f88

>>329708

When I mean seconds, by the way, I mean about 10 to 15 seconds, or longer if Wordblood is distracted. The change is an extensive enough working that she'd fall over if she was standing or sitting up.

Agility is the most complicated of the four upgradable Talents.
>>
No. 19911 ID: 74f2e9

wanna bet that next update we will change our minds?
>>
No. 19912 ID: 2eac65

And how long would it take to train?
>>
No. 19914 ID: 8bdb6a

Good to know. Next time, we'll know to just vote for stuff instead of arguing. Preferably, in a hurry, too.

"A good solution applied with vigor now is better than a perfect solution applied ten minutes later." -George S. Patton

(Also, I think your email might be down again, Jukashi.)
>>
No. 19920 ID: 3c77ec

>>329710
Do you have any comments on the viability of the various power word ideas being thrown around? GM review would be appreciated.
>>
No. 19925 ID: 2eac65

Hold up a bit. I wasn't going to continue this argument, but since it looks like we're going to absorb another ghost soon, it's important to remember that Efficiency of Consumption won't reduce the mental strain. We'll need to get Ease of Consumption for that. So let's do that instead of getting Agility, and we can get Agility from the next ghost's soul.

Is this okay with the rest of you?
>>
No. 19927 ID: e973f4

>>329725
Makes enough sense. Nice catch there by the way.
>>
No. 19928 ID: 9f6778

>>329720
Not would be a ridiculously powerful Power Word that would wipe things or aspects of things from existence, or reverse them. It would take large amounts of TW to make and require more MP to cast than Saulanna currently has.

And using it would have... consequences.

Truth would cause a person to become unable to speak falsehood, and alter existing forms of deceit to become blatantly transparent as such to anyone who sees them. It is suited to Wordblood, so 2 TW to make it.

Reveal would be quite powerful: it would cause hidden things to become visible or be spoken (You'd have to have a particular secret at least vaguely in mind, though, or it will just reveal something random) but could also dispel magical concealment at higher levels of Soul Force, open containers and remove impediments to vision, such as mist, curtains or overgrown plants. Or clothes.

Confess would be more direct and more limited; a lesser word than Reveal, as it would only work on people and only make them unburden themselves of things they personally have kept hidden.
>>
No. 19929 ID: 8bdb6a

>>329725
Couldn't we just store him for now?

I agree if there's more than one ghost present, however. That could get tricky. And delicious!
>>
No. 19931 ID: 74f2e9

>>329729
we definitively need the motes and the bonfire from the soul. plus, brand new discussions about what agility buff to get!
>>
No. 19932 ID: 74f2e9

>>329727
i also agree with this extra buff.
>>
No. 19934 ID: 54aa3e

>>329725
very agree, double upgrade consumptions and with the new TW we should get a soul force upgrade for saulunna and wordblood.
>>
No. 19935 ID: 8bdb6a

This is of course also on the condition that we actually get the ghost in our head without trouble.

Where's a Power-Pill when you need one?
>>
No. 19937 ID: 2eac65

Also, he concluded that, since we haven't used any titan magic on him yet, we don't have any useful titan magic. This gives us a chance to surprise him. Using the right Power Word at the right time could win us the fight.
>>
No. 19941 ID: 54aa3e

also, from how powerful it is, NOT could maybe bring back the dead. and simply say to it "you are NOT dead" and.... yeah.
>>
No. 19942 ID: 2eac65

>>329741
It could, but why would we want to? Ghosts seem to be fine as they are for the most part, and once they reincarnate there's nothing to bring back.
>>
No. 19943 ID: 54aa3e

>>329742
just the fact that we CAN is a HUGE deal. the pattern spiders would probably all flip their shit off the handle.
>>
No. 19947 ID: c00244

>>329728
Thanks! Would you mind giving your take on "submit", "silence", "discern", and the suggested World Reading ability? I found those to be some of the more interesting and potentially useful suggestions.

>>329737
This is true, but he might very well be right. We're burning through Moon Power like nobody's business and our soul force is relatively low; perhaps they should be left for until we've got a soul force upgrade or three under our belts. The additional Moon Power would give us a lot more flexibility in using whatever words we create, not to mention that we'd be better with using them anyway.
>>
No. 19948 ID: 54aa3e

>>329747
that's why i propose using two TW from this next ghost to get saulluna and wordblood a soulforce upgrade.
>>
No. 19950 ID: d86f54

>>329748

You need two for EACH's soul force upgrade. So that'd make four.
>>
No. 19955 ID: 2eac65

>>329747
And "cleanse".

I also recall some mention about granting Power Words to other people. How does that work?
>>
No. 19970 ID: 1cef1b

>>329755
the same way it works with saulanna and wordblood.

anyway id say cleanse is a big no. "stop" seems to be the next best bet, we can even tell people to "stop" dying if it comes to it.
>>
No. 19971 ID: e31d52

>>329770
"STOP dying."
"STOP this poison."
"STOP shooting me."
"STOP that falling boulder."
etc etc etc
>>
No. 20173 ID: 2eac65

>>329770
Cleanse won't be much help now, but it will if we run into anyone who uses poison or magical curses, which I expect will be quite often. It can also help us cure the sick; that would be very helpful.

I don't think Stop would be that versatile. I expect it would be limited to freezing people and objects in time, which is still very useful.

On the subject of things that would help us in this battle:

Power Word: Brand
Sends out white-hot runes to deliver a painful message to one or more enemies or objects at a range. Once a target is branded, this word can be used again to make the runes flare up, causing debilitating pain or fatal burns at the user's preference.
>>
No. 20176 ID: e31d52

>>329973
But that's only a combat-useful word. Stop would let us stop things. Lots of things. It's not Za Warudo, its a word of law, it would not only stop the boulder flying in our faces, but the poison in our veins, an opponent's heart or thoughts, thier words, their spells. So long as we could imagine something being stopped, we might be able to stop it.

Meanwhile, Brand is pretty much a time-delay firebomb.
>>
No. 20182 ID: 620bfb

>>329771
"STOP EXPLODING YOU COWARDS!"
>>
No. 20188 ID: 2eac65

>>329976
If Stop were as broadly useful as you expect, it would be prohibitively expensive.

>Meanwhile, Brand is pretty much a time-delay firebomb.
Also useful as a method of coercion, especially if we could set up different triggering conditions.
>>
No. 20209 ID: 516618

>>329973
now you are just fantasizing. we are using the meaning of the word as magic, not as a spell. it would not make sense for brand to use a curse by itself.

brand could work as a means to mark a target and keepit in check. so if he is hiding we could brand him for everyone to see, or use branding to use effects of charms and spells in someone previously branded. maybe even use branding to make his anima flare.
>>
No. 20220 ID: 331878

GENERAL NOTE: Keeping in mind this Quest uses a turn-based battle system, please suggest actions when Saulanna is fighting, rather than broad strategies.

>>329973
Brand would be a minor Power Word that makes a mark on something, that's all.

Cleanse would make things clean, and help with infectious diseases and with poison but not with most other afflictions. Also, though those things might be removed, their symptoms could persist for a time.

I explained Stop before. It halts the current motion of something that is moving, and at high levels will freeze things for a while. Using it to Stop the spread of poison would not be a good idea, you'd probably end up stopping your own heart.
>>
No. 20225 ID: 9ded95

after wordblood digests this guy stop would perfect, it has low power requirements and even if it just stops him for just a moment, that opening we can do something nasty.
>>
No. 20239 ID: 2eac65

>>330025
That's true. Or maybe something like Bind or Wrap or Weave. Some way to capture Kaan so we can extract information out of him instead of just killing him.
>>
No. 20253 ID: 69beeb

>>330039
maybe. we may need to keep a secret on what we can or cant do yet.

if possible, we should peform wordblood soulpower upgrade or maybe saulanna's soul power + moon boost. something we shouldnt notice so easy.
>>
No. 20257 ID: e31d52

>I explained Stop before. It halts the current motion of something that is moving, and at high levels will freeze things for a while. Using it to Stop the spread of poison would not be a good idea, you'd probably end up stopping your own heart.
My bad! I thought that would be more like Halt. I wonder... is momentum conserved? Like, once stop wears off, does something continue as if it hadn't? Because I can imagine some interesting combat tactics with that.
>>
No. 20269 ID: 8e7d2a

>>330057
Oh god no

Physics discussions in any sort of Exalted setting never end well.
>>
No. 20270 ID: d3dfb8

>>330069
Discussions in any sort of Exalted setting never end well.
>>
No. 20276 ID: 69beeb

>>330070
any sort of Exalted setting never end well.
>>
No. 20284 ID: 2eac65

For the future, what about Power Word: Commune, to send messages over long distances?

Or Power Word: Soulfire? Creating false soulfire will mitigate our primary disadvantage in this fight (our lack of stealth), and we can ignite our own to use its bonus power.
>>
No. 20294 ID: 8bdb6a

Do we really need to ask about every single last word that pops into our heads?
>>
No. 20295 ID: 404e6c

>>330094
i agree, would be best to have just a few really good ones then a thousand mediocre ones.
>>
No. 20297 ID: 2eac65

>>330094
We're just making suggestions and talking about them. You don't have to be so hostile about it.
>>
No. 20302 ID: 69beeb

>>330084
everyone first has to understand that the power word is linked to the concept. we are not making complex spells, but quick magical reality-changing concepts we can abuse.

power word dim could act to dim the soul fire? it would be interesting to consider using it in other exalts as well to dim their soul fire buff.
>>
No. 20305 ID: 545b13

>>330095
Considering that narrow or less powerful words cost less Titan's Will to create and less Moon Power to use, there's something to be said for having massive piles of not-incredibly-excellent powers.

I think my favorite ideas so far are Stop, Reveal, and Discern. I'd want to boost our soul before getting any of them, though.
>>
No. 20306 ID: 2eac65

We can also grant Power Word to others. What are the limitations on that? Can we grant one to a mortal, and if so, what will he use to power it? Does it cost more or less than getting one for ourselves? And if we give someone a Power Word and absorb their soul later (like, say, as part of a prior agreement), will we get anything back?
>>
No. 20308 ID: e31d52

Gentlemen, Stop may be good, but what about...

Accelerate?
>>
No. 20310 ID: e31d52
File 127944260498.jpg - (11.47KB , 400x226 , ohyes.jpg )
20310

>>330108
Of course, saving up enough for STOP and ACCELERATE would be rather awesome and hilarious, with the kind of crazy antics we could pull.
>>
No. 20320 ID: 8e7d2a

>>330110
VIEWTIFUL JOE: EXALTED EDITION
>>
No. 20368 ID: ceeb74

>>330057

If something is in the air, it floats. If it's rolling, been pushed, etc., it just stops. A new external force can set an object in motion again. Momentum disappears.

If targeted at a creature, it works more like a command that they have to obey, and certain magical protections can shake it off as if it were any other supernatural compulsion.

>>330084
Commune would let you communicate telepathically with the targeted being.

At this point I'll make note that Power Words usually work on a target Saulanna can see or at least point to, but most Power Words will also work through an ARCANE LINK such as a drop of blood, a lock of hair, a creature's True Name, et cetera. You know the kind of thing I'm talking about.

"Soulfire" isn't actually one word. It's Soul Fire. The Fire of your Soul. But in any case all it would do is cause Saulanna's Soul Fire to appear, either around herself or attached to something else.

Please note that Soul Fire is only light and does not in fact burn any more than regular moonlight does.

>>330106
You can directly graft the ability to use a Power Word onto someone else (which costs TW, but is quick and requires nothing special from them aside having a soul and whatever their equivalent of Moon Power is) or teach it to them: anyone who can learn sorcery can learn to speak Power Words as well. This does not cost TW but does, however, take time and effort, as they need to hear and to practice saying the words themselves, and this is a spiritually strenuous process. They will then be able to teach Power Words that they know to others, but only Wordblood (or Saulanna, if she learns to do it herself) can craft new ones.

>>330108
Makes things go faster.
>>
No. 20369 ID: e31d52

>>330168
I hope we're not annoying you. It's our nature to pick apart a system we are presented with.

Reminds me of my first successful textquest. The players got a hold of a hat that worked like a bag of holding and had a few other functions and then proceeded to use it as a primary weapon.
>>
No. 20377 ID: 8e7d2a

I just want to mention I really love what you're doing, Jukashi, both here and with Keychain. Don't let stupid suggestions get you down, this is a blast for everyone!
>>
No. 20383 ID: 2eac65

>>330168
So if we used Stop to float something (like ourselves after jumping), how long would it last? Could we cancel it at will?

>whatever their equivalent of Moon Power is
Which means no normal humans, I assume. Can ghosts have Power Words?

>anyone who can learn sorcery
Does that mean anyone who knoes sorcery, or anyone with the potential to learn?
>>
No. 20479 ID: 5fa2f4

>>330183

Something that's been stopped in midair remains floating until something else tries to move it (or it tries to move itself), at which point gravity takes notice of it again.

Mortals can be enlightened and develop elementally neutral SOUL POWER. Ghosts can have Power Words grafted onto them but cannot learn them through study - only living souls have the natural potential to use TITANIC MAGICS such as Power Words, Shadow Arts, Sorcery or even Necromancy. Normally, ghosts can only learn their own intrinsic Ghost Powers. Even if they knew such things in life, that only leaves them the ability to teach once they're dead.

It's easier for a person to learn Power Words when they know Sorcery already, but it's not essential.
>>
No. 20486 ID: 2eac65

>>330279
>Mortals can be enlightened and develop elementally neutral SOUL POWER.
Does this cost any more than simply giving them a Power Word, and can it be done separately?

Is it posible to bind a spirit to us as a subsoul without damaging their sense of self? How much would that cost, and what effects would it have?
>>
No. 20548 ID: 736caa

So... how much does it cost to absorb an abyssal?

Also: wordblood does language hax. How hard is it for him to change effects related to language, like, symbols in flying cards?
>>
No. 20549 ID: 736caa

ok, where is the boss fight music from? how can I get more of things like that?
>>
No. 20551 ID: 8e7d2a

>>330349
By paying Daddy Cool lots of money to gain access to a secret area of VIP quality
>>
No. 20559 ID: bffb4b

>>330286

Giving a mortal enlightenment "by magic" would cost 2 measures of TW; providing a single Power Word for use costs only 1, but to actually use it you need Soul Power (or Moon Power or Sun Power or Death Power or etc. etc.). As with other forms of direct gift, however, the mortal's magic would then be slightly elementally flavoured, influencing their aptitude with various magics.

Methods exist for mortals to be enlightened in a more "pure" fashion, but this is either very dangerous or requires a lot of time and effort.

I suppose I should explain about the Elements.

There's DIVINE MAGIC, under which the intrinsic powers of gods and elementals belong, as well as the Abilities of the Sun, Moon, Star and Dragon Heroes. It's relatively cheap and easy to use but you can only normally learn it if it's part of your nature to begin with. It comes in flavours of the CELESTIAL ELEMENTS (Sun, Moon and Star) and the TERRESTRIAL ELEMENTS (Earth, Air, Fire, Water and Wood). Then there's TITANIC MAGIC, such as Sorcery, Necromancy and the intrinsic Abilities of certain beings. Under this heading are also the powers unique to each Titan, and are also grouped like elements: Wordblood's Power Words are linked to the concept of Language, the Dragon's Shadow's Shadow Arts are obviously linked to the concept of Darkness, et cetera et cetera. There's SELF MAGIC, which harnesses the internal power of your own body and soul; the primary example of this is the Supernatural Martial Arts, although other species long ago had their own forms. Ghost Powers also fall under this category, once you're dead. And finally there's CHAOS MAGIC, drawn from the madness beyond reality, which is typically used by the Fae. It is very cheap but also very unreliable, being mostly illusion and trickery. Hard to learn, as well, though Lunars such as Saulanna can, with a teacher.

It is possible to absorb a soul without taking their sense of self - or at least, the appearance of it. You can even leave them alive in their own body, if they're not dead yet! But they are still an extension of you, and will do whatever you want them to do; if you leave them alone, they will act on their own best judgement and according to their personality, but they will essentially have no free will in regards your desires. Essentially they are turned into a sock puppet, with your metaphorical hand up the rear end of their soul. The upside for them is that will now be more powerful and have access to your magic, as you do to theirs, and you can use TW to improve them as if they were you. Which they will be.

Such a perfect absorption, however, can only be done with prior consent! This is basically the sell-your-soul deal.

>>330348
Once he's dead, he can be absorbed as easily as any ghost. Alive though, he can't be absorbed without his free will. The HERO'S SOUL specifically prevents such things. The best you can do is crush his soul into a broken mangle of suffering!

Wordblood does not have any more than normal power over direct pictographic representations, unless they mean something different from what they actually look like. There is a bit of grey area on this, though.

>>330349
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night. Techno remix of music from the original Castlevania.

The piece is called "Vampire Killer".
>>
No. 20560 ID: bffb4b

Man.

Renaming things from Exalted is more fun than I would have expected.
>>
No. 20561 ID: 8bdb6a

If canon Exalted called it a "Hero's Soul" instead of an "Exaltation Shard," it'd probably make the whole concept easier to explain.
>>
No. 20564 ID: bffb4b

>>330361

Yes!

Hun and po, then, I'll just call them the NOBLE SOUL and the BEAST SOUL. Easier to understand even than "higher" and "lower", and still pretty cool-sounding.
>>
No. 20565 ID: 8bdb6a

I still prefer 'Primordial' to 'Titan,' but... it certainly beats 'Yozi.'
>>
No. 20603 ID: 37bccd

At this point I will mention: Saulanna is more prone to anger and violence when she's in her War Form.
>>
No. 20807 ID: 42838c

So what units of time is Wordblood counting in there? On the order of seconds, minutes, beyond?
>>
No. 20809 ID: f4d08a

>>330607

Turns!
>>
No. 20834 ID: d93589

i didnt wanted to clog the main trhead but i wanted to talk about what peregin is doing, so in order to maximize me not being cared for, i decided to post here!

im pretty sure peregrin is draining saulanna's motes, but trhu the old fashioned way of exausting the opponent. the "rage" spell must have been to force saulanna to engage him nonetheless, and now he must be waiting for us to be weak enought to send in the attack of his army.

its possible we can pretend to be weak and force a early activation of his trap, but im not sure this is possible. if we show him we can "digest" souls he should either adapt his strategy or run.
>>
No. 20843 ID: 68584a

>>330634
he doesn't know that eating dudes gives us more motes.
>>
No. 20846 ID: cfe1c2

we already had a soul bonfire because of it. even if he didnt considered it by then, when we recover motes and have another bonfire it will be impossible for him to think otherwise.
>>
No. 20877 ID: 2eac65

>>330359
And how much would those options cost, in terms of time and resources? Do we need to increase our power for any of them?
>>
No. 20878 ID: 593c69

okay, when this guy finishes being eaten what should we do with the 2 or 3TW we get from him? assume it's two points and have anything for the third point under 'optional'
i think increasing saulunna's soul force would be good.
>>
No. 20880 ID: d5220e

>>330678
if i had the photoshop skills, id place saulanna saying "ITS TW CHOICE TIME!" with a curling wordblood in the floor screaming "NO SAULANNA, NO!"
>>
No. 20881 ID: 8bdb6a

We already have one earmarked to Agility. Good thing, since we're just not quick enough to reliably hit Peregrin.

The second TW should either be more agility, or Power Word: Halt.

If I had to vote for just one, it'd be Halt.
>>
No. 20882 ID: c00244

>>330678
I'm with you on the soul force bit, I think. I don't want to start playing with power words until we have enough soul force to really back them up; using them before that seems like showing an ace we don't have to. A dangerous ace, since anyone who hears us use them and knows what's what will immediately catch on to the fact that we're no normal Lunar.
>>
No. 20883 ID: d5220e

>>330681
that is counting with the 15 seconds needed to implement agility buff?

i am against any power word. maybe stop or halt indeed, but id rather not to. how about something that can help us when we get actual magical spells?
>>
No. 20885 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/213132
>Eating people's souls isn't the only way to gain strength.
It's the only currently known way. The other methods are "maybe someday somehow theoretically."

>>330682
I'm a little fuzzy on what soul force is good for when we don't have any power words or spells or anything.
>>
No. 20886 ID: 714b9c

>>330685

To be precise:
>other methods

Given time and practice, Saulanna can train herself in things the mortal boring way (and can do it faster and better with a teacher). The way things work in quest-Exalted, she will also occasionally mature new Moon Abilities or Shapeshifting styles over time, but only once her Caste has been set (in which case these "natural" new abilities will be based off her Caste and her needs as dictated by the situations she finds herself in and how she reacts to them). These methods can only improve things natural to Lunars or to ordinary humans, however.

Titan's Will can be gained either by eating souls (or spiritual beings such as gods, elementals and demons, but these will be harder to subdue than most human souls) or by absorbing Titan Fragments: Titan Fragments will also give Saulanna whole new types of powers, based on the nature of the Titan who lost them.

Saulanna can also gain supernatural power by being worshipped as a goddess.

>what soul force is good for

Soul Force increases general supernatural resilience and power; it will also increase the level of the things Saulanna can learn (so if Saulanna doesn't increase her Soul Force, she will never develop the most powerful/useful abilities and shapeshifting; several other things, such as sorcery, also need high Soul Force). Each dot of Soul Force will also increase Saulanna's Moon Power pool by three.

Soul Force is effectively a combination between regular Exalted's Essence and Willpower. it costs an amount equal to its current rating to improve.

I will also take this moment to say that increasing a Talent (such as Agility) costs 1 TW plus 1 for each time you improve it this way; hence since Saulanna's base Agility is 2, increasing it to 3 will cost 1, increasing to 4 will cost 2, etc.
>>
No. 20887 ID: d5220e

in exalted, some charms use essence/soul power to determine their potency. we would also get a MP increase.

actual, regular trainning is always possible. we need to find a lunar tribe anyway.

yes we do. they can even teach us magic spells and other charms, the tatoos are a big bonus if we choose to hide in the wyld.
>>
No. 20890 ID: 8bdb6a

What I meant was more that TW's the only method of improvement that we actually know the mechanics of, and the only one we actually have access to right now. Sorry for being unclear.

Normal training and learning takes awhile, but soul-eating lets us run around turning bystanders into power in minutes. Though, I think we need to worry more about Peregrin at the moment. He's full of dirty tricks. If, however, he's leaving us alone for now, gobbling up a whole crowd of mooks and leveling right the hell up, in flagrant defiance of normal character progression, is damn tempting.

Also, Soul Force looks equivalent to Permanent Essence, meaning it's very important over the long term, but isn't so great for immediate benefits.
>>
No. 20892 ID: c00244

>>330686
>once her Caste has been set
Can I get an explanation of this for those of us with weak Exalted-fu?

>Saulanna can also gain supernatural power by being worshipped as a goddess.
What kind of supernatural power are we talking here? And just how much worship do we need to get it- are we talking one guy silently praying, or cities conducting daily blood sacrifices atop grand temples to our glory?

>>330690
>gobbling up a whole crowd of mooks and leveling right the hell up, in flagrant defiance of normal character progression, is damn tempting.
Is it ever. I back this plan completely.

>Soul Force... isn't so great for immediate benefits.
The greatest immediate benefit looks to be the extra dots of moon power. Throwing four titan's will at increasing our soul force would give us a 50% increase in maximum moon power, which is huge- since our moon power is basically the limitation on how long we can keep pulling powerful tricks out of our hat in combat, we'd be able to fight half again as long when we need to. Throwing general resilience and power increases on top of that is just icing on the cake, at least in the short term.

Admittedly, there are diminishing returns here- if we have thirty moon power, getting another three doesn't count for much. But for now, we're looking at dramatic improvements in our abilities with soul force increases.
>>
No. 20893 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330692
True, but you have to compare it to other things we could spend 4 TW on, like stat bonuses (meaning more ability for zero MP expenditure) or Words of Power. ("Halt" could help us hit Peregrin)

While more MP couldn't hurt, we've already got enough to buff ourselves and then Moon Boost for several turns, which is all we can really do with our powers right now.
>>
No. 20895 ID: 8bdb6a

>Can I get an explanation of this for those of us with weak Exalted-fu?
Different Exalted types are further subdivided into different Castes. The Solars have the Dawn (warrior/general), Zenith (demagogue/king), Twilight (sorceror/artificer), Night (spy/assassin), and Eclipse (diplomat/politician) caste.

Lunars have the Full-Moon (physical), Changing Moon (social) and No-Moon (mental) castes. Unlike Solars, they don't exalt with a caste, but instead choose one, and have it 'fixed' by having their skin tattooed with elaborate moonsilver designs. Whichever phase of the moon this happens under decides their caste.

Right now, because it's a Full Moon in the quest, Saulanna counts as a Full Moon. In normal Exalted, a casted lunar also gets other benefits for getting their tattoos (full moons get higher physical stats, no-moons get higher mental stats, etc) but we don't know if that carries over to Lunar Quest.

PS: Peregrin appears to be a Daybreak-caste Abyssal, which is basically a Twilight-caste Solar except evil. That would make him a sorceror/artificer/scholar/all-around-nerd. (Though exalts don't always have to fit the archetype, nor behave like their stats dictate. Just look at how Saulanna took Mental as her best abilities, but has spent most of the quest running around punching things.)
>>
No. 20896 ID: c00244

>>330694
>Right now, because it's a Full Moon in the quest, Saulanna counts as a Full Moon.
So we're getting benefits from this caste system already? Does this imply that as long as we don't tattoo ourselves, our caste will remain unfixed and we'll get a shifting set of benefits?
>>
No. 20898 ID: c00244

>>330697
>casted lunars are immune to reality-warping effects, such as Yozi (read: Titan) magic
Couldn't this be a problem for us? We're using Titan magic to warp ourselves every time we pay Titan's Will for a stat increase.
>>
No. 20899 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330696
Yes, but in canon Exalted, casted lunars get an additional bonus to their stats. A big one. For this reason alone, PCs almost never play casteless lunars. Additionally, casted lunars are immune to reality-warping effects, such as Yozi (read: Titan) magic or the mutating effects of the Wyld. (which can turn casteless Lunars into insane shapeshifting tentacle monsters)

We have no idea if, or how, this stuff carries over to Lunar Quest.

(Woops, I deleted/reposted because of a mistake after someone replied to the post I deleted, here: >>330698
Sorry!)
>>
No. 20900 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330698
It very well could be. We're just speculating, though. We don't know how it works in this quest.

If that's the case, well, all the more reason to spend a lot on stat improvements ASAP, huh?
>>
No. 20901 ID: 2eac65

Responding to the actual question:

>>330678
Something that will catch Peregrin off guard, and something to keep him from deceiving us.
>>
No. 20902 ID: 49cd6d

>>330700
i thought of something great. we use TW to become a Tri-caste. get full benefits of all castes at the same time, immunity to the wyld but still able to be effected by wordblood. making us immune to the wyld shouldn't be that hard for something that can reshape reality.
>>
No. 20903 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330702
That would be pretty fucking sweet.
>>
No. 20904 ID: e346c1

>>330692

Worship goes in levels from a few villages' worth of people, on up to several towns worth, up to a city-state, to a sizeable nation, to several nations, to a large portion of the world, to the whole world. Most Heroes only gain increased Power regeneration from being worshipped, but Saulanna will also develop godly powers appropriate to what he's being worshipped as.

Saulanna can also get godly powers by eating gods, but in both cases the gods as a whole will notice her more the more powerful she gets and there will be consequences.

On the subject of Soul Force, I will remind that Saulanna and Wordblood gain Soul Force separately, but Saulanna gains the benefit of the combined total. If she grows extra souls, those will also contribute.

HAX

>>330699

Tattoos are indeed still the method the Lunars came up with to fix their castes and protect themselves from wyld corruption.

How the whole thing interacts with Saulanna's situation is yet to be covered in the quest.
>>
No. 20905 ID: 94dc61

>>330704
if we have enough power to eat a god then i am pretty sure we have already practically beaten the quest at that point :P
>>
No. 20906 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330705
If this is like canon Exalted, think Spirited Away instead of God of War. In normal exalted, there's a whole gradient of gods of different power. A river would have a god, a town might have a god, a city will have a god. A tree will have its own spirit.
>>
No. 20907 ID: 94dc61

>>330706
oh okay... also would it kinda be like Karas then? the will of the city and it's chosen protector.
>>
No. 20911 ID: 24363d

>>330707
the god can choose to not care to its domain, but losing it, even if to another god, has really bad consequences for him.

a born god that loses his ground becomes senile and weak in the very least, a adquired godhood may have troubles using its skills to the point of maybe losing his status completely.
>>
No. 20912 ID: 8bdb6a

We now have 3 TW. I vote:

-Power Word: Halt
-Power Word: Burn
-Agility (when we have half a minute sideways)
>>
No. 20914 ID: 42838c

If we're going for combat-oriented Words of Power, you could do a lot worse than Power Word: Explode. With that, she could turn anything on the battlefield into an explosive, shrapnel-generating weapon. (Maybe I just like the image of Saulanna quietly opening her eyes after that lightshow, pointing at a tree amidst her foes, whispering "Explode," and making it seem like a bomb has gone off.)

But there are many other options, too. Something like "Liquify" could reduce anything Peregrin has with him to slag. (She might aim it at his cane and drop him to the ground and disarm him at once!)
Something like "Heavy" might multiply the weight of a target, potentially having similar effects as "Fall," though perhaps more long-lasting than a single fall?
Mental effects could theoretically remove our enemies' will to fight, perhaps? Things like "Fear," "Confusion," or even "Laughter" could be incapacitating to foes, perhaps?

And we might get really weird and hack into our opponents' minds more directly, (though this may need more power. I confess that I do not know as much about the effects and requirements of what these Words can do as I would like.) Maybe (emphasis on "maybe," I don't really know,) "Friendship" could make an enemy into a friend, by changing Intimacies, (or whatever they are in Quest-Exalted.)

All of these are just options, (I hope they are. That at least some are!) and our options are, (I believe) not too much more limited than our vocabulary, so I'm just throwing these out here.
>>
No. 20915 ID: e346c1

"Insta-kill" Power Words will tend to be expensive, and Heroes by nature are particularly likely to be able to resist them. This goes as well for powerful mental effects. Other magical creatures are also likely to identify these powers as most dangerous and concentrate their defenses against them if they can.

Regular mortals are, of course, totally boned.
>>
No. 20917 ID: 2eac65

Having two different attack Power Words would be redundant. We should also spend a point non Reveal, which will be useful in a wide variety of situations (for instance, gaining information from prisoners, or removing clothing).

We should choose something that will let us quickly gain a victory or significant advantage, so the thing to focus on will be binding or incapacitating effects. I'm guessing his physical strength isn't too great, so Bind or Weave would be effective if it can catch him. Stop would be a very versatile choice, as we can also use it to make traps. Or we could use Burden or Encumber to increase his weight and make him less agile.

Other options include Oil, to make his cane slip out of his hands (and to make him flammable) or make him lose his footing, or possibly Regret for a mental attack.
>>
No. 20921 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330717
We don't need more wishy-washy ideas that'll only be useful in very nar-
>Reveal, which will be useful in a wide variety of situations (for instance, gaining information from prisoners, or removing clothing).
This is a solid plan.

My vote's unchanged for now, though. ('Fall' is a pretty good replacement for 'Halt,' that said.)
>>
No. 20923 ID: 2eac65

>>330721
"Burn" is more specialized than any of those. Even Oil could be set on fire, and it could also be used for cooking and maintaining equipment. Plus, we're perfectly capable of horribly maiming people ourself, without setting them on fire.

Another option is Renew or something similar, to refill his poisoned flowers and use them against him. That ought to really catch him off guard if we hide it in our Inner Den until we strike. And the word could be used again for any situation where we find old, expended or broken-down tools.

Another question: It was said earlier that we could bind willing subjects to ourself as subsouls. What are the requirements for that? Does it cost any Titan's Will, and can we do it in our current state or do we need more upgrades first?
>>
No. 20924 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330723
>Burn" is more specialized than any of those. Even Oil could be set on fire
The difference between "could be" and "is presently" is immense.
Just because fire is always the same kind of fire doesn't mean it isn't useful in a tremendous number of situations, for a tremendous number of reasons.
>>
No. 20926 ID: c00244

I'm not a fan of "Burn". Fire is an imprecise and overly destructive tool; using manipulation of motion or other properties would be my preferred magical style. "Halt"(/"Stop") or "Fall" are both good as an attack word, and "Reveal" is definitely on my to-buy list (though I still suspect that "Discern" might be a preferable alternative) but it might not be the appropriate time for it at the moment. "Explode" is interesting, and might be worth buying at some point, but not as our first attack spell- that's the sort of thing that we need a large stack of Soul Force to back up before we really make use of it, I think.

If we can get through this spending only a single Titan's Will on a power word, perhaps more soul force is in order. We'll get three more from that other ghost, at least; that should give us enough.
>>
No. 20929 ID: d86f54

>gobbling up a whole crowd of mooks and leveling right the hell up, in flagrant defiance of normal character progression, is damn tempting.

Fully opposed, now and ever. We'll either have to compromise, or keep yanking Saulanna's emotions hither and yon. There are simply some things I will set my foot down on and seek to guide Saulanna away from.

Personally, I can stand the odd gobbling for the right reasons (rather than the very wrong one you're describing there), but I'd like to see some normal character progression as well. As clever as our Ricanya is, she'll be able to learn skills commendably fast, provided we make the effort of having her do so, and finding teachers.

'sides, keep in mind, the more powerful we grow by unorthodox means, the more attention we'll get. Last flare-up brought us Peregrin. Who knows if anything new noticed us this time?

>A whole load a words.

The more I think on it, the more 'Halt' seems like a good choice, so I'm throwing my support in full behind it now.

It can be used to line up foes for DEATH STRIKES, delay a chasing foe (or catch up with a foe we're chasing), put mooks out of commission while we fight the Big Bad, allow us time to explain our situation to someone who's attacking us for Wrong Reasons, jump from a mountain and survive by halting herself, etc.

For a one-TW PW it seems pretty handy.
>>
No. 20930 ID: 3fcfb0

>We're robbing people of their futures and identities here
>futures and identities
ghosts have no future, they are eternally trapped doing whatever it is they did in life. and re-incarnation strips them of their old identity anyway. seriously we are not doing anything as bad as you seem to think. also, once wordblood is powerful enough he can MAKE souls. NEW souls, not the reused a thousand times system they have now.
>>
No. 20932 ID: 2eac65

>>330729
Personally, I think Stop just sounds better.

We could also use Reveal as an attack, if we ask sufficiently distressing questions, such as "What was the most painful moment of your life?" or "Of all the people you've killed, who do you regret killing the most?"

>>330730
All the ghosts we've encountered have acted just like living mortals would. They have the same thoughts and feelings they did when they had their bodies; if there are any exceptions, they haven't been apparent.
>>
No. 20933 ID: 5c3933

>>330732
sure they ACT normal...

what about ghosts that want to not be here anymore? like they want to move on, would they be okay to munch?
>>
No. 20936 ID: 2eac65

>>330733
If we can convince them that uniting with our soul is preferable to another life as a mortal, but it's really up to them.
>>
No. 20938 ID: d86f54

>>330733

'cept from the looks of it, not all ghosts are like that in Exalted. Our buddy was, but we shook him out of it and since then he's been very human-y.

I think ghosts willing to pass on would be problematic to munch especially because they WANT to move on and get a 'new' life. We might be able to create one for them with enough TW, but then we'd have to spend it on that, rather than upgrading ourselves... which means it might be simpler to just help them move on to reincarnation.

As for reincarnation stripping them of their identities... I've ceased to look at that as a viable excuse for chow-timing ghosts with abandon. While admittedly without having much setting-based knowledge, I suspect there is more to Exalted's reincarnation system than simply losing one's identity and being recycled back into Creation. The long backlog of souls (and even the total identity strip) that was mentioned earlier on is also based on Standard Exalted-lore, so Lunar Quest might differ on some points there.

This is speculation, but the reincarnation process itself might be more along the lines of renewal, and involve other processes important to Creation or the soul itself. Remember Wordblood speaking about the mobster ghost being terribly stale? I wonder if there wasn't a hint of something in that. We could ask him later what he meant.

Ghosts that WANTS to become a part of the Saulanna Collective ("Resistance is SHINY") could be okay to munch, but I still think we should mainly focus on locating Titan's Fragments and seeing what we can do with those.

>>330732

Stop /=/ halt?

Pick 'Stop' if you'd like. I'm supporting PW: Halt. The difference should be negligible since they're near-direct synonyms.
>>
No. 20939 ID: a8c7f2

i do not support any PW. maybe something we can use casually, like in the talk we had with peregrin.

>>330714
suddenly we are gambit! why not power word bleed or leak? imagine what we could do with the eyes!

>>330717
wouldnt reveal only work on things we know that are there?

>>330730
in exalted this is not true. not much anyway. a ghost is free in the underworld, so much that they have cities, economies and smugglers to get things from the normal, living world. they choose to not return mostly because they dont want to "die" for real. a ghost citizen can also live forever, if we find a old enought ghost, he will be as powerful as a exalt. at least skill wise.

also we would not be making souls but rather recycling the ones we ate.

>>330733
they just go get reborn. its literally as easy as sneezing. except the wait line is humongous and you will return to a land more broken and unfair that the underworld. they fare better as ghosts that as humans, even if you consider the fact they canstill suffer.

>>330736
NO. they actualy suffer a worse fate that being reborn!

if they get stuck in soulsteel destroying the soulsteel will release their soul, if they choose to be reborn eventually they will, if saulanna eats them ITS OVER. we can remake them but they will be a hollow husk with no will, serving us forever.

there is no resistance in saulanna, there is only saulanna.
>>
No. 20940 ID: 63261d

>>330739
the titans made souls, so it is reasonable so think that wordblood will be able to make souls as well. and instead of recycling adult souls he would make a baby soul that grows with it's container.
>>
No. 20944 ID: 8bdb6a

'Stop' and 'Halt' should have the exact same effect. I just prefer 'Halt' because it sounds more like a command.

Also, why are some folks focused on more Soul Force? I'm not really clear on what good it'll do for this fight. (We just refilled our MP, so we're not really desperate for more)

I'm in favor of more Soul Force in the mid-long term, but it doesn't seem helpful right this second, and is probably going to make Saulanna vulnerable. (If editing her agility means 15 seconds of downtime, imagine what rewriting her soul will be like)
>>
No. 20952 ID: a8c7f2

>>330744
peregrin most likely has 3 or 4 soul force. these little motes of us are not that useful mostly because we dont have charms/spells to channel them, but he will always have more to exaust us with.

one of the reasons why i want moon power boost as well is because we will likely get new charms and stuff to use the motes we just got.

sincerely, i still disaprove of any atribute buff untill we could get actual spells, but if we could get the time before this battle ends, 2 or 3 TW to agility sounds wonderful.

also notice our skills piling up. we may not need to do trainning ever again, except for spells and attributes.
>>
No. 20953 ID: 5f20de

>>330744

Hey, it's far more in line with Saulanna's mindful nature than an agility upgrade, at least. And more Soul Force = Better Power Words. We might need an edge if we want any power word to stick to magically-inclined Peregrin for long.

It's also my understanding that only physical upgrades take a long time to do. At least according to what Jukashi said here:

>>328141

'nyway, responding to a couple of things here, rather than adding to the clutter of the main thread:

>SIRTEN: Wordblood said that we aren't destroying souls when we absorb them. They were bound by Titan's Will and would be again through eventual reincarnation. Saulanna seems to be a safe haven of sorts from this effect. By absorbing them we remove them from that grasp. I got the impression it was a good thing.

...Uh. I think you've misunderstood just a lottle. Independent souls aren't bound by Titan's Will, that's what makes 'em independent. They're just made FROM it, ostensibly to fight off CHAOS by providing BELIEF to the GODS. When Wordblood absorbs them, he peels off the layers of memories and personality to get at the juicy Titan's Will they're made off, which we then use for upgrades. The memories and personality are still kept around, I suppose, but not tied to the core that kept them INDEPENDENT, i.e. the juicy Titan's Will.

I'd call this a form of extreme symbiosis at its best, and absolute slavery at worst. THOUGHTS MAY DIFFER ON THIS. For example, it's pretty natural for Wordblood, as a titanic fragment, to look on souls as food for thought (HAH).

Jukashi's mention of sock puppets and "sell-your-soul" deals are also pretty illustrative when it comes to souls and the effect Saulanna nomming on them has:

>>330359

>0d11d9: Power word: Stop might be better than Power word: Halt. Halt implies just not moving. Stop can be applied to other things.

Have I misunderstood -completely- or weren't Halt and Stop one and the same?

...Alright, I've bit the bullet and gone through Jukashi's comments in this thread twice now, and it looks like Stop and Halt really are one and the same to him. Please correct me if this is wrong, J-dawg.
>>
No. 20955 ID: 42838c

More thoughts relating to potential Words of Power, as incapacitating ones seem to me to be the quickest and most efficient way to end the battle.

"Stop/Halt" (They're the same to me) seems to be the most useful one overall, as we could use it to stop projectiles or blows heading our way, and should we use it well, we need never fear falling again. But it's not that useful in this fight, I feel, because if Kaan is on the ground, "Stop"ping him will only stop his current motion, and he could keep heading our way if he so chooses. It mightn't do anything more than slow a determined enemy down.

"Fall" sounds good to me for this current situation, if less versitile overall. It would, of course, be most useful if Kaan is still in the air, which we don't know but Saulanna might, as her field of view is different from ours. But then again, even if he's not, it could be used in other ways, too. We could use it to cause a large branch above him to "Fall," or just use it on him while he's standing up, as knocking someone over is a good way to temporarily immobilize a biped. Or, if we want to be a bit sillier, we could use it to drop his trousers from a distance, and either trip him up or aim for a Defeat By Modesty.

Going by other, more unusual vectors may surprise him and catch him off guard.

Perhaps "Hot" could be aimed at his cane, or at anything he touches, (like the ground, or his glasses, or his shoes!) rendering it searing and painful to touch.

Maybe "Vacuum" could create an airless bubble around him. I would think that no amount of Death Magic or Force of Will would create air where there is none, so perhaps it could work as a trap?

"Itch" could be a powerful distraction. It certainly wouldn't seem to be a formidible effect, maybe not even worth resisting at first glance, but boy it's hard to fight effectively when you feel like you've got ants in your pants! Other things could have similar effects; the first one that came to mind was "Tickle," but maybe other simple, innocuous physical effects could be generated that cause the human body to go bonkers.

Or if we want Saulanna to use something on herself that would be useful in this fight, I think Power Word: Invisible could provide significant stealth.

I am not sure if any of these would work as described; I am no expert at all. I'm just throwing out ideas. Maybe one could work!
>>
No. 20956 ID: 8b4e03

What about power word LEARN?
>>
No. 20957 ID: a7a85a

>>330753

The point still stands that they're not getting devoured and Wordblood is performing what would have happened to them anyway.

And without a personality the soul is either a blank slate or energy, I'm not how sure a blank soul feels enslavement or said symbiosis. Might be something to look into.

Either way it sounds like it's not that harmful and a necessary function of the game. I think people are looking at it as a choice between good an evil when it might have only been intended as a power up by the author.

Either that or I'm incredibly evil. o_o
>>
No. 20958 ID: 94ed01

>>/quest/213675
Or... buildings. Actually, upon reflection "fall" is a fair substitute for "destroy" when used on anything which has a rigid structure.

Of course, "halt" could do things like protect us from incoming projectiles, save someone falling from a height, make machinery cease working, and so forth.

There are ups and downs to both, but ultimately they're actually not nearly as redundant as I originally thought. It might be worth putting both on our to-buy list, although only one for now, obviously.

>>330757
If you're incredibly evil, we can be incredibly evil together. From the Titans they came, and to the Titans they shall return.

What is the value in a soul being independent? We're getting into metaphysics here, but I would argue that there is none. Not to get all nihilistic, but existence merely is; people do whatever they do because that's how they are, but there's no particular reason that it's somehow morally better to leave others as not part of us. We can let wariness that others will detect and kill us, sympathy for others and a desire to see their independent existence continue, or even simple apathy stop us from relentlessly devouring anyone we please for power, but should not do so due to some sense that it's morally wrong to absorb souls. It's not.

Do what we want, not what we think is right. We can write our own code of ethics here. If we're nice to others, it should be because it makes us feel good to be nice, not because it's the right thing to do.
>>
No. 20960 ID: 8bdb6a

>Halt vs Fall
Ah, hell with it. Let's just take both. There's a bit of overlap, but so what?
>>
No. 20964 ID: 42838c

>>330760
'Cuz we could need the Titan's Will soon for something else!
>>
No. 20966 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330764
Well... like what?
I don't want to be all 'I told you so,' but if we'd taken more Agility back when it was first proposed, we'd have had it for this fight. Maybe we'd have been able to hit Peregrin more often. I'm not a big believer in hoarding TW 'for when we need it.' Better to build a good, robust set of abilities.

Though, if you have a better idea of what to buy, I'm all ears.

PS: No offense intended, but it would be much more helpful and more likely to succeed if you proposed just one course of action instead of many at once.

>>330758
>Do what we want, not what we think is right. We can write our own code of ethics here. If we're nice to others, it should be because it makes us feel good to be nice, not because it's the right thing to do.
This is a good attitude. Not to hurt anyone's suspension of disbelief, but this is a game and we're playing it to have fun.
>>
No. 20967 ID: 2eac65

>>330766
This isn't "hoarding". This is not wasting resources when we don't gain anything from it.
>>
No. 20969 ID: 8bdb6a
File 128045899416.gif - (6.38KB , 433x494 , 1245298632782[1].gif )
20969

>>330767
I don't think it's a waste. They're useful abilities. Even if there's a debatable amount of overlap, they're both useful power words that do things the other does not.

Personally, I'd prefer "Halt," and "Burn," but people don't seem to like Fire... which is crazy, in my opinion, but there you have it.
>>
No. 20970 ID: 42838c

I just think we should wait until the end of the fight before deciding what other useful things we should invest in. So long as we're not currently in a situation where a sudden, dire need for powerful magic could pop up, (Say we get poisoned again, and we need some sort of antidote; or we have an immediate fear that we could get caught in a fiendish trap of Kaan's and we need to Reveal it, etc.) by all means, go ahead!

And I'm terribly sorry if I've inconvenienced you or anyone. I'll just shut up, now.
>>
No. 20975 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330770
>I just think we should wait until the end of the fight before deciding what other useful things we should invest in.
Buying some powers could help us win the fight.
We might not be able to win or even escape without more abilities. We can't reliably land a blow on him, and I guarantee he's got way more dirty tricks where the other ones came from. Maybe his weapon implanted some weird magic that'll go into effect soon. Maybe he's got powerful reinforcements on the way. I don't know, but I doubt his plan is "dodge Saulanna's attacks until she gets tired and goes away and then let her leave."
We shouldn't waste time.

>And I'm terribly sorry if I've inconvenienced you or anyone. I'll just shut up, now.
Aw, I didn't mean it like that. It's just that when you go "We should do X or Y or Z or P or Q," then we're like "Wait... huh?"
But if you go "We have points to do X and Y, and maybe some day Z would be good," then we can either agree or disagree with that.
>>
No. 20976 ID: 0d5620

>>330769
>Personally, I'd prefer "Halt," and "Burn," but people don't seem to like Fire... which is crazy, in my opinion, but there you have it.
Saulanna is getting Stop and Drop. Later she will buy Roll.
>>
No. 20977 ID: 18169f

i say the only time saving up is a good idea is if we know the exact cost of something and have nothing cheaper that is good.
>>
No. 20978 ID: 8bdb6a
File 128046508754.jpg - (220.68KB , 977x1483 , the_red_star_drop_protocol.jpg )
20978

>>/quest/213675
>Fall would be useful any time we want something to hit the ground. Even people standing on the ground. Or walls. Or basically anything else that has potential energy from elevation.
With enough points, why stop there?
>>
No. 20990 ID: 70b4d8

man alright guys, you've convinced me

To make Fall more expensive than I was going to!
>>
No. 20993 ID: a594b9

>>330790
D:<
>>
No. 21000 ID: 2eac65

>>330744
>I just prefer 'Halt' because it sounds more like a command.
Yes, but it sounds like the sort of command a policeman would give to a fleeing criminal. It's the sort of thing you expect to be ignored. If we simply say "Stop" and things stop moving, it's like we know what we want and the universe has to listen to us.

>>330777
Okay, I'll explain my reasons for not wanting to rush.

Imagine a timeline with points A and B, where A is now and B is when we need to use a Power Word. We have two options:

Option X is that we craft a Power Word at point A and use it at point B.
Option Y is that we do nothing at point A, craft a Power Word at point B and use it immediately.

Option X works out well for us if we choose the right word. However, it runs the risk of choosing a word that doesn't help (for instance, Burn versus a problem that isn't flammable). If that happens, we won't be able to solve that problem in an appropriate way.

Option Y, in an ideal situation, has the same effect as option X. In a less than ideal situation, it offers a significant advantage in that, instead of crafting the word we were planning to craft, we can craft one that is more useful to the situation we end up in.

Basically, waiting to craft a Power Word until we need it doesn't cost us anything and leaves our options open.
>>
No. 21003 ID: b86a96

>>330800
silly question: how do we know we are not at point B?

serious question: how can we get a constant supply of TW to craft on the fly instead to fit generic situations because we wont have that many TW?

i am still against any TW. lets boost our moon charms and soul power to stay low as a lunar instead of a primordial wannabe.
>>
No. 21004 ID: 2eac65

>>330803
I'm not saying anything like that. I mean that, if we're thinking about the future, planning to make a Power Word is as good as actually making one, until we intend to use it.
>>
No. 21009 ID: d86f54

>>330800

Far as I know 'Halt/Stop' are one and the same. Essentially, since we've suggested both, so it's perfectly fair that it's Saulanna's choice on which she'll use regularly... if it gets made.

Making this whole discussion

point

less.

>>330804

Not gonna work. If we get TW, we'll use it, because there's a lot to use it on that can be considered generally universally useful (whether or not it actually turns out to be is another matter), and it's also a matter of character progression. You don't often see a gamer waiting with distributing his skill points 'till he meets a challenge he knows he'll need certain skills for.

You can suggest keeping points in reserve, and we might consider it, but chances are it won't fly. If it does, it's more because we can't agree on anything to upgrade than a genuine will to save something for later.

...Hell, you guys want a REAL hax?

A Titan's Work power that'd allow us to undo the things we've alloted our Titan's Will on thus far and return them back to the pool. Re-specialization power.

...It's going to be costly as fuck.
>>
No. 21017 ID: 8bdb6a

>waiting to craft a Power Word until we need it doesn't cost us anything and leaves our options open.
Saulanna's in a boss fight and can't reliably hurt the boss. If that's not "needing it," then nothing is. What are we waiting for? Another, stronger boss right behind this one? Well then we still wouldn't spend points because what if there's another boss right behind that boss?

Screw that. Everything can be replaced except time.
>>
No. 21022 ID: 2eac65

>>330817
I don't understand what you think that has to do with what I said. Whatever point you think I'm implying, I'm not. I only said what I said.
>>
No. 21024 ID: 1b8ddf

>>330822
>implying you didnt mean what you said
wat. wat?

i am the only one here that is allowed to be confused about my statements.

>>330817
lets NOT do any TW. id go with wordblood or saulanna's soul power buff and moon power also because they are versatile.
>>
No. 21025 ID: 1b8ddf

>>330824
i mean power word, not TW
>>
No. 21028 ID: 2eac65

>>330824
No, I meant what I said. You're not talking about what I said. You're talking about something unrelated.
>>
No. 21035 ID: 1b8ddf
File 128054264583.gif - (0.97MB , 612x332 , MAXIMUN TROLLLLLING.gif )
21035

>>330828
i am pretty sure that you where talking about what you said. however your comment specified that you did not discussed on the subject related to the subject you are talking now, by claiming it to be unrelated while it was about the subject that was developed in the main topic of your original post.

>>330817
im pretty sure that if we invest enought TW we can time travel.
>>
No. 21037 ID: 7e8901

Voting Time

Lots of people are bucking to do something with the new TW, so please vote on it now. Post only your own suggestion (there's been discussion enough at this point) and vote only once, as if I need to remind you.
>>
No. 21039 ID: 701a19

>>330837
Fall.
>>
No. 21040 ID: 7e8901

To be helpful:
Stop/Halt: 1 TW.
Fall: 2 TW.
Burn: 1 TW.
Commune: 1 TW.

Efficiency and Ease of Consumption increase in price by 1 for each "level". Level cannot exceed Wordblood's Soul Force. Soul Force itself costs an amount equal to the user's current rating (2, in this case) and would require time. Agility would similarly take time and cost 1 TW (this time).

There are many other imaginative choices. Wordblood, for example, has many optional extras.
>>
No. 21041 ID: 4c7b39

Fail.
>>
No. 21046 ID: c00244

>>330840
I'll throw my vote in for "Fall".


If I may also discuss slightly different topics, "optional extras" caught my eye. Reading back through the thread, there are several interesting options- though I do not support buying any of them right now. I would request costs for:

"World Reading", which is basically a heads-up-display labeling everything that Saulanna sees; this could include magical effects, pierce concealment and disguises, and provide convenient additional information about things viewed at higher Soul Forces.

"Dream Snare", which yanks a soul out of a living body and traps it in Saulanna's mental soul hangout area. Also for a possible follow-up ability allowing Saulanna to put other souls into the stripped body, for body-switching shenanigans and the easy resurrection of faithful minions. I'm not sure how this would scale with Soul Force.
>>
No. 21048 ID: 8bdb6a

Burn
>>
No. 21049 ID: 7e8901

>>330846

World Reading would begin at 1 TW for very basic information (how much Power the target has left, their face-name, their health) and scale upwards with improvement, requiring additional TW. Would also allow miscellaneous minor effects like seeing deception in written words and making out worn carvings and the like. Saulanna will also need to let Wordblood use one of her eyes while it is in effect.

Dream Snare, as you describe it, would follow on from certain other powers: you would first need to give Wordblood the ability to project himself outside Saulanna's mind, and then the ability to enter other people's minds, then the ability to possess them, then the ability to take stuff back with him (extracting memories, emotions, etc.), then the ability to take whole souls. Doing things with those souls is yet another branch of abilities.
>>
No. 21050 ID: 2eac65

>>330835
I don't see how this is unclear. Someone said that there was no reason we could ever want to save it for later, I gave a possible reason. Then you acted like I said not to use any now. I hadn't said that.
>>
No. 21051 ID: c4c313

Okay okay here's some legitimate ideas for power words.

Quiet aka "shut up" (effective against spellcasters and politicians!)
Heal maybe not as useful as "Cleanse" because Saulanna already regenerates in war form.
Fetch compels its target to go catch whatever you just threw!
Freeze as an imperative it refers to cessation of movement, not getting cold, sounds better than "Stop" or "Halt" I'd say.
Rock Mode the only way to stay safe while moving
Fear makes the target afraid of you, the equivalent in raccoon language of growling.
Open opens all doors, boxes, etc
Unlock unlocks all chains manacles, doors, boxes, etc.
Break might turn out to be more useful than Mend.
>>
No. 21052 ID: c4c313

There are other things TW could be used for. Here's what I know, all of which could be better than an overly specific power word (then again, the GM can always throw faster stronger harder at you.)

Boost stats
The stats I've seen so far have been
* Agility
* Intuition
* Inspiration
* Might (is Strength the same thing?)
* Acuity
* Beauty
* Arousal
* Dickery

Anything else? What kind of a hierarchy do these fall in with regards to the stats that Luna actually gave us Body Mind and Persuasion.

Moon Points

Pretty simple. Nobody realizes how important these are until you run out of souls to eat.

Soul Force

A general vague unspecified thingy that will result in increasingly powerful effects the more we (or any of our allies) have of it. I'd like to know more about how much TW it would take to get Freeze to have the temporary stasis effect!

Are there any other thingies that Titan's Will can be used on, that I missed? I have a hard time following such a popular quest, and I swear this Exalted system must have been designed by Andrew Hussie!
>>
No. 21053 ID: 2eac65

>>330851
We've already got Black-Striped Thief for opening locks and containers.

Stop is the only option that's worthwhile. We've passed the situation where we need to make things fall.
>>
No. 21054 ID: 701a19

>>330841
I think that would be like a 5TW word or something. No way we could afford it, let alone its casting cost.

Also:
Stop doesn't interrupt actions like spellcasting; it is useless here, we don't want it.

Fall leaves us with one point of TW left, so lets spend that on Mind Split.

Mind Split: This trait makes a person able to focus on more things without losing the benefits of paying full attention. Aside from being able to engage in independent actions without penalty, it also renders the target harder to distract; should a distraction attempt be successful only one focus will switch to respond to it, including inner turmoil, befuddlement, and deep contemplation.
Note, however, that this ability does not grant any extra organs, limbs, or orifices; foci can not attempt contradictory actions at the same time.
>>
No. 21057 ID: 5f20de

>post only your own suggestion
>there's been discussion enough at this point

Given the current situation:

Confusion
>>
No. 21058 ID: 5f20de

>>330852

>BODY - MIGHT: Remarkable | AGILITY: Average | TOUGHNESS: Average

>PERSUASION - INSPIRATION: Astonishing | BEAUTY: Remarkable | DICKERY: Remarkable

>MIND - SAVVY: Ridiculous | ACUITY: Astonishing | INTUITION: Astonishing

We can only upgrade four stats at the moment, per what Jukashi has said. The three BODY stats and the BEAUTY stat.

Arousal - Not a stat but a STATE.
>>
No. 21059 ID: 7e8901

>>330852
Only Might, Agility, Toughness and Beauty, as physical traits, can be improved with TW. The others are personality/mental traits.

Freeze would not be a synonym of Stop or Halt. It would literally freeze its target.

>>330854
>doesn't interrupt actions like spellcasting

???
>>
No. 21060 ID: c00244

>>330859
>???
I believe that the logic there was that the word as described only halts existing momentum; all it would accomplish at our current rather unimpressive level of soul force would be making the target stutter/pause briefly, since they could just choose to continue. If spellcasting requires total concentration, it would still interrupt it, but if there's some flexibility there my impression was that the caster could just power through.
>>
No. 21061 ID: 7e8901

>>330860

As I described it here:

>>330168

It can work on creatures as more like a magical command.
>>
No. 21067 ID: 42838c

"Stop" has my vote now.
>>
No. 21071 ID: 2eac65

>>330853
Amend my vote to Stop and nothing else. I'd want to save some for later.

Speaking of which, what do we need to convert another living person into a subsoul? If it costs more Titan's Will or requires an upgrade, I'd like to leave that option open.

I think this was a bad time to call for a vote; our situation just changed, which rendered much of our previous discussion irrelevant and brought new issues to deal with.
>>
No. 21077 ID: a594b9

>>330840
Let's go with STOP.
>>
No. 21082 ID: 5a2e05

I vote stop and hammertime, whatever the second one would end up being.
>>
No. 21105 ID: c00244

That went well. It seems that Power Words burn through MP rather quickly, though; we'll need more Soul Force if we plan to use them significantly on a regular basis. That said, I'd say that our next immediate investment should be in Efficiency of Consumption; getting more Titan's Will for less is highly desirable, not to mention reducing the whole "walking beacon of Luna's power" bit.

From there we can move on to Soul Force, body modification, additional power words, and world reading (which could be exceedingly handy in future boss battles, if only to tell us how we're doing).
>>
No. 21106 ID: 55c4cf

just posting that i still think Naked would have been the best power word, you know, for the future.
>>
No. 21107 ID: 5a2e05

>>330906
Too specific. Power Word: Strip maybe? It can be used for paint, screws, clothes, and plenty of other applications!
>>
No. 21109 ID: 2eac65

>>330906
That's covered by Reveal.
>>
No. 21111 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330907
Oh, don't worry about that. Better, broader, more useful words cost more. Narrower, less useful words cost less. Something exceedingly narrow in focus might cost less than 1 TW, even.

...that said, I think Naked could be quite useful. Imagine casting it on someone wearing heavy armor. Or someone attempting a Social feat in front of a crowd. Or an attempt to obfuscate the truth.
>>
No. 21113 ID: c4c313
File 128064425118.png - (10.24KB , 600x600 , 656726.png )
21113

Power word: depantsu!
>>
No. 21114 ID: c4c313
File 128064426992.png - (11.72KB , 600x600 , 662581.png )
21114

>>
No. 21135 ID: 8bdb6a

>>/quest/214587
We're counting our chickens before they hatch with this whole 'take peregrin prisoner,' thing. We don't know if he's beaten yet.

Even still. Come on. He's an evil vampire magician. He's already deceived and tricked us, and obviously can't be trusted. He'll pretend to surrender, then break out of any imprisoning we try, throw blinding dust in Saulanna's eyes, and so on.

About the only way we could trust him would be the soul-binding thing described here: >>330359

Well, or maybe the mangle-of-suffering thing. I guess that could technically work, too.
>>
No. 21147 ID: 2eac65

>>330935
Of course he'd try to escape if he thought it would work. So we'll have to be cautions and thorough, and make it seem like cooperating with us is much less risky than continuing to fight.

>About the only way we could trust him would be the soul-binding thing described here: >>330359
That's what I'm planning. I think we know enough of his personality to convince him to do it. There are two important points about his character:

1: He's a man of science. He wants to study new and interesting things about the universe. We do, too; we'd be excellent allies for each other if he wasn't such a sneaky bastard.
2: He is, as mentioned above, a sneaky bastard. He came into this meeting with the intent to trick us and capture us by force; he didn't even try to cooperate except to get us to let down our guard. This is working out very badly for him.

Emphasize these two points, and with the right phrasing, we can make it seem like a very beneficial arrangement that he would be lucky to be part of.
>>
No. 21148 ID: 8bdb6a

>>330947
>That's what I'm planning.
If he's actually found in a vulnerable but alive state (which could be a trick) and if he actually agrees to sell us his soul (big assumption, and could be another trick) then I agree, it's worth a try.
It'd be really, really useful, and more dramatically appropriate than taking the Raziel/Alex Mercer approach to defeated bosses.
It's a great big risk, but that's exalted for you.
>>
No. 21150 ID: 2eac65

Aiming to intimidate and/or wrestle him into submission won't be too much harder than dealing a deathblow, and it'll play to our stronger attributes. And if we can't reach an agreement with him, we can ritually sacrifice him to Luna and possibly earn a favor from it.
>>
No. 21279 ID: c00244

It might be worth considering to invest a point of Titan's Will into World Reading, right now. This is because the immediately provided information
>(how much Power the target has left, their face-name, their health)
would immediately tell us if Peregrin is really as beaten as he seems. If he's holding out on us and has a dozen Power left, I'd rather like to know.
>>
No. 21283 ID: 2eac65

It is within our current capabilities to make people into SOUL PUPPETS, right? Because I'm going to feel really stupid if I overthought our post-capture conversation with Peregrin that much and it turns out we need three measures of Titan's Will, a higher Soul Force and/or a jar of demon's blood and garlic.
>>
No. 21333 ID: b9bd4f

So what do you all think we should do? Should we make him our servant, Devour him, or let him go? Personally, I think making him our servant would be the most profitable choice. The only thing is that we need to be sure he wont betray us, and cannot lie to us.

And of course, a good reason for him to submit to us is that he will be free from the grasp of his Deathlord patron. Considering that he says he is a "rebel" death hero he should have no problem with this. As long as he agrees to help us and not work against us, he would be much better off (ie, have more free will)than he would as the unwilling servant of a Deathlord.
>>
No. 21334 ID: 8bdb6a

I didn't realize the soul-puppet thing would have backwash. Let's avoid that. We don't want backwash, especially from him.
Saulanna's personality is kinda vulnerable right now due to the amnesia. She doesn't have a really strong identity to serve as a bedrock, y'know?

Still, if we go with the oath instead, we ARE giving up a whole lot of potential power, and leaving him a potential 'out' to betray us later... If it wasn't an abyssal, I'd vote that she take the risk. But abyssals are either evil or crazy or both, and are constantly plagued by weird supernatural death-related problems that we would like to have none of.
>>
No. 21335 ID: 3a289a

Oath:

[truename] does hereby solemnly swear fealty to [us]. He swears not to strive against our endeavors, nor to attempt to bring harm to us or our charges, and to speak as honestly as he is able when queried by us, except when directed or given permission to do otherwise.

Any other points we should add?
>>
No. 21336 ID: 3a289a

Oh, and in other news, the thread is huge as fuck, and we ought to start a new one as soon as reasonably possible.
>>
No. 21337 ID: d86f54

>>331134

We could try turning his exaltation back into a Solar's, if not at once, then in time. It would solve his problems of being hunted by EVERYONE, by making him hunted by merely ALMOST EVERYONE like any normal exalted.

Also, you're basing yourself on Standard Exalted lore again on this 'either evil or crazy or both, with lots of unfun extras' conclusion. I don't doubt Peregrin is heavily amoral, and willing to sacrifice people to get power, but the I'd rather ask 'why' than simply say 'because he's like that'.
>>
No. 21342 ID: 2027a7
File 128101898693.png - (2.21KB , 191x62 , tdpo.png )
21342

>>331134

If it helps, Abyssals are now more shadow/darkness than they are death/destruction.
>>
No. 21344 ID: 81b252

>>331136
True, we need a new thread ASAP.

Also, in response to what somebody in the quest thread said about Gevin, I don't think Gevin would at all enjoy becoming a death hero. Besides, he's pretty much Saulanna's best (and only) friend. If Gevin Exalts, it should be willingly, not forced. Perhaps once our power is great enough, WE can exalt HIM.
>>
No. 21346 ID: c6d5c5

>>331144
well he wont exalt. he is very ded and the exaltations literally requires a living human(ish) body.

to make a exaltation it would be a huge amount of work. its easier to pick a already existing exaltation and corrupt it to fit our will. with all due respect, we should not suceed in copying authocrhon, but we should think in making a ghost exaltation.

you know what is funny? the exaltations are made of souls.
>>
No. 21347 ID: 81b252

>>331146
>corrupt it
More like purify it. Us taking the exaltation of an infernal or abyssal and making it ours would be a blessing, not a curse.
>>
No. 21348 ID: c6d5c5

>>331147
no, it would be like picking a ID card that someone already hacked to serve his purpose and hack it again to serve ours.

we most surely cant learn how to make a exaltation, but if we find authocrhon, we definitively can find a way to ask for a few exalts of our own.
>>
No. 21350 ID: 81b252

>>331148
I think it's pronounced Autochron. Which brings up a good point. Autochron and Gaia may be potential Primordial allies. After all, Gaia is a close ally to Luna, who is our current patron. And autochron is, from my knowledge, a very reasonable being. If we do find a Alchemical Exalted, we should be sure to befriend them. Getting in contact with Autochron could prove beneficial. Perhaps he could teach us a few things.....like how to make an exaltation, for example.
>>
No. 21351 ID: 8bdb6a

>>331142
>If it helps, Abyssals are now more shadow/darkness than they are death/destruction.
Oh. Well that's not so bad.

>throw down / puss out
I suppose the oath option is pussing out.
I still think we should eat him.

>>/quest/215754
>How about we lay out all his options, and see what he thinks about them?
Oh come on. Ask him for advice on what to make him do? Seriously?
>>
No. 21354 ID: a594b9

>>331151
Yes. Both to taunt him a little, and see if he tries to play mindgames with the choice. Above all right now we need to find out exactly what his personality is.
>>
No. 21363 ID: dda21a

>>331154
this is kinda good. we can tell what he wants with us better if we hear what the reason of what he would choose for himself
>>
No. 21365 ID: 5f20de

>>331151

I believe that's just poking fun at the situation as we're not actually wussing out of anything. The oath option is just another way of dealing with him. I doubt it makes Saulanna much less of a MIGHTY LUNAR TITANIC BABE.

... plus we could always eat him later if he tries to screw with us notably.
>>
No. 21373 ID: 550758
File 12810574919.png - (542.14KB , 606x305 , silly.png )
21373

>>331165
I am suddenly reminded of another Jukashi production involving a Lunar.
>>
No. 21405 ID: 3a289a

>>331173
Speaking of which...

I totally did not notice the arms in the latest comic until I was being like "what the fuck are they screaming about" and ready the little blurb thingy at the bottom.

I suppose this signifies the end of the transition from crappy OotS rip off to full-fledged comic in its own style. Even though it was better than OotS from pretty much the very beginning.
>>
No. 21406 ID: f4e4f9

Am I missing something, or are these oaths not accounting for the fact that Peregrin thinks he's ALREADY helping us through his actions? "For your own good/safety/etc" was what I believe he said.

I think an oath to "Not act against our wishes" would be necessary, not just to "not do us harm"
>>
No. 21408 ID: d560d6

>>331205
Likewise, except that OotS is superb, you cretin.
>>
No. 21410 ID: 8bdb6a

>>331206
>Am I missing something, or are these oaths not accounting for the fact that Peregrin thinks he's ALREADY helping us through his actions? "For your own good/safety/etc" was what I believe he said.
And you can't think of any reason why he might be lying?
>>
No. 21412 ID: e31d52

>>331208
andherewego.gif
>>
No. 21416 ID: f4e4f9

Not really he point I was going for. The point is that IF its true, it leaves a large amount of wiggle room.

Or are you implying that it cant possiby be the case that that was his actual view, so we shouldn't even concern ourselves with tightening up the oath?
>>
No. 21417 ID: 49a137

>>331206
The problem with that is that, given that he knows our general beliefs- whatever they are- his actions will become restricted by whatever we wish for him to do. Essentially, all his actions would be limited to things that we would approve of- he'd never be able to do anything which he knows we'd dislike again, including relatively meaningless/harmless stuff and daily habits.

In my interpretations, anyway. He probably wouldn't want to bind himself to that kind of restriction. If we can get him to do so, well, more power to us. It would probably leave him more than a bit resentful, but I imagine that we can somehow magically mess with him to get around that, too.
>>
No. 21420 ID: a488cf

>>331206
>>331217
If that's what we're worried about, we could always define a more narrow stipulation that doesn't cover the huge swath of things we might (even just minorly) disapprove of. Would something like "don't take any action <i>that involves us</i> against our wishes" do the trick?
>>
No. 21429 ID: 49a137

I wonder, does Saulanna know/have a True Name that we should get Wordblood to tell us? I hear there's power to be had that way.
>>
No. 21433 ID: 3a289a

>>331208
It's decent if you want something to eat some time, I suppose. I can think of no other virtue which I could attribute to it.

>>331206
>>331216
We're best off leaving him with the free will to do what he feels is best, even if our perception of the favorable course of action will inevitably not align with his at some point. It is beneficial to us, obviously, and the potential downside is unlikely to be insurmountable, should it even occur. And of course, it's morally superior to robbing him of his free will, though that seems to be a lesser concern to many of us.
>>
No. 21437 ID: 2eac65

We're going to want a more specific oath than what he offered. Some of the suggestions in the main thread would offer less room for abuse, while at the same time being less restrictive on him.
>>
No. 21441 ID: 5f20de

>>331237

Actually, the nature of the oath seems to allow US to make demands of him as we'd like. He's really putting all his eggs in one basket by joining us this way.
>>
No. 21467 ID: 2eac65

>>331241
But only if we ask. Otherwise, he won't have any obligation apart from not actively working against us. Compared to his suggestion of "complete active and passive support, within reason", this is significantly better (for him if "within reason" is as limiting as he implied, for us if it isn't).
>>
No. 21500 ID: d14bbc

we really should make him do the oath. in the original lore the primordials corrupted the solar exaltation to allow the deathknights to act if the primordials were controlled and told to hold their pawns.

also dont worry about the oath wording. saulanna has humongous savvy + we can reinforce it with his true name.
>>
No. 21520 ID: 2eac65

>>331300
You're confusing Abyssal Exalted with akuma.

I think this is a good point to create Power Word: Commune and teach it to Peregrin, so we can communicate without having to physically return to his land.
>>
No. 21537 ID: d14bbc

>>331320
he is obviously a abyssal. however he can also be made a akuma, by us or another demon.

we should use the true name because then if we are controlled or tricked somehow, he will not be controlled by the one controlling us.

this is the main difference in the plot devices that made akuma and abyssals.
>>
No. 21550 ID: 2eac65

>>331337
I meant that your description was a mixture of how the Abyssal Exalted were created and how the Green Sun Princes were created, both of which are distinct from the ways that akuma are created.
>>
No. 21582 ID: c00244

This seems an opportune moment to comment that Lunar Quest is wonderful and I look forward to your every post within it. Chapter 1 has been quite an experience, and I hope that you plan to run many more.
>>
No. 21583 ID: 27828f

>>331382

As I've stated before, I intend to alternate between chapters of Lunar Quest and another, different Quest. As they'll have significantly disparate styles, my hope is that I'll "recharge" on one while I'm doing the other. So keep an eye out for the start of that other quest soon!

For now, though, a bit of a break.
>>
No. 21584 ID: c00244

>>331383
Ah. Well, good things come to those who wait, they say. Enjoy your break.

I assume that the gains from chapter end- Agility point and Moon Ability- are from our gaining experience conventionally? What does Scent of Victory do?

Out of curiosity, did things go roughly how you expected it to, from the ideas/plans you had at quest start?

And is that "Souls Eaten" counter there just to tease the people who wanted to rampantly devour everyone, or does it serve some other purpose?
>>
No. 21587 ID: f4e4f9

An awesome end to the chapter. Can barely wait for the second.
>>
No. 21591 ID: d86f54

>>331384

Well, let's have a look at the number of people/ghosts we've encountered in the quest and consider that we theoretically could've eaten the whole lot...

Gevin (now the 'ally')
Peregrin (now the 'sworn servant')
3 goons who harassed Gevin
5 goons encountered with Peregrin

= 10

... son of a dog, we must've missed someone somewhere!

>>331383

I'll keep my eyes open for your next quest, Jukashi, not to mention on your webcomic. I'm no Exalted player, so it's to your credit as a storyteller that you've managed to get me interested in both. Have a nice break!
>>
No. 21597 ID: adf48e

>>331391
gevin's girlfriend confirmed for dead.

feels bad, man =c
>>
No. 21604 ID: 5f20de

>>331397

Er. Since when?
>>
No. 21605 ID: d560d6

>>331397
Oh, whole music box thing?

I'd completely forgotten that what with all the poncing about with our new goth friend.
>>
No. 21609 ID: 805b7e

the 11th soul is saulunna's. in other words, wordblood could of eaten her.
>>
No. 21962 ID: 2eac65

Well, that was a very exciting first chapter. All eight months of it. Looking forward to anything else you make.

I really liked that stat page at the end. It showed how much Saulanna has grown; not just her stats (and hair), but also her posture and demeanor show someone who's much more confident and in control than she was in the beginning.

I'm curous as to how much of the quest's setting and characters were pre-planned, and how much you made up as we went along.
>>
No. 26543 ID: b9bd4f
File 128950895120.jpg - (11.43KB , 200x250 , 1289451932893s.jpg )
26543

I saw this and immidiatly thought of Lunar quest. It has charms that make you into a Titan.
>>
No. 26565 ID: e2b4f3

Man, I saw this thread bumped and thought for a minute that the next chapter had begun. But it is not the case. :(

Also
>>336343
Is it a bad sign that I wrote a First Saulanna Excellency in the few days before this book came out?
>>
No. 26578 ID: 741399

>>336343
To be accurate, it has charms that set the foundations for a new titan.

Return of the Scarlet Empress has the charms that transform one into a new titan.

>>336365
>First Saulanna Excellency
Why do you not post this?
>>
No. 26594 ID: 0d59df

>>336378
Mainly because I wasn't sure of myself on the thematics - reading how we played Saulanna in Chapter 1 gave me a certain impression, but whether it matches others' impressions or motivations is a question I'm more shaky on.

That said...
First Saulanna Excellency (subject to revision)
The mind of the Bandit Scribe is filled with dead languages, exhumed knowledge, and excavated wisdom. Hers is a sapience that is a fusion of the lore of ages past and the ancient intuition of the animal kingdom, reading the situation as readily as she might read an ancient tome. But although her appetite for knowledge is great enough to span the boundary of life and death and is not above theft and misdirection, it is held in check by her still greater empathy for all thinking beings, whether friend or foe. To those who have proven themselves true, she shows loyalty and dedication, and while her rebuke of those who have proven false is both swift and decisive, it is not without mercy. She would rather make alliances and friends than enemies, the better to learn their viewpoint while preserving their right to exist.

Characters may apply this charm to enhance comprehension of spoken or written communication, study of new concepts, understanding of the motivations of others, or investigation of past events. Characters may also enhance actions aimed at building and rewarding loyalty, or acting with all possible swiftness to prevent destruction of either knowledge or other thinking beings. This excellency may never be used to obliterate meaning, whether it would be erased from the mind or the page; even that which Saulanna allows herself to devour is consumed with the knowledge that it will live on as a part of her.
>>
No. 51114 ID: ed57e8

THE STARS HAVE ALIGNED! THE QUEST RETURNS!!
>>
No. 51116 ID: fcf88e

You have no idea how giddy I am right now.
>>
No. 51117 ID: b6edd6

Le Gasp!
>>
No. 51118 ID: e73349

Most excellent.
>>
No. 51119 ID: fcc78d

Suddenly!

...the same thread as last time. What the fuck, ju?
>>
No. 51120 ID: f730a1

>>360919

What, same discussion thread? I don't get it.
>>
No. 51125 ID: acc786

Huh, so Wordblood appears to have phrases written in him/her now.

First is: "Now when did put"
Second is: "Should I even be Ca Ma"

Think they mean anything?
>>
No. 51127 ID: 431fa8

>>360925
By my understanding that's whatever Wordblood is thinking. It seems like it's moving more towards coherent phrases/sentences than before, but I'm pretty sure it was always that way.
>>
No. 51128 ID: ec0dea

Think they're supposed to be 'Should I even be called male' and 'Now where did I put'. They're probably what Wordblood's currently thinking.
>>
No. 51130 ID: fcc78d

Jukashi, has anyone ever told you your style would be perfect for ponies?
>>
No. 51132 ID: e73349

>>360930

I'm pretty sure he knows this

http://jukashi.deviantart.com/#/d31zz27
>>
No. 51133 ID: 13dce2
File 133401761360.jpg - (93.07KB , 423x414 , oldfashionedreact.jpg )
51133

>>360930
>has anyone ever told you your style would be perfect for ponies?

Technically speaking, no.
>>
No. 51135 ID: fcc78d

>>360932
>>360933
WELP, consider myself answered.

Also, the round-faced yawning pic is adorable.
>>
No. 51144 ID: 431fa8

>>360927
Yeah, I'm rereading the first thread and it's fairly definitely Wordblood's thoughts. Poor guy.

how long has... I need to know... thousands of years... could we really have lost but the dragons shadow is still here I should... have to learn...

I remember having wings ... able to fly... change the world with my words... long ago... but I can... you to soar and to speak as I once did you can be more than...
>>
No. 51145 ID: 2eac65

Yaaaay it's back! I've really been looking forward to it!

So, how does everyone want Saulanna to develop? Thoughts on her personality? Long-term goals?
>>
No. 51146 ID: b9d767

>>360945
Personality? Likely inquisitive, what with the literary themes going on.
Long term goals? Recover the other Titan Fragments, and grow in power.

But that's just a guess on my part.
>>
No. 51147 ID: fcc78d

nice 90s Anime hair, Saulanna
>>
No. 51149 ID: ee834a

Holy crap, is this for real? I feel like I'm in a dream. Lunar Quest was the very thing that brought me to tgchan in the first place, following from Key of Creation.
>>
No. 51153 ID: a21b1b

At last, the Void Nights have come to an end!
>>
No. 51155 ID: 3947e9

Oh fuck yes! Lunar quest is back!
>>
No. 51175 ID: 369d34

Would it be possible to have a cutoff for the Saulanna clothing submissions, then allow voting on them for a day or so? Just so the early submissions don't run away with the vote.
>>
No. 51183 ID: 3947e9

Ghosts Carried in Saulina's Brain:
1 Captured Enemy, Unharmed
http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/res/88264.html#213070

1 Enemy which I can't figure out if he was merged or not
http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/res/88264.html#209202

1 Throwaway character we inexplicably got attached to Ally
http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/res/88264.html#195051
>>
No. 51184 ID: 431fa8

>>360983
The second one you linked was absorbed. We successfully merged him just after your first link and used the resulting power to win the battle.
>>
No. 51210 ID: 3947e9

>>360984
Thank you, I reread from it and I see it now.
We finished eating him here http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/res/88264.html#213361

>>/quest/400312
>We know for a fact that souls attached to ours have bleed-over
Yes,but we also know for a fact that will points are amazingly powerful reality altering thing and if we spend them specifically on it we could create filters that would prevent the bleed-over effect.
>>
No. 51211 ID: ce4a4d

>>361010
Doesn't that strike you as needlessly complicated when we can just strengthen Saulanna, which will do all that and more?
>>
No. 51216 ID: ed57e8

indeed, more soulforce stops bleed over AND makes words of power better. so the STOP power that made peregrin stutter would actually hold him for a bit.
>>
No. 51218 ID: 70591e

>>361016

well, we were told we can do more stuff with TW, so maybe we should explore our options first before spending our last bit. because I heard somewhere that there's more important things in life than acquiring personal power. for example, I'm thinking maybe it'll help us fulfill a certain promise.
>>
No. 51224 ID: 3947e9

>>361011
The issue is that people voted to "not eat immortal souls and prevent them from achieving their afterlife"... (despite it being completely wrong for the setting) That was the MAJORITY CHOICE.

So my plan is basically to allow us to continue to grow as a titan by sidestepping the issue by spending TW to make it "nicer" process...

Or do you mean that you could render bleed over irrelevant by simply dumping points into saulina's soul to grow it to the point where the bleed over will not matter?

>>361016
>Growing saulina's soul stops bleedover
>Growing saulina's soul empowers her words of power
Where do you get that info from?
>>
No. 51225 ID: b6edd6

For reference:
>>"We currently have a total SOUL FORCE of 4; 2 on my lady's side, and 2 on mine. Increasing her soul force will increase the potential for greater SHAPESHIFTING and MOON ABILITIES, while increasing mine will improve our capacity for more potent TITAN'S WORKS. Improving either will cost 2 measures of Titan's Will, and will add 3 to the maximum supply of MOON POWER, as well as increasing general spiritual potency."

'Spiritual potency' would probably reduce overlap, but it is Wordblood's SOUL FORCE that improves WORDS OF POWER, not Saulana's.
>>
No. 51226 ID: 431fa8

>>361025
My understanding is otherwise. See >>328146:
>The effect of individual Power Words will ramp up with the total Soul Force available to Saulanna.
Power Words can be learned by anyone, although only Wordblood can craft new ones. Once someone knows them, their potency is based upon the Soul Force of that person, as well as the base power of the word itself.
>>
No. 51230 ID: 3947e9

>>/quest/400525
>Wordblood absorb written knowledge
He can do that? Where is the nearest library!
>>
No. 51239 ID: b6edd6

Can WORDS OF POWER have multiple functions if the word has multiple definitions?
For example, if we used the word LIGHT, would be be able to choose with each use whether it makes something weigh less or produces a flash of light?
>>
No. 51242 ID: 3947e9

>>361039
That is a very good question...
Maybe worth researching in the quest.

I am guessing no... but if yes then it raises another question. How many people need to know a word's definition for it to be made into a word of power? Could we invent a word with lots of meanings and then make it a word of power?
>>
No. 51245 ID: ed57e8

jukashi explained that. the more broad a word is the weaker it is. power vs versatility.
"STOP" makes things stop. nothing except another titan or fragment can really even defend against them since they effect the fabric of reality itself.
>>
No. 51246 ID: ce4a4d

>>361045
I know this quest is different from canon, but it's safe to assume Exalts of all types can defend against titan magic, if prepared.

The setting kind of breaks down if they can't.
>>
No. 51247 ID: ed57e8

>>361046
oh, okay. but i seriously doubt they will be prepared for a lunar to use titan magic.
>>
No. 51250 ID: 0a3290

>>361046
>>361045

If you're familiar with the game, Power Words are basically another kind of sorcery variant. They're primarily either Shaping or mental influence effects, and the right protection will shrug them off completely.
>>
No. 51251 ID: b9d767

>>361024
Actually, souls in Exalted have no true "afterlife". After dying they either pass into the Lethe, which scrubs a soul clean of most everything and sends it off to be reborn, or remain as a ghost and face the horror of Oblivion. Considering all the horrifying things that await the dead, we're pretty much doing them a favor by recycling them.

And speaking of Oblivion, there is something that concerns me. How do we know that these experiments of his weren't for the purpose of obtaining and then KILLING part of a Primordial, thus adding to the number of Neverborn?

Another thing, do we have any idea what position Wordblood held in the soul hierarchy of He Who Bleeds The Unknown Word? If it was high, then we might be able to use that as leverage if we come into conflict with the other primordial fragments. This is assuming that Wordblood was/is a deva.

Regarding the setting, this is set in a Creation where The Shadow Of All Things' escape from Malfeas went off without a hitch, yes? If so we will eventually come into conflict with those loyal to him. Considering that we are part-primordial, and that The Ebon Dragon did infact betray the Reclamation, we might be able to find an ally in the forces of Malfeas. If Elloge exists in this setting, then things will get VERY interesting.
>>
No. 51252 ID: 431fa8

I'm more interested in coming up with interesting Titanic abilities than in investing heavily in Power Words, personally. We can learn sorcery- and really well, with our crazy mental stats and ability to learn things incredibly quickly through Wordblood- so Power Words feel like they might be slightly redundant for us, unless we need a specific one to fill a given niche. The first one we definitely needed to get us out of a bind, and it's convenient to be able to essentially invent spells on the fly by coming up with new Words so keeping some Titan's Will on hand for that would be prudent, but developing a full vocabulary of Power Words ahead of time doesn't seem that useful.

It seems there are some concerns about Wordblood bleeding into Saulanna. Why is this a problem? Saulanna was wiped to a blank slate, and Wordblood seems pretty chill. I don't have a problem at all with getting some Wordblood into her personality. And by my understanding since Saulanna and Wordblood are a mini-Titan with two souls, worrying about keeping Saulanna dominant feels like panicking that your right hand is going to lose out to your left one- pretty much totally ridiculous. It doesn't matter which is dominant; they're facets of the same being. Peregrin did his job pretty well as far as that goes.

>>361051
See >>/questarch/197236 from the first thread.
>"I was a key part of my progenitor, I think. My memories haze, somewhat. I may even have been the defining soul of He from whom I came. I wonder what happened when I was torn away. To damage a Titan's souls is to alter their nature."
Wordblood was pretty up there in importance as part of He Who Bleeds the Unknown Word. Whether that'll do anything for us, who knows. It was a long, long time ago.
>>
No. 51258 ID: 3947e9

>>361051
>Actually, souls in Exalted have no true "afterlife". After dying they either pass into the Lethe, which scrubs a soul clean of most everything and sends it off to be reborn, or remain as a ghost and face the horror of Oblivion. Considering all the horrifying things that await the dead, we're pretty much doing them a favor by recycling them.
Actually this is verbatim what I said.

>And speaking of Oblivion, there is something that concerns me. How do we know that these experiments of his weren't for the purpose of obtaining and then KILLING part of a Primordial, thus adding to the number of Neverborn?
He is bound to us now in such a way that not only must he obey, but that he cannot deceive us. Ask him (no seriously, post to ask him in quest).

>It seems there are some concerns about Wordblood bleeding into Saulanna.
No, its other bleedover we are discussing.
http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/res/88264.html#215695

As you can see, there is blurring of the line separating Saulina and Wordblood, as if they are merging (a process I would suggest accelerating).

The issue is bleeding over of OTHER hypothetical souls which we would process in a way where they remain within us.
That is ONLY an issue if we choose to even do this with souls in the first place and that only came up because a bunch of fools are voting on the quest while refusing to read the questdis or setting info.

Specifically, when we wanted to merge with the last soul we captured the actual majority of voters said "do not eat immortal souls, that is evil and something a devil will do and denies them the afterlife" as if the setting occurs in christian pantheon instead of exalted world.

If saulina holds such a warped worldview and refuses to consume souls she will end in fail. And this is our problem.

However, the salvation is
>You are not a whole Titan, into whom a single soul will vanish
What if we could do carefully invest our titan's will in order to simulate this without becoming a whole titan. This will allow us to take in souls at will and actually grow into a whole titan.
>>
No. 51260 ID: 431fa8

>>361058
That seems like a spectacularly wasteful expenditure of Titan's Will, when we could just man up and devour the souls instead of mucking about with making everyone akumas while insulating ourselves. I'm pretty sure that takes a willing person anyway, which we're unlikely to get most of the time.
>>
No. 51262 ID: b9d767

>>361060
The reason why it was better to bind him into our service, rather than eat his soul or make him an Akuma is because being a DEATH (ANTI?)HERO his soul is pretty danm corrupted by his Exaltation. Eating him would mean incorporating Death Essence into ourselves, which is the worst possible thing that could happen to a primordial.

Though, this gives me an idea for a useful ability. If, while going OMNOMNOM on a soul, to be able to expel/vomit it instead of consuming it and incorporating it. My reasoning behind this is because of all the horrific things one can find in the SHADOWY LANDS, and in the Underworld, and they might not go down too well if snacked on.

Another ability that might be useful is one shapeshifting-related. Why can't we use our literary abilities to augment our shifting form? He Who Bleeds The Unknown Word had a a body covered in scales of thick prose after all, so it's not that much of a jump to being able to supplement our shapeshifting with titanic power to re-write (figuratively and literaly) our form.
>>
No. 51263 ID: ed57e8

that's what upgrading our SOUL FORCE does. make it so our soul is more powerful then the other sub souls. making us in charge and them simply minions.
>>
No. 51265 ID: 3947e9

>>361060
Hey, I AGREE with you. But we haven't been able to convince people to man up YET.
If we can convince people to man up and start nomming them souls then full steam ahead.

>>361062
>If, while going OMNOMNOM on a soul, to be able to expel/vomit it instead of consuming it and incorporating it. My reasoning behind this is because of all the horrific things one can find in the SHADOWY LANDS, and in the Underworld, and they might not go down too well if snacked on.
That is a fairly good point.

>I'm pretty sure that takes a willing person anyway
Eh, we are a titan, we can make it work eventually.

>>361063
So, you are saying that if we just upgrade saulina's soul enough then such absorption will no longer have bleedover/significant bleedover?
>>
No. 51267 ID: ed57e8

>>361065
it would change it from someone sitting next to her at the controls. to something like us. fleeting voices.
>>
No. 51269 ID: 2fe09b

>If, while going OMNOMNOM on a soul, to be able to expel/vomit it instead of consuming it and incorporating it. My reasoning behind this is because of all the horrific things one can find in the SHADOWY LANDS, and in the Underworld, and they might not go down too well if snacked on.

And hey, if we can turn it into an attack, all the better.
>>
No. 51281 ID: 3947e9

>>361069
You are a genius!
+1 internet
>>
No. 51285 ID: be7cc0

>>361069
>Turn it into an attack.
Best idea ever. Eating a Creature of Death, finding that it's deathly essence cannot be safely recycled/incorporated, and then vomiting it back up at another CoD. I'm going to try and think of a way to fit that into a literary theme.

Also, something that might fit in both Lunar and Literary themes is us WRITING OUR OWN TATTOOS. By doing this, we can get the benefits of a tattooed MOON HERO, while still being able to incoporate our own shaping effects on ourself.

And for those concerned about potential mental bleeding between Saulanna and Wordblood, IT'S TOTALLY NORMAL. Him affecting us means that we are indeed becoming a Primordial. Let me put it this way, component souls each represent a conceptual part of a Primordial. Thoughts, feelings, ideas, and desires are all manifested as different Souls. For example, Malfeas is the Yozi who composes most of Hell. His Fetich, (central core soul) is Liger. One of Malfeas' themes is his own self-loathing, and this manifests itself in Liger's disgust at Malfeas' dancing. In the same manner Gaia's elemental themes manifest as the different Elemental Dragons. tl;dr nothing to worry about
>>
No. 51286 ID: 2fe09b

>>361081
>>361085
And here I was just making a reference to Kirby. :V
>>
No. 51291 ID: b6edd6

Having skilled and knowledgeable subjects/minions is useful, right?

You see, I was thinking about how we
- Are very good at acquiring knowledge through both magical and non-magical means
- Have high INTELLIGENCE and PEOPLE SKILLS
- Have a significant bonus to communication (which would include conveying information)

What if we make a power word TEACH, to drastically increase the rate at which we can teach or train others? (It would probably cost a lot to use, but we might manage it with the bonuses we get from the aforementioned attributes.)
>>
No. 51296 ID: 117433

>>400847
As another note, a good inch or an inch or so has probably been lost to the chaotic realms of the Wyld since that map was made. Think of that map as a quilt. The quilt is pinned down on its four sides by four knives (with one in its center). These knives are the poles of the elements, and they keep the world from scrunching up improperly.
The Wyld proper is True Chaos (off the quilt). That is just Things Not Of This World. Don't go there; you'll die.
Halfway between Creation and the Wyld is the Middlemarches, which is like signifigant fringe on the end. It's half Wyld and half Creation, but that half Wyld makes it VERY dangerous (lots of faeries and mutants with two sets of arms and stuff).
Lastly, there's the slight fraying of the Bordermarches. Here, it's not too weird, and mostly safe. Things start taking on abnormal attributes, like crocodiles made out of rocks.
>>
No. 51297 ID: 3947e9

>And for those concerned about potential mental bleeding between Saulanna and Wordblood, IT'S TOTALLY NORMAL
There has never been a single post by anyone here showing concern about it.
Bleedover concerns is only if we merge with other souls in the future.
>>
No. 51299 ID: ed57e8

>>361096
as a titan we would be able to enter the wyld without succumbing to horrible mutation. since a prime example of things titans did is BUILD THE WORLD.
>>
No. 51300 ID: b9d767

Oh god, I just realized something. Shouldn't the Ebon Dragon be ruling CREATION, not the Underworld? It's kinda obvious that he has darkness as his big thing, and so is hating all life, but death? That's going a bit too far, even for him, and that's really saying something. That TED one day chose to not deactivate Ultimate Darkness Internalization has some rather disturbing implications.
>>
No. 51307 ID: 6e44d2

>>361096
What're the elements in this world? I mean, I can figure out most of them, but what's the one in the middle of the map?
>>
No. 51311 ID: 3bad4c

I must say I'm not very fond of this "oh no don't eat souls" part. Here's my suggestion.

Power Word - Echo
For one scene, briefly reconstitute one or more echoes of a soul/souls that has/have been eaten - doubling a number of competencies up to a maximum of SOUL FORCE rating.

I'd say being remembered in ridiculous detail is a fair trade compared to reincarnation.
>>
No. 51312 ID: 7fa633

>>361099
We'd also be able to do that if we got moonsilver tatts... Although the odds of such a plan going horribly-wrong on us is... well, let's just say those odds aren't in our favour.

>>361107
Centre is the Elemental Pole of Earth, which is the stabilising pole. Without a Pole of Earth, Creation begins to unravel entirely.

To the West is the Pole of Water. North is the Pole of Air, East is the Pole of Wood and south is the Pole of Fire.
>>
No. 51313 ID: 3bad4c

MOON BOOST only doubles the talents, right? So we should have one that boosts (absorbed) competencies too.
>>
No. 51327 ID: fcf88e

Honestly, we need Power Words designed for various uses and can be utilized when needed instead of for specific scenarios. I have a few here.

Power Word: Break. Exactly how it sounds. It cracks, breaks and general busts something. Can BREAK a lock, sword or even tougher things the better she gets.

Power word: Ignite. Ignites targeted thing. Can serve as a different type of attack or as a distraction.

Power Word: Repel. Simple defensive word. Repel projectiles or object. Could serve other uses if you use it to repel yourself from say, the wall.
>>
No. 51328 ID: 2fe09b

>>361127
>Power Word: Break.

I imagined her doing the pose for using a Power Word and then suddenly Saullanna and Peregrine are wearing monocles, top hats, and drinking tea.
>>
No. 51335 ID: 431fa8

Been thinking about random things that we might be able to do.

I find myself wondering if places have True Names. Manses might, at least, since they're locations of significant power and spiritual energy, right? That might have a number of interesting applications.

Still looking forward to getting the World Reading ability. Depending upon how we build it we might eventually become able to read the future/fate, opening the door to being able to write/overwrite it.

We've discussed the potential for a Commune power word that would enable long-distance communication through a link, but it's likely also fairly easy for Wordblood to just get a Titanic Ability to speak to whomever he pleases regardless of distance or barriers involved. The essence of language is communication, after all, so it's something very, very close to his heart.

Likewise I would expect it to be very easy for Wordblood to craft us up some abilities which would improve our communication abilities to Titanic proportions, making learning things from others, persuading them of things, teaching, etc. all extremely easy for us. The proper use of language is what enables all that stuff, after all. We don't need to muck about with Power Words for things like that when we can simply enhance ourselves directly with inherent powers.

Writing our own Tattoos is a great idea. It opens the door, in fact, the the concept of magical writing in general- maybe we could learn how to write down power words, spells, or... anything, actually. I'm not sure if Exalted normally has any form of runic magic or otherwise written spells, but if they do we'd probably be a near-instant master at it, and if they don't we could probably start writing one up just like with Power Words. Certainly this would be an easy way to get into making enchanted items.
>>
No. 51337 ID: ed57e8

>>361112
do you mean the tatts would go wrong or titan power going wrong?
>>
No. 51338 ID: 3947e9

>>361127
Since creating PW is instant and costs the same whether we do it ahead of time or not, we should come up with a dictionary of ideal power words ahead of time (here in questdis) but not actually invest the TW in them until we actually need them. This prevents coming up with a poorly chosen power word in the heat of battle, but also prevents us wasting TW on frivolous pursuits.

Also, lockpicking is something thats better done with lockpicks. We need our TW to grow our soul.

Also, I think we should eat some sorcerer souls and then focus our power words/TW on what sorcery CAN'T do or doesn't do well.
>>
No. 51343 ID: 6e44d2

Where are we on the map, currently?
>>
No. 51344 ID: 3947e9

is there a max value to efficiency of consumption? it is possible to go over 100%?
Normally I would think not, how can you consume more then there exists...
But this is exalted...
>>
No. 51347 ID: 431fa8

>>361144
See >>330840; that and certain other abilities are capped at Wordblood's Soul Force.

If you haven't read through the entire discussion thread yet, or at least all of Jukashi's posts, you should really do so. There's some key information in here.
>>
No. 51348 ID: 3947e9

>>361147
Thank you.
That cap is increasing as WB increases in power.
My question is weather efficiency can ever go over 100% absorbed.
IRL you can't have efficiency over 100% and even that is not practically possible to achieve (unless your goal is to generate heat)

But this isn't IRL so I am wondering if we can reach 100% efficiency? what numerical level is it? how much do we improve per point, and ...

Actually that isn't what I am wondering at all.
What I am really wondering is at what point investing in efficiency no longer gives returns and the above info could potentially help answer this.
>>
No. 51349 ID: ed57e8

>>361148
efficiency gives a flat +1. not a %
>>
No. 51357 ID: 57b09c

>>361113
Moon Heroes... Don't quite work that way.
>>
No. 51368 ID: b6edd6

>>361157
Good thing we are only partly a Moon Hero :V
(Though we probably would need to spend some TW to get an ability like that.)
>>
No. 51379 ID: cd9cc2

>>361168

What are we? Some sort of moon/hell hero combo?
Wordblood is practically an unwoven coadjutor, no sign of torment or urges yet though.
>>
No. 51382 ID: ed57e8

oh man, could we order around pattern spiders?
>>
No. 51383 ID: b6edd6

>>361179
Hell Heroes were created by Titans (or something like that). We, on the other hand, are a Titan (partially at least).
>>
No. 51387 ID: 7fa633

>>361137
Let's just say that Lunar elders tend not to look too-kindly upon Titans...
>>
No. 51397 ID: 9beecc

>>361149
1TW could very well be equivalent to the percentage point increase in efficiency per level.
The question still remains of whether there is ever a cap.
>>
No. 51402 ID: cd9cc2

>>361183

But aren't all Hell Heroes embryonic Titans?
Where as when Sun Heroes learn charms, it is basically "I am really good at this", but when Hell Heroes learn charms, it's "I am [Titans name]." due to the fact that Titans are literally their charm set.
>>
No. 51406 ID: 9beecc

>>361202
Maybe they are just using dead titan fragments rather then being titan embryos themselves?
>>
No. 51407 ID: ed57e8

>>361202
nonon, peregrin for example was made by a deathlord capturing solar exaltation fragmant and turning it inside out. in theory we could reach into him and pull back to normal turning him into a solar.
>>
No. 51410 ID: cd9cc2

>>361207

I'm talking about Infernal exalts, who can eventually learn charms like (Yozi) Cosmic Principle, which is essentialy "I am (Yozi)".

They even lose there exaltation shard upon learning this charm.
>>
No. 51420 ID: cd9cc2

>>361210

their*

Posting late.
>>
No. 51440 ID: f633b5

>>361210
Yes, but that is for INFERNAL Exalts. Saulanna is not an Infernal, not in the usual sense.

Info-dump on INfernals for those not in the know:
Infernals are normally Solar, not Lunar. They are formed from SOlar Exaltations that where captured by the Yozis, and tainted by thier power, overriding the Solar Charmset with thier own.

Saulanna is more akin to a Devil-Tiger, often called a "Supernal Exalt" by fans. They are Infernals that have through the combining of themes/charms of two different Yozis freed themselves of thier control, and begun a metamorphosis into a new kind of primordial. Because they build themselves and their own charms, they have no need to divorce themselves of their own Exaltation.

Speaking of Primordials, what does everyone think would be a good name/title for the Primordial Saulanna is to become?
>>
No. 51441 ID: 70591e

>>361240

Scruffina.
>>
No. 51470 ID: 3734f6

>>361240
Saulanna
>>
No. 51537 ID: 61e7f9
File 133496667822.jpg - (58.85KB , 512x384 , 1229957819006.jpg )
51537

>>devouring the souls of the dead to gain power is immoral
>>
No. 51538 ID: 3734f6

>>361337
who are you quoting
>>
No. 51548 ID: b85f8c

Shall we raise Efficiency again?
>>
No. 51554 ID: 2fe09b

>>361338
For the love of god and all that is decent in this world

don't bring that shit here
>>
No. 51555 ID: ce4a4d

Look, if you're not going to kill Dr Mengele, who are you going to kill?
>>
No. 51556 ID: 3734f6

>>361354
Don't bring what shit here?
>>
No. 51557 ID: fa9f7e

>>361356
I think he meant the morals bitch-fight in the quest. Which actually is supposed to belong in here, not the quest, but eh. And I'm also fairly sure he was talking to the guy you quoted.
>>
No. 51566 ID: 3734f6

>>361357
ah thanks, i see it now.
Yea that is definitely a palm meet face situation
>>
No. 51567 ID: ed57e8

no, waht it is is "whoa re you quoting" ahs become a dumb fourchan meme, so he thought you were bringing that dumbshit meme in here.
>>
No. 51568 ID: fa9f7e

>>361367
Oh. Well, that's awkward. Why would that even become a meme?
>>
No. 51570 ID: a6e66f
File 133504584725.png - (138.61KB , 777x1360 , Robe.png )
51570

I missed when we were suggesting clothing, so here and some things I've drawn since then.
>>
No. 51571 ID: a6e66f
File 133504588233.png - (150.98KB , 985x1314 , Cape.png )
51571

A cape is the only piece of clothing a true adventurer needs, right?
>>
No. 51572 ID: fa9f7e

>>361371
Why does she have a saroshi and panties then

Also I think you could put these in fanart maybe
>>
No. 51573 ID: 3734f6

>>361367
ah, thanks for explaining. I am not familiar with that particular meme
I also do not frequent 4chan
>>
No. 51583 ID: 2563d4

>>361372
There's a thread for paperdolls over here: >>2155
>>
No. 51610 ID: 3c84c7

Ok guys, gonna need to draw up a bit of a cutscene now, so cool your jets a little. Can't draw so much during the week (which is why the last update gap was so big) so it might be a bit until the next update. Hopefully not, but we'll see.
>>
No. 51630 ID: 4cefdf

I can't wait for the update. I am curious though, at some point we will have to contact Luna again whether for information or to fulfill our role as a Moon Hero. We should find out what Kaan knows about Luna and how she might react to him now being our vassal.

Since Kaan originally put the titan into Saulanna before she was made a moon hero, it's entirely possible Luna has been watching this like a game just as we the readers have, knowing of the titan's existance all along.

Either way, talking to Luna about our situation will shed some light on matters further and possibly give us more information. If she didn't know about the titan before its only a matter of time before she notices with us gaining power quickly through exerting titan's will.
>>
No. 51633 ID: 3734f6

>>361430
It is plausible luna knows.
Which means it is plausible that luna is judging us and that weather we keep it a secret or not will impact her decision.
Are we an apparently loyal vassal? (Luna: Sweet! I got a baby titan working under me!)
Or are we a liability that needs exterminating while still weak.

Of course, it might be that she doesn't know and in which case revealing ourselves might cause our death.
>>
No. 51635 ID: 4cefdf

>>361433
Agreed. However if Luna rejects us then what does that say about her? I would hope that she would at least hear us out as she gave us a second life, and she is in some ways like our mother now. We can choose the time and place to contact her about the matter here in this fortress, with the support of Kaan. That is why I believe that if we consult Kaan about the matter he might have some suggestions for how to handle it if she reacts poorly, i.e. threatens to send Moon Heroes and Sun Heroes after us.

But honestly I think it'll be better one way or another once we come clean, Luna is a smart goddess and I think she suspects at the very least something odd is going on.
>>
No. 51658 ID: 3734f6

>>361435
I agree
Also, if she doesn't suspect yet she will soon.

>>/quest/403797
So, all these people talking about will, passion, and sympathy in a way that implies it is some sort of exalted mechanic.
Is this the case or are they just being moralfags?
>>
No. 51662 ID: 04b86a

>>361458
Yeah, based on the way they were presented they seem to be roughly equivalent to Exalted's virtue system.

http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Virtue

Depending on how much Jukashi's changing things, we're basically determining which urges Saulanna's more likely to want to act on in the future, and how well she'll be able to resist certain things.
>>
No. 51664 ID: 3734f6

>>361462
Thanks
This, this is metagaming on a whole new level.
>>
No. 51665 ID: 4cefdf

>>361464
I think the main point of the key words was from the last game post where Jukashi emphasized the morality issue. By picking one of those words it helps him get an idea for the motivation behind why she decides to eat the soul. And sure there is a little metagame due to the fact that everything in the quest can be viewed as a stat, even arousal.
>>
No. 51666 ID: 1417a1

I really hope we don't get more than average DISCIPLINE. It's really the virtue of not having any fun.

Initially, I voted for it, thinking "Well, I sure don't want Saulanna to become a slavering soul addict" but WILL can help with that too so I switched to the more intresting choice of SYMPATHY and PASSION. It was after Jukashi said he had started drawing so I don't know how much good it will do. Disappointingly, a lot of people went for DISCIPLINE.
>>
No. 51673 ID: 1da170

I dunno. In the last chapter of the Quest the responders seemed to get a bit antsy when Saulanna got out of control. It seems like at least some level of Tempe-I mean, Discipline is best for everyone.
>>
No. 51684 ID: 61e7f9

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcJjMnHoIBI&ob=av2n
>>
No. 51718 ID: 1417a1

>>361473
Out of control? I don't recall that. (Though I didn't read the quest until after it was completed.)
>>
No. 51725 ID: 41d52a

Here's a little thought for y'all to rip apart while we're waiting for the next update.

Currently, Saulanna is totally working up her Titanhood cred and being all transcendent and stuff. That's all fair and good, and surely as it should be.

However, the tone of the quest so far (and I'm aware it's not been that many updates yet) has been pretty stiff. I just want to voice the opinion that we shouldn't gain too much respect for Saulanna, even if she is a proto-Titan. Let's not be afraid to be silly and impulsive (within reasonable limits of course), because that's a lot of the stuff that drives a quest like this forward and makes it fun to read and participate in. :3
>>
No. 51737 ID: 431fa8

>>361525
I am a lot more inclined to agree with silliness in quests that move quickly. In a quest that takes weeks on end to finish a single conversation, random antics feel like a waste of rare and valuable author posts.
>>
No. 51906 ID: 3734f6

Alright, I went and made a specific page just for Saulanna's character sheet.
http://tgchan.org/wiki/Lunar_Quest_Saulanna_Ricanya_Rockblossom

If someone can fill in the known possible upgrades, the rules for upgrading, and the costs it would be awesomely useful.

I went and filled in all the competencies she currently has.

1. Standard Environmancy. Does standard = average?
2. Environmancy: What does Environmancy do?
3. Is jewelry the appraisal or crafting of jewelry?
3. What do the magical competencies do, specifically Deathlore, Abjuration, Magelearning, Theurgy, Necrosurgery, and Metaphysics.
>>
No. 51920 ID: 1417a1

This was probably my favorite update so far. Saulanna going from manic laughter to throwing up manages to be both hilarious and kind of sad. Add to that the pic of Peregrin taking notes... Well worth the wait.

>>361706
Enviromancy is probably similar to geomancy.
Necrosurgery probably isn't a magical skill, but rather the art of stitching corpses together in useful ways (usually before applying Necromancy)

Also, what about caps? Didn't someone say we had maxed Efficiency with the last increase?
>>
No. 51924 ID: b6edd6

>>/quest/405407
ARGH, it is starting to really annoy me how people refuse to use the discussion thread for the souls discussion.

Anyway, the difference between soulcrafting and eating souls is fairly simple.
With soulcrafting, the soul's mind is mostly intact and trapped in a prison in which it suffers immensely.
When souls are eaten, the memories and personality are removed, basically destroying the soul's mind. This sounds bad at first glance, but is essentially the same that process happens when a mortal or ghost is killed through normal means.
The difference between eating a soul and normally killing them is that when they die normally, their life-force is made into a new person, where when we eat them it isn't.
>>
No. 51929 ID: 4cefdf

>>361724
Aye. For those moral people out there who are still on the fence about eatting souls, think of it this way. No energy is destroyed, it is merely absorbed, thus should we die the energy will return to the cycle. Ideally at some point we will hit the singularity that is a Titan and be able to create souls even with our own will without having to rely on absorbed will. Of course that maturity is a long ways off and by that point if we haven't prepared we might find ourselves in a bit of a tricky situation with Gods and Heroes of all types coming after us to try to kill or imprison us like the Yozi were.

Ultimately I fear necessity will drive us to seek out the other titan fragment in the Labyrinth we were told about in Chapter 1. I suspect that is where Kaan found the shard he used to create Wordblood in Saulanna.
>>
No. 51930 ID: 3734f6

A thought occurs, the only source of new souls are titans, the gods took out the titans.
Currently no new souls are being created in existence AND a variety of unsavory beings are destroying souls.

This means that the ONLY way for reality to avoid soul starvation is for a new titan to come about and create souls. Saulina is that titan, we are not "ruining the cycle of reincarnation"... we are saving it from soul starvation that is currently taking place due to irresponsible behavior of gods and mortals.

>We should eat other titan fragments
Of course, each one should be worth a fuckton of TW compared to the paltry amount we get from mortal souls.
>>
No. 51944 ID: 256d52

Hmm, if we're keep being so on the fence about morality why don't we, you know, get Saulanna ask someone what their position on morality is?

Peregrin's thoughts ought to be illuminating and then we can chat with Luna.
>>
No. 51946 ID: c4a1fc

>>361730
Hm. How would we create souls? It seems we have a potentially unlimited supply of soulsteel on our hands if we can get at it.
>>
No. 51947 ID: b6edd6

>>361746
We kind of have to ascend to major titan status first.
Even at that point we would need to re-invent soulsteel to produce it, seeing as how it no longer exists. (And all of that is assuming we want to make soulsteel in the first place, which I don't think we do.)
>>
No. 51948 ID: ed57e8

couldn't a titan make it out of raw soul energy or is soul steel powered by the suffering of the souls in it?
>>
No. 51949 ID: 3734f6

ok so... peregrin was smooth as fuck from the beginning and I am really liking him...
Anyone else shipping Saulanna / Peregrin?
>>
No. 51950 ID: 3734f6

>>361748
Soulsteel doesn't work anymore. The gods altered reality itself so that soulsteel will cease to function.
>>
No. 51951 ID: c4a1fc

>>361750
Iirc, that was the Dragon's Shadow, aka the Ebon Dragon's older form, aka another Titan. Guess who is/will be a Titan? Us. Let's see if it applies to us.
>>
No. 51958 ID: ed57e8

yeah, if one titan can alter reality to fuck something up, then another can change it back.
>>
No. 51961 ID: 0d0533

Well, we do have this discussion thread for a reason, and late evenings do make me feel like waxing eloquent.

>In the main thread, Juroku sez':

>Time and time again, the process of 'cleaning' the souls is about equal to reincarnation

Wish I had the confidence in this that you have, but I'm still somewhat uncertain, through my own ignorance of setting standard and of Jukashi's adjustments to it. That aside, there's a number of off-topic reasons why I don't think Saulanna consuming too many souls is a good idea. A lot of them were aired in the previous thread. Some have been adressed to satisfaction, others, not so much.

>chances are the reason they linger are usually not nice.

We've already met the less selfish version of such ghosts in Gevin. Ought we truly judge ghosts like him under this reasoning and think of them as potential power sources just because 'chances' are they stayed behind due to ill will? It's a slippery slope, and Saulanna is not under our control (I have this sneaking suspicion the sense of empowerment from consuming souls may have a slighly addictive effect). If we give her the right reasons to keep consuming souls, she could certainly keep it up without our prompting. Hence my posts. A little mote of conscience to poke at the morals of 'pre-emptive necessity', as the argument goes below.

>I'd rather eat a monster now and have a few nightmares from his cruel past than need to eat innocent souls later to fight a powerful foe and have nightmares from what we have done.

As for this, we cannot judge how things may turn out with such certainty! We do have the option of seeking Titan's Fragments to fulfill Saulanna's likely needs for Power. We also have the option of being cautious and clever and applying what power she has in a good manner, rather than depending on Titan's Will to brute-force our dilemmas. Saulanna is a Moon Hero, after all, and not without her innate strengths.

>As for giving the cleansed girls their memories back? ...

Fixin' 'em does not necessarily mean giving 'em back their old identities, mind you. Nor would old identities being returned necessarily end as badly as you claim it would, as we, frankly, do not know the degree to which these women are even capable of forming new identities... or if old and new identities would even conflict in the manner you describe. What we see could be the vestiges of old identities, not fully scoured clean. Perhaps recoverable, perhaps not.

One of them, at least, can't remember her name at all, so as something's clearly wrong there I'd like to at least to encourage Saulanna to investigate that and see what she and Wordblood might be able to do. Even if it's not advisable or possible to give back memories, perhaps doing something about their scoured souls and lack of identity can be done. Peregrin did damage them in some way and I wonder if the damage is of the irreparable sort, if it's healing on itself or if Saulanna can actually do something for them. It couldn't hurt to investigate, certainly.
>>
No. 51967 ID: 3734f6

>Wish I had the confidence in this that you have, but I'm still somewhat uncertain, through my own ignorance of setting standard and of Jukashi's adjustments to it. That aside, there's a number of off-topic reasons why I don't think Saulanna consuming too many souls is a good idea. A lot of them were aired in the previous thread. Some have been adressed to satisfaction, others, not so much.
Name them

>We've already met the less selfish version of such ghosts in Gevin.
Which nobody argues we should consume. How is this a reason not to eat bad guys though?

>Lets make soulsteel work again
That... would be ridiculously evil, restart the soulsteel crafting business, and will draw negative attention to us.

>Seek titan fragment
It is worth noting that they will rape the shit out of us if we don't first level the fuck up by eating a ton of souls.
>>
No. 51968 ID: 256d52

I feel I should point out that Saulanna is blessed with titan-killing weapon-ness even before you factor in Wordblood.

Don't let the nascent titan side of things overshadow her MOON HERO-ness in your thinking.
>>
No. 51969 ID: ed57e8

uhh, the exalted kinda GANGED UP on the titans. there were a bunch of them. in a one on one fight though, titan win.
>>
No. 51970 ID: 256d52

>>361769

There's no such thing as a one on one fight with a titan. It's a collective entity.

The fragments though, are much more managable. They are probably just shed parts of a titan's soul hierarchy (I wouldn't rule out weirder things though).
>>
No. 51989 ID: 1bb360

>>361767

>Name them.

Very well, though on some pro/con judgements we should probably just agree to disagree.

-Empowerment issue. Is eating souls addictive? I would think it could be. Cripes, remember the whole 'laughing maniacally' thing just now? Big, big warning sign. We got a sign as to that in the previous thread as well, where it felt 'good' to eat a soul when the memories weren't getting in the way. I'm actually glad Discipline became a virtue, because it could help us deal with that particular bit of bad mojo.

-Allies/enemies issue. Peregrin's cool with us eating souls. Others? Very much the opposite. We've been warned that most everyone else outside of our little shadowy domain (and likely most within it, if they knew) would look, understatement, poorly on our eating habits. The more we do it, and the more obvious ways in which we do it, the more likely we are to not garner any support from, say, other Exalted heroes. In fact, the opposite might very much become the case even if, and I say if, we only keep to eating the vilest of criminal scum.

-Morality issue. In specific, Saulanna's morality. See earlier mention of slippery slopes. Our suggestions form Saulanna's tentative morality, as it were. The more we tell her it's okay to eat (and justify eating) certain souls, the more she will consider it an option. We're not in secure control of her actions. It could, say, go something like this.

Vile Villains? Eat 'em. They deserve no less.

Enemies? Eat 'em. They would have done the same to you, had they the chance, and this way you're killing two birds with one stone.

Minor Villains? Eat 'em. Eh. They're mooks, they're in your way and it'll do ya good for the boss fight!

And so forth. This isn't necessarily what will happen, but what I fear may happen if nobody steps in to say 'Oy!' at the soul-munchies. If you don't think this is a bad thing, then we will just have to agree to disagree.

>How is this a reason not to eat bad guys though?

Two reasons. One, we have to start judging every 'bad guy' on a scale of wickedness and, ironically, the lower this scale is set, the easier empowerment will be, and the more nightmare-worthy skills we avoid.

At what point of 'bad guy' is it enough to have us tell Saulanna to eat someone? How can we, the advisors, be certain of someone's 'bad guy' status and the reasons for it? Peregrin handed us a villain on a platter, for sure, so the case seemed legitimately clear-cut there, but it will not always be so.

Two, it is conceivable that we could be plain, downright wrong about someone's level of villainhood. I'm sure some people are happy to take that chance, but, in general, I'm not.

Furthermore, mon ami, we are more than the sum of our sins. A villain is seldom just a villain. What lead this particular vile ghost down his path of soul-forging... we don't know. We do have Peregrin's oath-sworn words to lean on, but as he is a skilled manipulator I am disinclined to take them -quite- at face value. No doubt that he told the truth, but little of the ghost's past was explored or explained so we can never know for sure now.

I guess all I'm saying is that judging the severity of villainhood in every lingering ghost or opponent won't be easy (or it could be, but that would defeat the 'only eating those who deserve it' thing, since we can't know for sure). In essence, mistakes could be made, and it seems to me unnecessary to push so hard for eating souls when we do have another option to conspicious mass consumption; seeking titan fragments.

>It is worth noting that they will BLEEP the BLEEP out of us if we don't first level the BLEEP up by eating a ton of souls.

It is worth noting that titan fragments aren't titans. If something like the current ruler of the Underworld was gunning after us, then, well, yeah. Otherwise, though, we won't be quite that desperate for empowement since we're a MOON HERO and all.
>>
No. 51997 ID: 3734f6

>Is eating souls addictive?
Just so you know, addiction co-ops the biological mechanism for eating food, having sex, exercising, etc.
All essential bodily functions release endorphin which is "addictive" by design to ensure creatures perform them rather then wasting away to nothing.
Addicted to eating is not exactly a bad thing. And total abstinence is not the way to go about it.

>Allies/enemies issue. Peregrin's cool with us eating souls. Others? Very much the opposite.
If we eat souls we will be powerful, if we don't we will be weak. Many will try to kill us for what we are.
If we eat we gain power and be able to create MORE souls then we eat. Titans are the natural source of souls by eating aged souls and creating multiple new souls per each aged soul consumed.
We are also first and foremost a social character, so we could convince them of the need for us to do so.
Also we can be discreet about it, recall that outside the land of the dead souls dissipate and go to reincarnation.

>Morality issue
Nothing immoral about it, even of good people. Her eating a soul is morally superior then letting it go through natural reincarnation. As
1. Some of it is preserved.
2. It is necessary for the cycle of reincarnation (as titans are the only source of new souls)

>slippery slopes
Good, the faster we slip down it the sooner we could restore the natural order of things by creating baby souls.

I actually agree that there slippery slopes exist. The thing is, that doesn't justify an extremist known to be wrong position to avoid overshooting the correct golden middle road.
It possible to overshoot, but you should strive towards good not towards mediocre. And if you overshoot you can correct it.
People constantly misuse the slippery slope argument to justify a position that they know to be wrong and unjustifiable.
Slippery slope is justification to not allow even small injustice lest it lead to big one. It is for issues where the extreme IS the correct position. For example, freedom vs slavery. "just convicted felons shall be made slaves for only X years" becomes "people X are slaves by default and cannot be free" via slippery slope.

>It is worth noting that titan fragments aren't titans.
Good point. But how strong are they? We are a neophyte moon hero after all.
>>
No. 52017 ID: 1bb360

>>361797

-I don't see that there is anything inherently wrong with abstinence of certain substances not necessary for life. It's a simple choice, like others in life, and is not necessarily an expression of extremism, though it certainly is an expression of opinion and choice. Anyway, addiction in this case probably isn't as tightly tied to the biological, since we're talking about a magical world with its heroes and demons and monsters and ghosts and gods and who knows what else. Fairly sure from what little I remember of the setting that there were magic drugs, for example.

-I don't see how it is very 'morally superior' to preserve only the part of someone's soul that benefit yourself, but I will grant that morals are a variable set of beliefs. Advice Saulanna as you want on this.

-Power is relative. Even a neophyte MOON HERO can kick seven kinds of crap out of most mortals (or large groups thereof), and unless something dangerous comes up, Saulanna doesn't have to hurry in expanding her powers. We've got time to look around at the branching paths to power.

>Saulanna is first and foremost a social character.

I'm afraid she is a character of the Mind moreso. Savvy is Ridiculous and Acuity and Intuition is Astonishing. She is Astonishing at Inspiration, but only Remarkable at Beauty and Dickery. Your point stands, of course. Saulanna could be convincing and argue her way to other supporting allies, but it will be easier to argue that if she doesn't display a -tendency- towards voluntarily seeking out and devouring souls to empower herself. The 'self-defence' or 'they deserved it' arguments can only carry someone so far. Keeping a comparatively low profile is definitely a good idea either way. Being a MOON HERO is a good cover, and may be used to explain some of Saulanna's Titanic magic uses to the less enlightened.

>Titans are the only way for souls to reproduce.

Now, here's a thing. I don't know the setting or Jukashi's adjustments to it enough to say for sure one way or another if this is the case. Are we certain creating 'baby souls' isn't a function of the normal cycle of reincarnation? If we actually got word that the world was losing souls faster than it could replenish them, I'd see -some- sense in your argument, but as it is, we really don't know... so we're making our own assumptions, I suppose.

>Relative strength of titan shards.

It is probably a variable factor, dependant on the size of the fragment. That said, how difficult might it be to consume them? Let's hear what Wordblood has to say on the issue:

>"Before that, between the war and my "waking", I do not think I was alive. I was like a puppet, awaiting strings, and a hand; at least, I reckon it so. I may be wrong, but if I am not, other fragments of Titans would be the same."

While it is conceivable others have been awakening their own proto-titans, the real difficulty might lie more in finding and obtaining the fragments in the first place, rather than wresting control over them.
>>
No. 52021 ID: 431fa8

So guys, Titan's Will.

I am inclined to invest our current 8 points thusly:
-2 to increase Saulanna's Soul Force to 3
-2 to increase Wordblood's Soul Force to 3
-3 to increase Efficiency of Consumption
-1 banked for now

This will increase our overall strength and keep us balanced with Wordblood while continuing to optimize the gains we get from future consumed souls. Objections?
>>
No. 52022 ID: 1bb360

>>361821

Well. My opinion is that we should, at most, spend only roughly half our Titan's Will and keep the remaining 4 in reserve. Titan's Will is an incredibly useful resource, but once it's spent it's spent forever. We should always keep a sizable reserve for emergencies. Upgrading Saulanna's Soul Force would fulfill Wordblood's request that she has more spiritual strength than her and prevent the blending between them. I believe it'd also give her more MOON DOTS? Which is useful.

As for the remaining point, there's a few options available for 1 TW, improving Toughness (will take some time) or creating another Word of Power among them. Jukashi noted down the cost (and likely application) of a few Words of Power, further up in this thread.
>>
No. 52026 ID: 431fa8

>>361822
Giving either Wordblood or Saulanna Soul Force will provide us with additional Moon Power, so upgrading them each once would provide us with 6 additional dots- a huge increase in effective combat endurance.

We don't have a lot of information on this whole blending thing, which strikes me as fueled in large part by paranoia. If it is significant, I suspect that any imbalance in Soul Force will prevent the blending between them only one way- that is, the weaker soul will continue to absorb characteristics of the stronger soul. If we want there to be as little blending as possible, the route to that would be to either pump up both of their Soul Forces really high or to invest in some kind of Titanic Ability that keeps their essences distinct.

I would really like Wordblood to get more Soul Force- more than Saulanna, really, but since he wants her to be at least as high as him increasing them together seems fine. As Wordblood grows stronger he'll be able to get a better read on how he can improve Saulanna and generally be more potent backup, not to mention that our Efficiency of Consumption- which governs both the amount of usable power we get from consuming things and the massive flare that we send up because of it- is capped by his Soul Force so it's worth increasing just for that.

You are right about the value of keeping reserves, though. After upgrading both their Soul Forces I'd be willing to leave it at that; there's not really that much point in an Efficiency increase until just before we're planning to use it, after all.


I am a bit interested in getting a "write", "book", or "transcribe" Power Word- that would be VERY in alignment with Wordblood's nature and therefore probably be quite potent, and maybe it would allow us to make books out of what we know near-instantly. That would let us basically absorb entire libraries without destroying them as long as we had the Moon Power to burn, and could thus let us pick up truly impressive amounts of knowledge very quickly.
>>
No. 52028 ID: 3734f6

>I don't see that there is anything inherently wrong with abstinence of certain substances not necessary for life
It is necessary. She is a titan fetus who needs it to grow into adulthood. An "addiction" to eating food that allows you to grow from a fetus to an adult is not a harmful one. It is no different then the natural biological addiction to food and water and air.

>I don't see how it is very 'morally superior' to preserve only the part of someone's soul that benefit yourself
It is morally superior because the natural order of things is to preserve NOTHING. What of this do you fail to understand?
Natural order: Nothing is preserved, no change in quantity of souls in universe.
Saulina eating: Useful parts are preserved, net gain in souls in universe.

Saulina eating is at worst neutral and at best morally superior.

>The 'self-defence' or 'they deserved it' arguments can only carry someone so far.
How about "its the natural order of things and required for life to exist"?
If souls are not recycled babies will not be born, people will grow old, die, and all life will end with nothing but ghosts remaining.
Souls then MUST be recycled, and saulina recycles souls more efficiently then the natural processes of reality.

>Power is relative. Even a neophyte MOON HERO can kick seven kinds of crap out of most mortals
But a titan fragment is NOT a mortal.

>it will be easier to argue that if she doesn't display a -tendency- towards voluntarily seeking out and devouring souls to empower herself. The 'self-defence' or 'they deserved it' arguments can only carry someone so far.
But it can carry, and there is also the issue that those souls are using dark magic to resist the natural order of things (not cast by themselves, but by the death mense) and the only way her eating them differs from reincarnation is that if she eats them she can create more souls then she took in.

> Are we certain creating 'baby souls' isn't a function of the normal cycle of reincarnation?
We are certain it isn't in the normal setting. Jukashi could have houseruled it otherwise... but if even so, then so what? she will still be providing a net gain in souls.
>>
No. 52039 ID: 1bb360

>Only two other test subjects, one male, one female.

Huh. Coulda sworn there was a mention of several female subjects. Oh well!

>>361826

Hmm. I guess improving both their Soul Forces would be a good thing if it gives us more MOON DOTS, which have their own uses. It's also tempting to use our current reserve and come up with some way to find or point our way to Titan fragments in the world, though I'm not entirely sure how it could be accomplished. We should speak to Wordblood about it. No rush, though. We've got oodles to do just familiarizing ourselves with the domain and its inhabitants.
>>
No. 52044 ID: 9718f3

On the topic of eating souls or not: in the setting, it is no different from simply killing the person, in effect. We should eat the souls of those we kill and debate over who we kill. A lot more sensible a debate than the current one.

The only real concern is that if we eat souls en masse, the powers that be will chase after us for messing with their cycle of soul rebirth. But we aren't going around killing people indiscriminately so that shouldn't be an issue. Exalted have tons of natural enemies already.
>>
No. 52054 ID: b6edd6

>>361839
He did say those two were the only remaining subjects, so presumably there were other male subjects.

>>361844
Basically this.
>>
No. 52057 ID: 1417a1

You don't have to fret about removing specific souls from the cycle. This is a whole world. Probably still untold billions of souls. If we can get multiple TW from a single soul, it's very much worth the growth we get.

>>361844
Really good advice
>>
No. 52162 ID: 3bad4c

>>/quest/407180

sudo -u wordblood cat /home/wordblood/* | more
>>
No. 52184 ID: f548f1

Glad I wasn't the only one who thought of that
>>
No. 52223 ID: b9d767

Maybe it's just me, but I have a suspicious feeling about whats happening right now. What if the ghost captain is actually a servant of The Ebon Dragon? Think about it, it's just the kind of dickery he (or one of his "heroes") would pull. It would give him an excellent opprotunity to be alone with us while our servant is away.

This is, of course, assuming he is indeed a Shadow Hero, and not just a ghost. Paranoia ahoy!
>>
No. 52239 ID: 4cefdf

Wordblood has certainly given us a nice bit of information to piece together. It also helps confirm that at some point coming to Luna is not a mistake, we just need to do some things first to show we are still the badass MOON HERO she knew we could become. Information gathering on these emissaries and then using our resources to perhaps halt the growth of this shadowland or defeat/subjugate some enemy of the moon would definately show her we are a titan seed with good intentions at heart.

Just for future planning I suggest after we learn what we can do with our titanic power, we eat the food the servant brought(I think its safe to rule her out as a spy as she was mind wiped in the soul cleansing process). After that we can have the servant girl show us to the library. I would not recommend using any titans will in plan sight of the captain of the guard or any unknown persons. If we need to do an upgrade to disguise our aura we can ask the captain to wait outside while we eat our meal using the excuse his staring is bothering her.
>>
No. 52273 ID: 4349bf

TEN maidens of Fate? Jukashi, you tease!
>>
No. 52290 ID: b6edd6

>>362073
What is the standard number of them?
>>
No. 52292 ID: b9d767

>>362090
Five. One for each of the classic planets. Mercury is Journeys, Mars is Battles, Venus is Serenity(love/romance), Jupiter is Secrets, and Saturn is Endings(death).
>>
No. 52294 ID: b9d767

>>362092
And I should not that Saturn's governing over death is not the same death that empowers DEATH HEROS.
>>
No. 52327 ID: b6edd6

>>362094
Is it the kind that is inherently opposed to undead (treating undeath being an evasion and/or perversion of death)?
>>
No. 52333 ID: b9d767

>>362127
Yep.
>>
No. 52366 ID: 256d52

>>362092

Soooo, Uranus, Neptune, Pluto, Eris and, uh, X?
>>
No. 52377 ID: 86e159

>>362166

Opis. Not a planet.

>A story told by the Roman Hyginus in the Poeticon astronomicon (ultimately based on Greek myth) says that the milk came from the goddess Ops/Opis (Greek Rhea), the wife of Saturn (Greek Cronus). Saturn swallowed his children to ensure his position as head of the Pantheon and sky god, and so Ops conceived a plan to save her newborn son Jupiter (Greek Zeus): She wrapped a stone in infant's clothes and gave it to Saturn to swallow. Saturn asked her to nurse the child once more before he swallowed it, and the milk that spurted when she pressed her nipple against the rock eventually became the Milky Way.
>>
No. 52403 ID: 72d49b

>>>/quest/409610
It's a duly sworn oath, so we do need to abide by it. But it's pretty discretionary on our part, seeing as we're only required to teach a "fair" portion. If we continuously refrain from teaching we'd be not acting right, but reasonable education to the point which benefits us anyway would easily suffice. We're certainly not obligated to let him watch any particular thing, but it might nonetheless be nice to do so.

Also, upon reviewing the oath:
>Any command I give, you will obey; save that I would gain by it.
Our oath has an exception to the "follow our commands" clause, saying that he can ignore commands that benefit us. There are other clauses that more or less invalidate the exception (The following):
>You will serve faithfully, wisely, and well, as best as you can do.
>You will not go against my will, nor what my will would be.
But still, why was that even there in the first place?
>>
No. 52404 ID: b6edd6

>>362203
When the situation changes, a previous set of orders can become counterproductive, and we won't always be nearby to give new ones.
For example, remember the red hand in elf-crown quest. The poor bastard literally could not say the Scavenger Lord's weaknesses to save his life, which ended up letting us learn that and more.
>>
No. 52405 ID: 09e5bf

>>362204
I think the problem is Cruxador's misreading it.

Peregrin can't ignore commands that benefit us. What he can do is ignore commands when doing so is in our best interests.
>>
No. 52406 ID: 72d49b

>>362205
Maybe that's what it was intended to mean, but that's not what it actually says.
And if that's the case then it essentially voids the entire clause, because he can disobey at any time he thinks it's in our interests, and he's bound to serve our interests anyway.
Better than tearing him apart by making him do something that would hurt us, I guess.
>>
No. 52415 ID: ce4a4d

Y'know, if you want to modify an earlier suggestion, you can delete your old posts. Helps reduce clutter.

Sometimes it ends your session and makes this impossible, but it's generally possible.
>>
No. 52425 ID: 15cdb6

Someone made an assumption in the thread that I have to refute.

Soul Force is not directly equal to the Essence Rating from Exalted, for various reasons. A Soul Force of 2 is actually "between" Essence 1 and Essence 2; a heroic, strong-willed mortal or an exalted newer than default character generation assumes - a "high 1" or a "low 2"- are both Soul Force 2.

So Saulanna is actually weaker, at the moment, than a standard "new" Exalt, if you consider her on her own. If you consider her as a whole entity including Wordblood, of course, she's stronger.
>>
No. 52438 ID: 71d68e

>>362225
That suggests that Soul Force isn't on a 1-10 scale.
>>
No. 52440 ID: 5029d1

>>362238
you think a gaia has soul force 10? hell no, like.. 1000 or something
>>
No. 52442 ID: 15cdb6

>>362238

It's 1 to 15. Every pair from one to ten (1 and 2, 3 and 4, etc) have an extra "mid" level squeezed between them, pushing each aside a bit. Stat limits, though, if they ever come up, are still tied to the old system.

I've got a little chart.

>>362240

Individual Titan souls are limited to 15, but a titan as a whole counts all their upper souls, for some purposes at least.
>>
No. 52443 ID: 1facc9

http://tgchan.org/kusaba/quest/res/399781.html#i409751
>Create a Feeding Soul. Possibly a scholarly Scavenger Lord or a great library adorned with the busts of those we have devoured.
>busts
>>
No. 52448 ID: baa08d

Ten maidens of fate?

What else do we know?

A second sun, the death of the Ebon Dragon, beastfolk taking Thorns and Leviathan conquest of the isles of Skullstone.

Is that all of them? Should we ask about the Scarlet Empress and her empire?
>>
No. 52449 ID: c4a1fc

>>362248
Ebon Dragon isn't dead. The Dragon's Shadow is what the Ebon Dragon was before the gods rebelled. He's... reverted, I guess... to the Dragon's Shadow since the Reclamation succeeded.
>>
No. 52453 ID: 72d49b

>>362242
>Every pair from one to ten (1 and 2, 3 and 4, etc) have an extra "mid" level squeezed between them
What? Why? That sounds needlessly complicated.

>>362243
Just in case you're actually confused, a "bust" isn't just breasts, but also refers to a kind of statuary depicting head and upper torso, but not the arms and it only goes down to (roughly) the middle of the ribcage.
>>
No. 52455 ID: 15cdb6

>>362253
>That sounds needlessly complicated.

I have a variety of relatively weak reasons: distinguishing between weak and strong examples at a particular Essence level, adding more levels to feel achievement for as the ranks are climbed, increasing the Power pool given the new system, things like that. But you're probably right.

Still - this is a game with such mechanics as mysterious SCHNOZZLEPOINTS and obtuse COMPETENCIES, after all. The changes to the system aren't necessarily to make it simpler!
>>
No. 52462 ID: b9d767

If we make any new souls, we should avoid making any that would manifest as external geographical locations, as that would give away our titanic presence. We should keep them internal, at least for now. We should also think of a way for our internal souls to manifest externally, should we need them to. Perhaps them showing up in our Soul Fire and acting through it. That way they can act upon the outside world while staying inside.

Does anyone have any ideas as to what our next soul should be? I'm not saying that we should make it right now, just brainstorming.
>>
No. 52470 ID: 210977

>>362255

BOONDOLLARS and ECHELADDERS, amirite?
>>
No. 52475 ID: 197830

Could someone better at interpreting than me try to figure out what Wordblood is displaying in the last couple of images?

All I could get is "We need to grow", I think.
>>
No. 52491 ID: b9d767

>>362249
But if you look back, it was the birth of Sol Invictus that transformed him into the Ebon Dragon. Perhaps the ignition of the second sun caused him to revert?
>>
No. 52504 ID: 886469

>>362275
Okay, so basically right now we have two souls, Saulanna and Wordblood. Woordblood thinks we should make another one that provides us energy and makes things more effecient. Essentially, if we're a cell, this would be the mitochondria. To do that we need to split off a bit of our soul, because we can't make something from nothing, and to do that safely, we need to make our soul bigger first. All of this is done through the expenditure of energy (Titan's Will, which is basically XP) but we have enough to spare.
>>
No. 52505 ID: 5029d1

>>362304
yes but we have no idea what the effects are. it supposedly can alter our personality and we don't have much of one to begin with.
>>
No. 52506 ID: 886469

>>362305
Wordblood did give us a substantial overview, and I'm sure more details would come as we go through this.

As far as effects on our personality, it's presumably just because we are a sum of our parts, but regardless, Wordblood did indicate that we'll be able to shape it ourselves.
>>
No. 52508 ID: b9d767

>>362305
Which is why we need to design it, instead of simply creating it. I'm thinking something avian, perhaps a corvid. Seeing as how this soul is going to be our Feeding Soul, it would be logical that it be an omnivore, to ensure not being stuck on any one source of sustinance. Corvids are also know to be carrion feeders, which will help in that we are going to be feeding on ghosts. They also have some symbolism with death, so deathly abilities may be useful as we are likely to spend in shadowlands or the underworld. Just no Void-related death stuff. Corvids are also intelligent and capable of speech, so that ties in with our literary themes.

Anyone else have any ideas for what our new soul will be like?
>>
No. 52509 ID: 431fa8

>>362308
I would like it to embody the emotions that we focused on when we were feeding on the imprisoned ghost- our discipline, self-control, desire to deliberately and carefully do what must be done without seeking personal satisfaction or being wavered by either sympathy for or the desire to punish others.
>>
No. 52515 ID: 5029d1

>>362309
so a... dapper crow?
>>
No. 52522 ID: f15c1e

Question about Soul Force: When we raise it, we get a free Moon Ability, is it a one time thing? As in, if we raise it from 2 to 3, then lower it to 2 for the feeding soul, then raise it back to 3, do we get one moon ability or two?
>>
No. 52524 ID: a391c8

>>362322

One.
>>
No. 52527 ID: 72d49b

>>362315
Or basically the Collector.
>>
No. 52530 ID: 746f27

We should make it a raccoon. I mean, for one thing, they wash their food, and cleaning out memories is going to be part of this thing's job.
>>
No. 52534 ID: e3aff6

I liked the suggestion of making the feeding soul an autonomous library, except if we do that the obvious thing would be to store memories of souls as books or bookshelves rather than statues. I like it because of the obvious Wordblood synergy as well as because libraries are all about sorting, organizing, and looking up information, which I think we will be doing a lot as we accumulate more competencies and memories from souls. Not being a creature would also quite possibly help deter the formation of troublesome instincts such as hunger, and libraries in particular are disciplined in nature.
Books would also be handy because things we don't want popping up can be can be securely filed away rather than popping up at inconvenient times in the way that traumatic memories tend to.

>If we make any new souls, we should avoid making any that would manifest as external geographical locations
Presumably a soul shaped like a building would still be in our mind like Wordblood or any other soul of ours.
>>
No. 52539 ID: 72d49b

>>362334
Books would be the individual memories. Each aisle would have a bust of the person we ate at the head of it.

Also yeah, I'm thinking this would basically be the background for the "talking to Wordblood" scenes if we go library. Although I don't know how possible this is, maybe souls have to be sapient entities. I mean, that would make sense.
>>
No. 52542 ID: b9d767

>>362339
Oh, it's totally possible to have a soul as a geographical feature and still be sapient. Happens all the time, really. They also tend to have seperate bodies that are not thier geographical selves.

>>362334
Actually, I like your idea for the Feeding Soul better. Still going to hang onto the Raven idea though, might come in handy for later souls.
>>
No. 52548 ID: 3734f6

>>362334
That is a really neat idea. I overall like it.

But I would like to first see what those choices are he mentioned we must make during creation. Perhaps there are benefits and penalties for each option and one is how "aware" that soul is...

It should be noted also that it will not be a separate individual. Saulanna and Wordblood are parts of the same entity and the lines between them are blurring, likewise this will be a third part of that entity.
>>
No. 52551 ID: 197830

I like the idea of a library.
Perhaps we should include a fire-pit or large stone fireplace for the disposal of harmful 'books' that we decide we don't want to risk contaminating the rest?
>>
No. 52552 ID: 5029d1

again, while the library is NEAT it may simply be impossible if the soul must be the form of something alive.
>>
No. 52560 ID: 1417a1

>>362352
The soul could probably take the appearance of a librarian if it/he/she needs a more personal level of interaction.
>>
No. 52594 ID: 3734f6

>>362360
that is a good one. A sexy librarian aspect of saulanna which manages the "library" of memories from consumed.
>>
No. 52595 ID: 256d52

Clearly a psuedo-Saulanna with origami clothing who bleeds ink and pages is the way to go.
>>
No. 52607 ID: 197830

>>362394
...I will second this idea, but only if biblio!Saulanna wears horn-rimmed glasses.
>>
No. 52609 ID: 1417a1

Remember that this is a separate entity from us though. We probably don't want her to look like a twin of Saulanna since she's just a sub-soul and hopefully just one of many to come.
>>
No. 52611 ID: 197830

>>362409
How about...color-reversed Saulanna in a "sexy librarian" outfit?
>>
No. 52613 ID: 5029d1

>>362409
it wont BE a separate entity it will be apart of us and us a part of it.
>>
No. 52615 ID: b9d767

I'd like to have everyone here keep in mind that while deciding the Feeding Soul's appearance is something we have to do, what it's appearance MEANS is just as, if not more, important. How a titan's component souls act, think, and interprate things all play a part in a Titanic psyche.

It's obvious that "Library" is a consensus, but what exactly that entails could be many things. A research library, where mysteries are explored and science is done? An open and accepting institution, spreading knowledge to all? A diabolical hoard of lore, sceaming and planning to take secrets for itself? These are things we need to decide.
>>
No. 52617 ID: 5029d1

>>362415
again, library may not be possible.
>>
No. 52621 ID: 71d68e

>>362417
Titan sub-souls've included far, far weirder things. Stuff like a deadly wind, etc.
>>
No. 54476 ID: d6d7bd

>>362421

If I recall correctly, there's one who's an emotion.
>>
No. 54478 ID: c4a1fc

>>364276
There indeed is one like that. A soul can be pretty much anything.
>>
No. 54506 ID: 1417a1

>>362413
"Separate" might be the wrong choice of words, but it is partly it's own individual. It will be a part of us, but we won't be a part of it. Like a hand.

It could look like us, but that should be for a specific reason. A quirk of that soul. Perhaps Saulanna imagines her soul as looking as her self and thus creates it as such, which could have side effects.

Perhaps the soul really is a library, but in order to talk to people it creates an avatar based either on the visitor or a character in the books, depending on what it feels like. But it could still represent it's personal theme somehow (like specific style of clothing).
>>
No. 54507 ID: 1417a1

>>362415
Indeed. A curious thing is that the library we're talking about is our feeding soul, not our knowledge soul or memory soul or whatever. So it should say something about the way we view feeding.

I like the idea of a hoard actually. The other suggestions seem more fitting for a different type of soul. I see the Library-soul as a place of both curiosity and greed. We want to understand the world, to know what others know and the power that comes with that. That why our feeding soul is a library. Visually, I see it as a bright and open place, with books and mementos proudly on display. Paintings with important memories on the wall. It's not a place of science were new things are discovered, but it is a place of research were old things are uncovered once again. We're not jealously hoarding it though. As soon as it's in our library, it won't be forgotten, so if we have visitors in our mind or learn to manifest our souls, we would gladly invite guests, though perhaps some thing are best kept in the off-limits basement.

The library herself is a custodian of Creation's knowledge and a creature of infinite curiosity and desire to learn. She projects her librarian avatar because she loves to interact with intelligent beings and she wears other people's appearance as she tries to understand their perspectives.

This kind of started as a general musing on souls but ended up as a suggestion. What do you think?
>>
No. 54542 ID: baa08d

>>364276

A virulent emotion at that.

(Lypothymie, page 122 of CoCD V: Malfeas)

>>364278

There are also forests, streets, highways and non-physical things such as alternate realities and darkness.
>>
No. 54563 ID: 7472ad

>>364306
>"Separate" might be the wrong choice of words, but it is partly it's own individual. It will be a part of us, but we won't be a part of it. Like a hand.

That might not be entirely sure. I was going back over the Broke Winged Crane and other Infernal/Malfaen books, and I find myself worrying that the feeding soul will end up being the equivalent of one of her Third Circle Souls. I realize this isn't following Exalted perfectly, but in it when a Yozi creates a Third Circle soul, whatever the Third Circle's motivation is made to be becomes a strong unbreakable intimacy for the Yozi itself.

If that applies here, we should think about it carefully and make sure it's focus is something we want Saulanna to care deeply about herself, not just something that would be neat or cool as a minion/associate/whatever.
>>
No. 54575 ID: e3aff6

>>364363
Whether we are following that or not, it is practically guaranteed that any soul we add at this point will have a large impact on us due to our low soul count if nothing else.
Many of the traits I want in a library soul are traits that would be useful to us overall, such as desire for knowledge and self-control.
(Also, the vague idea of a long term strategy I have involves acquiring vast amounts of knowledge and transferring it to our mortal followers, which fits with a library. Large numbers of highly skilled mortals can be useful enough for that plan to be worth it, right?)

Hmm, about the shapes of souls; can you shape one of your souls into a weapon? We wouldn't want it for this feeding soul, but for future reference would such a soul be useful in mental combat (or physical if we get some way to manifest it)?
>>
No. 54579 ID: 40c366

The fair folk make extensive use of such, so it should be usable.

I belive mechanically Wordblood was/is such.
>>
No. 54588 ID: b9d767

>>364379
Fair Folk use Grace, which arent actually weapons, except when they are. Graces aren't souls, Raksha lack souls altogether.

>>364375
We can totally do that. One of Malfeas's more written about souls is Gervesin, a second circle soul of Liger. Gervesin has the ability to take the form of a spear, often to be weilded in battle by another being. He can also take a humanoid form, and debatably weild himself. In short, we can totally make a soul a weapon.

We can make a soul anything. ANYTHING.
>>
No. 54603 ID: 4349bf

When did Saulanna become so disproportional? She's positively anorexic in the latest update.
>>
No. 54608 ID: 91c438

>>364403

Er, well. Sometimes, I just... fluctuate, a little.
>>
No. 54611 ID: 1f8505

>>364403

The moon did it.
>>
No. 54615 ID: 7472ad

>>364375
Mechanically, First Circle Souls have no influence on a Yozi's personality. Second circle don't either, but a major shift in those can alter the Third Circle which can. But then those rules might not matter here.

Anyway, I don't see any problem with the Library idea, just wanted to point out it may not be just like a hand and that the whole carrion feeder thing might make us REALLY want to do so ourselves.
>>
No. 54628 ID: eea689

>>364408
>>364403
I'm not seeing it. Compare the latest update: http://tgchan.org/kusaba/quest/src/133684958146.png
with the 'paperdoll' from the beginning of the latest quest:
http://tgchan.org/kusaba/quest/src/133402777105.png

I'm not seeing any major difference in build/body between those two pictures.
>>
No. 54671 ID: 589f6f

>>364408

Do moon heroes lose weight the more they eat?

If she eats much more, she WAIST away!

(Waist. Geddit? D'oh ho ho ho!)

Puns aren't funny.
>>
No. 54673 ID: cda15c

>>364428
it does kinda look like her butt got juicier (wider hips)... mmm yummy.
But only until you realize that its just looking at her from a different angle. I see your argument as to lack of change.

I like the idea of it being library and projecting an avatar looking like a color reversed sexy saulanna librarian in horn glasses when interacting with visitors.

The term "research" is lacking focus though, it can apply to both invention and studying prior work. So its best to clarify.
>>364307
I like this.
>>
No. 54674 ID: 197830

>>364473
She does have a nice set of Hartman Hips, doesn't she?
>>
No. 54685 ID: 197830

Forks are fairly recent as a utensil for common use - using a knife, or better yet two knives, is much more accurate to most settings.

One knife can hold down the meat, while the other one cuts. Then someone realized, hey, I can hold down the meat better if I give this knife two points...and thus the fork may have been born.
>>
No. 54687 ID: e3aff6

>>364473
That brings up the question of what non-embodied secondary souls spend their time on while not actively helping with something? Do they usually just watch what the body is up to?
>>
No. 54697 ID: b9d767

>>364487
Pretty much, yeah.

Also, I look forward to seeing what our Second Circle souls look like. Second Circle souls also are most often not actually made by the Titan, but by the Titan's Third Circle Souls. This is because they are not direct aspects of the Titan, but aspects OF thier aspects. Of course we obviouslly aren't a normal Titan, so who knows how things will turn out?
>>
No. 54712 ID: 03fa18

I should probably mention that I have exams over the next two weeks and likely will not update during that time.

Please do not explode the thread.
>>
No. 54713 ID: eea689

>>364512
Good luck on exams! I expect most people will lurk until you return, hopefully triumphant.
>>
No. 54716 ID: 3760e5

>>364485
I prefer two forks.
>>
No. 54717 ID: 3760e5

>>364512
good luck
>>
No. 54739 ID: 197830

>>364516
That's fascinating. How do you cut your food?
>>
No. 54741 ID: fa9f7e

>>364539
Forks can be used to cut soft food, if you accept "wedge it into smaller chunks" as "cutting". Or if you sharpen it.
>>
No. 54758 ID: e3350e

>>364541
yes to both of those :)
Also, you lift something to your mouth, bite a chunk, and put the remaining down on plate.

I usually use two forks when traveling and forced to use plastic utensils. Plastic knives are a joke and don't work, at all.
Sometimes the mood strikes me to and I use 2 metal forks at home even though I could use a knife too.
Rarely I use 2 knives to eat...

Oh, and I always hold the knife and fork backwards. That is, knife in off hand and fork in main hand.
I don't know why the standard is to use knife in main and fork on off (that's both weird and stupid)
>>
No. 54762 ID: 1417a1

>>364558
>knife in off hand and fork in main hand
I thought this was how everyone ate.
>>
No. 54763 ID: 197830

>>364558
Interesting...as far as I've heard, "knife in off hand" is European-style table manners. It always seemed to make more sense to me; American table manners often seem intentionally inefficient, to slow down eating.

Also, if you're having difficulty with plastic knives, perhaps your stroke could be changed? If they are too flimsy, it might help if you thought of them like a saw - don't push them away from you, only cut when you're pulling it towards you, to avoid buckling.

(Myself, I like chopsticks best, but they are rather limited in terms of the food they can handle.)
>>
No. 54764 ID: e3350e

>>364562
Oddly enough, no.
http://www.chefalbrich.com/etiquette/proper_knife_fork.htm
http://www.askandyaboutclothes.com/Lifestyle/proper_table_manners.htm

these are just the first results on google.
Also, ask around, turns out most of the world is doing it ass backwards for some reason. I guess they are too feeble to cut meat with their off hand?
>>
No. 54765 ID: e3350e

oh, also... in real polite company in europe you are supposed to load the forks tip, not side, and load it upside down... so, the absolute minimum amount of food that it can possible scoop.
>>
No. 54766 ID: 197830

>>364565
My personal hypothesis is that "polite" table manners are intentionally inefficient to a) appear 'dainty' and b) prolong social meals.
>>
No. 54767 ID: e3350e

>>364566
I tend to agree... I think there is another reason though. To spot those low class peasants trying to act above their station.
>>
No. 54783 ID: 40c366

I love your your luna btw.
>>
No. 54831 ID: b85f8c

A lot of proper table manners are there to make you look like you aren't that hungry. A sign of high class was not actually needing to eat the food placed in front of you, I think.
>>
No. 54835 ID: 197830

>>54831
Ooh, that's a good point!

Come to think of it, I wonder if there's any market in Exalted for things like moonsilver cutlery?
>>
No. 54838 ID: 3734f6

>>54831
isn't this basically a form of
>To spot those low class peasants trying to act above their station.
>>
No. 54839 ID: 197830

>>54838
I don't think it would be consciously done in that way, but I think you're right that it would serve as a marker of in-group status.
>>
No. 54840 ID: fa9f7e

>>54835
There are moonsilver yoga pants that do nothing but scream "look at my crotch and ass". Yeah, people would make cutlery out of it, easy.
>>
No. 54841 ID: 197830

>>54840
...I refuse to believe this until I see pictorial proof.
*cough* ...Purely for research purposes, of course.
>>
No. 54874 ID: 3734f6

>>54839
>I don't think it would be consciously done in that way
Why not consciously? Remember all that "divine right to rule" thing and "nobles are born better then commoners, blue blood" and all that.

They have a lot of free time since they don't actually need to work, so they can and will use some of that free time to making sure those of lesser breeding do not rise above their station.
>>
No. 54926 ID: 87d18a

>>54835
The real question is what the magical material cutlery does.
I mean, they were dicking around with piles of magic, it probably cooks the food while you cut while seasoning it to perfection and additionally makes a perfectly serviceable set of weapons in case you get jumped while eating AND lets you deflect social attacks by responding to the talking with a fork to the eye.
>>
No. 54936 ID: fa9f7e

>>54841
Sorry, no pictures, just stats, a backstory, and a description. They're pants made of moonsilver that the moon used to try and seduce Gaia. They're described as very tight, thin pants that call attention to your ass and genitals and increase Appearance/Beauty by 4, which is rather a lot.

Biref summary and link to the book it's in: http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Artifacts:Moonsilver_Pantaloons
>>
No. 54937 ID: fa9f7e

>>54841
Also, a link to download a pdf of the Scroll of Swallowed Darkness, which is a noncanon April Fools' NSFW book. It has a picture of the Scarlet Empress receiving a spaghetti breakfast from her husband, the Ebon Dragon.

http://www.4shared.com/office/s1E85rdD/Exalted_2nd_Ed_-_ExXxalted_-_S.html


I've heard that they plan to make a canon NSFW sourcebook if the Alchemicals one sells enough copies, but that could just have been a rumor, and it could be long past even if it was legit.
>>
No. 54963 ID: eea689

>>54937
I've read that awhile back! I still can't believe they did it.
>>
No. 55050 ID: 197830

I wonder if Jukashi will ever try to sneak in cameos from other quest threads here? Like, Maolla in a background or something?
>>
No. 55441 ID: f37427

It seems to me that the guard captain's hostility towards us is based on the fact that some of his own men went up against us, and are now permanently gone. This would be rather alarming to him as a ghost, seeing as how he has already died once. While he is not outright afraid, he is cautious because we are something that can cause a ghost a final death. It would probably be best to start off by making him come to the realization that while we are indeed dangerous and deadly, there is no reason for us to cause him or his men harm unless provoked. However, outright saying this fact may come across as a threat, which we may or may not want. It would probably be best for us to lead him into realizing this on his own. After that we should try and seem supportive, in a "I help your master and he helps me, therefor helping me will help your master" kind of way.
>>
No. 55448 ID: 197830

>>55441
Because I don't have the best grasp of Exalted metaphysics, I want to confirm:

The souls that we ate, their memories are integrated, but the soul itself is returned to the cycle of reincarnation.

So the only difference between being eaten and dying normally is that your memories are stored within the eater rather than destroyed - the rest of the soul does what it would have done anyway?
>>
No. 55450 ID: 1417a1

>>55448
From how I understand it, the rest of the soul is turned into Titan's Will.
>>
No. 55451 ID: 132b99

>>55448
nope. the memories are taken out and then the soul is turned into pure energy.
>>
No. 55455 ID: b9d767

>>55448
Saulanna happens to be something unique to this quest. As such, we have no way of knowing the exact mechanics of the soul-eating process. What we do know is the mechanics of the soul, death, and reincarnation.
>>
No. 55464 ID: e3f578

Is the soul consciousness though? The point of view we all use? Can that be used up or thrown away?

Mind, Body and Soul are constantly debated in real life, especially where the consciousness would be located. Many think consciousness as the soul or mind, and fantasy settings often play with the soul and mind concepts, but never discuss the direct concept of consciousness which drives all these debates, which makes much distinctions pointless.
>>
No. 55465 ID: 132b99

>>55464
no, the soul is utterly obliterated when we eat them.
>>
No. 55466 ID: 71d68e

The consciousness dies. Lethe or being devoured, both kills the consciousness equally thoroughly. The only fate that avoids this is becoming a ghost.

Our soul-devouring is pretty much equal to murder, and we should treat it as that. So, essentially, save it for the circumstances where we would consider killing someone justifiable.

This has already been debated, anyway.
>>
No. 55468 ID: b9d767

It should be noted that all we have consumed of people so far is the Hun, or upper soul. We have yet to consume a Po, or lower soul. For those who don't know, when a person dies in exalted and becomes a ghost, their Hun and Po split. The Hun retains the memories and concousness of the person while the Po retains thier passion and instinct. This split also makes the Po a bloodthirsty mindless creature, called a Hungry Ghost. It because of this split that ghosts are so drained of emotion and passion. In fact, we fought our friend Gevin's hungry ghost at the start of the quest. If we hadnt, it probably would have attacked him next.
>>
No. 55474 ID: b5f6db

>>55468

In the interests of completeness, I should point out that ghosts aren't exactly emotionless. In fact, powerful emotions tend to be what make them become ghosts. Rather, what is meant is that ghosts don't have the ability to feel new emotions. Their capacity for emotion is based off nostalgia; things that remind them of feelings they had when they were alive.
>>
No. 55486 ID: 3734f6

>>/quest/416543
I can't believe it took me this long to get the Mortal Kombat reference...
>>
No. 55493 ID: 4e8344

Skills are information and could come under the purview of wordblood. Can we copy rather than consume the relevqnt bits of the hun? Suck it up, take it apart, find what we want, put it back together and spit it out. Im much happier with the thought of eating po.
>>
No. 55494 ID: 132b99

>>55493
possibly later after getting more power.
>>
No. 55496 ID: 4e8344

Blargh. Knight has a point. We have the great curse to worry about after all... We dont even know how it will manifest.
>>
No. 55528 ID: 431fa8

>>55496
Fortunately, we can almost certainly Titan's Will ourselves into not being subject to silly things like that. Curing it for everyone would probably be really hard, assuming we even want to, but just fixing ourselves should be within our power relatively soon, I'd say.

Definitely one for the to-do list, right up there with protecting ourselves against horrific mutation.
>>
No. 55530 ID: 197830

>>55528
Aww, a mutation or two could be fun! I bet Saulanna could find all sorts of things to do with tentacles or a third eye.
>>
No. 55531 ID: 132b99

the curse was made BY titans. so yeah. another titan being able to fix it sounds doable.
>>
No. 55707 ID: 431fa8

The conclusion of the social tutorial has made me much more interested in getting World Reading sooner rather than later- and then adding an upgrade to it, if necessary, to let us read others' social stats, mal/affections, and hearts' desires. That could be an exceptionally potent boost to our manipulative abilities.

So little Titan's Will, so much to do with it...
>>
No. 55708 ID: 3734f6

>>55493
We could but it serves no purpose! (did you even read any of the discussion here?)
If we spit them back up, then unless we use the blackest of magics which corrupts the very land itself and causes death to those living in it, then the soul we spit back out will immediately be snatched up by the cycle of reincarnation and scrubbed of all personality and memory.

The reason there are ghosts in our current locations is because it is the deadlands, corrupted by wicked magic. And ever spreading into normal lands, corrupting them (that is why the mortal kingdoms fear and hate peregrine)

The best we could do for them is to make ourselves more like an afterlife/god. Disassemble memories gently, make copies, reassemble the personality but without the soul energy, use the soul energy to grow. Eventually spit out new blank baby souls into the cycle.
>>
No. 55711 ID: 242d5c

Heh.
Social Kombat is an awesome system. We could just talk out every conflict.
>>
No. 55712 ID: 71d68e

Another thing: in this discussion, people've been talking of eating the po as if it's a lighter matter than eating the hun. But that isn't necessarily so. The po contains the capability for emotion and without it the hun is essentially an half-existence. Their inability to form new emotions as opposed to reliving old ones is, ultimately, fairly crippling in its own way, if not quite as much so as the lack of rationality of the po.

Regardless of which you choose to consume, you're essentially destroying a vital part of that person.

That's why I advocate viewing soul eating with the same gravitas as we would view murder. That doesn't mean never doing it, but it does mean doing it only in circumstances where we would view taking a life as justifiable. Though there might be possible exceptions such as where someone would die anyway.
>>
No. 55713 ID: 242d5c

Also, we should search for other Titan fragments.
Could be useful to be more... "titany"
>>
No. 55722 ID: 3734f6

>>55712
Murder is the unjust killing. If murder is ever justified then its not murder, its just killing.

Also, again you continue to ignore the fact that what saulanna does when she "eats" a soul is at LEAST equal and potentially more moral to what the universe does to someone the moment they die, barring evil magics interfering to preserve them as a ghost.
>>
No. 55723 ID: 3734f6

Also you provide no solid reason why we SHOULD limit ourselves so.
>>
No. 55724 ID: 242d5c

Dunno what you think, but I don't want to be a emotional frankenstein.

Currently, we have not a real personality. We have little memories. We don't even have a hearts desire. We are a moral infant, lacking ethics and character traits.

Everytime we eat a soul, they gonna be a part of us. We consume other memories and their character, making them us.

This will affect us.
What do you think, when we eat all this criminal souls? Sooner or later we will think, be bad is part of us.

I dunno, but I want to decide by myself if we are bad or not, and not let it decide someone else.
>>
No. 55725 ID: 242d5c

Also, sorry for the bad english.
Not my native language and I slept through my lessons.
>>
No. 55726 ID: 3734f6

>>55724
1. We don't HAVE to keep the memories, we just need the purified soulstuff, the memories are optional.
2. We could just eat good people, it is NO WORST then them reincarnating normally. only more of them is kept.
3. It is a self correcting problem, if we get evil from eating evil people then we will start praying on good people until we are too good to eat anymore good people.
>>
No. 55727 ID: 3734f6

Also, saulanna is not an amalgam of those she eats. She is her own person and and those upper tier souls within her (wordblood, the feeder soul we would create, etc).
She exhibited her current personality (based on us) before she ever ate memories
>>
No. 55728 ID: 242d5c

Hey, I don't have anything against the soul force, just somethign against these fucking memories.

WE JUST LEARNED TO TORTURE AND NECROSURGERY STUFF, FOR LUNAS SAKE!
>>
No. 55729 ID: 71d68e

>>55723
So, I used the wrong word. Kill, not murder. Anyway, what sort of alternative're you proposing to the restrictions I was talking about? I will put it quite simply: our choice of which souls to devour will indeed have an impact on our moral filter. But not the effect some people're thinking of.

If we devour the souls of people who don't deserve such an end (i.e. good people), we're truly murdering, unless there're sufficient circumstances to excuse it. That will have far more effect on our morals than any sort of corruption you're worried about from eating bad people. If that's the quest you want to play, feel free to suggest that sort of thing. I will suggest against it.

Saulana already has ethnics. They are the set of ethnics established by our suggestions. Thus, if she acts immoral based on suggestions (i.e. murdering people just to eat their souls, even to 'balance out' the sorts of souls she eats), she will be an immoral person. If she acts moral based on suggestions, she will be a moral person.

And did you forget how she puked upon learning torture and necrosurgery. That isn't the reaction of a sociopath. That's a normal reaction of a person with qualms against those things. Yes, she might know how to do those things, but she doesn't have to use thaat knowledge.
>>
No. 55749 ID: 3734f6

>>55729
1. Any and all mortal that dies in our presence (regardless of who killed them) when out of the deadlands.
2. In the deadlands, any soul we can get away with without losing political power (don't want to "collapse" our kingdom so that means limiting ourselves to criminals of sufficient caliber).
3. Other titan fragments get consumed unless we like them enough to make them an ally.
4. Exaltation spirits get consumed based on our relationship with the gods who own them. (don't want to piss off the wrong god)

What I am against:
Killing people just to consume their soul (its fine if we kill them because they deserve it though). Saulanna could eliminate whole towns... but she shouldn't.

>you're worried about from eating bad people
I am not worried about that. People agreeing with YOU are worried about that.
And the author explicitly told us its not like that. Its as if we read it in a book not memories of doing it ourselves.

>Saulana already has ethnics. They are the set of ethnics established by our suggestions
Ethics. Please look up ethnic in a dictionary.

>And did you forget how she puked upon learning torture and necrosurgery
I did not, and that is from eating quite literally THE MOST EVIL soul in the deadlands.
Normal souls don't do that. And repeated exposure would make her more jaded.

>So, I used the wrong word. Kill, not murder
>That isn't the reaction of a sociopath.
And here lies the problem. You insist on referring to her method of absorbing souls as killing/murder. Sociopaths have no compassion and view murder as no different then the average person views squashing a bug.
But eating a soul is neither murder NOR a justified killing.

The cycle of reincarnation snatches up and recycles any soul whose body is killed outside the deadlands. The deadlands are a horrible evil magic zone that is devoid of live (not just sentient life) and is spreading its corruption constantly growing. It is the only place where souls can artificially escape the cycle of reincarnation (removing souls from it and thus removing the amount of people that can exist).

Saulanna's "consumption" is her reading the entire lifetime of memories as if from a book. Followed by purging them (same as in reincarnation). Followed by merging with the energy (a little different to reincarnation, but overall good for the cycle as she eventually will create more baby souls then she outputs). The cycle of reincarnation cannot create more souls by itself and as such it is essentials to have titans doing it for them. (currently gaia is the only one who does).
>>
No. 55751 ID: 3bad4c

>Ethics. Please look up ethnic in a dictionary.
BAM. Anonymous has been reduced to Crippled status!
>>
No. 55752 ID: 71d68e

>>55749
>Ethics. Please look up ethnic in a dictionary.
I already knew what ethnics means. It was just a typo.

>1. Any and all mortal that dies in our presence (regardless of who killed them) when out of the deadlands.
No issues with that.

>2. In the deadlands, any soul we can get away with without losing political power (don't want to "collapse" our kingdom so that means limiting ourselves to criminals of sufficient caliber).
I consider that a little more dicey. But I'm fine with devouring particularly bad criminals.

>3. Other titan fragments get consumed unless we like them enough to make them an ally.
No issues with that. A lot of titans've been rather unpleasant.

>4. Exaltation spirits get consumed based on our relationship with the gods who own them. (don't want to piss off the wrong god)
Are you talking about Exaltation shards, i.e. the part that makes you an Exalt? Interesting notion. I'd rather judge that on a case-by-case basis.

In the end, it doesn't look like we really disagree all that much. More like I poorly worded some things. Actually, it looks like our main point of disagreement is over ghosts.

Essentially, I consider devouring ghosts as close enough to killing in terms of morality. It might be an incomplete existence, but it's still an independent existence with a consciousness, and eating it ends that consciousness.

Of course, you seem to be making the argument that such existences are harmful. I don't necessarily consider it so much as that it's the existence of the Shadowlands themselves that're harmful. Their spread definitely should be stopped. And the whole problem of the Dragon's Shadow should be dealt with someday.

But I'm not going to blame the ghosts for happening to depend on such things for their continued existences, as long as they don't help spread the Shadowlands.
>>
No. 55753 ID: 71d68e

You're right that devouring souls isn't necessarily the same as an act of killing. If we kill a living person and then let their soul pass on to reincarnation, that's just as same as if they killed them and then devoured their soul. Likewise, devouring the soul of someone that we didn't kill isn't an act of killing.

Ghosts are just a special case here, and the main one I was thinking about when I made that argument, given that we're currently in a Shadowland full of ghosts.

That said, it looks like we pretty much agree on the same course of action in regards to the ghosts of this particular Shadowland (only eating criminal souls) in general, just for different reasons.
>>
No. 55763 ID: 3734f6

>I already knew what ethnics means. It was just a typo.
Only reason I pointed it out is that you made the same typo twice in a row.

>Essentially, I consider devouring ghosts as close enough to killing in terms of morality. It might be an incomplete existence, but it's still an independent existence with a consciousness, and eating it ends that consciousness.
>Of course, you seem to be making the argument that such existences are harmful. I don't necessarily consider it so much as that it's the existence of the Shadowlands themselves that're harmful.
I would hand you the argument that they have a consciousnesses. Furthermore, I would for the most part agree that it is the shadow-lands and not the ghosts that are harmful (mostly, they are still denying reincarnation which has the issue of soul depletion). However the ghosts depend on that harmful shadowland. The instant the shadowlands are purified all the ghosts in are sucked into the cycle of reincarnation and their consciousness ends.

Just something to keep in mind if we ever want to fix this (which we could... we could potentially invert the exaltation shard in whatshisname and make him into a solar, and then modify the deadlands).

We could of course do something more exotic, like create a partition within us where they may remain and retain their consciousness. But that raises other issues which we might not want.

>That said, it looks like we pretty much agree
Yep. From the whole "consider it with great gravity" and "murder" talk I misunderstood you to be opposed to consumption. But it seems we agree on the specifics.
>>
No. 55765 ID: ca6df7

I feel the need to say that the SHADOWY LAND is not necessary for ghosts to exist. Ghosts happen anyway, most anywhere in the world; they happen less often, especially since the Dragon's Shadow took over, but a soul with sufficient unfinished business will still become one of the restless dead. It's just that outside, they wake up in the underworld instead, and have to live with the Dragon and all his dudes.

As Peregrin described, most of the ghosts in this particular land are actually refugees from the rest of the underworld.
>>
No. 55768 ID: 71d68e

So, it sounds like the best long term solution might be to find a way to freeze the Shadowlands' growth (or just leave them be while we work on the next step), then overthrow the Dragon's Shadow and put the Underworld under better management, and finally solve the new soul generation problem.

Of course, that's waaaaaay long term. We're nowhere close to that point. But it looks like nomming ghosts won't really stop the problem, so we might as well just nom only the wicked ones (of the ghosts, other souls fall under the rules MrTT already proposed that I pretty much agree with). Hungry ghosts, as well--they're basically rabid beasts that need to be put down.
>>
No. 55769 ID: 132b99

yeah gevin didn't say he couldn't leave this shadowland but he can't enter the mortal world. which has no way to support ghosts so he needs to hitch-hick in our head to leave.
>>
No. 55771 ID: 3734f6

>>55765
Thanks for clarifying
>>55768
Agreed to everything.
>>
No. 55887 ID: 2ae487

Just back from a mini-holiday of sorts, hence why no updates for a while. Will resume shortly. First, though, I want to gather an opinion. How's the length of this chapter for all ye, currently?

I face a choice of stopping relatively soon, thus having - shocker! - some actual brevity for once; or going on to the next foreseeable stopping point, which will likely double the postcount we have currently.

It's summer, which is nice, so I intend I'll be going on with more quest stuff either way.
>>
No. 55888 ID: 1f8505

>>55887

I'd say use that good stopping point. It it feels good in terms of timing and all that, I say go for it.
>>
No. 55889 ID: 132b99

i like having well made stops. otherwise w are left scratching our heads wonder what happened
>>
No. 55890 ID: 2ae487

>>55888
>>55889
>good
>well made

Now now, I never said that. ;V
>>
No. 55891 ID: 1f8505

>>55890

Oh you. :Y
>>
No. 55892 ID: 431fa8

>>55887
Stopping now/shortly would feel unsatisfying and incomplete. What have we done this chapter, really? Woke up, got a bit of an info dump, ran through a tutorial. We've basically had no significant action at all- everything in this chapter thus far is setup. There's some building tension and suspense from this Emissary character, but unless something is done with that it'll just fall apart- particularly if I'm correct in thinking that ending the chapter means cutting off the quest for another year or so while you go draw other things.
>>
No. 55898 ID: 65e012

>>55887

I wouldn't mind stopping now, depending in part on what you plan to do next.

For example, do you feel up to doing anything for KoC again yet?
>>
No. 55903 ID: 2563d4

>>55887
I am in favour of anything that switches you back to Will of the Battle Underpants Quest.
>>
No. 55904 ID: 1da170

I think we should keep going. This Emissary seems like a good target for our newfound Social mojo, which would be a good epic battle after our tutorial fight.
>>
No. 55905 ID: fb69eb

Personally I would prefer more Lunar Quest to more of most other things.
>>
No. 55906 ID: 72d49b

>>55905
I do as well.
>>
No. 55909 ID: 6a1b9a
File 133921437376.jpg - (10.11KB , 259x194 , images.jpg )
55909

Hey, Jukashi! Hey, Jukashi!
OOC info here, but is Wordblood the old fetich of the Sphere of Speech or not?
>>
No. 55910 ID: cb0cc3

>>55905
Agreed. The Sword was very good by the end, but Lunar Quest is still the best thing Jukashi's run on /quest/ in my opinion.
>>
No. 55916 ID: e7deb9

>>55909

The Titan Fragment which became Wordblood is formed from what remained in Creation of He Who Bleeds The Unknown Word, the rest of whom regenerated into Elloge, the Sphere of Speech, yes.
>>
No. 55928 ID: 9f2fff

>>55916

Does expending moon power stoke the soul fire for everyone or do we just have the equivalent of the "Beacon of Power" flaw?
>>
No. 55931 ID: 3734f6

Alice is just too adorable... Saulanna must seduce her!
>>
No. 55935 ID: 1f8505

>>55931

Or y'know... make actual friends with her.
>>
No. 55936 ID: e7deb9

>>55928

The first third of the moon power in her pool causes no soul fire. Every dot spent beyond that starts stoking it up, starting with the caste mark. It basically works the same as in the original system, but without such complex mote pool calculation, and assuming that the personal essence will always be used first.

Currently, consuming souls automatically blasts the soul fire to full power.

Things may change in the future.
>>
No. 55939 ID: 72d49b

>>55935
Moon heroes tend to have a lot of sex, regardless of what you call the relationship.
>>
No. 55942 ID: d5ee6f

Isn't it a rule that caste marks can't be concealed?
>>
No. 55951 ID: 728568

>>55942

It's somewhat ambiguous. In the original material, it's stated that characters can attempt stealth by using cover, but take a large penalty. It says that you can't cover it with the like of hats or bandannas, but presumably things like walls and hunks of solid material would still work. I'm making the assumption that if you do cover it, the light "bleeds" out the sides to an extent.
>>
No. 55960 ID: 9f2fff

>>55916

Wouldn't that basicly make him an unwoven coadjutor?
>>
No. 55972 ID: 728568

>>55960

There are similarities. They will probably fade.
>>
No. 55978 ID: cb37ea

Craft (Tinfoil) time:
We know there's now two suns in the sky of Creation: a golden one and a red one. Let's assume that the golden one is still Daystar. We also know that the red one appeared in the sky when Dragon's Shadow took over Underworld.

Well, the idea is, if these two facts are connected then the most likely candidate for new sun is one of DS's subsidiary souls, maybe even a fetich. But why red?

Consider the following: other that Dragon's Shadow, names of all Primordials/Yozis match the ones in the original setting, only Shadow of All Things is different. Obvious answer is: what-was-once-Ebon-Dragon changed his name. The best way to do this for a Titan is to change your nature by changing your subsidiary souls.

Now, let me remind you that a certain very red person was rumored to be TED's bride. Could this mean that Red Sun is Clark Kent actually Her Redness?

Disclaimer: I didn't read RotSE. Any and all similarities are completely accidental.
>>
No. 55983 ID: 7cbc54

This is just an idea, but there is likely a way we can attain power and TITAN'S WILL without eating souls, though it does involve souls. Prayers. According to lore, the Primordials made the mortal races and especially designed their souls to produce Quintessence/Ambrosia from thier prayers, which is why most mortals are incapable of channeling essence: they were not designed to. Prayers coagulate in Yu-Shan (heaven) as Quitnessence in special basins. Divine beings can take this Quintessence and use it to make Ambrosia, which is then eaten/drank. It can also be used as a crafting material for just about anything, which is also a plus. The problem with this is that cannot exist outside Yu-Shan or a god's Sanctum. Outside either of those places, it goes *POOF*. The good news is that our Inner World where Wordblood and any future component souls reside can easily function as a sanctum. It would likely take a great deal of prayers to net any TITAN'S WILL.
>>
No. 55989 ID: bb39ed

>>55978
It never said that there was two suns in the sky, it only said that there was a Red Sun. Two suns could be possible, but it is unlikely. If The Dragon's Shadow is out of Malfeas, then it is likely that the events of RotSE happened, in some shape or form.

One of the BIG plot points of RotSE is that UCS gets killed or dies. TED does this in an attempt to become completely invulnerable, as his Flaw of Invulnerability leaves him weak to anything that is Holy. In Exalted UCS is the very definition of being Holy, so with his death all holy effects simply stop working. It should also be noted that among the effects of UCS's death is the Daystar TURNING RED. Because of this, I find it unlikely that The Red Sun is Her Redness, though the possibility remains.

I also find it unlikely that The Red Sun is the Fetich of The Dragon's Shadow. This is because if it was his Fetich and there were two suns in the sky UCS would not stand for such a thing. If The Red Sun was the only sun in the sky, then that would mean there is no UCS, and TDS would be running rampant across creation. But he is not, therefor it is unlikely.

If TRS is his Fetich however, it raises an interesting question. Why would TDS hide in the Underworld if his Fetich is running free across the sky? The position of the Sun has always been associated with Virtue, so it could perhaps be that TRS is a creature of supreme Virtue, thus making TDS need to hide from his own heart. After all, would it not be the highest act of self-betrayal for a being of complete evil to have a heart of ultimate righteousness?
>>
No. 55999 ID: 431fa8

>>55989
Please don't use so many abbreviations when discussing things. I have a hard enough time following these discussions lacking any significant background in Exalted lore without being confused by a pile of shifting acronyms, even if they can be deciphered after a minute of rereading and context.

>>55983
It was made clear that Saulanna can gain power from being worshiped as a goddess, but those powers are not Titan's Will so far as I know- see >>20904 for more on that.
>>
No. 56012 ID: 034053

>>55999
UCS=Unconquered Sun, TRS=The Red Sun, TED=The Ebon Dragon, TDS=The Dragon's Shadow
Sorry for the confusion.

So, it seems that the Red Sun is indeed Her Redness, and Merela on top of that. That has got to make relations between her and Sol Invictus awkward as heck. On the bright side though, it mentions nothing about the sun getting killed, so that's a plus. It also explains why the Dragon's Shadow hangs about in the underworld: he's scared shitless of there being two suns.
>>
No. 56013 ID: 431fa8

Urgh. So much background and terminology I'm not quite grasping here, and I don't know what's an in-quest plot point and what's just Exalted lore. After the line
>This quest should be just as fun for people who aren't familiar with Exalted as it is for people who are.
at the top of the thread I feel vaguely cheated. Time for a barrage of questions. If someone could answer these, preferably in a manner as informative as possible, I would very much appreciate it.

What is an Incarna?

The Ebon Dragon made the Red Sun out of his lover; why did he subsequently turn into the Dragon's Shadow? And how would this make them go hostile to one another- shouldn't they be really close if he's the one who gave her all that power?

What is the significance of the Maiden of Strife returning? It seems like there's backstory there.

What is Calibration?

Who is Queen Marela?

What was the Old Realm?

What is a Fetich?

Who/what is Elloge, the Sphere of Speech?

>>56012
>That has got to make relations between her and Sol Invictus awkward as heck.
Why? What is the background here that would do that?
>>
No. 56015 ID: 4c4ae4

>>56013
>What is an Incarna?

The gods that have their own Heroes, basically.

>The Ebon Dragon made the Red Sun out of his lover; why did he subsequently turn into the Dragon's Shadow? And how would this make them go hostile to one another- shouldn't they be really close if he's the one who gave her all that power?

These are not things people would know from familiarity with Exalted. Perhaps you can find out in the quest.

>What is the significance of the Maiden of Strife returning? It seems like there's backstory there.

This is not something people would know from familiarity with Exalted. Again, maybe find out in the quest.

>What is Calibration?

5-day period at the end of the year. Strange things happen.

>Who is Queen Marela?

Ruler of the Old Realm; a Sun and Fire Hero, as already stated in-quest. Saulanna knows no more than that.

>What was the Old Realm?

Human civilization during the First Age.

>What is a Fetich?

A Titan's most defining soul. Saulanna is her own Fetich, for example. I don't think I'm going to use this terminology in the quest, though.

>Who/what is Elloge, the Sphere of Speech?

Someone Saulanna doesn't know about yet.

>I feel vaguely cheated

This is such an open quest, almost everything is equally relevant and non-relevant until Saulanna involves it in her business. Thus far, she has no long-term goal beyond "gain power", so there essentially is no difference between "in-quest plot points" and general lore, save for events happening right next to her. Perhaps she will decide to go find the Red Sun and ask for help, and then all this will be important. Perhaps she will run off into isolation and sit on her ass meditating for a few centuries to slowly build up her strength without involving herself in anything, in which case none of this will be important! All I can say is that when things are of immediate import, and Saulanna would reasonably know about them, she'll take note of it.

In the meantime, exploration and discovery is part of the quest's appeal; part of why I set it in an altered version of the setting is so that people already familiar with Exalted could get some of the same sense of feeling their way about in an unknown world. And although I want the quest to be accessible, that doesn't mean I'm not going to make some small in-jokes or other references.
>>
No. 56016 ID: 431fa8

If someone feels like offering more complete answers than Jukashi, that would be great.

>>56015
>These are not things people would know from familiarity with Exalted.
>This is not something people would know from familiarity with Exalted.
When you say this, does it mean that these characters are completely original and do not feature in Exalted's backstory at all (clearly not the case for at least some of them)? Or do you mean that what you've done with them is nonstandard so familiarity with Exalted might give enough information to establish a basis for logical speculation, but provide no definitive answers?

>Saulanna knows no more than that.
>Someone Saulanna doesn't know about yet.
But other players obviously know these things, or they wouldn't have been discussed in this thread like they meant something. I'm not asking what Saulanna knows, I'm asking to be brought up to speed on what we collectively as a player base apparently should know.

>so there essentially is no difference between "in-quest plot points" and general lore, save for events happening right next to her.
Arguably, this reads as "every bit of Exalted lore that you can learn or know is a potential plot point, and will improve your ability to understand and make appropriate decisions in the quest". That means that getting as detailed and complete an OOC infodump as possible is basically essential in order to play well and fully enjoy it, whether this comes in the form of answering random questions or links to Exalted book downloads or whatever else.

Reminds me strongly of Guns for Hire, actually, where those players who regularly get information on IRC or read the IRC logs where Bob rambles on about custom setting lore are several times as effective in planning and reacting to in-quest events because they have a much more complete picture of what's going on and what it might mean. That was frustrating as hell for a while.

>exploration and discovery is part of the quest's appeal
That, I get. But there's no sense of exploration or discovery when I know perfectly well that the information we're discovering is something both the GM and a fraction of the other players already know; that's just playing catch-up after being uninformed. It's not good to spend in-character time chasing after answers to questions that some of us already have out of character; for some people that is a waste of time and for others it only brings them up to par on what they should have known already.

A small in-joke is something like giving the books on the shelf funny and referential names. World setting information that could get Saulanna killed if she acts without accounting for it- and not just immediately, I mean in the long term as well- is not small. Unless huge amounts of Exalted setting information is not merely outdated but fundamentally incorrect in your altered version of the setting, then the players knowing about major personalities, historical events, magical mechanics, and setting principles from Exalted is a life and death issue for Saulanna, all the more so because this quest is a relative sandbox. Thus being informed on it is essential for any player desiring to play well.
>>
No. 56017 ID: 72d49b

>>56016
It sounds like you just want to read some Exalted books.
http://rs.4chan.org/?s=Exalted&from=%2Ftg%2F

But really, it's not that closely related. So far all that's happened is people think that the red sun might be analogous to another established character, but frankly even if that's true, what she used to be in the time that Exalted takes place is not very relevant to the current state of things. Perhaps the sun was once an empress, it's unlikely to matter now.

>why did he subsequently turn into the Dragon's Shadow?
If the notion that the red sun is a soul of his is correct, then it may be a result of what Wordblood mentioned, that new souls alters a being's nature.
>And how would this make them go hostile to one another
Maybe the Red Sun liked her former state better?
This is all conjecture, and not based on established Exalted setting, though.

>Or do you mean that what you've done with them is nonstandard so familiarity with Exalted might give enough information to establish a basis for logical speculation, but provide no definitive answers?
It doesn't provide much basis for speculation either, at the moment all that's being speculated at is possible relations between what we've heard about in-quest and stuff in published setting. It certainly hasn't been a basis for any speculation of anything that matters.
>>
No. 56018 ID: 71d68e

In short, the stuff people've been talking about with the Scarlet Empress and such is ultimately immaterial. It's essentially trivia right now, like pointing out that there's a blue jay in the background of a scene in a movie.

From the descriptions of recent history in the quest, there've been some massive upheavals from the world Exalted players're familiar with (and it's set a fair while after that setting). The political landscape's going to look totally different. To put it simply, who the Red Sun once was doesn't really matter anymore. The world's changed too much.

The book people were talking about, Return of the Scarlet Empress? It's irrelevant. Judging from what we know of the quest's setting, the stuff in that book didn't happen. Jukashi went a different direction than that.
>>
No. 56020 ID: 71d68e

In fact, I'd actually say that you might be at an advantage when it comes to not having preconceived notions. I've seen people get tripped up by what they thought they knew about the setting.
>>
No. 56023 ID: a52bc1

>>56016
>World setting information that could get Saulanna killed if she acts without accounting for it- and not just immediately, I mean in the long term as well- is not small.

I can assure you that I avoid things like that. Where knowledge of the existing setting would help, I will try to include at least some clues to the same thing within the quest itself. I may miss things sometimes, but wherever I notice a situation like that, I'll fix it.

I kind of like doing exposition, anyway.

As well as which, I think I have introduced, and intend to continue introducing, enough differences in the setting that even people who are already familiar with Exalted can't be sure their knowledge is dependable until confirmed. I can tell you that there will definitely be situations where the prior knowledge is more of a liability!
>>
No. 56024 ID: b9d767

>>56015
>Perhaps she will decide to go find the Red Sun and ask for help, and then all this will be important.

This is actually a damn good idea. However, not with the Red Sun. If we go to someone with the intention of seeking help it should be someone with reason to help us, who would have a (hopefully) positive reaction towards us. Gaia and Autochthon are more likely to be helpful than the Red Sun. Plus if we get on Gaia's good side, Luna will be on board as well.

Of course this is all long-term planning.
>>
No. 56031 ID: b85f8c

There's way too much discussion going on in the main thread.

Re: Jukashi not being a bastard GM-
Having a non-evil GM is no excuse for rushing into things and making big choices without being informed of the consequences. And there are consequences. There will always be, unless your GM is really bad.
>>
No. 56034 ID: fb69eb

>>56031
Good GMing indeed involves consequences, but those are consequences for actions guided by information that can be acquired in-game and player common sense (or lack thereof).
Consequences based on things players could only know through meta-knowledge are an entirely different matter.
>>
No. 56036 ID: 71d68e

Quite simply: I don't fear consequences. As long as we make reasonably informed decisions for the most part, we should be able to manage any consequences that might come up, and they can make things more interesting. Trying to minmax everything and avoid every single negative result makes for a boring story.

If we try to make our character safe, a good GM will find a way to put pressure on them anyway. Otherwise it'd just be boring.
>>
No. 56058 ID: 71d68e

Now that I've had some sleep, let's address some of your concerns.

1. There's been absolutely nothing so far to imply that the feeder soul would manifest outside of us instead of inside us like Wordblood, especially since we control the manifestation. If you're worried about being more blatant, from what Wordblood's said it might actually make us less blatant since apparently a feeder soul could help us reduce that flareup upon eating a soul.

2. When I take a choice between introducing a potentially interesting character and having zero weak points, I'll take having the character. The same argument applies to Wordblood anyway (even if it isn't as much of a concern since he's inside us).

3. We might actually be able to start getting returns on the feeder soul more quickly than we could the Depth of Comprehension ability, given that Peregrin already has other criminal souls prepared for us. It'll take time for him to have his people round up and copy books for us to eat, anyway. That said, I do agree Depth of Comprehension might be worth investigating first. But I don't think it's necessarily necessary to micromanage with such in-depth questions.

4. Judging from what's already been said about recent history (no more superpower dominating the world, just a chaotic shifting political climate), I suspect the Empire's already fallen or been reduced to a far less powerful state, which would cut down on the Wyld Hunt's power if not eliminate them outright. If they still exist, they likely have far larger concerns with all the Heroes running around blatantly in plain sight and running entire kingdoms without bothering to make a secret of it. We might as well worry about being overwhelmed by some random powerful Hero or something.

This is why I'm generally against making assumptions based on metaknowledge. Attracting attention is still a concern in general, but I suspect we could take over a kingdom in plain sight for everyone to see, and no one'd blink at another yet Moon Hero showing up out of the blue. They'd just mark us down as a potential political rival which is why I think it's still a good idea to lay low for the moment. And of course, we have the Heroes of the Dragon's Shadow to worry about right now.
>>
No. 56128 ID: ba9615

I was just reading the description of Halkomelem, the Enigma in Red and Gold. Specifically, how he looking during the Primordial war, which reads

"...the shape of a dragon of living calligraphy. He flew on wings of poetry; his fangs dripped with satire; he wore armor of endlessly folded layers of impenetrable legalese. In his breast, his true name pulsed like a star." (CoCD: Malfeas, p. 153)

and I thought of Wordbloods description of that time

"...wings of elegant song; my fangs and claws were of cutting wit, dripping with venomous slander, and my armour was of the most impenetrable legalese. Voice was my bones, and ink my blood; my true name burning inside me was my heart."

Are the two related by any chance? Was Wordblood inspired by Halkomelem or is the similarity just a coincidence?
>>
No. 56129 ID: 132b99

>>56128
wordblood was part of the titan involving words themselves. he doesn't eat the words out of books, he simply asks the story to return to him and they do. every book ever written is a part of him
>>
No. 56130 ID: 7e8002

>>56128

Read more closely. The description you quote from the book is not actually a description of Halkomelem.
>>
No. 56134 ID: e894c0

right. this guy.

http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=He_Who_Bleeds_the_Unknown_Word
>>
No. 56135 ID: 132b99

>>56134
yep and wordblood told us he was part of that guy, himself.
>>
No. 56145 ID: ba9615

>>56130

Ah, I described He Who Bleeds the Unknown Word himself.
>>
No. 56153 ID: e3f578

Would film and video games work on wordblood too? If there were any around, I mean.
>>
No. 56157 ID: 132b99

>>56153
is there a titan of visual art? like paintings. if so then i think film and games would be it's domain.
>>
No. 56165 ID: a6f316

>>56153

He's about language, really. Words. Symbol-based communication. Writing, speaking, probably sign language and such as well. The thought processes of sapient beings. And so forth.
>>
No. 56219 ID: 1417a1

>>56157
Oramus, the Dragon Beyond the World has associations with that:
"At other times, he appears in the dreams of demons or mortals as a psychic muse, overwhelming their souls with impossible visions that can only be exorcised through imperfect mimesis in painting, sculpture, dance or song"

(http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Ink_Monkeys,_vol._46:_The_Geomancy_of_Hell)
>>
No. 56279 ID: 3a3910

Apologies for taking so long to update, I have a few things going on this week. Have to draw a new background "set", as well.
>>
No. 56281 ID: e3aff6

So many beings in exalted have 'Dragon' in their names...
>>
No. 56282 ID: 3a3910

>>56281

It's not official, but the way I see it is, Oramus was the first Titan (pretty much the first anything, except maybe some Fae), and he was a dragon. Titans by their nature define reality even without trying, just by existing, so then everything after him was imprinted with the concept that dragons were the awesomest/most powerful thing. When things become awesome and powerful, therefore, there is some tendency for them to become dragon-shaped. Happens to all elementals, and some gods.

Exalted fluff is left deliberately vague so that people can adapt it for their own purposes. It's possible that The Dragon's Shadow may initially have been Oramus' shadow? It's an idea I like, anyway. There is a description of when the Titans all came into being relative to each other, but TDS is suspiciously listed as "revealing himself" at a certain point, with implication that he was around before any of his siblings were aware of him.
>>
No. 56285 ID: 4411c7

>>56282
Why you no update Keychain?
>>
No. 56300 ID: 91f547

>>56285

Several reasons. Some of them I've already given, in various relevant places online, and others I don't care to discuss.
>>
No. 56365 ID: fae0af
File 134055495264.png - (82.42KB , 911x937 , koc0325.png )
56365

Hey, look! Is that Wordblood?
>>
No. 56366 ID: 132b99

>>56365
no, it would be the titan he came from, He Who Bleeds The Unknown Word.
>>
No. 56367 ID: 6cbad7

>>56365
>>56366

Ha ha! Yes, that's HWBtUW. Wordblood is really just a tiny version of him, so it's a good catch.
>>
No. 56368 ID: 3734f6

>>56365
where? I am not seeing it.
>>
No. 56371 ID: a3b384

>>56368
The rightmost engraving on the wall.
>>
No. 56372 ID: 50f19a

>>56368

Fourth panel, far right. Saulanna also makes a single panel cameo in panel six of strip 269.
>>
No. 56383 ID: fae0af

Ugh I am sorry for triple posting but the website hates my computer and won't let me save the password, and makes up a new one every time I need to use one, so I can't delete posts to merge them.
>>
No. 56402 ID: 92aded

Just dropping by, jukes I love you for picking this quest back up. I was bummed when you cancelled KoC and then lunar quest looked like ending up a one shot. I am glad to see you haven't left us entirely
>>
No. 57043 ID: cee89f

Jukashi, you are awesome. KoC was awesome. LQ is awesome. Saulanna is awesome. YOU are awesome.

That is all. *goes back to lurking*
>>
No. 57208 ID: 32b5e5

Could we get some more information on how Power Word: Commune would work? Specifically:
1)Once the initial word was shouted would others be able to hear anything?
2)How long would one invocation last? and;
3)What would we have to do to teach Power Words to others?
>>
No. 57222 ID: f2f4ee
File 134244251079.png - (32.31KB , 250x250 , wbanswers.png )
57222

>>57208

"To begin with, Commune would not exactly be telepathy. Rather, you and-or the target would gain an intuitive understanding of the other. This would include "what would they say to me", but could also be rather more revealing than you might prefer. It would last until either party deliberately broke it off, and while it was active would be somewhat distracting. Perhaps something more along the lines you were thinking would be Knowledge, which you could use to implant any information you wanted into another being; although in that case, it would be a one-time delivery, so to speak. Telepathy might be closer to what you were originally thinking. To be frank, however, I'm not sure how well it fits into the epic fantasy milieu, you know? There are lots of assorted supernatural abilities that allow that sort of thing, but they tend to be more... fanciful. Prayer, secret whispers carried by tiny spirits, notes tied to the strings of fate, et cetera."

"As for teaching Words of Power to others... I've been thinking about it. I'm not certain how to proceed. A Power Word is a word in the True Speech, delivered with such iron certainty and purity of meaning that the world will obey the command. For Titanic beings, myself especially, this is simple; we are in direct contact with our own core nature - the "reality of self", you might say - and have implicit authority over reality. For more transient beings, however, it is likely to be much more difficult. Normal mortals could damage themselves simply by attempting the speech: if they were too weak to master it, the power in the sounds could twist the breath in their very lungs! Even then, the absolute understanding needed to give the word its force is likely to be elusive."

"Qualities such as the Hero's Soul would make a student more apt, but likely there would be long months of training, regardless. Using Titan's Will to directly bestow the ability would be much quicker. Or, perhaps, making a Power Word specifically intended to endow others with the capacity to use them. The most daring option of all would be to permanently tweak the laws of reality make this all easier for everyone, everywhere, but that would attract a lot of attention. We'd also need to locate a proper, ah, access point."

>>
No. 57225 ID: d8f016

>of course we could just rewrite the laws of reality to make it easier.

Wordblood, may I just say, I like the way you think. You certainly don't do things by halves.
>>
No. 57234 ID: 431fa8

>>/quest/433610
>stuff on why Beauty is not important here
I don't think you have an entirely complete grasp of what Beauty is and does, no offense intended. Saying it "affects how positively disposed our opponents are towards us" isn't simply an abstract first impressions thing; that's the flavor explanation for the mechanic of adding extra damage to every social attack we make. Look at what happened in the tutorial.

Everything we say deals damage expressed as:
>Attack damage ([Inspiration or Dickery] + [Competency] + [Beauty bonus]): [Result]

Consider that formula. Beauty is a social damage bonus. It adds to damage regardless of what other skill we use, regardless of whether our opponent likes us or not, and regardless of what argument we make. Every round, so long as we stand there are say something, our Beauty damages our opponent's will to resist us simply because they find us so pretty and therefore want to do what we want them to do.

To the best of my examination of the ruleset, no circumstance has been presented to us in the rules as we currently know them that Beauty would not provide an equal or greater bonus to Inspiration or Dickery. Beauty is the social combat power stat.

>Also, beauty is probably the most... obvious trait. An instant, out-of-nowhere permanent boost might raise suspicions among some of the people/ghosts of this city.
In my opinion, this is a strong argument for raising it now, when all of around nine people have ever seen us and none of them know us well enough to be sure that our appearance really changed drastically. If we wait until later then there will be more people who know us to become suspicious.

>I still want to create a feeder soul after we resolve this business with the lunars and the Emissary
I also want to create a Feeder Soul, and am hoping to do so immediately after concluding matters with the Moon Heroes but before we have to deal with the Emissary. This is not mutually exclusive with increasing our Beauty right now. Yes, it will nearly deplete us of Titan's Will, but the Will is there to be spent to our advantage- and once we have a Feeder Soul up and running it will be easier to acquire more.
>>
No. 57236 ID: 6b9d7f

>>/quest/433610

I agree with this post.

"Just eat more people" is NOT a decent solution for getting more TW. Peregrin is amoral and Saulanna should not become a serial killer, and should not become dependent on that out in the living world. A Feeder Soul will generate TW just by existing. We should make one, after this encounter.

To get through this encounter we should not do something like make obvious physical changes in our appearance, because people who have already met us will notice. That risks outing our Titanic nature. I think we could wait until we are alone on our way back from Lunar-Land to Shadow-Land. Everybody in Shadow-Land can think we got it while learning Lunar shapeshifting coolness. Any Lunars we meet later can think we improved it using experience, because I think you can just do that with Beauty.

I think either improve Dickery, improve Inspiration, get that Titan ability that lets you instantly know if words are lies or truth (I forget the name for it), or save it for later/emergencies.

We CAN just Moon Boost Dickery, Inspiration, and/or Beauty. I don't know how the Moon Heroes would react to a glowing Moon Mark, though. They might ask what Saulanna's been up to.
>>
No. 57237 ID: 6b9d7f

I forget, can Wordblood get more Titan's Will by eating books? Can we regenerate Moon Power that way? Got to ask Peregrin about any books he doesn't mind losing.
>>
No. 57238 ID: 431fa8

>>57236
>We should make one, after this encounter.
Agreed. In fact, I think just about everyone agrees on this.

>To get through this encounter we should not do something like make obvious physical changes in our appearance, because people who have already met us will notice.
But no one that we've met so far is someone that we need to be concerned about noticing! All of them can be relied upon to be loyal and/or keep their mouths shut, and for that matter how would they know that we didn't use experience anyway? As long as we make the change before the Moon Heroes get here, we will be entirely in the clear on this score.

>I think either improve Dickery, improve Inspiration,
Neither of these are a physical stat. We cannot improve them with Titan's Will, or at least we cannot do so with a single point like we can our physical stats. Even if we could, Dickery and Inspiration are basically worth strictly less than Beauty in social combat so it would be silly to improve them instead.

>We CAN just Moon Boost Dickery, Inspiration, and/or Beauty.
And I fully expect to do so, but as you point out, if we abuse it we can probably expect things to start going south with the Moon Heroes- and they might well start boosting their own social stats right back at us, which could be very dangerous.
>>
No. 57239 ID: 6b9d7f

>>57222
>There are lots of assorted supernatural abilities that allow that sort of thing, but they tend to be more... fanciful. Prayer, secret whispers carried by tiny spirits, notes tied to the strings of fate, et cetera."

Oh, hey Wordblood!
What about creating tiny, invisible words written on air that float at super speeds towards our target and then crawl into their brains? Would that work?
>>
No. 57242 ID: 6b9d7f

>>57238
>But no one that we've met so far is someone that we need to be concerned about noticing! All of them can be relied upon to be loyal and/or keep their mouths shut, and for that matter how would they know that we didn't use experience anyway? As long as we make the change before the Moon Heroes get here, we will be entirely in the clear on this score.

The ghost goons and soldiers worry me.

Alice either can't form new memories at all, or has probably heard SOMEthing about Peregrin's experiments on her.

Gevin, I have no idea. He's not anyone important, but rumors can spread and we're already called a soul-eating monster.

Captain Metion is someone we want to be friendly, and while he's probably no spy of the Emissary, he'd likely be unhappy about a soul-devouring Titan Hero.

Can we be certain that we haven't been seen by any spies of the Dragon's Shadow? We encountered some guys in battle, including those two mob goons, but mostly in War Form. Is that enough to assume we're safe if they turn out to be spies?

I see what you mean about using experience, though. If we can slip out of here, with the Moon Heroes, without a single ghost seeing us before we get back from Lunar-Land, then it'd be alright.
>>
No. 57243 ID: d8f016

>>57237
I believe Wordblood's said we could gain from eating books, but it would have to be on an enormous scale to do any good. And if we walk into major cities and start absorbing entire libraries, we'll get noticed.

On beauty v conservation- will have have enough titans will left over for the full feeder soul creation process after the +1 to beauty? Because if we will, I suppose there's no point in arguing about it. We can have our cake and eat it too.
>>
No. 57254 ID: 9718f3

>>57243
We would have enough for creating the feeder soul. We would be just barely short of the amount required to boost our Soul Force back up to the current level, I believe. But we'd have a feeder soul, the entire purpose of which is to produce more Titan's Will. And if we wanted some immediately, we could eat a slaver prisoner. Slavers aren't nice people. Slavers are dicks.
>>
No. 57256 ID: 99636c

>>57234
Ah, that's what I get for looking at the fluff text instead of the math. Apparently, beauty is added to every attack in social combat. And it counts just as much as our other attributes. Weird. So why would any social combatant NOT maximize beauty? It is a cost efficient choice. I'm still against it for the other reasons though.

>>57238
> But no one that we've met so far is someone that we need to be concerned about noticing!
I doubt any of our minions could stand up to serious interrogation by the Emissary. The Emissary is almost certainly a powerful social combatant, and we haven't done enough to build up loyalty. The servants are only loyal by proxy through Peregrin and may not understand how seemingly small details about ourselves could hurt us.
>>
No. 57259 ID: a73dec

Now that I think about it, do the effects of beauty mean that blind people are awesome at social combat?
>>
No. 57262 ID: 60af05

I feel I should clarify on Beauty, OOCly, because it's a little complex.

At the most basic level, Beauty gives you a +1 to all your social attacks for every level of it you have above 2. This is, indeed, very useful! However, there are caveats. First, as >>57259 suspects, it's only useful if people have seen you.

Second, the bonus is also sort of based on the target's standards. "Normal" Beauty is 2, so for normal people, the bonus begins above 2. Some characters, however, will have higher standards: generally, people who either have more Beauty than you themselves or who are continually exposed to people with higher Beauty. Higher gods, Fair Folk, experienced Heroes and so on are all less likely to be impressed by mortal standards of attractiveness. A person who has or is used to Beauty 4, for example a king who surrounds himself with attractive servants, will only begin being affected by other characters with Beauty 4.

Finally, Beauty's "always on" nature has some downsides. It makes a character stand out in crowds and in people's memory, and can attract unwanted attention from jealous spouses, lusty drunkards, slavers and so on, in a way that neither Inspiration nor Dickery will.
>>
No. 57268 ID: 1417a1

>>/quest/433826
It's not impossible that one of them could tell. So what? Why would it be suspicious? Are you suspicions towards people in makeup or people who smile when they meet you?

If anything, Saulanna expending Moon Power to make a good first impression will probably have the following effects:
- We seem like a nice, friendly person, since we're willing to make a small effort to make a good impression.
- We seem to be at ease and comfortable here, which will make us seem less like a prisoner which Garmir seems to suspect.
- We will also seem relaxed and not hostile. If we were planning to attack them or use mind control powers, we certainly wouldn't waste our powers on
>>
No. 57269 ID: 1b9919

They would be suspicious of you spending power in that it implies you need to spend power. Why would you need to use your abilities again the nice friendly lunars coming to see you? I mean, come on, they're going to be pretty suspicious when we tell them we don't want to leave the deathlands for the moon-clan initiation and whathaveyou. Us burning power at the same time won't help.

Also: I'm now wondering how much our beauty would actually affect people who are natural shapeshifters, and hang with other natural shapeshifters. You'd think they'd get used to people looking good.
>>
No. 57273 ID: 6b9d7f

Or they have really strange standards.
>>
No. 57284 ID: 1417a1

>>57269
Not really, spending it only implies that we _want_ to spend power, which have the benefits mentioned above.
>>
No. 57299 ID: 147853

>>57262
Yes! Reason! I love reason, do you love reason?

I think some people just don't think our Raccoon Lady is attractive enough. Meh.

Inspiration and Dickery both work incredibly well with our current skill set, even though I still kinda want to make a feeder soul. We don't yet know all the fun little ways it could come in handy.
>>
No. 57301 ID: 9718f3

>>57262
Didn't having a beauty of 1 give you a negative to social combat? If so, then logically having only 2 or 3 would also put you at a disadvantage against somebody used to scores of 4 or higher.

On the other hand, we could also run into somebody who hates beautiful people, I suppose.
>>
No. 57310 ID: 4411c7
File 134258034537.jpg - (187.98KB , 860x1006 , Pumpkin Chariot Prana.jpg )
57310

Hey, Jukashi. I don't know how else to get this to you, so here! I made this for you based off one of the new Charms in Shards of the Exalted Dream.
Turns out you made a good prediction, except with the wrong Exalt type!

Also I just realized this bicycle has no pedals.
>>
No. 57312 ID: 60af05

>>57310

I understand I've actually been confirmed as having given ideas to the writers before! One of the second ed. Alchemical Charms, if I recall.

I've slacked off on keeping up with Exalted products lately, now I think on it. Mainly because I prefer actual books made of paper, really.
>>
No. 57314 ID: 6b9d7f

>>57312
Elegant Nova of Progression is apparently listed as a sample Alchemical name in one of their 2E books.
>>
No. 57324 ID: 431fa8

>>/quest/433888
>no normal Moon Hero can recover Moon Power in a Shadowy Land
What Saulanna discovered in the first thread was, from >>/questarch/88763:
>MOON POWER takes some time to recharge, especially if you don't rest, and especially especially in this SHADOWY LAND.
Recharging slowly is not at all the same as not recharging at all. Further, we have actively regained points of Moon Power while in the Shadowy Land by doing things that any random Lunar could do, as in >>/questarch/90736:
>Luna is impressed by the OVERKILL. She restores one point of MOON POWER!

Thus, while it might be expected that Saulanna would be low on Moon Power, and certainly they won't expect the sort of reserves that we have due to Wordblood, for all they know she's been stunting every action since she manifested and Luna has been raining extra Moon Power down on her every five seconds as the most favored of her Chosen. Plus she's had time to take a nap and probably regain at least a point or two normally, even with the slow pace of power recovery in the Shadowy Land. There is need for her to pretend to be largely depleted of energy.

>>/quest/434078
>Guys, a Feeder Soul has nothing to do with eating human souls.
Also incorrect. As Wordblood says in >>/quest/409526:
>any higher titanic subsoul can assist with the absorption of souls, but a deva birthed for the purpose will ultimately be superior at the task
A Feeding Soul is birthed explicitly for the purpose of absorbing souls (human or otherwise), as well as self-generating Titan's Will, recovering magical power from other sources, and managing magical power- presumably aiding the efficiency of our manipulation of Moon Power. Since it would be a Soul Force 2 soul belonging to us, presumably it will also provide us with six Moon Power, just as Wordblood does.

If all it did was pop out a point of Titan's Will every few months, I really don't think there would be such widespread approval for the idea of investing the vast majority of our remaining Titan's Will into its creation.

>>/quest/433977
>the cover story for what happened
We don't necessarily have to provide a cover story. We can just say that we had a bit of a disagreement with Peregrin shortly after gaining our Hero Soul, but that it was sorted out quickly enough and there are no hard feelings on either side. If necessary, we can honestly say that Peregrin has known us longer than we can even remember, implying that we are a native of this territory and/or were a personal acquaintance of Peregrin prior to gaining our Hero Soul. Implicitly claiming this background would provide a reason that we would want to stay with him, as well- if we consider the Shadowy Land to be our home, then for better or worse it's logical to think that we would want to stay here.

Not a completely airtight story, I admit, but it's probably enough unless we do something to give them significant reason to question it.

>>/quest/433989
>Hm... would it be possible to just like... convert Gevin into a feeder soul or something?
We could probably take him as akuma, which gives us their powers but causes massive personality feedback since we're effectively making them one of our souls, as I understand it, when we're not strong enough to absorb them without noticing. But that wouldn't give us the desired powerset anyway. A true Feeding Soul would be custom-designed for the purpose, made from Saulanna's own soulstuff; short of simply eating Gevin and used his raw material for Titan's Will to craft the Feeding Soul, he's not going to be of any help in making it.

>>57262
While this does make Beauty somewhat less useful than originally anticipated, in some ways I can't help but interpret it as "if your Beauty isn't helping you win a social encounter, it's because you're not using enough of it". It wouldn't even take that many Titan's Will to get our Beauty up to extremely high values.

Admittedly before too long down that path, everyone who ever sees us would be remembering us forever as the most jaw-droppingly gorgeous woman they've ever seen, we'd probably start spontaneously generating cults worshiping us as a beauty goddess, and we'd be in severe danger of being kidnapped and/or socially attacked for the purpose of seduction by anyone who wants the most beautiful woman ever (which is everyone) and thinks they have the power to make it stick. But hey, combine with our impressive Inspiration and our expert Intimidation, and we could probably berate people into willingly sacrificing themselves to us specifically to feed us Titan's Will, with nothing more than a Moon Boost to ensure that we'd be doing something like 20-25 social damage per attack.

I know, we probably don't want to go down that route. But it's fun to dream.
>>
No. 57325 ID: 34cbef
File 134260032340.png - (60.00KB , 964x619 , 130780585052.png )
57325

jukashi, i like your word blood creatue because it reminds of my anthyptus creature- is there anychance that it gets it's own quest?
>>
No. 57348 ID: 6b9d7f

>>57324
I read the Feeding Soul description as having two options: Saulanna can make a soul that only absorbs souls, OR she can make one that makes its own Titan's Will without eating anyone. I did not read those as being the same type of soul at all.

And Saulanna cannot just go around blithly eating people forever. Remember what Peregrin said about how people will react to such behavior? Remember the Captain's reaction to the rumor? We keep doing that, and eventually people WILL find out. Then Saulanna can forget the Moon Heroes being friendly. Indeed, since it probably ain't something normal Moon Heroes can do, it would probably reveal her Titanic nature.

And eventually somebody, if not Luna herself, will probably find out Saulanna is part-Titan. We want that to be on Saulanna's terms, not by accident in the context of devouring human souls. For Saulanna's long-term survival, she needs Moon Heroes and especially Luna to be favorably disposed towards her. And she shouldn't do things that would horrify/outrage the majority of the living, either.
>>
No. 57349 ID: c7f8fb

The feeder soul is intended to some kind of a manager. A banker or accountant for our magical currencies. We probably can decide to order it to focus more on accumulating interest, or on hostile takeovers. We can probably even design it to be better at one over the other.

But making it incapable of taking apart souls seems a foolish painting ourselves into a corner. There's a big difference between not wanting to have to use lethal force, and not being able to. We should leave ourselves the option if we run into a situation where it's necessary, even if on the whole it's better off avoided.
>>
No. 57351 ID: a73dec

>I read the Feeding Soul description as having two options: Saulanna can make a soul that only absorbs souls, OR she can make one that makes its own Titan's Will without eating anyone. I did not read those as being the same type of soul at all.
Where did you get that impression? When feeding souls are described in >>/quest/409526, they are described as being able to help us eat, let us do generate, and also assist with recovering power. It doesn't say anything about those things being mutually exclusive.
>>
No. 57383 ID: 431fa8

What the heck is Saulanna holding in her left hand in >>/quest/434231 and >>/quest/434233?
>>
No. 57397 ID: 24b8ac
File 134268448756.jpg - (16.82KB , 300x400 , BucksPAFireplaceTongs.jpg )
57397

>>57325

It's unlikely. Wordblood is sort of attached to her, ba-dum tisshhh

>>57351
>>57349
>>57348

The Feeding Soul will take over the efficiency/ease of consumption progression from Wordblood, and will introduce a periodic gain of Titan's Will for "free". I mean, theoretically you could make one soul for soul-devouring and one for self-generation, but that would probably be redundant? Saulanna should be making more souls for herself eventually anyway, if she's intending to become a fully grown Titan.

Perhaps I can explain this better.

Think of it as a base-building game, like Dive quest was/is partly, or that bit in Skies of Arcadia after you get your own pirate island. The base is Saulanna's internal world. Right now, it's pretty bare. "Recruiting" new souls is like adding shopkeepers and blacksmiths and such to your base, only instead of goods and services, you get magical powers. And in this analogy, a Feeding Soul would be like a banker or manager character, who helps you accumulate gold and resources, and helps spend them. All of Saulanna's souls will be able to do it a bit, but a Feeding Soul specializes in it and will make everything more efficient. And the more you upgrade them, the more they can do, and the better they can do it.

She doesn't have to make a Feeding Soul first, though. She could make herself a Soul to help with any sort of purpose, like fighting or crafting or mind control or healing or anything. It's just Wordblood's recommendation.

>>57383

That's a pair of fireplace tongs, like so. For picking things up when they're on fire.
>>
No. 57406 ID: 9718f3

If we do decide to shoot for becoming a titan, we should figure out what our gimmick is. I think that something like Understanding would work for us. The search for, and comprehension of, knowledge but also the sharing of ideas and view-points between individuals and groups, which language in general can be seen as a manifestation of. Understanding of our self, of our surroundings, of others, and the presence of growth of the same in, and between, others. It fits with Wordblood, with our approach to problem-solving, and with our stats.

The Feeding Soul could take on the form of some sort of scientist, taking souls apart to discover how they work and what they know. The passive TW generation could be seen as the product of inspiration, or from internal contemplation.

I'm just toying with ideas really.
>>
No. 57417 ID: a3b384

>>57397
Someone had come up with the idea of using Gavin as a feeder soul, which while isn't a job he'd be suited at does bring up the question of recruiting instead of eating and creating souls. Is it possible, practical, and perhaps a way to get around the "soul devouring monster" schtick? Could we have an internal base of souls, protecting and empowering us while also generating titans will?
>>
No. 57418 ID: bf54a8

>>57417
possible? yes
practical? hell no.
human souls re-purposed for titanic things SUCK at the new job. it's like making a guy at a desk job do field work. while they CAN do it, they will not do a good job.
>>
No. 57419 ID: 24b8ac

>>57406

Try not to nail things down too soon; it's pretty early days for Saulanna's development, and she's never going to be "normal" Titan to begin with. Who knows what might come up?

Answer: me.

>>57417

Human souls could live in Saulanna's internal world. Technically, eventually, maybe, anyone will be able to, if she lets them in. And they'd be able to do some things for her, certainly, the same way they can do things in the real world.

However, I should make it clear that Titan souls and human souls are not really very similar. Titan souls are naturally spiritual entities, complete in themselves and created with powers and capabilities designed to help fulfill their purpose. They're actually very much like gods, only attached to a Titan (or it may be more accurate to say that the gods are like a Titan's souls). Human souls, on the other hand, are designed to be plugged into human bodies and drive them around doing human things. Dead ones get ghost powers, because of eldritch shenanigans, but they're really quite limited. If you wanted to give them the powers you'd want them to have, you'd have to work thorough enough changes to them that you might as well eat them anyway.

You could herd some together to pray to you. Human souls are good for praying. That'd provide benefits.
>>
No. 57433 ID: 997ce7

>>57419
Do we get in trouble like we do in vanilla Exalted for having too high a Cult rating?
>>
No. 57437 ID: c7f8fb

>>57433
I'd think it would be pretty safe to assume attracting worshipers would come with sociopolitical consequences among mortals, and possible problems of competition and jealousy from other established worshipies. Obviously exacerbated the bigger our following gets. With great power comes great complications.
>>
No. 57440 ID: 431fa8

>>57419
>Human souls could live in Saulanna's internal world.
>Dead ones
>Human souls are good for praying. That'd provide benefits.
So we can have a few hundred thousand ghosts shoved into our internal world running a massive prayer-battery to feed us a constant stream of power, right?
>>
No. 57441 ID: 8e921b

>>57440
That might honestly be a better deal than being stuck in the Veil with the Dragon's Shadow and his followers.

I wonder if a Cult can provide Titan's Will? Hmmmm....

I don't know what "trouble" Cult causes for Exalted in the game, but how do we know... would it effect Saulanna like a Lunar, or like an Infernal?

I suspect all that would take more TW than buffing up a Feeding Soul enough to generate its own TW, though.
>>
No. 57443 ID: fa9f7e

>>57441
Ingame, depending on what age you're in and what type of Exalt you are, being worshiped too much draws the ire of the Solar Deliberative, the Wyld Hunt, the bureaucracy of Yu-Shan (heaven), priests of Cecelynne (probably, they deal with shit like that, iirc) -the desert surrounding Hell- or the Deathlords, ghosts of evil high-Essence Solars.
>>
No. 57450 ID: 24aae6

>>57443

This can pretty much be summed up as that becoming too popular can attract the attention of whoever sees themselves as being in authority over you, justified or unjustified. And then they go all "Yo, why you becoming too big for your britches?"

In the chaos the quest's set in, who knows who might take notice? Politicial rivalry might be the more common reaction.
>>
No. 57465 ID: 06dae0

I just realized that seriously need to do something about the research Kaan has for grafting titan fragments to mortals, and not just because of the possible danger an army of amnesiac artificial titans would be. Allow me to explain.

1. Artificial Titans gain power by absorbing souls that would otherwise be used for a new life.
2. Once past the memory bleeding effect, the feeling of absorbing these souls is very pleasurable, to the point that it could get addicting.
3. Generally the more souls absorbed, the easier they get absorbed and more become capable of being absorbed at once.

Say someone made 100 artificial titans, which would, over the span of time, each come to absorb about 200 souls to gain power. That's 20,000 souls that would otherwise be used for new life right there. Now say 20 of those titans become addicted to the feeling of absorbing those souls, and go on rampages through which they absorb more like 2000 or so. Then in order to put these soul-thirsty titans down the others would need to absorb more souls to gain enough power to take them down. From there things would quickly escalate to the point that at least 70,000 souls would be lost through these titans, but would probably drain a lot more than just that.

And that's not even going into the possible power gained by absorbing a hero's soul or a titan fragment. Hell, all it'd really take is a single artificial titan becoming addicted to absorbing souls to cause incredible damage to all of existence.
>>
No. 57466 ID: 4190ec

>>57465
70000? We obviously have different definitions of "damage to all creation"
>>
No. 57467 ID: 7472ad

>>57465
I'm just going to say that not only can Titans create souls, as we're talking about doing so at as low as Soul-Force 3, but we're not the only thing around that can end a soul. Pretty sure Vodak has eaten a whole hell of a lot more then 2000 souls while sealed in Six Gates.(Counting those he ate when he was sealed at least.)
>>
No. 57468 ID: 7472ad

>>57466
That's another thing to keep in mind. Creation in terms of land surface is bigger then earth, and there are souls in the watery bits too. Plus add in all the non-human souls, and the fact that it was massively bigger when the whole reincarnation system got put in place, so souls:land ratio may very well be out of balance even keeping in mind the underworld having more souls then creation.
>>
No. 57469 ID: c7f8fb

There's also the fact that this new titan creation thing is hardly easy to pull off. And I highly doubt there are enough Wordblood equivalents laying around to roll up 100 of us.

And seriously, the potential upheaval and damage that could result long term from the birth and rise to power or prominence of just a single being from the race that created the gods goes waaaaay beyond n pounds of soul stuff don't make it back for reincarnation.
>>
No. 57470 ID: e3aff6

>>57465
Also, those rates are assuming they don't get killed off by all the other superbeings running around. I seem to recall hearing that normal Exalted were more or less to built for the purpose of killing titans, and those weren't even the little titans that this method produces.
>>
No. 57472 ID: bf54a8

yeah the first job exalts had when they were created was to kill the titans. so yes, there are plenty of things stopping rampages. and absorbing souls is only a rush since we are so weak it's giving us a lot of energy because we have so little. once we become more powerful a single soul will be as a drop in a bucket.
>>
No. 57477 ID: 431fa8

Creating a subsoul while we're still at 2-3 Soul Force is extremely inexpensive, really; it takes a mere 3 Titan's Will.

So. We get something like 3-4 Titan's Will right now from a reasonably competent but not particularly exceptional ghost; call it 2.5 from an average ghost. Presumably, once the feeding soul is created even at its base level this will improve to a reliable 3/ghost, discounting standouts- meaning that a single uninteresting ghost can provide us with a single baby subsoul.

Given these costs, we should be able to make a couple dozen subsouls with minimal difficulty, and I suspect with little or no attention drawn to us as well. With them safely sealed away in our inner world following creation, detecting that they exist at all would require (at a guess) truly exceptional perception.

Using this pattern of action, we should be able to acquire a wide variety of exceptional specialized capabilities without doing the whole "be a monster who consumes everyone" bit- I doubt that any but the most tentative of us would be worried about devouring, say, ghosts who make their living by imprisoning other ghosts and selling them to hell as slaves. There are targets available which are not particularly objectionable.

The reason to do this is that Saulanna will want to start really raising her Soul Force sooner or later, and the higher our Soul Force goes the more effective Titan's Will it will take to raise it. If a new soul is always created at Soul Force 2, which seems likely, then every point above 3 that our Soul Force is when we make a subsoul is an extra Titan's Will that we shouldn't have to pay. Now, if the new soul is created at equal Soul Force to Saulanna's new value, we could get a cost break by splintering off subsouls at as high a value as possible and doing things the other way around, but I don't think that's how the system is likely to work- guidance from Jukashi would be appreciated, however.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure this would be an effective way to set the stage for long-term growth with minimal exposure and investment of resources. Once we've got a solid circle of subsouls, then it's just a matter of getting them (and Saulanna) 104 Titan's Will each to max them out and tossing handfuls of Titan's Will at various other useful abilities- and we can spend as short or long on that project as we please.
>>
No. 57481 ID: 9718f3

>>57477
I'm also wondering how making new souls works at different Soul Force levels. It could be souls always start at Soul Force 2, or they could match us after we split them off. If the first is true, there's still a couple ways it could be handled. It could be that at Soul Force 4, we can produce multiple Soul Force 2 souls at once, instead of only the one. It is also possible that at sufficiently high levels of Soul Force, we can produce new souls without losing a level, so long as we only do so occasionally. We could even theoretically make a soul dedicated to making more souls, either from itself, or from us, to further increase the efficiency of the process.
>>
No. 57483 ID: bf54a8

subsouls will always be difficult and we can only have so many. they are the upper class of our soul civilization. once we have so many we instead start making lower souls. for the banker analogy if the feeding soul is the banker then their sub-souls would be clerks tellers. souls whos job is to improve the soul above them. and the sub-souls improve us. and don't think we can just ignore the limit and keep making them. we will start getting overlap in jobs and that causes bad things.
>>
No. 57484 ID: 431fa8

>>57483
I'm pretty sure that making enough lower souls to keep things stable is our subsouls' problem, not ours. Besides, "ignore the limit"? What limit? I'll admit that Saulanna doesn't have much of a personality right now, but her subsouls should be able to be centered around anything that she can imagine and hold as part of her, I think. We would want to be careful that we didn't design souls which would hate each other, so it would likely behoove us to keep things fairly unified in essential purpose, but that should still give us plenty of room to make quite a few souls which can work together without serious problems while handling different aspects of what we will.
>>
No. 57485 ID: c7f8fb

Well, Jukashi made the point that these sub souls are gonna be basically the useful npcs of our inner town. The feeder soul is gonna be our banker. What comes next isn't necessarily lesser clerks. We want different shopkeepers. Get us an item shop, weapon seller, wizard school, guild hall, etc. The metaphor stretches a little thin, but you get the point.

For example, we could have a soul dedicated to managing our crafting powers- creating objects and artifacts directly from our energy reserves.

Or a soul focused on utilizing our powers offensively in combat (so we get an RnD guy, or an internal gunner). Or a soul focused on throwing up magical defenses before we can even react to threats. Or a soul focused on applying any of the schools of magic we've started to dabble in. Or an intelligence gatherer who passively data mines and mind reads everyone we meet. The possibilities are kind of endless and open for creatively.

We're just focusing on the banker first because if we want to build up our base, we need to get a handle on the resources and economy first. Once we've done that, we fund cool things.
>>
No. 57486 ID: 334456

>>57397
Wait.

The feeding soul generates TITANS WILL?

Fuck everything else, feeder soul ahoy.
>>
No. 57487 ID: 24aae6

>>57486
At a rate of 1 per month when starting out. That's just to start out, though (it'll get better as we upgrade it). It was mentioned earlier in the quest when the feeder soul was first mentioned as an option.
>>
No. 57488 ID: b85f8c

I hope it doesn't cost too much to get it up to 1/day. 10 more TW invested to get it that far is about as much as I'd want to pay.
>>
No. 57489 ID: 9718f3

>>57488
Assuming the period halves with each upgrade, the upgrade costs one more Titan's Will each time, the cost of upgrade starts at one Titan's Will, and months are the same length of time in Exalted(I honestly can't remember), it would cost 15 Titan's Will.

Using only the Titan's Will generated by the Feeder Soul itself, it would take three and a half months to upgrade the ability to that level, unless I screwed up the math somewhere.

Realistically, we are going to need to eat some more souls. Even eating one would cut about two months off of that figure.
>>
No. 57491 ID: bf54a8

may be even better. it would improve the amount we gain per soul.
>>
No. 57493 ID: b85f8c

>>57489
Um, if it halves every time... looks like your math's right but let me take it a bit further than that:
1(1) TW: 15 days (TNL 30 days)
2(3) TW: 7.5 days (TNL 23 days)
3(6) TW: 3.8 days (TNL 15 days)
4(10) TW: 1.9 days (TNL 10 days)
5(15) TW: 22.5 hours (TNL 6 days)
6(21) TW: 11.3 hours (TNL 3 days)
7(28) TW: 5.6 hours (TNL 45 hours)
8(36) TW: 2.8 hours (TNL 25 hours)
9(45) TW: 1.4 hours (TNL 14 hours)
10(55) TW: 42.2 minutes (TNL 8 hours)
11(66) TW: 21.1 minutes (TNL 4 hours)
12(78) TW: 10.5 minutes (TNL 2 hours)
13(91) TW: 5.3 minutes (TNL 74 minutes)
14(105) TW: 2.6 minutes (TNL 39 minutes)
15(120) TW: 1.3 minutes (TNL 21 minutes)
So basically if it halves the time on each TW we put in after making it... I would expect it to be capped at some point, as going much further than 10 makes it just completely ridiculous since you can start upgrading it once a day. Or, maybe, capped at 2x Saulanna's soul power.

Then again Wordblood did say that eventually it would be a superior way of getting TW than eating souls, didn't he? Maybe it is going to get as ridiculous as 1 TW/minute. It does take over a hundred TW to get that far though...
>>
No. 57499 ID: 7472ad

Keep in mind that in order to increase how much Titan's Will it generates we're almost certainly going to have to raise it's Soul Force, and raising it above our own may not be a good idea.
>>
No. 57500 ID: 9718f3

Ah, good point. That'd basically triple the cost at this point. The Feeder Soul's Soul Force and our own. And that's assuming that upgrade costs don't start increasing by more than just one at some point, which they may.
>>
No. 57501 ID: bde53b

Er, hmm, well.

This is a bit early for such information, but I guess it'd be harmless. So: a theoretical absolute blank slate Feeding Soul would begin with Will Generation of 0, which would provide 1 TW per year. Saulanna's would start at level 2 of that, though, giving 1 per month. It would also begin at Soul Force 2. Generation, like similar abilities, can at most be equal to Soul Force, so you have to upgrade the latter to upgrade the former. From a month it would go down to a week, then to a day, and then to an amount per day equal to the amount of top-level souls Saulanna has. Upgrading beyond that will require the Feeding Soul to create its own subsouls, at which point TW generation will shift from amount-per-time to a system more like Exalted's Resources background, where you're assumed to have enough to purchase things below a certain cost for "free", and upgrade from there.

That's just base level, though. Depending on what kind of Feeding Soul is made, certain circumstances will increase or decrease TW generation.

New souls begin at a minimum of Soul Force 2, assuming Saulanna sticks to only doing so at SF 3 or above. As Saulanna becomes more powerful, though, her new souls will begin with a Soul Force rating based on how much Saulanna's lost point of Soul Force cost her. So, for example, if we say she was at level 5? Getting from 4 to 5 costs 4 TW, so the new Soul would begin at (1 for 1) + (1 for 2) + (2 for 3) - Soul Force 3. Essentially, the equivalent amount of TW Saulanna "loses" is used to upgrade the new soul automatically.

It should be noted that, beyond a certain overall power level, Saulanna will find it more and more difficult to conceal her true nature. Eventually - well before becoming as powerful as any of the existing Titans - it will become essentially impossible.

... Unless she creates a Stealth-themed soul with special powers just for that purpose, I guess.
>>
No. 57503 ID: 431fa8

>>57501
Thanks for the information.

>... Unless she creates a Stealth-themed soul with special powers just for that purpose, I guess.
I'm pretty sure this was already on the agenda. The odds of us wanting to buy time before the world notices we're a Titan approach 1 with time spent thinking about how the world might respond.

Also on my agenda is playing with Saulanna's nature as a Moon Hero to see if we can rig our Hero Soul so that it contains our full personality and automatically overwhelms its next host, and is keyed as the central soul of our titan-self... so that even if we die, we'll pop right up (preferably at full power, but even a diminished form would be fine) when our Hero Soul finds its next host. And any of our subsouls which are still alive at the time of our death, which I would hope would be most of them, would stay as the subsouls of our new incarnation.

Basically, I'm pretty sure we could make ourselves roughly as hard to kill as our Hero Soul itself with a little work. It would make a nice safety net in case we royally fuck up- it's hardly perfect, but it would be good to learn from how the Titans died the first time around, and ward ourselves against being ended in the same way.
>>
No. 57507 ID: c7f8fb

>>57503
Actually, that raises the somewhat interesting question of where our consciousness currently resides.

The pre-Saulanna mortal soul was wiped clean, then we were fused with our titanic soul fragment and then somehow escaped captivity and gained our hero's soul (actually, I'm not 100% sure that's the right order- could we have attracted the hero's soul after or even during the mindwipe, but before Wordblood. Or after Wordblood, but before the escape- which could explain how we ever got out).

In any event, the current Saulanna consciousness didn't start up until all three souls were in place. It kind of makes sense to assume Saulanna's running off the mortal soul, since Wordblood mostly has an independent personality and consciousness, and the hero's soul usually serves as a power pack with limited passive influences on host personality. But we can't really be sure- she could be running off of processing power pulled from all three. So she's not the manifestation of any subsoul, but the gestalt. Which would actually makes her interactions with Wordblood all the more interesting- a whole interacting with a piece of itself. Puts Wordblood in some kind of spiritual superposition state- simultaneous contributing to/existing as the gestalt personality/consciousness and his individual one.
>>
No. 57509 ID: bf54a8

wordblood has said repeatedly that they are merging.
>>
No. 57515 ID: b85f8c

>>57501
Okay. To get it to 1/day we would need to spend 5 TW to get the soul to 4 SF, then spend 5 TW to upgrade the generation. That costs 10 TW total, which is about as much as I'd want to spend on it at this point.

Well, that assumes that we don't have to upgrade Saulanna's SF so that it's always greater than or equal to the feeder soul's. If we have to do that, then it costs an additional 3 TW (part of the cost of making the soul is getting her to 3 Soul Force afterwards for safety's sake apparently), which is a downer.

Hey, could you clarify what "top-level souls" means?
>>
No. 57517 ID: a3b384

Can we get any more info on that whole "rewriting reality" thing Wordblood mentioned? Depending on what that is all about, what we can do with it and how things go that may actually provide as an ultimate goal for us.
>>
No. 57520 ID: 8e921b

>>57467
Titans can create TITAN souls. That has boo-all to do with creating human souls, which are a totally different thing. SOME Titans could do it, but that is not where human souls come from now, or normally.

That said, in normal Exalted there is literally an infinite supply of human souls, so the question is the morality of putting so many thousands at risk or termination, and the other, more world-ending things any number of random new Titans could do.

Just one Saulanna is enough for reasons unrelated to eating souls. She needs to make Peregrin stop the project before he finds another Titan fragment.


>>57515
Keep in mind raising Saulanna's Soul Force has lots of other benefits: More Moon Power, and I think an additional Moon Ability per increase. It's also necessary any time we want to raise Wordblood's Soul Force.

I'm assuming "top-level soul" means Wordblood, hypothetical Feeder Soul, and any others Saulanna makes personally. Each of these souls will probably have to make its own sub-souls when it gets enough Soul Force. A "normal" Titan has about 12-20 souls, each with its own 7 sub-souls.

No idea if her human souls and/or Hero Soul count here.
>>
No. 57521 ID: 8e921b

Arg, still can't delete posts.

Saying "boo-all" sounds too condescending. Sorry.
>>
No. 57529 ID: 7472ad

>>57520
I was going to talk about Solar tier exalts making souls, but apparently Wyld-Shaping Technique and it's tree got nerfed in errata. Huh. Still, if we want to make souls, becoming capable of it is an option. Even without a dedicated soul for it, I'm sure there's some string of Power Words that would give us the capability.
>>
No. 57534 ID: 147853

>>57520
Finding more titan fragments is a good thing. We've gone over it before. It's one of the best ways to increase our abilities and soul force.
>>
No. 57537 ID: 8e921b

>>57529
Yes, if we want to develop the ability to create specifically human souls, there's probably a way to do it eventually. But remember Saulanna isn't a "solar-tier" Exalt, and Wordblood isn't a Wyld-Shaping sort of spirit.
>>
No. 57539 ID: bf54a8

uhhhh... human souls all started with the titans. they built the world and then people to live in it. the reincarnation cycle was built later. to deal with the back-log. the thing human souls did normally would be a titan eats it on death and makes new ones. can make several new souls from the power in an old one.
>>
No. 57542 ID: 1fa0a0

>>57507
>Actually, that raises the somewhat interesting question of where our consciousness currently resides.
"Here I am, floating in a vat, being stared at by my own eyes."
>>
No. 57543 ID: fa9f7e

>>57542
...


...

WE ARE SECRETLY DANIEL DENNETT

I KNEW IT
>>
No. 57550 ID: 8e921b

>>57539
My point is that human souls aren't at all the same things as Titan souls, and making a Titan soul is not the same as making a human soul.

Titans created the first humans. But the current supply of human souls does not require Titans to create each one individually.

I was also trying to say that there's probably no danger of the world running out of human souls, no matter how many new Titans start eating them.
>>
No. 57553 ID: bf54a8

>>57550
uhhh... no. the reincarnation system doesn't make any more souls. it takes an old one, scrubs out the memories and puts it in a new body.
>>
No. 57555 ID: f3d7da

>>57553
Of course the reincarnation system doesn't make any souls; that is not its job. The soul creation system (of which there is one, in canon!Exalted) creates souls. Where did you get the idea that anyone was saying that the reincarnation system has anything to do with the soul creation process?
>>
No. 57561 ID: bf54a8

i'm trying to find it and i can't. where is your info about the soul maker?
>>
No. 57578 ID: 8e921b

It's called the Well of Souls. I don't know what book it's in, but my understanding is that it's plugged into the infinite Wyld, sucking infinite Wyld energy in and spitting out potentially infinite human souls (or maybe only as many as are needed).
>>
No. 57579 ID: 8e921b

Also, I should point out that in canon!Exalted it's never been stated that Lethe is a Primordial who eats human souls and births new ones. I'm not certain Lethe's precise nature has been detailed at all, but I know that isn't the canon answer.
>>
No. 57580 ID: bf54a8

what? i never said lethe did that i said it's a machine that scrubs souls clean and spits them out. only primordials with any freedom are autochithon and gaia.
>>
No. 57581 ID: 8e921b

OK, while I don't know about books (having only 3) these should help:

http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Neall_Raemonn_Price_on_The_Number_of_Souls_in_Creation

http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Ink_Monkeys,_vol._4:_Soulgems_and_Thaumaturgy
>>
No. 57582 ID: 8e921b

>>57580
OK, I misunderstood. You said
>uhhhh... human souls all started with the titans. they built the world and then people to live in it. the reincarnation cycle was built later. to deal with the back-log. the thing human souls did normally would be a titan eats it on death and makes new ones. can make several new souls from the power in an old one.

I've never seen this mentioned anywhere.
>>
No. 57592 ID: 256d52

Hmmm, looks like Garmir has a whole pile of (paid off) blood-debts.

Iiiiiiiinteresting.
>>
No. 57596 ID: d60c80
File 134305411721.jpg - (68.54KB , 800x560 , 1330532173638.jpg )
57596

I honestly thought that Askalaff was female. It make sense that he isn't though, as he isn't exposing his midriff like nearly every other female Jukashi draws.

I'm also getting owl vibes off of him like many others, but he's small and friendly so I'd like to think that's his totem is a corgi.

Besides, wouldn't a corgi war form be adorable?
>>
No. 57597 ID: c7f8fb

There's still hope! "Two men" could have been using the sexist masculine group plural. And the midrift could still be there, just hidden under the cloak!

...okay yeah. That's probably reaching. Don't worry, you weren't the only one to guess the wrong way, apparently. The owlgirl is dead, long live the owlman, and all that jazz. :p

>>57592
Is that all the crossed out circles on his arm? For those of us not running off the source material, blood oaths got anything special in this setting?
>>
No. 57598 ID: 8e921b

>>57597
This is all I know: http://keychain.patternspider.net/archive/koc0316.html
>>
No. 57604 ID: 4c14a9

>>57596
>I honestly thought that Askalaff was female
Me too. But hey, with the right charm, he could be!
>>
No. 57606 ID: e7e90d

>>57604
Oh, right. Base gender becomes somewhat irrelevant for free form shapeshifters. We have no evidence if there two are in their native forms.
>>
No. 57608 ID: d60c80
File 134308504985.png - (154.60KB , 320x335 , Lunars p 36.png )
57608

>>57597

A blood debt is basically an "I.O.U one (1) favour". As Saulannas rescuers, Garmir and Askalaff will both have their names tattooed onto her flesh, and will be owed one blood debt by her (marked by an empty circle).

Garmir has had a lot of debts but they've all been paid off, indicating that he is ultimately trustworthy, if brash.

One way to get someone into debt is to challange them to one-on-one combat, the loser owes the debt to the winner because the winner refused to slay him. Furthermore, the combat is not always physical and the terms are set by the challenged party. As such, Garmir may have challenged someone to conflict only to be caught up in a game of cards, a poetry writing contest, or even a riddle-solving contest.

There's more on page 38 to 42 on the laws and customs on The Silver Way, which reminds me, the Lunars are split into six (almost entirely co-operative and amicable) factions, one of which we are going to be indoctrinated.
>>
No. 57610 ID: e7e90d

Wait, the tattoos are explicitly defined as a language? That means Saulanna should be able to read them automatically, without even being taught, thanks to Wordblood.
>>
No. 57612 ID: dd287a

>>57608
Rescuers? are they going to rescue our intrepid raccoon girl from the castle that she actually sortof owns now?
>>
No. 57613 ID: e7e90d

>>57612
They don't know that, and we kind of don't want to let them know that either. It's suspicious, and raises the kind of questions we don't want asked.

The trick is going to be hiding the full truth from them, while convincing them we don't need to be rescued from the death lands and death hero.
>>
No. 57614 ID: dd287a

>>57613
Jus' saying, we should probably avoid unnecessary debts.
>>
No. 57663 ID: 431fa8

Been reading Manual of Exalted Power - Lunars. Informative, and highly useful information applicable to the current encounter based upon the apparent level of accuracy it's had so far. The traditions and social structures presented there obviously have to be taken with a hefty pinch of salt given the timeline we're working with, but at minimum it can guide us in what questions to ask to figure out how much of the metaknowledge still holds.

Anyway. Tangentially related to this, I was contemplating subsouls. Perhaps we could create a "Second Moon" subsoul, whose function is essentially to (eventually) let us treat the usual restrictions on our Moon Hero powers as laughably breakable guidelines. Caste powers dictated by the phase of the moon? Nah, let's have our internal Second Moon shift phase and will and key our current caste off that instead. Shapeshifting powers limited to things that we've eaten the hearts of? Not when our subsoul is on the job, pushing our powers beyond their limits and letting us shift into anything that we can imagine. Moonsilver tattoos keeping us static? No, our internal moon owns those things and can twist them into emulating any caste, history, or artifact it pleases on a whim just as easily as our body changes shape. The broken/lost castes, assuming they exist in this setting, would likely be accessible as well- or simply re-constructable. Bond with a Sun Hero? Hey, I bet that with the proper application of Titan's Will that can be shifted to a different Sun Hero, its emotions can be twisted into a different form, or the whole thing can be inverted so that the power rests with the Moon Hero instead.

While concealing our Titanic nature and thus the existence of this subsoul, we could use the evidence of our obviously superior Moon Powers to gain credibility amongst other Moon Heroes. Potentially, we could design Moon Abilities, spells, or artifacts which we claim are a result of our deep understanding of our own Moon Hero condition and its nature, and were developed to exploit that nature in ways which others have not. Talk a lot about soul mechanics and philosophy (the nature of the Moon Hero is one of true, endless change! All things are possible for one who knows and wishes to change themselves!) and we should be able to pass. Hopefully this excuse would let us gather Moon Hero followers to build a power base, or at least gain allies and respect, with the associated resources. As others learn the abilities that we teach them, we can (optionally) have those abilities secretly draw upon our Titanic powers, inherently bind those who use them to our will, corrupt their Hero Souls on our behalf, and generally otherwise prep things so that one way or another we'll be able to count on a serious Moon Hero base of support no matter what comes.

At high levels of Soul Force and development of its powers, which is to say "once the whole 'we are a Titan' thing has come out and it's time to seriously throw down", this subsoul would expand its abilities so that the light of the second moon shines down on every Moon Hero, not just Saulanna. At that point it can grant them the same sort of ridiculously amped Moon Hero powers it grants Saulanna- if it wants. Given that we've got Titan's Will to throw around, even curing or preventing chimerism in those it favors isn't out of the question. For those who are our enemies, it could abuse its ability to shift phase to repeatedly smack them with the first rays of the full moon, which is to say, pump them full of Limit and thereby drive them insane on a whim.

We might even be able to specifically craft this soul so that part of its nature is that Luna cannot detect or oppose it. That would probably require making it the Dark Moon or something, specifically designed so that it is present in places where Luna is not, and that its face is always present when hers is turned away. There are probably ways; we can figure them out.

This is a preliminary sketch at the moment, and could end up going either very well or very poorly, but ultimately I do think that it's within our abilities. With appropriate presentation, continual spin, constant discretion, and probably victories in a few serious social throwdowns, Saulanna can become first more powerful in the use of her Moon Hero abilities than any before her and then a secondary source for Moon Hero powers, ultimately culminating in hijacking many or all Moon Heroes as her own allies and/or servants.


Speaking of getting Hero allies and/or servants, need to work on making sure that Heroes who swear themselves to our service have the oaths apply both to themselves and to their Hero Souls, so that if they die both their ghost and the next Hero to use their Hero Soul will be reliably loyal to us.
>>
No. 57664 ID: 24f833

The moon-management soul to subvert and customize our Lunar powers as you describe is pretty interesting. It's worth exploring, and potentially way more useful than just fluid tattoos.

Stealing / Binding / whatever other Lunars' heros' souls seems a bit sketchy though. We do that, and we're essentially stealing them from Luna. She's our patron and potentially one of the few gods who might accept a new titan- a direct play against her like that seems pretty likely to piss her off.
>>
No. 57666 ID: 8e921b

Yeah, making a Second Moon soul (after Feeding Soul is producing regularly, of course) to enhance Moon Powers and manipulate tattoos sounds awesome. Being able to offer its benefits to other Moon Heroes, hypothetically, would be a nice bonus.

Using it to subjugate, trick, or enslave others? Not good. I'm opposed to it because I want Saulanna to be a better person than that. But it's also a dangerous thing because once Saulanna's Titan-ness comes out, powerful entities will take notice. Luna herself may take a keen interest in Saulanna. Her best bet to be accepted is to act in a way that Luna would approve of, or at least not disapprove.

Luckily, we have Moon Heroes who can suggest what that is, and can pray directly for direction. It isn't like Saulanna has a lot of goals or motivations that could conflict with whatever Luna wants, considering "Destroy All Titans" isn't going to be part of it.
>>
No. 57669 ID: a3b384

>>57663
That's... a lot of shenanigans. I'm not so familiar with exalted but I was hoping for something a little less confrontational, if possible. As a titan we can make any god follow our commands, that fact alone puts us at odds with all the gods and their heroes. So doing anything obvious is out of the question for now. First we need to see about keeping our titanic power hidden, and then we can explore our options.
>>
No. 57673 ID: 431fa8

>Stealing / Binding / whatever other Lunars' heros' souls seems a bit sketchy though.
>Using it to subjugate, trick, or enslave others? Not good.
>I was hoping for something a little less confrontational, if possible.
I should be clear here. The reason my plan there ended with "and that's how we can hijack all the Moon Heroes and turn them into slaves!" is because I am very concerned about the fact that every Hero is basically a Titan-murdering superweapon, and we're a helpless baby Titan. Because of that, in my view we need to take all feasible steps to ensure that as many Titan-killing superweapons as possible are friendly to us, whether that means actual alliance, swearing them into our service willingly/semi-willingly, or secretly corrupting/mind-controlling them into enslavement. Any that we cannot ensure work for us, we should be preparing measures to rapidly and effectively eliminate in the event that they oppose us.

Do I actually want to offend Luna? Of course not. She seems nice enough. But I do think that we need to be ready to go to war with Luna, if when we say "Hey Luna, can I be your newest Titan buddy?" she replies with "I KILL YOU!" It's highly unlikely but not completely out of the question that the gods will all send their Heroes notes that say "Hey, go kill Saulanna please, she's an abomination and I want her dead", bringing literally hundreds of Heroes down on our head. It's a worst-case scenario but not an unthinkable one.

So I see our future as something like this:
1. Stay subtle as long as possible, pretending to be a Moon Hero.
2. While acting as a Moon Hero, clandestinely move to war footing.
3. When we are inevitably revealed, try to be friends.
4a. Be friends with everyone, and never need to really use step 2.
4b. Everyone tries to kill us, and be very glad that we've got an army up our sleeve from step 2 that can beat them.
5. Saulanna lives happily ever after.
>>
No. 57674 ID: 9694e2

Okay, that analysis makes sense. It would be prudent for us to be prepared.

That said, we should be careful in how we set up (2). We don't want to gear up in such a way that we make (4b) a more likely outcome. That's likely going to be a fine line to walk if we're subverting the gods' forces.
>>
No. 57682 ID: 3163d4

So it turns out I might not be updating for a while. I updated my OS and apparently the version of photoshop I was using isn't supported any more. :/

Hopefully I'll have a solution as soon as possible.
>>
No. 57683 ID: a3b384

>>57673
I get the feeling that if we want a happy ending, we'll have to alter the rules of reality. Perhaps something that frees the titans but removes them as a threat by removing that whole "tell the gods what to do" thing. I dunno, just random guessing at what might be possible.
>>
No. 57694 ID: e3aff6

>>57683
We probably wouldn't want to free the titans, as by now many of them are incredibly pissed and/or insane, but giving them a final death as opposed to their current eternal suffering would be nice. (I think that in itself would need considerable changes to the rules of reality to accomplish, which is why the gods didn't do it to begin with.)
>>
No. 57696 ID: 08a77c

>>57694
On the other hand, I can imagine that once Saulanna learns of the fate of the surrendered Titans, she might be a tad angry at the Gods. It was pretty fucked up, and reduced some of the mightiest, most amazing (if limited in scope) beings to crippled, traumatized madmen. Hell, just what happened to the greatest of them, The Holy Tyrant is very depressing. He'd welcome death, even if he'd fight it with ferocity. All encompassing hatred and self-loathing does that.
>>
No. 57698 ID: 431fa8

>>57696
She already knows the fate of the surrendered Titans. Perhaps not the particulars of how each one changed, but see >>/questarch/207447; Peregrin gave a pretty decent overview.

Anyway, my understanding is that it is possible to both "fix" and free the Yozis (and thus presumably the fallen Titans, since metaknowledge seems to hold) by having their Infernals (Hell Heroes) invent new charms, which will be automatically learned by their associated Yozi and can contain behavior-altering mandates, by selectively killing or modifying certain subsouls which embody undesirable traits (which is basically what the gods did in the first place), and then finally using one of the Infernal charms which already exists that allows any binding, including the ones which bind the Yozis, to be broken when the ability is used at Essence 10.

I don't know that "fix the Titans and then free them from Hell" is actually our objective here, since it would be something which puts us way more at odds with everything else in Creation than any other path I can think of other than freeing the Titans without modifying their personalities first, but it's not impossible. Just very, very hard and it would require dealing with numerous ridiculously scary people and beings.
>>
No. 57701 ID: c5f587

The problem with a moon soul is the risk that upon eventually straight up being a titan it would make us a moon titan, and while Luna may or may not be willing to have a new titan show up, a new titan that is stealing her gig is a HELL of a lot less likely to meet her approval.
>>
No. 57702 ID: f03e5a

>>57682
I'm sorry to hear that Jukashi. Was the OS update required and what would be affected if you rolled back?
>>
No. 57710 ID: 256d52

>>57663

Oooooh, moon soul is a very clever idea!

>>57701

I imagine it'd be something a little like the Unconquered Sun and the Green Sun, the core soul of Malfeas (the Demon City). Lot of parallels, but they're clearly separate things.

Poor, poor Malfeas. The Solars turned the king into the kingdom. Can they even imagine how cruel that was?

(Yes. Yes they can.)
>>
No. 57718 ID: b9d767

>>57701
I don't think having a soul that is a moon would make us a Moon Titan specifically, but it would make the Moon a big part of our titanic themes. We are a Moon Hero after all, so it would be prudent to capitalize on it. And on Luna getting mad at us for stealing her gig, it's not like our hypothetical Moon Soul would be replacing her. And when the Incarnae eventually DO find out about us, there is one thing we can point out that is sure to win some respect: That we could have used the Primordial Geas on them at any time, but didn't.

Also, Luna is technically our Sister/Brother/Whatever-in-Law.
>>
No. 57720 ID: 7936fe

There is a Moon-Deva already, Ligier's "sister/Queen" the "Blood-Red Moon".
(Infernal Lunars are called Red-Moon Princesses)
>>
No. 57721 ID: 8a69ab

Please try not to use too much metaknowledge.
>>
No. 57722 ID: 842d23

I don't think the moon-soul idea as proposed would result in us becoming the titan of the moon or anything. We're not usurping Luna's domain- we're merely finding a creative way to harness and unlock the power she gave us. We're modding or hacking the skill tree, kind of the way Red Mage functioned. In a way, it's the same thing the tattoos do, just in a much more powerful and dynamic way. It grants us control instead of mere stability.

Us being considered competition by mere virtue of being Titanic is another matter.
>>
No. 57723 ID: 8a69ab
File 134343059025.png - (105.86KB , 500x500 , tabletproblems.png )
57723

As an update on the situation with the, er, updates, I managed to acquire a version of Photoshop that works with OSX 10.8, but now, as you can see, I seem to be having problems with the sensitivity on my tablet.

So, still no updates for a while.
>>
No. 57724 ID: bf54a8

i am imagining she is like NOT THE BEEES! and the dots are bees.
>>
No. 57725 ID: 431fa8

>>57723
In the meantime, could you give us some guidance on subsoul design? It seems like a fairly complex topic but there is overwhelming support for making a new subsoul in-thread as soon as we can get away with it, so we might as well learn the rules for it now and argue it over in advance in the discussion thread, like with power words.
>>
No. 57726 ID: 8a69ab

>>57725

Thing about that is, I was actually anticipating doing an update (or a "side update" in this thread like >>57222 ) where Wordblood talks about souls and how Titans and Devas work, for the benefit of non-Exalted players as well as to help with decisions on how Saulanna should develop. But that, of course, requires an image...

In any case, perhaps it would be a good idea to refrain from talking about long-term soul formation plans until after you get an experience with producing one. Who knows what surprises might be in store?

(it's me)
>>
No. 57727 ID: 431fa8

>>57726
>In any case, perhaps it would be a good idea to refrain from talking about long-term soul formation plans until after you get an experience with producing one. Who knows what surprises might be in store?
With all due respect, that's one of the most interesting topics we've got to discuss at the moment and it's vitally important to our future plans, so at least my perspective the difference is mostly between talking about it while uninformed and operating off metaknowledge that I'm basically yanking out of the Lunar, Infernals, and Malfeas books specifically for this quest, and talking about it after having been briefed on the in-quest rules and thus having a solid grasp of how things work.

I doubt that the "forge ahead blindly" option would result in something so inaccurate that it would take more than a bit of patching to fix up, anyway- thus far I'd say that metaknowledge outside the mechanics and specific charms has proven to be about 95% correct, so there's no real reason not to keep working off it and our own guesswork in the absence of more useful data.

And even if you skip the art or do a cheap edit of a previous image for your planned mechanics dump we're certainly not going to complain about it.
>>
No. 57728 ID: 842d23

We can speculate and plan all you want, man. There's no need to try and rush him to push the story ahead of time. :p

Besides, we're almost certainly going to have to make the feeder-soul first. Setting up our power grid, future energy production, managing the resources we have... that's fundamental. You gotta have a working economy before you can tech up and build any kind of strategy dependent on it. You can't skip industrial build up, and try to Zerg rush with high tech options- it just doesn't work (I realize I'm using the analogy of 4X mechanics, but I don't see a better way to explain it).

Good luck with the computer troubles, J.
>>
No. 57729 ID: 8e921b

Come on, what can Wordblood or Jukashi say about soul-creation that would deter us at this point?

Heck, I want to see these surprises.
>>
No. 57732 ID: 8a69ab

All right, I'll give you a little something. For a start, though, I'll say that Saulanna's way of growing souls is supposed to be a little bit mysterious. No other Titans grew this way, they all appeared fully-formed out of the Wyld; part of the fun is supposed to be finding out how this process works, or at least being interestingly intrigued by the mystery of how it works. Also, perhaps there are other methods of acquiring souls than just making them yourself? This is part of the quest.

But anyway. I can tell you some about mechanics.

Let's use the example of a Feeding Soul based on knowledge. Or, rather, Knowledge, with the capital letter. Such a soul will align itself spiritually with the overall concept of Knowledge, and have an affinity for creatures and individuals who themselves are invested in the concept of Knowledge. A Knowledge-based feeding deva will gain extra Titan's Will (depending on its level of TW generation ability) when Saulanna learns significant things, when she is in places of Knowledge or learning, and in general when the "essence" of Knowledge is ascendant; if everyone in the world is, in general, acquiring and teaching and maintaining Knowledge, the Knowledge deva will become stronger. The converse of these things is true also: if Knowledge is being lost, with rises in ignorance or deception and so on, it will become weaker, and its ability to generate TW and magic will be reduced with exposure to high levels of such things. The Soul will develop powers related to Knowledge, and will have an attitude disposed towards learning and teaching.

Basically, there are two elements to Titan soul, a deva, as I've formulated it for the purposes of Lunar Quest. First, its Purpose, and second its Element. Wordblood's element is Communication, and his Purpose would be something like "assistance". You could even make it a fanciful title, something like "He Who Aids In Understanding". Hence, his powers are focused mostly on supporting others, and on facilitating understanding. Other powers close to those themes are also available to him, along with a few more generic spirit abilities. The Feeding soul's Purpose will be acquiring TW and magical energy, and choosing its Element will decide how it goes about that best: they'll become something like "He/She/That Which Feeds On [X]", or possibly "Feeds By Using [X]". In time, higher souls like these will make their own sub-souls, which will have their own Purposes and have Elements that are sub-elements or related elements to their parent.

If you want another analogy, getting a Feeding Soul is like Saulanna developing a titanic digestive system, and choosing its Element will be deciding what her preferred diet is or, for that matter, if she foregoes eating for photosynthesis or something. Metaphorically.
>>
No. 57737 ID: a3b384

>>57732
I was thinking we could get a make single soul that could handle hiding our titanic power, scrying and communicating. I guess it's element would be Secrets? And a purpose of... I dunno. Deception? Protection? Hiding? Might those work?
>>
No. 57738 ID: 431fa8

>>57732
Hmm. The Purpose/Element concept is similar to the essential design elements that I was thinking we'd have to use, although it's more free-form; I was thinking that instead of merely stating whatever kind of purpose we want, we'd choose part of Saulanna's personality that the deva is meant to draw upon and exemplify, and then everything it would be ultimately derived from that with some input from us on what powers it is meant to use to express that personality trait. This isn't terribly dissimilar, but it does mean that the devas are significantly less tied to Saulanna than I expected.

The key devas that I've been thinking we'll need are the Feeding Soul (exemplifying Saulanna's desire to learn and grow), Second Moon (exemplifying Saulanna's desire to push past accepted limits to become whatever she can dream of being), and what I'm currently calling an Ambush Soul (exemplifying Saulanna's desire to keep her secrets hidden until the time comes to use them to best effect). Adapting them to this system might be tricky, depending upon how much control we have over how the devas express their Purpose and Element.
>>
No. 57741 ID: 842d23

Okay, if I'm understanding how this would work then...

>>57737
Communication, scrying, and hiding your own secrets could all fall under Knowledge. Or in more modern parlance, Intelligence. Everything intelligence gathering organizations do is essentially passing, acquiring, or concealing knowledge in some form or another.

We can probably simplify the problem by leaving communication to Wordblood- it's his element, and he's already indicated he'll be able to offer us means to communicate with mortal minds when he's upgraded.

That leaves the spy stuff. Seeking secrets, and hiding our nature. That's... either controlling information, or managing secrets (secrets and information are basically the same thing- one's just kind of the opposite of the other).

Information/Secrets would be the element, I think. Something like management/Control over/Archivist of etc. would be the purpose. You want to word it so it works for both concealment and acquisition- He or She Who Decides Who Has Access to Information or Secrets, basically. They grant that access to us, and deny it to others, as necessary.
>>
No. 57742 ID: f03e5a

>>57723
I'M COVERED IN BEES!
>>
No. 57743 ID: bf54a8

it's not her fault bees think scellor smell like giant flowers stuffed to the gills with nectar.
>>
No. 57758 ID: d0b1e7

>>57738
>I was thinking that instead of merely stating whatever kind of purpose we want, we'd choose part of Saulanna's personality

You can still do that, though a better way to describe it would be parts of her identity, rather than personality. Almost anything can be an Element, and things like Knowledge and Secrecy are already part of who she is; so, for that matter, are things like Hunger, Compassion, Anger, Mortality, Femininity, Blood, Sight, the Lost, Life, et cetera et cetera and so on.

Picking Elements related to the "human condition" will keep her more human, but her powers will be limited and specialized along those lines. Picking more fanciful Elements will move her more away from a mortal perspective, but give her better opportunity to collect a variety of abilities.
>>
No. 57771 ID: 67e8b2

Hey. If we give her a Feeding Soul, would it be a character? Could we give him/her/it a name like "Eaty McNoms"?
>>
No. 57773 ID: 842d23

>>57771
Yeah, that's the impression I got, although it sounds like there might be an incubation period before it's up and talking. We might be able to do more than just name it- I'm thinking we can design it's very personality to suit our purposes.

The interesting question is what element we chose for our feeder. We want something that will be passive- that will give us as much power as possible without having to eat actual souls or even do anything. We also as much as possible want to avoid a relevant double edge, if possible.

I'd like to suggest Time as a potential feeder element. This would suggest our feeder gets what it needs quite easily, as time passes. As it grows stronger, this might also have interesting uses- devouring time directly ahead of us to skip past things, or immobilizing / destroying opponents by eating their time out from around them. Possibly opens up balefire type exploits- we target/eat past events, and then they never happened and the timeline is forced to readjust.

Obvious possible downsides include becoming the time devourer and consuming reality, or that eating time as it goes by means the past ceases to exist, so no one will ever get to do any time travel.

We don't ever lack for food unless we're somehow transported to a place where time doesn't work / exist. (Which is possible in a setting like this, I suppose).
>>
No. 57774 ID: bf54a8

no, don't cut ourself off from something. may not LIKE eating souls, but don't make it hard to do so.
>>
No. 57775 ID: 842d23

>>57774
Oh, I agree. Passive power generation is nice, but we should be able to eat souls if we need to. But Wordblood is already able to do that, despite that not having anything to do with his element or purpose. I'd assume the feeder would still be able to eat souls regardless of its element.

More predatory elements would just be better at it, I assume. With a feeder of souls as the restricted, carnivorous extreme.

For something like the suggested Time feeder, I'd assume we'd get more from souls the older they were.
>>
No. 57779 ID: d0b1e7

>>57771

Yes indeed.
>>
No. 57782 ID: 431fa8

Thoughts on the Feeding Soul:

How about we tweak its purpose to the somewhat broader to acquire power? Titan's Will and magic are the most obviously accessible means of doing that at the moment, but they are far from the only possible ones. The deva is meant to give us the strength we need to accomplish our goals, and for that purpose we should not restrict its methods.

Of course, with any deva whose purpose is something like that- even if we just left it at "acquire TW and magic", in fact- we have the rather nasty problem that it would be likely to run wild with it. Just as we were previously concerned that Saulanna would become a world-devouring monster going wild on the high of eating souls, there's the concern that we would be constantly in the position of needing to restrain our Feeding Soul's impulses. That is obviously undesirable.

For that reason, I would suggest that we give the Feeding Soul a counterbalancing Element, based upon a personality trait which we want the Feeding Soul to bring out in its actions. An element like Discipline, Forethought, or Wisdom would have many potentially useful magical applications and more importantly would eliminate the potential problem of having a rampant all-devourer on our hands by replacing it with something that literally embodies the dedicated servant, insightful savant, or wise sage. It would also be likely to bring out such desirable personality traits in Saulanna, which is a handy bonus.
>>
No. 57785 ID: d0b1e7

>>57782

Er. You know, in a sense, every single one of your souls' purposes will be about "acquiring power". A war soul would be about getting the power to fight, a stealth soul about getting the power to hide, and so on. Salanna's reason for growing ANY new souls is to acquire power, of some sort or another. So I don't know if you can make it that broad.

Also, I know balance isn't exactly a priority in Lunar Quest, but I'm going to come out and say that in general, the broader you go, the weaker you'll be in specifics; and, the more specialized you go, the stronger you'll be within said specialization.

Devas will also be somewhat possessive. Once you've made one, you can't make another that's too "close" to it without it being a sub-soul of the first one, particularly in regards Element. You couldn't have, for example, a Knowledge Feeding Soul and a Learning Feeding Soul, and you couldn't have a Learning Feeding Soul and a Growth Feeding Soul. Either Knowledge or Growth Feeding Souls could have a Learning-based subsoul. You could possibly have a Knowledge and a Growth Feeding Souls together, but they would probably keep trying to eat each other. If you had a Growth Feeding Soul and a Knowledge, say, Sensing Soul, they'd get along fine.

That's sort of vague, but I hope you get what I'm trying to say?
>>
No. 57787 ID: 431fa8

>>57785
>A war soul would be about getting the power to fight, a stealth soul about getting the power to hide, and so on.
That's... I'll try to explain what I meant better. The purpose of almost all our devas is going to be to use power, not to acquire it. We make them in order to build up our abilities in specific fields, yes, but the real purpose of the deva is to put its abilities to use after it grows into them. We make a war soul so that we're more able to fight, but its purpose isn't to acquire the power to fight- it purpose is to excel in the actual fighting.

The Feeding Soul is unique in that its purpose isn't to use power at all, but rather to give power to Saulanna and her other souls, so that they have it to use. Does that make sense? Its purpose is to extract, harvest, grow, or otherwise get its hands on power in whatever form, maybe to refine that power into more useful types and keep track of it, but distinctly not to put that power to use. It is the living resource pipeline, so that when we order someone else to get something done they can rely on being able to do so instead of worrying about the cost and logistics.

Maybe that's still too broad to be effective in your opinion, I don't know. Maybe "provide power" or "acquire and provide power" would be a better expression of what I'm shooting for.
>>
No. 57790 ID: c8d934

>>57787

In that case, I'm not sure what difference you're going for. The acquire-power soul will be acquiring... what, exactly? Money? Political connections? Steam?
>>
No. 57791 ID: 842d23

I think you're trying to combine our digestive track with, well, the complete act of hunting for food. And they're supposed to be separate. The feeder soul is meant to be an organ (or system) that digests and manages energy, not the whole predator.

Not that we couldn't have other organs to help us find power/food. I believe that was the appeal of scrying.

...and since there's been no authorial vetoing on it's impossibility, I'll take that to mean time is a viable potential element. =D
>>
No. 57792 ID: b9d767
File 134352850607.jpg - (81.24KB , 340x407 , The Infinite Library.jpg )
57792

>>57787
I think it was already discussed earlier what our Feeding Soul was going to be like. It would take the form of an internal geographical location, a library to be specific. Associations of knowledge, learning, and memory were what was tossed about.
>>
No. 57794 ID: b9d767

>>57791
I think you have a valid point here. Just because it's going to be our feeding soul doesnt neccesarily mean it's going to be doing the eating. The actual act of predation should probably be in the hypothetical Moon Soul idea talked about earlier. It would also mean that anything regarding the Heart's Blood for new forms would be associated with that soul, instead of our feeding one.
>>
No. 57798 ID: 431fa8

>>57791
>I think you're trying to combine our digestive track with, well, the complete act of hunting for food. And they're supposed to be separate.
Are they, though? A Yozi's third circle soul is a spectacularly powerful being, as strong or stronger than even the greatest of First Age Exalts. Admittedly that may or may not also be the case here with Titans and their devas, but I'm inclined to say that it is.

Given that, is it really reasonable to say that the same deva can't be responsible for basically everything involved in, to use your example, turning random animals into usable calories? Yes, it's a difficult and complex task to conduct on a Titanic scale- but we're not talking about some piddly mortal here. This is a deva, which even taken separately from Saulanna will have the potential to be one of the top few thousand beings ever. It's not stupid, it's not weak, and it is fully capable of handling a complex, nuanced, and difficult task even on a scale that will potentially encompass literal worlds.

My expectation (which could admittedly be wrong) is that we aren't going to have hundreds of devas; at most we're likely to top out at a couple dozen. Each of them has only a single Purpose. If we try to express everything important that Saulanna wants or needs to do in a list of twenty-five Purposes, they will have to be fairly broad.

>>57790
>The acquire-power soul will be acquiring... what, exactly? Money? Political connections? Steam?
Titan's Will, magic, money, allies, secrets, armies... anything which, when Saulanna says "I need X to happen", lets it reply with "Here, [resource] has been gathered and can be drawn on for accomplishing that". I've been envisioning a being which would spend its life compulsively organizing the build-up of stockpiles of things that it thinks we're likely to need at some point. And for subsouls, like the example of the Knowledge soul having a Learning subsoul (which is basically a specific way of manipulating knowledge), this one would probably divide out its subsouls based upon kind of power or method of acquisition- so an Acquire Magical Power subsoul, a Build Armies subsoul, a Learn Others' Secrets subsoul, and so forth.

Even on the "1/25th of everything Saulanna will need to do" scale this purpose might be too broad in scope, though, so it wouldn't be unreasonable to pare it down a bit. There is a fine line between acquiring and using resources in some spheres of activity, and we don't want devas who are constantly at each others' throats... plus there's the specialization-as-power bit. I just can't help but think that "acquire TW and magical energy" is such a... small scope of purpose for a being of this power. It's a very important purpose, and we desperately need it to be done, but...

Well, whatever. Even if we end up using that as its Purpose it won't hurt us; any deva is useful, after all, and at least it'll be very, very good at what it does.
>>
No. 57799 ID: c8d934

>I just can't help but think that "acquire TW and magical energy" is such a... small scope of purpose for a being of this power.

I feel compelled to remind you that these are resources which a) are acquired by devouring souls and/or suckling off the teats of the underpinning concepts of reality, and b) are used to shape reality to your whim.

Really, though, you have to consider the scope of what you're suggesting. Things like money, armies, allies, secrets... how are these things acquired? Talking to people, making deals, greasing palms, giving inspiring speeches, are these things you want to delegate, to happen automatically? How are they supposed to be given to others to use? What sort of creature does all those things, and how does it do them while leaving space for anyone else to need do anything? How, for that matter, is it it supposed to do them from inside Saulanna's internal world? Saulanna's pretty far from the ability to let her souls out, much less on any long-term basis.

Consider, as well, the Titanic perspective. Our default assumption, just the plain Feeding Soul concept, is a being that generates the ability to shape reality. Money? A dot of Titan's Will can turn a cliffside to diamond. Armies? Titans make their own armies, out of themselves, if they don't just obviate the need for an army by breathing nuclear lasers at their enemies. Want Secrets? Upgrade Wordblood so that he can pull them out of people's heads. Almost anything except Titan's Will and magic is too small, I'd say.

In any case: Don't get too attached to the notion you'll have 100% control over how this thing forms.
>>
No. 57800 ID: b9d767

>>57798
Remember, a Titan's souls aren't just what they DO, but representations of the Titan's feelings, emotions, and attitudes. What about the Titan Saulanna will "aquire resources" represent? This is why a Library would be an ideal form for such a soul to take. My reasoning for this is because a Library is a place for things (mostly tomes, but other things too) to be collected. It also fits into the Titanic themes we so far express.
>>
No. 57801 ID: 842d23

The point I'm trying to make is the feeder is supposed to handle internal functions. Management, banking, refinement, processing, generation, etc of energy. Hunting, searching, acquisition... that's external. I don't think it can be both at once. And I'm pretty sure all internal energy regulation and processing is good enough for 1/25 of her. Biological systems spend waaaay more than that fraction of themselves on it.

Also, if it can be completely autonomous, there's no point for Saulanna.

But, this is stupid. I don't really think we should be bogged down discussing the minute semantics of what "feeder" means so we can exploit it as much as possible. It means what it's going to mean.

We should be trying to figure out an adventurous element to pair with the feeder. I'd love to hear some more suggestions, or feedback on using Time.

There has been discussion of a soul with a moon element, but I don't think we want a "feeder of the moon". That doubles down on our existing strengths and weakness- as the feeding would likely wane and wax with the moon. We want a "manipulator" of the moon, or something, so we can adjust/hack our powers, tattoos, etc.
>>
No. 57803 ID: b9d767

>>57801
I don't ever think it was proposed that the Feeder Soul would be the Moon Soul. And as for a soul relating to Time and time-based things, I don't think that would exactly work as-is. Or rather, I don't think Time fits in with our capabilities and powers as a Titan. If perhaps we can find a way that Time would "branch off" of our titanic capabilities as a Titan of words then I think it would be an awesome idea. Or do you rather think that "time" would be the general theme of that one soul, and not a power of the greater self?
>>
No. 57804 ID: 431fa8

>>57799
>Consider, as well, the Titanic perspective.
If we're going to get all "Think about what Titan's Will can do!" about it, we might as well chop everything except generating more and more of it out of the thing's purpose to make it a stupidly effective power plant, then declare all of reality the nail to our hammer. In a case like this that could actually work, because with enough Titan's Will at our disposal literally all other factors fade into total irrelevance. Heck, we could break "self-generating Titan's Will" and "absorbing Titan's Will from other things" into two separate devas to eliminate overlap and improve efficiency, thereby giving us a greater ammo supply for our solve-everything gun.

Your point is well taken, however.

>>57800
I don't have any issue with libraries, but I'm kind of expecting the deva to take whatever form it finds most suited to its initially defined Purpose, Element, and personality. On the other hand, there's nothing about Wordblood's defining features that says "dragon", so who knows.

>>57801
>We should be trying to figure out an adventurous element to pair with the feeder. I'd love to hear some more suggestions, or feedback on using Time.
I'm not a fan of Time- or any wholly abstract elements, really. At least for the first few souls I think Saulanna should avoid Elements which would move her toward significant separation from the mortal perspective. Basically any Element that's more about the structure of reality- Time, Fate, Space, Matter, that sort of thing- than about something that humans possess as a quality or use as a tool is likely to do that. For that reason, I'm inclined to go with a desirable personality trait which will hopefully shape the Feeding Soul's actions into ones we find desirable and which will provide Saulanna with beneficial personality changes, as I mentioned at the end of >>57782.

For now, at least, Saulanna is operating on the scale of humans and Exalts, so her Elements should be things which are tied to that scale. As she grows in power enough that she operates on the scale of greater beings and can influence reality on a large scale, then she should start building souls with Elements that are useful for operation on those scales.

Also, a note on time in particular; by my understanding time in Exalted basically exists because there's an existing being in place actively maintaining the concept of linear time and causality as a thing. If you go out into the chaos of the Wyld, there's no longer any such thing in place and any being of sufficient power can basically take utterly nonlinear actions and edit both the past and future at will. So making time an Element would be essentially tying our deva to the being that makes time work like we think it's supposed to work.

Of course, the same can be said of many or even most things in the setting, I suppose, so this might not be worth caring about. Might not even be a thing in the quest edition we're working in here.

>...I don't think we want a "feeder of the moon".
Obviously not. That concept is entirely separate, and the stealth soul is a third one. There's also the issue of how to make the moon soul work at all without tying it to Luna, since obviously she'd notice, and without somehow making its existence dependent upon her- we don't want to get into a situation where Luna dies or leaves reality and our deva dies/has an existential crisis/can't function because of it.
>>
No. 57805 ID: 842d23

No, no one one had suggested feeder + moon together. I was just making the point those are really the only purpose / element we've discussed, and they don't fit together.

I was thinking a feeder of time means well, we eat time. Like a whale, drifting along the river of time, eating moments of plankton. As long as there's time, there's a power source. And when we upgrade the soul, we gain the option to move from passive feeding to aggressive devouring or damaging specific swaths of time to do interesting and useful things (blink ahead of attacks, haste/time dilating, slowing, freezing, removing past events, etc).

I'm open to other elements to use for our means / basis of feeding, but what I like about time is it neatly sidesteps a weakness. A feeder of <foo> is weaker when <foo> is unavailable , or when we or our environment is contrary to <foo>. (Dumb examples: feeder of fire needs a source a fire. Feeder of cleverness would be hurt by stupidity). Time is always available, and hard to counteract. (Unless there's a timeless void or something in the Exalted setting we could be tossed into).

We're not restricted to be the titan of words, I think. We become what we make ourselves. Wordblood was once part of him, but now he's a part of us. We can still do all kinds of interesting communication and word based things when we upgrade him, I'm sure.
>>
No. 57807 ID: b0abc8

So people are talking about manipulating the tattoos and potentially other lunars by mimicking the moon powers with a moon-based soul. What if we approach it from the other end and make a mimicry-based soul?

>I'm open to other elements to use for our means / basis of feeding, but what I like about time is it neatly sidesteps a weakness.
The Siderials already specialize with screwing with time, so they could probably counter time tricks we use. They also already have a bit of of a habit of killing off beings who they feel are growing too powerful (such as most of the solars at one point).
>>
No. 57812 ID: 1da170

A Feeder Soul of Knowledge would possibly get weaker if the underlying element of Knowledge were weakened in the world, and would be stronger in places of great Knowledge.

So this is incentivizing us (and by extension, it) to spread knowledge and fight ignorance in the world and hang around places of great learning. Presumably it would also have powers related to Knowledge the same way Wordblood has powers related to Communication.

Is any of this a bad thing? We like to hang out in libraries, fighting ignorance sounds like a worthy endeavor and our current resources strongly support both.

I would guess that a Time-based soul would give the same TW and be the same strength pretty much regardless of everything else - but its TW-generation and its powers would be weaker as a result.

Besides, for the Time element we need a Lord-Soul of Time. Or a Knight-Soul of Time. =P
>>
No. 57815 ID: 7936fe

Think carefully about the form a new soul would take and how others would react to it.
(I'm mostly worried about the reaction of Orabilis to our "Library-Soul" considering that they would have almost opposite motivations.)
>>
No. 57818 ID: 842d23

>Worried about what <foo> would think
I don't think we'll get anywhere by consciously trying to avoid stepping on the flavor of other entities (Siderials, Orabilis, or whoever). It's not like everyone is going to magically welcome us with open arms if we manage to cast ourselves as the Titan of something new that doesn't encroach on anyone's turf.

Existing power players are going to oppose us simply because of what we are, our potential power, and the threat we may pose to themselves, or the existing order.

>Feeder of knowledge
I would think a feeder of Knowledge would have to eat information. So we'd be at our best when we were learning new things, and at a disadvantage when we can't. I dislike that weakness- that's a double edge. Whenever we're caught off guard, or away from our resources, libraries, etc, we'll be even weaker for it.

Potentially, eating knowledge also means denying it to others (like Wordblood's book feeding/reading). If you want to grow by increasing the stores of knowledge in the world at large... that seems more like a feeder of Education or Teaching. We grow stronger as we better the world, and those around us. But again, there's a double edge- something starts destroying our works, or our students, and we end up all the weaker for it. Heck, we might be weaker if we're just caught away from anyone we can better.

I really do think the trick here is to come up with an element that doesn't make ambush or being cut off from our power base and/or allies even worse. Situations like that will crop up eventually, and we'll need to be strong when they do.

>Time critiscm
I don't see one group being able to counter time attacks as being an major problem. We do have other powers. If we attract Siderial attention early though, yes, that could be bad. We want to remain hidden as long as possible while we grow.

The wyld being timeless or outside of time would seem to be the more obvious weakness if we're ever caught out there. potentially that would make us cut off. Or maybe we'd be stronger because it's more malleable? I don't really understand how that would work.

>Personalty trait as an element
One problem I have with this is there's an obvious weakness to this. All personalty traits have an opposite. If we draw strength from kindness, we're weak to hate, etc.

The other thing is the question of if we need to do this at all. Shaping Saulanna's personality is kind of something we're supposed to do ourselves, through our guidance. I wonder if we really need an internal extra check on that kind of thing. It could be handy, yes, but if we don't need it, there's a heavy opportunity cost of not choosing something more dynamic.
>>
No. 57832 ID: b0abc8

>Potentially, eating knowledge also means denying it to others (like Wordblood's book feeding/reading). If you want to grow by increasing the stores of knowledge in the world at large... that seems more like a feeder of Education or Teaching
Titan souls are closer to embodiments of their theme than eaters of it. For example, the text Wordblood 'eats' is already connected to him, but he gets more immediate value from it by drawing it into himself.

>One problem I have with this is there's an obvious weakness to this. All personalty traits have an opposite. If we draw strength from kindness, we're weak to hate, etc.
I don't think quite as much of a weakness as you are implying. We would be vulnerable to our opposite, but they would be equally vulnerable to us by the same principle, so they would be more of a rival than kryptonite.

Also, actively attempting to have no weaknesses rather than having manageable ones is just tempting fate (if only because it would be kind of boring if you actually succeeded without some kind of horrible price).


On an unrelated thought, do Power Words need to be spoken to be cast, or could we write one down to act like a stored-spell scroll?
>>
No. 57834 ID: bf54a8

spoken of course. seems the way it works is you say it SO FORCEFULLY that reality itself complies to your demand.
>>
No. 57907 ID: 8e921b

Jukashi, can you please clarify if a Feeding Soul would feed by devouring its Element (thus removing it from the world) or by sucking up ambient Essence (and doing it more easily when its Element is stronger) ?

And can we shape its personality beyond just specifying its Element? Can it be a Feeder Soul with a Knowledge Element, a purpose of "aquiring Titan's Will and magical power/energy" and a personality of "Disciplined, Wise" ?
>>
No. 57911 ID: 68f8e8

>>57907

The interaction between Purpose and Element is ambiguous. As I said, it might be "Feeds on X", but it might also be "Feeds by using X" or "Feeds by spreading X". Or something else. Or several things. It can also have Purpose powers completely separate from its Element, such as generic feeding on essence and souls, and can have Element powers separate from its Purpose.

Its precise appearance and personality are among the areas where the process will be more mysterious. They should have a lot to do with the Purpose and Element, but Saulanna's actions and motivations, and the overarching "themes" that have become evident in her story, will also be a significant influence, as well as secret factors that the players are not yet aware of. So the answer to "can we shape its personality beyond just specifying its Element?" is "You already have".

I spent about an hour writing more about why I'm doing things this way, but really, it's like explaining a joke. If it turns out that I needed to explain then I was never doing it right to begin with.
>>
No. 57924 ID: c1a7db

Hmm. That makes intelligent selection of an element difficult at best.

You have no way of knowing ahead of time if your feeder of pie means you get a glutton, a baker, or a clown.

Do we have any way to predict how purpose / element combinations will react ahead of time? Or is it just intent that matters- ie, we get what we expect, regardless of the ambiguity?
>>
No. 57928 ID: 68f8e8

>>57924

Perhaps you will get a baker clown with an appetite? Consider, simplified for the purpose of explanation, that a soul is basically "made of" its element. Similarly, you are made of meat. Thus, you can eat meat! You also use your meat to eat. And, if you eat, you can make more meat. You are a meat creature. It would not be inaccurate to think of a titanic soul in those terms, though - like with humans - there is a lot of complexity added on top of this basic nature.

As for personality control, you're beginning to edge up against how much I'm willing to explain (this is supposed to be mysterious and magical and all that junk, you know?), but there is a certain commonsense element involved. Wordblood, for example, as an Aide, is naturally helpful; being based on Communication, he is well-spoken and understanding, and can get upset when he doesn't understand things. Being an Aide and a Communicator, he is prone to provide assistance by explaining things and offering insights. Something similar will apply to any deva.

If you're looking to find the magic pattern that gives you all the bonuses with no flaws, it's not going to happen. What fun would that be, anyway? But I'll guarantee you that any soul Saulanna makes will be an advantage to her, overall.
>>
No. 57929 ID: c1a7db

Hm. Thanks. That's a more helpful explanation. It's possible then that there will be interesting choices in the soul's function post-creation.

>you don't get no bonuses and all flaws
No, course not. The whole challenge is in trying to find a bonus we can exploit or leverage well, and flaw we can minimize, or at least predict or compensate for.

...gonna take some more thought though on what would do that well. I'm almost glad the quest is slowed now, gives me time to think.
>>
No. 57947 ID: bf54a8

or, just maybe, you can have some fun and not min-max?
>>
No. 57948 ID: dd287a

Fun is good, Personally I don't see why our intrepid heroine should be a power house, she seems to be doing good so far at this social combat wotsit, perhaps someday we will achieve victory through the careful application of big watery eyes... or you know, Rational and carefully worded conversation.

So far we seem to be a bit of a jack of all trades at the moment, barring advance knowledge of how to do terrible terrible things to people.
>>
No. 57953 ID: a3b384

My only real issue is that we have an endless wealth of options here, and our immediate needs aren't pushing us in any clear direction. We know we need a feeding soul, and something to mask our growing titanic will. So let's focus on those two and see what elements and purposes work for them.

>Feeding soul
This is intended to help us consume Human souls, so why not make its element Humanity? And if human related elements will keep our personality less strange, than humanity itself should be the most effective element. As for purpose, we want it to strengthen us so Empowerment seems viable. It may result in greater buff granting powers as well, which certainly can't hurt. Empowering others is also possible.

>Masking soul
This is a good opportunity to create a soul of an opposing nature to Wordbloods. Thing is, we should be careful of making it too negative of an aspect, or we may go from balancing ourselves to outright corruption. For this I suggest an element of Deception, with a purpose of Protection. Might lead to powers of illusion.

Character wise the feeder should be female (as to reaffirm our gender identity as well as our humanity). A strong, kind and motherly personality seems ideal. The deception soul should be a ninja, because ninjas. Or whatever the exalted setting equivalent is. Probably male or ambiguous... But I suppose a Kunoichi type would be fine too. I'm not sure how much the gender matters, really.
>>
No. 57957 ID: fa9f7e

>>57953
Sidereals are pretty much fate ninja.
>>
No. 57960 ID: c1a7db

>fun, not min-max
I've got nothing against fun! In my mind, min-maxing is really only a bad thing when you put it above having fun. There's nothing unfun about just considering your build in advance though. We're as much choosing the race and build of our newest character as we are messing with Saulanna's stats here.

>Feeder of humanity
A feeder of humanity... is interesting. That potentially opens us up to resources from eating, creating, being around, and/or interacting with humanity. Or exercising our own.

Disadvantage- it probably becomes weaker as we become less human and more titanic (when we're exposed and will need power to defend ourselves!). It also probably means we'll be penalized drawing from non-human energy sources- for example, titan fragments.

Overall, I'd have to say it has interesting short and medium term pluses, but the negatives look potentially crippling in the long term.

>female feeder
Was this ever in doubt.
>>
No. 57963 ID: 6a1ec2

He who Feeds on Humans. Vampire element. We will call him mini-Peregrin.
>>
No. 57965 ID: 147853

I'm not sure how humanity could work...

I really like Knowledge actually, to go with Saulanna's natural disposition. The Feeding Soul grew out of part of her, it would be natural for it to share her inclinations. From a character perspective.

Alternatively, I like Civilization as a Feeding Soul aspect. Saulanna seems more the civilized sort, rather than barbaric. She would be perfect to start refining civilized creation.

We have to rememeber that Her soul is going to have as much impact on realitv over time as it will have on her titan's will.
>>
No. 57981 ID: a3b384

>>57960
Hmm... well, maybe we can take the focus from building power based on the human element to making things more human like. That way the source of the power would mean less, but the results themselves would have that affinity. Essentially it would be a soul that keeps itself, us and all of our other souls within that mortal perspective as its primary focus. With a purpose of empowerment it would grant stronger boons to humans because of its affinity and may even provide for a stronger advantage against things that are inherently inhuman. That all ignores my ease of consumption point of a human based element, but I doubt consuming human souls can be that all more difficult regardless.

>>57963
Yeah that's a focus we're better off veering away from.

>>57965
Civilization? Not bad, it makes for an interesting contrast with our wilder Lunar nature. But I think between a human element and Wordblood himself we favor the advancement of human society as a whole. And I don't see it being very useful as an element outside of that context, anyway.
>>
No. 57982 ID: c1a7db

>Knowledge
My biggest complaint with this element would be how close it is to Communication. They're not exactly the same, but there's a lot of places where attaining knowledge or communicating information could overlap. I'd rather see us diversify than take something so close to what we've already got.

If we're going to verbal diplomat fighter, gathering friends and building alliances, we could always go the cliched power of friendship route. Set the feeder to grow on friendship, or alliance, trust, ect. Then we get stronger with each new bond we make. (Obvious possible downsides: we're doubly weak when caught without allies, and we may have urges to eat friends or friendships).

...or Hell, we could always just give into our slutty Lunar side, make a feeder of sex, and go the succubus route. (Not seriously considering this at all).
>>
No. 57984 ID: 256d52

Feed on the Moon?

Synergy! (This is probably a terrible idea.)
>>
No. 57994 ID: ff2b77

Just to let everyone know, I've gotten a new tablet! So, once I've spent some time getting used to it, I should be able to resume updates soon.
>>
No. 57999 ID: a3b384

>>57994
JUBILATIONS
>>
No. 58002 ID: dcd945

Yay!
>>
No. 58012 ID: 8e921b

Yays!

Hmm, I hadn't thought about Knowledge being too close to Communication, but we certainly don't want souls to overlap and start fighting.

However, I think the soul should be designed to focus fairly narrowly on getting TW and magical energy, so it will be better at those things than if we made it a generalist. I think we should make it able to consume souls, but have it focus on generating TW from nowhere, so that it can improve that ability ASAP.

Civilization could be good, but... well what if the world has just a few pockets of civilization surrounded by thousands of miles of wilderness? That's a pretty big downside. Knowledge/data, on the other hand, is in everything that can be observed. You can always learn something from your surroundings, no matter where you are.
>>
No. 58013 ID: c1a7db

>>58012
Heeeey.

How about a feeder of Observation?

It's very close to the idea of a feeder of Knowledge, we're but we're feeding on the act of gathering instead of the knowledge / data itself. So it's the got kind of the same advantages you suggest (always some kind of observing to be done, and it's what we do all quest anyways).

But it has some other advantages, too. Feeding by observation could lead to some form of scrying. Feeding off observation could be used for stealth, or anti-scrying. Then there's the synergy with us (Saulanna's multitude of observers). There are a lot of interesting ways it can be used without overtly powergaming, and it doesn't overlap what we could do independently through communication through Wordblood. I like it.
>>
No. 58020 ID: ff2b77
File 134395546753.png - (120.92KB , 600x500 , titanexplanation.png )
58020

>"It's time I took a moment to explain how Titans function, particularly in regards the role played by their souls - or, for a less potentially confusing term, their devas."

>"First, we begin with a Titan's manifest form; how they appear "from the outside". Some of us, such as I, the Dragon's Shadow, and Oramus, appeared in draconic forms; other Titans have appeared variously as mechanical colossi, celestial phenomena, physical locations, enormous hovering spheres, and so on; the possibilities are endless, and we can change these forms with relative ease. In the case of my mistress, currently, this would be her human body. Some Titans also create an avatar, which they can project beyond themselves to interact with lesser beings more easily."

>"Second, we have the Titan's world-body, the totality of what they are "on the inside". Within themselves, a Titan may exist as an environment, such as a forest, a city, an ocean, a desert, a system of caverns... again, the variations are without limit, though each Titan will generally maintain an individual set of themes. I believe that my lady's inner world, where I reside, will eventually develop into her world-body, empty though it remains right now. Normally, a Titan keeps their world-body separated from the rest of existence, but with some effort we can turn ourselves "inside-out", becoming a "place" in the wider world."

>"Within the world-body are born and dwell a Titan's devas. To facilitate your understanding, I will compare their structure to one of your human kingdoms. To apply this metaphor, then, there are three broad classes of devas: Lords, Nobles and Commoners. At least, that's what a fully grown Titan will have; in our state, we have only me and she, my lady's own soul. We are both Lords, and as is natural for Lords, one of us is raised to the level of King - or, in this case, Queen. Though in a sense we are equals, the Queen bears the balance of power - her nature dominates and dictates the interactions of all other souls, and she forms the central nexus and root of our identity as a Titan. The other Lords are subservient to her. Each Lord, then - including the Queen - is progenitor of a House of Nobles, who in turn assert dominion over their Commoners. Each House, nobles and commoners included, are unified by their associations with their Lord's Element and Purpose - just as how, among humans, one noble family might invest their influence in, say, mining, while another will have more interests in, again for example, farming. Their commoners will follow those crafts and the crafts related to them, and their Nobles will have the knowledge and power to manage them. Currently, I and my mistress must do all the work ourselves, as much as we can; but as well as creating other Lords to do things we cannot do, in time we will create our own Noble devas to help us in our tasks, and they and we may create Common devas to act as agents and tools on an even lower level of delegation."

>"Each House, then, though they desire the overall well-being of the kingdom, will know their own needs, but perhaps not those of others. They may form rivalries and competitions, pushing against each other for influence and resources. They will lack the "big picture", which is the responsibility of the Queen. If the Queen should die, a new Queen will usually be raised from her own House, with the assistance of her Nobles and the other Houses; their outlook and behavior may be slightly different, but for the most part they can be expected to maintain continuity. In some cases, however, if the former Queen's House has been weakened, or another House is getting too strong, the death of the Queen will shift the balance and a new King or Queen will be raised from one of the other Lords; then, though the old Queen's house will survive and she may be continued as a Lord, the focus of the kingdom's identity - the Titan's identity - will shift and they may become vastly different."

>"In other words: Titans, at least fully grown and healthy Titans, are immortal. Any one of our souls, if slain, can be remade by the others, given time and Will. Particularly traumatic injury in this manner, however, can cause a shift in the Titan's identity, altering their personality and powers. Only with wholesale slaughter of a Titan's souls, however, more quickly then they can be reborn, do we "die"."

>"For now, though, we have only two souls, so I would not place great faith on this."

>>
No. 58021 ID: c1a7db

>>58020
How does Saulanna's hero's soul fit into this picture?

Aside from succession, what is the function of the Devas in the Queen's own house? (not under a lord). Management implementation of the Queen's will, as the kingdom grows too large to command directly?

Are houses less likely to fall victim to destructive inter-faction rivalries if we avoid overlapping elements? Or would similar elements encourage cooperation and understanding?
>>
No. 58032 ID: 431fa8

>>57911
>Saulanna's actions and motivations, and the overarching "themes" that have become evident in her story, will also be a significant influence...
All right, this is somewhat reassuring- I think- because it means that, for example, any Feeder Soul that we make is going to have inside it the part of us that thought about a myriad of reasons to devour that last guy and decided that discipline and self-control were the most important things to focus on when feeding. Depending upon how strongly any soul we make expresses who Saulanna is and what she's done so far, we should have a relatively simple time finding them agreeable. I hope.

Thoughts on current suggestions.

>Humanity
I don't really agree with that. I would be just as happy to go around devouring gods, the low-level souls of another Titan, nonhuman mortal races, or whatever else as humans. Tying ourselves to a specific race as our food source is neither necessary nor desirable. I'm against this one.

>Knowledge
I don't really like this one that much. Yes, knowledge is important to Saulanna- but I'm inclined to save it for a later soul. We'll want a dedicated researcher, crafter, something like that eventually- and Knowledge or a related Element will synergize very well with that purpose. We have no immediate need for it, with Wordblood on hand and his abilities already helping us learn things fairly easily, and Knowledge doesn't have compelling synergistic aspects with the Purpose of a Feeding Soul- so let's keep this one in hand for the right Purpose to use it alongside.

>Civilization
This one... is interesting. It would open the doors to large-scale powers which affect entire societies at once at high levels, and it would let us draw power from being in any built-up area, as well as giving us a devoted interest in improving the world- because the more we can encourage civilizations to grow, the stronger we become. I think I am inclined to support it in the absence of any superior idea.

>Stealth soul ideas
After some thought, I am increasingly leaning toward Fate as the element for the stealth soul. A top-tier Fate user with a specific purpose of stealth is just the sort of firepower that we'll need to effectively conceal ourselves from the setting's existing fate ninjas in the long term, and it will potentially let us begin spawning our own legions of fate ninjas as it advances in power, and ultimately bring this most critical aspect of existence under our control.

>>58020
Time for a whole slew of questions.

-Given that Saulanna has a Lord-level soul and there are many of those in a Titan, is there any reason that it has to be her Soul Force carved off and used to create a new Lord deva, rather than say Wordblood's?
-What are the costs and procedure for creating Noble devas, and later Commoner devas?
-How powerful would Noble devas created in our situation be? We are quite weak as a Titan at the moment; is it a waste of time to mess with souls aside from Lords, or...?
-There is discussion of Houses conflicting with one another; the description of Houses implies that the Lords who generate them are not included, however. This implies that the Lords at the top of the House can see the big picture just as the Queen does- logical, given their similar nature- and are thus much less given to internal conflict. Is this so?
-Saulanna has Queen status; failing her death, is there any way for her to lose this status? Let's say we get into a situation where for whatever reason she has much lower Soul Force than another Lord, who for whatever reason has been displeased with the actions the Titan as a whole has taken; is there any chance of having her crown stolen, as it were, failing the extreme case of her House being devastated and then her personally slain?
-Wordblood and Saulanna are both apparently Lord level souls, but evince vastly different abilities- and some of Wordblood's abilities do not seem related to his nature; devouring souls, for example. Are there "base" abilities of a Lord deva which all of them would be expected to possess? If so, how does Saulanna fit into that?
-How does Saulanna's Hero Soul fit in with this hierarchy and Saulanna's place in it?
-Supposedly if Saulanna dies her Hero Soul will go flying off to find a new mortal that it can make a Hero; would such a Hero be inducted into our Titan soul hierarchy?
-How many Lord devas is normal or healthy for a full-grown Titan?
-How detectable are beings within our Titan world-body?
>>
No. 58034 ID: 7472ad

>>58032
>After some thought, I am increasingly leaning toward Fate as the element for the stealth soul.

I am against this, because doing so will likely get us caught immediately. Not only are there multiple Incarna of fate, and creatures outside of fate that we might want to hide from, but I think a Lord Deva of Fate being born will be very obvious in the Loom. If we want to hide from Siderals, finding a way to put ourselves outside of fate seems the best option. Which we might be already, given our Titanic nature.(If I recall correctly, Primordials in exalted are all outside of fate, as are their Second and Third Circle souls. First circle souls are outside it until they interact with it, where they get snared up in it)
>>
No. 58035 ID: bf54a8

>>58032
i would think since saulunna is the queen it must come from her to make a lord that serves her. a chunk from wordblood would create a noble of his house.
>>
No. 58036 ID: bf54a8

oh and here's a fun fact, alchemical exalted turn into cities inside of autoconth. (sp)
>>
No. 58039 ID: 431fa8

>>58034
I will admit that I have not read the Siderals book, nor any other books that would be critical to well-informed discussion of this topic, so you may well be right about it backfiring like that. Personally I don't see a "Deva Who Hides In Fate" as being likely to send up flares for anyone watching given its very nature as a being who is hidden, but that could be optimism on my part.

I had gotten the impression from other discussion was that Star Heroes would likely be one of the biggest things that we have to worry about picking up on our existence and alerting others/sending others to deal with us. If we are outside of fate and so they're basically totally powerless to stand in our way, why are we worried about them at all? And if they can be discarded as the most major threat to our secrecy, then what are the next most major things likely to pick up on us that we might wish to craft our stealth soul to effectively combat?
>>
No. 58041 ID: c1a7db

Might we posit that the Siderals (Star heros) or more general fate powers are weakened in the current setting? Owl-boy mentioned that star based divinations have become unreliable.

It's hardly definitive evidence, but if the natural order's been shook up enough then we might not have to worry about the fate though-police swarming in on us early.

Also- we should consider what kind of inner kingdom would be cool. It's shape might grow organically out of what we do or create in terms of Devas, but we can probably exert direct influence over it as well.

A library has been suggested. Conventional musty, rectangular library architecture is kind of boring though- something like a palatial library would be cooler. Lots of light, open areas, swoops, arches, spiral staircases, a ballroom, banquet hall- everything you'd expect in a palace. Except that recessed bookshelves have been installed everywhere, not just in the walls, but in the columns, ceiling, and steps of the stairs as well. xD A thematic nod to Wordblood's nature, and Saulanna's class.

>Any one of our souls, if slain, can be remade by the others, given time and Will.
Wordblood, when we have the resources for you to start populating your house, does this mean you can restore / remake fallen companions from your previous Titanic incarnation?
>>
No. 58042 ID: fa9f7e

>>58041
He did say *our* souls, not his previous incarnation's souls. Might still be possible, especially if we create a soul for that.
>>
No. 58044 ID: c1a7db

>>58042
I was of the mind that his devas might be our devas, as he himself is now ours.

That, and I assume the Devas closest to the King (Wordblood thinks he might have been- if not, he was an important Lord) make up the closest thing Titans have to family. Poor dude might be cheered at the prospect of recovering some of them.
>>
No. 58045 ID: 7472ad

>>58039
Given the description of the way the setting has changed, I don't think there is a primary group we need to hide from, outside of those nearby or who have already taken an interest in us. The assumption of the Siderals being a threat was probably because during the Age of Sorrows, they hunted(to kill or turn into a puppet) pretty much every Exalt that wasn't them or Dragon-Blooded. They had better resources then most other exalts, were more organized, more living elders, and had a great deal of influence over the Scarlet Empire.

As for the nature of the Deva protecting it, by being a hidden part of fate, the Bureau of Destiny's Division of Secrets will almost certainly end up with a file on it. Hell, if only person in Fate knows something, Nara-O the Divisions leader automatically has a file on it.(Assuming he's still alive, which i hope he is. One of the cooler gods) Jupiter surely has stuff that surpasses that, and who knows what the new maidens of Fate do. So bringing a new, inexperienced Deva with a low Soul Force into Fate and expecting it to be hidden is not something I'd rely on.
>>
No. 58047 ID: 8e921b

I am in favor of Observation for the Feeding Soul. That is a good idea.

I'm against Civilization because I think that could have limited application: it would be darn hard to use in wilderness, of which there may well be quite a lot.

As for the inner world, a palace-library sounds great. I'm hoping the Feeding Soul can be a sort of library with a raccoon librarian.
>>
No. 58049 ID: 3ee353

Possible procrastination tactic: "Over the course of a month I'll go through all the phases, right? And I'm not likely to turn into a chimera in a month, so I'll wait that long."

>>58041
I would think our library would become more palatial as we raise its soul force.

>>58047
A library and the librarian as a single soul? Seems a bit much to me.
>>
No. 58051 ID: 997ce7

>>58049
You're right, it's only a bit much. It needs to be even more. I suggest an ocean-palace with geysers, whirlpools, and waterfalls out of nowhere for bookshelves.

Also, the books are sharks. Magic sharks.
>>
No. 58052 ID: c1a7db

It's perfectly fine if the world-body grows in size and scope as we progress, I'd just like to get the tone set early. Visually interesting and dynamic beats regular, dark, and musty. Saulanna's too upbeat to have a depressing headspace library.

...and it would probably be less complicated if we had devas that all manifested as people / beings of some sort, not places. They can have appropriately thematic rooms / wings / houses (as scale dictates) inside the world-body landscape. But it would be nice not to have to run into starfish alien style communication difficulties, trying to deal with sentient rooms.
>>
No. 58058 ID: cee89f

>>58047
Alternatively, the Library could be one soul and the raccoon could be another one we later, or even a sub-deva within the library. A noble to the Library's Lord, if you will.

... But whatever the case, the raccoon needs horn-rimmed glasses. I can't stop picturing it without those bloody glasses *twitch* O_o
>>
No. 58074 ID: 962662
File 134409194247.png - (1.77KB , 150x155 , coon in glasses.png )
58074

>>58058
>Raccoon in horned rim glasses
>>
No. 58084 ID: cee89f

>>58074
Yeah... they're sorta blackish-reddish but that's basically it =P
>>
No. 58085 ID: 34cbef
File 134410784253.png - (0.99KB , 129x124 , hiddencatface.png )
58085

>>58074
>tfw you find out there's a cat in that picture.
my custom template reveals to me your secrets.
>>
No. 58086 ID: 147853

Is there any reason to NOT tell them that you're a baby titan? Luna'd probably be fine with it, she did choose you after all, therefore, she's happy with you having power like that.
>>
No. 58087 ID: 997ce7

>>58086
Luna's views are not their views. Like they said, Luna doesn't tell them everything. They might decide she needs to be killed to save Creation or some shit based on super-vague stuff they were told way back when.


And I am almost 100% certain that it was stated that Luna was unable to tell we're a baby Titan.
>>
No. 58089 ID: d6c330

>>58086
Because we honestly don't know who we can trust with that. We're a baby thing-that-came-before-the-gods, with the potential to dramatically change the world, or all of creation, in unknown ways. A lot of good and just people might consider it moral to kill us just because we're too dangerous to be left alive. People with power will want to kill us because we're a threat to their power. Exalted Heros might well remember lore that they were created for the explicit purpose of killing us. Etc. Lots of people could have lots of reasons to react less than well.

tl:dr- because we're weak, and it's dangerous to let the information out.

>And I am almost 100% certain that it was stated that Luna was unable to tell we're a baby Titan.
Wordblood didn't want us to tell her. That implies he thinks she doesn't already know. He might be wrong, but I don't think anyone else is more qualified than he to guess.

>>58074
Raccoons also don't have see though faces. :D

But don't worry, the next time I'm inspired to make minimalist pixel art, I'll grab the proper colors first. 9u9
>>
No. 58090 ID: 96be00

I saw a comment about it being hard to imagine a "neutral accent", so I'll explain what I mean. It might be outside a lot of people's experience.

So once upon a time I worked as an intern with a company that translated and recorded... instructions, basically, things like lectures on law and business practices, manuals on certain technologies in audio form, that sort of thing. During that time, I noticed that the people who did the recordings spoke in a certain way, and it was only later (when a friend of mine got a similar job and I was able to observe the change) that I realized that, after spending time recording one's voice over and over while being instructed to speak as clearly and distinctly as possible, such people began to develop what I can only describe as a "non-accent", or neutral accent. Essentially, it's when you speak very clearly, but not as if you're deliberately trying to do so.
>>
No. 58092 ID: 997ce7

>>58090
I can confirm this; I've been told that I speak like this. I'm deaf, and after a decade or so of speech therapy starting while I was a tot, I apparently have this exact accent.
>>
No. 58102 ID: 96be00
File 134411677951.png - (57.14KB , 500x500 , titanexplanations2.png )
58102

>>58020
- Aside from succession, what is the function of the Devas in the Queen's own house?
>"Er, well, for a start, the "succession" I spoke of was only a metaphor; the "heir" who ascends is actually the original Queen, pieced back together from whatever was left of her. Her Noble devas' contribution, they based on and possessing parts of her, is to form a template to assist her rebirth. Otherwise, they function as they do for any other Lord."

- Are houses less likely to fall victim to destructive inter-faction rivalries if we avoid overlapping elements? Or would similar elements encourage cooperation and understanding?
>"It depends. Fractitious and domineering devas will compete with their metaphorical "siblings"; more laid-back devas will be friendly with them."

>>58032
- Given that Saulanna has a Lord-level soul and there are many of those in a Titan, is there any reason that it has to be her Soul Force carved off and used to create a new Lord deva, rather than say Wordblood's?
>"Theoretically, no. However, devas made from a Queen will be naturally inclined towards trust and obedience to her, and get on more easily with each other. It gives them "common ancestry", so everything will generally be more harmonious. It also secures her supremacy; if another Lord had too many offspring Lords, the balance of power might shift enough that they become King or Queen."

- What are the costs and procedure for creating Noble devas, and later Commoner devas?
>"I'm not sure; no Titan has ever had to build themselves up from such a low level before. It's possible that a Lord might have to make all their Nobles at the same time! I won't be able to get an accurate feel for it until I'm stronger. Making Commoner devas should be easier; it's just like making any living creature using Titan's Will, except you leave a little of the connection in place."

- How powerful would Noble devas created in our situation be? We are quite weak as a Titan at the moment; is it a waste of time to mess with souls aside from Lords, or...?
>"Oh, we're definitely very far from making any Nobles."

- There is discussion of Houses conflicting with one another; the description of Houses implies that the Lords who generate them are not included, however. This implies that the Lords at the top of the House can see the big picture just as the Queen does- logical, given their similar nature- and are thus much less given to internal conflict. Is this so?
>"Some can, but conversely, some can't. It depends on their individual nature."

- Saulanna has Queen status; failing her death, is there any way for her to lose this status? Let's say we get into a situation where for whatever reason she has much lower Soul Force than another Lord, who for whatever reason has been displeased with the actions the Titan as a whole has taken; is there any chance of having her crown stolen, as it were, failing the extreme case of her House being devastated and then her personally slain?
>"Being Queen is less about being the most powerful and more about being the "centre" around which other Lords revolve. Power does come into it, but it's also a matter of the relationships between the various devas; if another Lord appears who is a more natural "leader" for a majority of their fellows, it is possible that supremacy will shift onto them. However, this usually only happens either if the original King or Queen is severely injured, or if the Titan in question is deliberately trying to evolve into a somewhat different being. Making new devas and shifting their internal power structure is how fully grown Titans grow and change."

- Wordblood and Saulanna are both apparently Lord level souls, but evince vastly different abilities- and some of Wordblood's abilities do not seem related to his nature; devouring souls, for example. Are there "base" abilities of a Lord deva which all of them would be expected to possess? If so, how does Saulanna fit into that?
>"There are a set of basic abilities which most (though not all) Lords will generally possess. However, my lady Saulanna's soul is still mostly human, so I would not expect her to have such abilities yet. I can't even identify what basic Purpose or Element she cleaves towards, but I am looking forward to finding out."

- How does Saulanna's Hero Soul fit in with this hierarchy and Saulanna's place in it?
>"I'm... not certain. Hero Souls are a titanic creation, but I have no idea how they work. My talents never ran in that direction. So far, all I can say is that it seems to be reacting well to what we've done so far; whether that will continue to be the case, I don't know."

- Supposedly if Saulanna dies her Hero Soul will go flying off to find a new mortal that it can make a Hero; would such a Hero be inducted into our Titan soul hierarchy?
>"I have no idea."

- How many Lord devas is normal or healthy for a full-grown Titan?
>"It's extremely variable. Some Titans have had upwards of thirty or so Lord souls! But it has no bearing on power or health. Gaia, one of the healthiest and most powerful Titans of all, has only seven Lordly devas. Autochthon has nine, and he's one of the most frail."

- How detectable are beings within our Titan world-body?
>"Almost entirely undetectable; it is, after all, essentially an attempt to see into another world. Only the mightiest of powers, dedicated to the task, would stand even a slim possibility of being able to do it. Unless, of course, we were to make specific provision for others to see into our inner world."

- Fate
>"We Titans are not subject to Fate; nor is it able to withstand our power for long, without the dedicated attentions of the Maidens to adjust it to our presence. We are only slightly subject even to the fate beyond Fate, samsara: the pattern-cycle which calls that which was to become again. We are the creators and the deciders."

>>58041
- Wordblood, when we have the resources for you to start populating your house, does this mean you can restore / remake fallen companions from your previous Titanic incarnation?
>"..."
>"... no."


>>58047
- Observation
>"That would seem more like a Purpose than an Element, to me. It certainly could be an Element - almost anything can be - but you might end up with trouble if you ever want to make a deva with a similar Purpose. It also strikes me as a recipe for a very passive deva."
>>
No. 58105 ID: 8e921b

Wordblood, if we made a Feeding Deva with a purpose of "Making TW and Magical Energy" and an element of "Knowledge," do you think it would overlap with you and potentally cause problems?
>>
No. 58130 ID: d6c330

>"... no."

Aw. I'm sorry for bring that up Wordblood. :(

I'd like to offer a hug, if I but I'm kind of insubstantial voice of the past floating here.

Oh what the heck. You're a floaty thing of words, I'm a floating bunch of words, maybe it'll work. *WORD HUGS*.
>>
No. 58178 ID: cee89f

We've talked about what kind of purposes and elements other devas may have but What element and purpose does Wordblood himself have? In addition, can these elements and purposes change with varying circumstances?

(sorry if this has been answered already, i just got here and haven't read from the very beginning =( )
>>
No. 58179 ID: d6c330

Jukashi explains it here.

>>57732

He's the Aide of Communication. His purpose his to act as our adviser, his element is all communication.
>>
No. 58186 ID: cee89f

>>58179
Ah thank you
>>
No. 58230 ID: dd287a

as a guy suggested, we should take our discussion of ROMANCE to here.

Now I'm not saying we should hump the guy but I don't want to make Saulanna out to be some sortof ice queen who reacts to attention with irritation and scorn.
>>
No. 58234 ID: d6c330

I've no problem with Saulanna pursuing romantic options, or even just a physical fun, I just don't expect it to be happening in the near term.

And fending off an unwanted grope, or an overly presumptuous taking of a prolonged ogle does not one an ice queen make.

We got several immediate real world problem to distract us from that: handling the lunars, the emissaries, the servants and castle, managing our realm sitting down with Peregrin and actually talking out some kind of working arrangement, and getting to know each other well enough to work together, etc. We've barely started with all that!

We've also got to handle building up our new Titanic persona, and creating, getting to know, and building relationships with our Devas. In addition to being time consuming, that'll eat up much of any energy we have to put towards relationships. Plus, it's hard to work towards any kind of relationship when your own identity is so unstable, and in a state of flux. Until we get a further, we don't know who or what we're really going to become.

Even if we limit it to just physical fun, any of the available partners could be disastrous. We can't sleep with the staff. We need to work out a working relationship with Kaan before we consider anything else, and even then it seems like a bad idea. Ghost-boi is pining for someone else. Garm's probably our best bet for an actual one night stand, but it might be risky to get involved with the other Lunars at all, at this point. I suppose it could be a useful distration, and if we win him over, he might be less suportive of Owl boy trying to get us to do anything.

I mentioned inner-Titan deva secs as a joke, but in all likelihood, it's probably possible, if we create a deva who's actually interested. I expect we can do anything we could in the real world in our inner world- and then some.

If peeps really want to turn on the debauchery though, we should make a feeder of intamcy, or sex, or something and proceed for the full on Saulanna Succubus route.

>some non sex stuff.
When I said we should get to know our devas better, that should include Wordblood. He's very helpful, informative, and loyal, but I can't help but feel we haven't got to know him, personally, very well. He's obviously kind of lonely, not to mention betrayed, and could use our support. He merits some non-infodump interactions.
>>
No. 58252 ID: 1417a1

>ROMANCE
A problem I have with romance is that since Saulanna have little personality beyond what we give her, she doesn't really seem to have much chemistry with anyone.

I guess we're left having to make any such decisions based on either pragmatic reasons (such as the argument above in favor of sex with Garmir) or our own personal taste.
>>
No. 58254 ID: 8e921b

Ugh, Garmir's a creep. No thanks.
>>
No. 58255 ID: e3f578

Peregrine and Gavin are pretty much the only legit options. Maybe 4-eyes (I can never remember the sod's name) since he seems polite but also seems a little uptight.
Can you even get intimate with a ghost?
Maybe Alice, but she'd forget however much progress on Jukashi's abstract romantic gameplay mechanic (if he's made one, which he probably has)
>>
No. 58256 ID: 997ce7

>>58255
I do believe there's a drug that lets you interact with ghosts, but it's addictive and has side effects iirc.
>>
No. 58257 ID: dd287a

There's likely more fish in the sea than the unwashed wolfman and our servant via magic pact, nobodies too enthusiastic on the former, and the latter has complications, ie, he's a death knight, and subservient to us right now, and he seems helpful but his primary characteristic is his scientific curiosity, he's not doing anything out the goodness of his heart, even our agreement is because he wants to learn powah words.
>>
No. 58258 ID: bf54a8

wonder what would happen if we grabbed peregrin's hero soul and inverted it back. how would he deal with now being a solar?
>>
No. 58261 ID: d6c330

>>58254
I'm inclined to agree. Since I initially suggested we might be able to use him, he's only grown creepier. I really don't think sleeping with him would give us any useful influence at this point. We'd just be another notch on his belt, or tattoos, or whatever.

>>58258
I'm not sure he'd appreciate it (and I doubt we're anywhere near strong enough, yet). A lot of his stuff seems pretty integrated with the dark he's got going on. And from a practical point of view, in the shadowlands, running a kingdom of ghosts, and doing diplomacy with evil things, he's more useful to us darkside.
>>
No. 58277 ID: 25c210

We should romance Autochthon.
>>
No. 58289 ID: 8e921b

Autochthon's got Titan-Leprosy, and we're a Titan. Do YOU want to get void-leprosy-cancer? I don't.
>>
No. 58298 ID: b85f8c

>>58289
Huhwhat? The wiki says he's just asleep in exile.
>>
No. 58303 ID: f8606f

>>58298
Oh, he is. Autochton is the Primordial that is based off of the Lamed Blacksmith character archetype, except where humans (or Gods, like Hephaestus/Vulcan) would have a bad leg, Autochton has Grotesque Horrific Blasphemous Techno-Organic Abominable Void Cancer. ...And several other highly disfiguring and disturbing (on every level) real-world diseases and conditions translated into magical whatever-Autobot-has.

Cause, you know, Autochton doesn't really have legs, so he needs something else...
>>
No. 58308 ID: 8e921b

Yeah, poor guy is the leper of Titans. It's possible he's more-or-less a nice guy (for a Titan) but regardless, he's ICKY. And may or may not be contagious.
>>
No. 58326 ID: f03e5a

So I've seen a lot of talk about a feeding soul and that all well and good to plan for it. I would like to throw out the idea that there is a labyrinth underground in this place where Peregrin likely found the original soul fragment he used to implant into Saulanna. Exploring it and finding where he came from might allow us to find more titan fragments which can be absorbed for titan's will. Also classic dungeon crawling style and fighting monsters, puzzles, etc.

Of course we'll have to deal with all the loose plot ends first before we go randomly off on an adventure, we still need to complete the very first quest we took which was Gevin and the music box which we still have. I'd say we should take time to examine that with our new knowledge and see if we can devise what it's function would be and if we can repair it.
>>
No. 58346 ID: 8e921b

Looking for more titan fragments would be a great idea, and they'd probably come with some Titan's Will. They'd also avoid the moral problems of permanently destroying a human soul, since a deva would become part of us instead.

I am concerned, however, that we first need an ability to read something of a deva's basic nature before we can know it's save to absorb one. We wouldn't want to end up stapled to a deva whose nature is harmful to us (makes us insane, self-loathing, violently malevolent, insatiably hungry, infected with void cancer, whatever).
>>
No. 58347 ID: 8e921b

Oos, "safe" not "save."

We'd have to avoid absorbing a deva that would be antithetical or hostile to any souls we already have (such as a deva of insensibility/confusion), or which would overlap and cause a conflict.

Which is an argument for looking for them sooner rather than later, I guess.
>>
No. 58350 ID: d6c330

I'm not so sure dungeon crawling is Saulanna's style. We built her to be a talker, not a fighter (although, to date, she's got somewhat a better track record fighting than talking. We gotta work on that). Personally, I'd rather magically search out scry for potentially useful titan fragments rather than wander around looking for them.

Applying new knowledge to the music box might be useful though. You'd think we'd picked up some mechanical skill from the evil soul-smith.

>Current Raccoon girl conversation failure and panic

I propose we need to do our debating here. Our multiple lines of thought (reveal to Luna, or is that stupid? How much and what do I say about Peregrin? Am I fucking up? Etc) seem to be crippling her. She's not very good at just listening to the majority, or picking her own path from the noise. So I'm thinking we need to shield her from more of it, at least till she regains her cool.

Long term, this could be problematic, especially if she's as bad with disagreeing devas as she is with disagreeing headvoices. Maybe once we upgrade her personal titanic power level, she'll be more resilient?
>>
No. 58351 ID: 1b9144

Number 1: Might I put forward general positive improvement(i.e. make things better for everybody) as an element to consider for the feeding soul?
Can't see any Huge flaw with it and it is a nice thing to be goin about helping.
Number 2: In reference to the now I think saulanna should change tack and stand up for herself.
The gently gently approach seems to be gaining us naught but scorn from the two lunars. Seeing as how bestial anger is supposed to honour luna, maybe we could threaten that we will stapple them both ass to mouth then grab the Ebon dragon by the throat and jam the giant concept of dickishness itself through both their assholes and see how they like being on the recieving end of overbearing jerkishness. Saullanna's Exalted to dammit she deserves their respect!
Admmitedly very confortantional but as I said, they probably wont respect a meek Exalt.
>>
No. 58352 ID: e3aff6

I don't think it is just trying to be polite and calm that is causing the trouble; Ascalaf seems to be fine doing just that.
With the bit about "defend Peregrin and talk about how he's not so bad and she can handle him, but that's not... that doesn't feel right!", I am wondering if part of her pre-mindwipe personality is starting to reappear.

>Number 1:general positive improvement
As expressed there, that seems like an overly broad theme to build a titan around. It would be almost like making a titan of 'stuff'.
>>
No. 58354 ID: 8e921b

She smells Askalaff disdains her too. I say time to switch tacks. Slap Garmir's face and tell them to quit intimidating her or they can get the crap out of her face. She doesn't trust them and won't go with them because they behave like jerks and clearly despise her, so deal with it.
>>
No. 58355 ID: 8e921b

Also, Askalaff may be trying to deceive HER at this point. They're up to something -- this is not a straitfarward conversation.
>>
No. 58357 ID: 8e921b

Lastly, if this horrid panic keeps happening a Feeding Soul of Calm or Logic might not be a bad idea.
>>
No. 58360 ID: d6c330

>>58357
Saulanna needs a deva of discriminating between suggestions, in order to make her own damn choices as appropriate instead of being paralyzed by indecision and confusion. >n<

Because there's no way of stopping people from throwing out tangentially related suggestions going in all directions. (Attack them? Mindwipe them with a new power word! Put them on hold and call Luna!)
>>
No. 58361 ID: 8e921b

Feeding Soul of Calm, Logical Decision-Making?
>>
No. 58369 ID: f8606f

>>58361
Presuming that the goal of that deva is to lessen the negative effects of the collective stupidity of tgchan, I would think that a Supporting Soul would be best: an Aide of Rationality, perhaps.
>>
No. 58386 ID: d6c330

>>58369
Aide of... dang it, I'm an idiot. We've already got an aide of communication. That's what we're doing wrong!

Hey Wordblood! Could you run some interference for us? We're having trouble talking to Saulanna.

She's overreacting to us. Our attempts at critical analysis come across as crushing condemnation of her performance. Our suggestions seem as heavy handed commands. Our brainstorming and disagreements serve not to give her perspective, but cognitive dissonance. Our very nature seems to be undermining her right now, not helping.

We need a buffer or a volume knob or something, so she can still listen to the maelstrom of our thought and ideas without being overwhelmed. I know to deny meaning is anathema to you, but could you help to blunt the impact of our words? Saulanna needs the room to stand up for herself, or I fear she will be overwhelmed.

It would be easier if we could reign ourselves in, but we're a group of disparate personalities, and poorly organized. By our very nature, we are inexorably chaotic and disorganized.
>>
No. 58388 ID: f647c0

Are people really arguing that this quest needs an in-universe method to make the protagonist ignore suggestions and make her own decisions?
>>
No. 58389 ID: 997ce7

>>58388
His point seems to be that she takes everything too hard, not that she needs to start ignoring us entirely.
>>
No. 58390 ID: d6c330

Well, for my part at least, it's more half joking frustration that our inability to come to any kind of coherent consensus is currently killing us.

But more generally yeah, I do kind of feel our characters are better off when they're willing and able to make choices among the possible suggestions.
>>
No. 58400 ID: 8e921b

>>58388
Considering that

A: The GM has made it clear that arguing on the main thread will fuck up the character, and

B: Many people continue to argue on the main thread because they're idiots,

Yes, this is the only way the character will not die horribly very soon.
>>
No. 58401 ID: 8e921b

It sucks, but it's looking like there's no other choice unless we want Saulanna to be a panicky, insane, perma-limit-breaking nutso for the rest of the quest.
>>
No. 58402 ID: 8e921b

I am concerned and confused, however, about the actual meta-process of decision-making for this character. Earlier Jukashi said that Saulanna is intelligent enough to make decent decisions, and that he choses what she'll do based on who makes the most intelligent argument, not on votes.

Now, it looks like she has lost her intelligence is can't make any decision, writing an intelligent argument makes things worse, and "voting" makes things worse.

And if we can't discuss what she should do on the main thread, how can we suggest anything? In fact, if the people who follow directions come here to discuss, while the idiots continue to argue on the main thread, then they're the only people who can decide what the character does, and "the most intelligent suggestion wins" goes out the window.

Seriously, are all TG quests set up this way?
>>
No. 58403 ID: 8e921b

Even if this method doesn't get her killed messily very soon, she'll have to waste all her TW on creating a deva that exists solely to give her the ability to use her intelligence to make decisions.
>>
No. 58405 ID: d6c330

>>58402
>Saulanna should be able to make decisions about our disagreements.
I think she would be, if we were arguing about, say, how best to handle the deception and conversation with these guys.

Instead, we were arguing about whether to have a conversation at all, whether we should reveal all our secrets, what to be afraid of, power words, Luna, etc. It was too much, too distracting, and too off topic for her to handle.

And Saulanna, on the scale of personality quest character suggestion resilience, is pretty weak willed, actually. She's very susceptible to us, and easily pushed around.

>Seriously, are all TG quests set up this way?
No.

Some quests are done by majority rule, or by the rule of persuasion / argument. Some by the rule of funny, the rule of all suggestions go, or by just whatever the author or character decides to pull from the pile.

There's also the matter of how independent the character is. At one extreme there are quests where characters have almost no independent will, and do whatever we tell them, and even crazy suggestions get worked in (currently, Pixel quest is an active example, where this is actually done well. Or... Desert Butt, but there we've mostly used that power to humiliate her). At the other extreme there are characters with strong, independent personalities, who may barely listen to us, and need to be talked into things (Larro's characters for instance, often need to be talked into things, and not just ordered around. And Gnoll's barely listen to us at all). In the middle, you have characters who manage to listen to us, but pick and chose when we disagree, or assert themselves when they feel the need (currently, I'd say Polo best fits this example).

Saulanna isn't completely devoid of independent will, but she's pretty low on the independence scale. Characters like that suffer when we can't agree. It's worse when the quest is popular, beacuse there's so many of us.
>>
No. 58410 ID: dcd945

Remember, guys, if we argue and it appeals to valid emotions, like fear, we will cause her damage. She can make decisions, but it's hard to decide on a course of action when the voices in your head are yelling several different things at once.

(PS. Thanks for getting me into Exalted, Jukashi. It's an expensive hobby, but your stories are worth it.)
>>
No. 58412 ID: f4f31b
File 134464570117.png - (84.62KB , 450x540 , wblooksback.png )
58412

>>58386
>Hey Wordblood! Could you run some interference for us? We're having trouble talking to Saulanna.
>She's overreacting to us.

>"... I don't think that's the problem."

>"All I can tell you is that my lady's confusion is not due to you or I - or at least, not the majority of it. Aside that, I can't provide any more information; the behaviour of these moon heroes is not clear to me. Perhaps you could try looking back over their words and actions, and over my lady's responses, and think about what kind of being a moon hero is."

>>
No. 58417 ID: d6c330

Oh, thanks Wordblood. Good to know it isn't us at least, but that means there's a real problem to deal with we've overlooked.

>What's happening
Okay, they're all Lunars. They're half animal. It's a full moon. Garm is coming on to Saulanna, hard. Ask is constantly concerned with mind control and questions of influence. Saulanna's got poor control, and her emotions are going up.

...shit. I think we're looking at some kind hormonal lunar full moon heat thing, possibly made worse by active use of Ask using mental debuffs or attacks, and Garm outright putting magical moves on us. Either to completely put her off guard and make her easy to control, or for some fucked up initiation sex. We're gonna get date raped.

What say you, people familiar with the source material? This theory at all plausible?

What stat would be relevant to resisting this kind of mental, hormonal, emotional, whatever attack? Could we moon boost it to resist?
>>
No. 58419 ID: 1da170

Ah, they're engaging in pheromone fuckery, maybe?

Also, Garmir's trying to exploit her instinctive reaction to having a dangerous predator looming over her, which is to either wig the fuck out or get the fuck out.

(Also, Saulanna should obviously romance Wordblood, he's by far the cutest character she's met. Of all potential headspace deva, she's not his progenitor, he's just been grafted onto her soul.)
>>
No. 58420 ID: 9ca64f

>>58419
Looks like it's a ton of UMI up there.
>>
No. 58422 ID: b6178d

>>58419

I'm wondering if it isn't a lot more primal than that. Like, Saulanna may feel that she's being cornered by two predators?

And the two moon heroes are keeping it up, because this way they can see how far they can push her, and also put the squeeze on her for information.
>>
No. 58425 ID: b85f8c

>>58422
I think that's exactly it. Raccoons bite when cornered.

Somewhere inside her I think she wants to do something along the same lines, and take advantage of their animal sides. I don't know shit about owls and whatever the fuck that other guy is though. If someone wants to try that and knows how, I'd support it.
>>
No. 58426 ID: d6c330

>>58422
Could be. I'm not sure how much the animal thing affects their psychology, but it's very plausible.

From our standpoint, it's kind of hard to know the exact mechanism they're using to get to her. What I think we can agree is that she needs to shake it off, take control of the situation, and get aggressive here. We are not taking this shit lying down.

I did go back over the dialog, wondering if Wordblood's hint meant there was a hidden message that would give away what they were doing (first letters, words, syllables, things like that). Didn't find anything.
>>
No. 58433 ID: 8e921b

I don't know if it's pheromones or outright magic, but they're clearly fucking with her head.

Whether it's a test or just assholes, I say it's time to get assertive, even aggressive. WITHOUT violence.
>>
No. 58435 ID: 8e921b

>It's... the problem is with her. She's trying to be polite and clever and logical and dodge dangerous topics and arrange things all nice and civilized and that's all wrong somehow. But what is she supposed to do? There's something inside her that knows the answer but she can't hear it clearly.

>Saulanna is getting pretty damn EMOTIONAL. She has to suppress the urge to start clawing and biting at someone.

Are those Moon Hero instincts telling her that outright attacking is the right move? I don't think physical violence is a good idea, but should we tell her to pay attention to her instincts?
>>
No. 58437 ID: fa9f7e

>>58422
Alternatively, we're becoming a chimera. Unlikely, especially since I doubt Jukashi would spring a.. well, not unavoidable, but unpleasant-and-extremely-risky-to-avoid Bad End on us so early. We should be aware of the possibility nonetheless.


Unless it's already been confirmed that it's not chimerism and I just missed it.
>>
No. 58440 ID: 8e921b

It can't be chimerism, Saulanna exalted only 2 subjective days ago.
>>
No. 58442 ID: fa9f7e

>>58440
You'll note Saulanna is quite unique. Was this directly stated or are people assuming from canon?

If it's the latter, remember: the Titans are huge chunks of primal Chaos that decided to become ordered for some reason. LQ doesn't seem to have changed the backstory from before the Ebon Dragon's victory. Now, Saulanna has a chunk of a being that was pure Chaos in her soul. True, the Titan in question became more ordered, but he was shattered and killed, which rarely if ever makes things any more ordered.

Of course, if Word of God contradicts me, just ignore me.
>>
No. 58443 ID: d6c330

>>58442
Well, Worldblood was pretty confident he could counter the ill effects of leaving our hero's soul unfettered by moon runes. Given that, it seems unlikely the chaos or whatever inside her has gotten out of control already.
>>
No. 58445 ID: fa9f7e

>>58443
True. I'm not saying it's at all likely, and I'm almost certain it really is just animal instincts, possibly heightened by Beast Senses. I'm just slightly paranoid, I suppose.
>>
No. 58447 ID: 8e921b

I don't think the GM is going to almost state outright that tattoos would mess up our Titan powers, have the Lunars claim chimerism takes a while to set in, and then say SURPRISE! You're becoming one already! Get tattoos or lose the game.
>>
No. 58450 ID: f8606f

>>58442
...No? I understand that "Primordials are evolved/mutated Unshaped" is a popular fan theory, but from all indications (most notably, when Wordblood outright says that Titanic energies are anathema to the chaotic energies of the Wyld within the Lunar Exaltation), that is not true for LQ's setting.
>>
No. 58479 ID: 7472ad

>>58450
>"Primordials are evolved/mutated Unshaped"

I'd like to note that it's a bit more then a fan theory. It's presented as fact in the Fair Folk book. But then that's a book whose Index references 4chan, Duran Duran, and lyrics to Journey's Small Town Girl.

Titan energies being anathema to wyld energies doesn't necessarily mean they didn't originate from the wyld either. Solars and their Unholy Solar Tier brethren being an example of this.
>>
No. 58484 ID: bf54a8

basically wordblood is 100% slowing down the corruption. once we get a bit stronger, soulforce 6 or so, we will be immune as our titan powers are stronger then the energy density in this area.
>>
No. 58547 ID: 6199fa

<Speculation>
The Ebon Dragon converted the Scarlet Empress into the Red Sun Incarna to give himself something else to be opposite of. The Red Sun is probably associated with Immortality. This changed him back into The Dragon That Was, now a Titan associated with eternal undeath nullifying the oath and allowing him to cross over into the Underworld.

He then used his new Underworld associations to seal off the labyrinth and turn the underworld into his own personal version of the afterlife.

TLDR The ED is a magnificent bastard.
</speculation>

Jukashi, have you heard the news about Exalted 3rd Edition coming out? And do you update at certain times or when you feel like it/ have time. Finally, how are your wrist troubles going?
>>
No. 58553 ID: 8e921b

>>58479
It was also presented as absolutely not true in Legend of the Titans.

Basically, it's a question of which story you believe. And the Raksha could just be a bunch of liars.

Or, it being the Wyld, maybe there were multiple origins, until linear time showed up and forced things to get all logical.
>>
No. 58555 ID: b9d767

>>58437
>becoming a chimera
This is highly unlikely. Chimerism comes from unprotected contact with Wyld areas and exessive shapeshifting, which we have done neither of.
>>
No. 58556 ID: 7472ad

>>58553
True. If I recall correctly Graceful Wicked Masques says the Primordials made the Shinma, while Legend of the Titans says they came from it. Anyway, I was just pointing out that the evolved/mutated Unshaped was more then a fan theory, having at least one of the Source Books backing it, even if the Ink Monkey Scroll contradicts it.
>>
No. 58564 ID: c09af0

>>58547
>Jukashi, have you heard the news about Exalted 3rd Edition coming out? And do you update at certain times or when you feel like it/ have time. Finally, how are your wrist troubles going?

Yes, when I feel like it, and not great.

To be more specific: when I'm "in the swing" I usually try to update once every two days. Currently my arm (which by this point I have to admit is now suffering pretty much chronic pain) is not doing so well after some physical labour I did, so I'm taking a short break until it fades back to the normal level. Drawing does not generally bother me, however, unless I do it for very long stretches or need to do a lot of colouring, for some reason. Something to do with applying pressure and what kind of movement I'm doing, I guess.

I generally don't like talking about it, but in this case it's directly related to why I haven't updated yet so there you go.
>>
No. 58584 ID: b85f8c

>>58564
Have you considered drawing with your other hand? Here's an example of someone who has been doing that:
http://www.johnnywander.com/
>>
No. 58691 ID: 3fc386

Wordblood, how obvious are words of power? Could we slip one into, say, an argument if we gave it the right emphasis?
For example "That's Enough! Garmir, Stop this foolishness at once!"
>>
No. 58692 ID: 08a77c

You lot know we're talking to a pair of Lunars right? They are all about passion. Punching Garmir in the face right now would likely do us better than any words.
>>
No. 58693 ID: 4a328b

But can we go "STOP being such a jerk!" as we punch him or will it stick out, is the question~
>>
No. 58694 ID: bf54a8

>>58691
>>58693
oh god no, that is super high grade no fucking WAY they wont be able to tell titan power.
>>
No. 58701 ID: dd287a

Way I see it, we need to establish dominance so he'll pack it in.

Obviously violence is the answer, well we could even outright tell them that Kaan is our wonderful host right now because you came to an agreement after you kicked seven shades of shit out of him.
>>
No. 58702 ID: b85f8c

Wordblood, what would a word of power FORGET do? Or AMNESIA maybe?
>>
No. 58703 ID: cb0cc3

>>58691
>>58702
The issue with Words of Power in the current situation is that they're resistable. We hit Peregrin with the first one all right, but every Hero will get a chance to defend against the effect- and while a sucker punch might work simply because they won't know that Words of Power are a thing that exists, it's not exactly a sure thing.

A situation where we try to use one and fail would be awkward at best, lethal at worst. So let's build up our Soul Force a bit more, or wait until we're a little more desperate, before using them in combat.
>>
No. 58705 ID: d6c330

I'm pretty sure if you slipped a power word into casual conversation the reaction would be something along the lines of "wait, what the hell was that? How did you do that, it wasn't even a spell, and definitely not a moon power!" It'll be worse if the person in question was knowledgeable enough to know what a power word is, or recognize a titanic work.

Also, I don't care what you call the forget word, it's not going to be reliable enough to do in combat. For memory alteration we're going to need them subdued, and possibly Peregrin's help since he's got experience in that area.
>>
No. 58710 ID: 6199fa

What should we do on the Tattoo problem, and them trying to pry us away from our vassal?

We could let them challenge us perhaps, and choose something that plays to our social / mental strengths
>>
No. 58724 ID: bf54a8

what if we captured that hungry ghost, and then used a TW to glue it back on to gevin, making him a full person again essentially. would it basically give him all the pros of ghostiness and take out a load of cons?
>>
No. 58747 ID: b85f8c

>>58724
Hungry ghost? What're you talking about?
>>
No. 58749 ID: b6edd6

>>58747
When people become ghosts they basically split into instinct and rational mind, each of which becomes a separate ghost.
>>
No. 58754 ID: a3b384

>>58749
I don't know much about that, but I would think getting stuck to a ghost that isn't your own split off part would have problems. Or even if there wasn't, the actual gluing together seems like it would be traumatic somehow.

An idea on a slight tangent: if we go around eating these instinct ghosts that might be a great power source that avoids hurting or freaking out any sentient ones. Maybe. Or they might just be useless empty filler to us. Worth checking on anyway.
>>
No. 58760 ID: bf54a8

>>58754
already had that discussion, a lot. and the hungry ghost i am talking about was most likely gevin's. so it would be having a part that broke off put back on.
>>
No. 58780 ID: 1da170

Mentioned before, nomming on hungry ghosts will give us Moon Power but no Titan's Will.

Useful in a pinch, but no good for building long-term power.
>>
No. 58801 ID: bf54a8

yea they are like empty carbs, good energy but no growth.
>>
No. 58804 ID: a3b384

>>58780
>>58801
Darn, forgot all about that. I wonder if there are some other ghostly things out there that would make for some less troublesome titans will.
>>
No. 58813 ID: 9718f3

We could theoretically eat rogue gods and elementals. We would have to be very very careful doing it, but keeping them in line does fall under our job description as a Lunar, I believe.

Probably not worth the risk.
>>
No. 58814 ID: bf54a8

as long as no one notices us 'eating' instead of just killing
>>
No. 58881 ID: d125b0

Wordblood, You seem to be able to talk to us directly. What are we, from your prospective? Are we just random memories lingering from saulanna's past incarnations, bits of thought from her prior exaltations, spirits created by(or gathered by) Luna to help her chosen, or some kind of weird raksha solidified from the chaos in her exaltation?
>>
No. 58882 ID: d125b0

Wordblood, You seem to be able to talk to us directly. What are we, from your prospective? Are we just random memories lingering from saulanna's past incarnations, bits of thought from her prior exaltations, spirits created by(or gathered by) Luna to help her chosen, or some kind of weird raksha solidified from the chaos in her exaltation?
>>
No. 58913 ID: 4a328b

For the Feeder Soul, how about a deva of growth with a floral theme?
>>
No. 58929 ID: cee89f

>>58913
I thought we were making a library?
>>
No. 58931 ID: 4a328b

>>58929
I wasn't around for that vote, and I think that's too close to Word Blood's thing. DIVERSITY!
>>
No. 58932 ID: d6c330

>>58913
>>58929

We hadn't really decided anything, yet. The conversation trailed off because we weren't getting anywhere.

We still need to pick an element for our feeder, and growth seems more like a purpose than an element anyways.

We rejected feeder of time, observation, and a few other things. Toyed with something constructive like civilization, and flirted more strongly with communication. Neither of those seem great to me, though.

We actually go further on the idea for a second stealth / ninja / fate deva, but that doesn't help us right now.

Stuff like what it looks like (floral, library, etc) is kind of secondary. And silly, because how we shape the mindscape can be completely independent of how we shape our devas.

>tl:dr
We could use more brainstorming of any actual elements, if anyone's got any bright ideas.
>>
No. 58933 ID: 4a328b

How about the Element of Surprise?

Is that the sort of element you mean>
>>
No. 58934 ID: d6c330

Well... we could feed on surprise, if we wanted Kogasa as a deva. That seems silly and impractical though.
>>
No. 58941 ID: 4a328b

How about a Feeder of Light? Every time our Soul Fire flares up it's like a damn feast for it.
>>
No. 58942 ID: bf54a8

>>58941
no, reverse it, darkness.
>>
No. 58943 ID: 4a328b

>>58942
Ok, so a Feeder OF Darkness that devours light, right?
>>
No. 58952 ID: d6c330

The problem is it's not a simple as feeder eats <foo>.

Jukashi's explanation is here
>>>57911

For a silly example, consider a feeder of pie.
>>57924
>>57928

So... a feeder of light could theoretically get us energy by eating light, by manipulating light, by making light, ect.

Now, is that useful? Theoretically, we could use that to hide or manipulate our soul fire, which has some utility. Also possibly unlocks light manipulations- invisibility, illusions and the like.

Downsides- we're likely going to either consuming or generating light. Meaning we're in the dark, or glowing, which could be inconvenient. Also, in the shadow lands, you'd expect their to be less light to eat, and any you produce to stand out more. Maybe it's harder to make light there too?

Darkness works out mostly the same, since we just flip the eating / creating cases. Except it would probably be better suited to working in the shadowy land. And hat we'd get from manipulating darkness would be different though. Shadow stuff, instead of illusions, I guess?
>>
No. 58953 ID: bf54a8

>>58952
was thinking the night. lunars gain power under the moon, during the night. in the darkness.
>>
No. 58955 ID: 4a328b

Wait wait I've got a punny one

ILLUMINATION!

It refers not only to light, but to images; as well as meaning "wisdom" in some contexts!
>>
No. 58963 ID: cee89f

Couldn't we theoretically have a feeding soul that feeds off of the waste in the mortal food we eat? We'd never have to take a s*** again! =D

...............stop looking at me like that, it started as 'couldn't we just both eat mortal food' -.-

...I think we should go with the 'Feeds by Spreading' thing. Better to add to the world than to take away, because then you're unlikely to run out - especially if the thing you're spreading is very fragile and/or temporary. Which brings up the question: what should we spread?

'Knowledge' would fit with Wordblood and Saulanna's mind-over-matter and book-absorbing thing, and it would then cause us to gain power as we teach Peregrin our power (Loophole!), and even that whole 'make books of whatever you want' thing would feed the soul, but spreading knowledge to feed seems like it would be very limited if we ever leave this shadowy land, since Moon Heroes were (last I checked) Anathema to most people.

Spreading arousal would be hilarious but otherwise pointless and would rely heavily on being around living things.

We could try asking Luna what kinda things she'd like to have spread (or even just research it) and then pick THAT. But even if we were able to get that answer without telling her 'cuz i can make it spread by walking around' that would get very suspicious very quickly AND encourage Luna to keep a close eye on us and closer scrutiny is the LAST thing we need right now.

We could pick a scent/smell and go with that (Titan perfume!) and honestly I think that would work out the best. Even if no one's around to smell it you can still pump the smell of lavender into the air.

This is all a moot point if the thing that must be spread has to be 'drained' out of Saulanna (for lack of a better phrase) and/or the area around her, in which case, feeding on Illumination or Light would probably work out better. We can generate light by using Moon Power if we ever need it badly, or even have it eat all/most of the light in an area to bathe it in darkness, faking sorcerer powers.
>>
No. 58999 ID: 240cc0

I keep having to add notes because people are thinking about all this much more than I thought they would. I worry that it's being built up in people's heads to something more involved and directly controllable than it will be.

Ok, so first, the Element has to be something... elemental. That is, it has to be something that conceivably has an essence or spirit to it, something mystical. This is why instead of something like Observation it should instead be something like Sight. I refer to Wordblood's element as Communication but in its proper elemental form it is just Words. I would advise thinking along said lines.

Second, you need to think of the use of the Feeding Souls' Element on a much broader level. A Knowledge Feeding soul might get its TW generation schedule bumped up a little faster if Saulanna's hanging around in a city full of scholars pumping out facts and wisdom all day, if she's worshipped as a goddess of learning or if she actively founds and builds an amazing school and attracts a load of students that go out and spread learning across the world, but not from something so small as her personally making books or teaching small numbers of students herself. It will certainly be a significant factor in how the deva does its main job, but what the Element will influence the most is its personality and flavour and what other powers and subsouls it eventually develops. Details which, I must remind, will be made by reference to the attitudes and actions of players but ultimately decided by me for my inscrutable author reasons.

It's kind of interesting to compare to the choice of Saulanna's totem animal in the first thread. It's a similar sort of thing - choice of animal decided what moon abilities Saulanna started with and what she was predisposed to develop more quickly and easily. This was not explained, however, so there wasn't really a giant discussion on picking an animal for the best benefits; people just chose what they liked, on a hey-that-seems-cool sort of level. This was supposed to be sort of the same thing, but it turned into a rather involved discussion, for a few people at least. I wonder which way will turn out to be better.
>>
No. 59000 ID: 240cc0

Heck you know what here's some LQ-canon Titanic Lord-deva Elements to give you ideas.

Gaia: Earth, Air, Fire, Water, Wood, ??? and ???
Autochthon: Steam, Metal, Lightning, Oil, Crystal, Smoke
He Who Bleeds the Unknown Word: Words (duh), Blood (duhh), Thought, Legacy, Beauty, Creation, others?
The Dragon's Shadow: Darkness, Deception, Freedom, Fear, Desire, Cunning, Change, Death, ???
>>
No. 59024 ID: 4a328b

I vote for the element of SECRECY/SECRETS!
>>
No. 59028 ID: 2a1b74

It is not voting time yet. I'll let you know when it is.
>>
No. 59029 ID: d6c330

I think part of the reason we're overthinking it is the pace. We've had more time to think about it. Plus, getting advance warning sort of implies it's important.

But this helps. If the element is more an influence on flavor and personality than function, it's simpler.

That said, I'm still not sure what to pick. Judging by the examples you give, we're shaping the flavor of the whole titan. What we become the titan of. Gotta mull a bit on what direction feels good.

>>59024
Eh, I don't like it. Secrets can turn negative too easily. I think we want a more positive element.
>>
No. 59031 ID: cee89f

>>59029
How about 'Discovery'? Or maybe 'Learning'? Maybe even 'Protection'?
>>
No. 59034 ID: 34d817

Hrm. Well, here's a stab at a package deal for several souls ahead, bearing in mind the fact that each of them makes up a single aspect of Saulanna as a titan and we want a fairly well-designed and cohesive whole without duplicating Lord aspects.

I still like Civilization for our feeding soul; complex and somewhat abstract, but it should definitely be permissible- much like Deception, it's basically a form of interaction between one or more people. And for all the wildness of her Moon Hero nature, Saulanna seems like the type who delights in civilization and makes the most of it.

Then we follow that up with a diplomat soul using Goodwill, to firmly establish what Saulanna is about- and potentially what she can demand from others. She would love to spread goodwill to all, means well for everyone, and wants them to mean well in turn. When thinking about magical effects which could derive from this, it quickly becomes apparent that there are some very powerful social defenses and attacks rooted in this concept.

On the stealth soul, perhaps we're approaching it wrong- maybe we can make its purpose protection and Stealth the element? Stealth certainly seems just as much an elemental quality as, say, Beauty, so we should be all right there.

So what does this come out to? It's only the first few souls, but taken together they establish a fairly strong theme of Saulanna as a friendly person who benefits and leads others, who builds them up and is built up by them in turn, who devotes effort to looking after herself and others but isn't blatant about it. That's a sort of being that I would like to become, I think.
>>
No. 59050 ID: a3b384

Even though the human element feeder doesn't seem to have quite the implication I was going for, I still think the feeder should have an element that keeps us grounded. Mortality might be a bit too dark, but would fit with the actual act of feeding. Counter it with a purpose of rebirth or somesuch. Love or Empathy are obviously positive human elements but their effects may be... troublesome. I could see Empathy being more efficient when consuming anything with emotion.

...I think what is most important to know is how being a feeder soul interacts with the element and purpose. Because I'm still not sure how that works out, and it seems we have a variety of ideas about it.

>>59000
Is there any problem if our souls elements overlap with preciously existing titans? Or if our elements are too close to the portfolios of the gods?

>>59029
>>59031
A negative element can be counterbalanced with a positive purpose. An element of secrets with a purpose of protection sounds like a stealthy soul that shouldn't cause us problems.
>>
No. 59052 ID: b6edd6

>A negative element can be counterbalanced with a positive purpose. An element of secrets with a purpose of protection sounds like a stealthy soul that shouldn't cause us problems.
That might work for a soul in general, but remember that our soul already sort of has a purpose of feeding, which in the case of secrets would probably mean creating secrets or acquiring them.
>>
No. 59053 ID: 4a328b

>>59052
OR just keeping secrets. Big secrets. Like the fact that we're a titan. I don't think it'll be easy, so might as well get some reward from it.
>>
No. 59054 ID: b6edd6

>>59053
I don't think just keeping a set number of secrets we have would be enough for the long term. To grow we would have to keep more and more secrets, which could get very troublesome for a number of reasons. (Also, I am not sure how certain we can be that a secret-based soul won't keep secrets from us.)
>>
No. 59065 ID: 7472ad

>>59034
That sounds... Very good actually. I can't find anything in there that I really disagree with. And as a bonus, all of that is close to how Saulanna has been acting in general. Well, maybe not goodwill. She may try the friendly approach, but being helpful and cooperative haven't really been her intentions behind that as much as keeping her ass out of the fire.
>>
No. 59076 ID: d6c330

So we'll be the titan of words, negotiation, diplomacy, building up something / groups, power of friendship, that kind of things? Those are the kinds of things we're good at. It's a good theme. And I guess it kind of fits Wordblood too- he liked humans a good deal before he was betrayed. If he comes to peace with that, or forgives humanity for the sins of their distant ancestors, he might well enjoy building up something with them.

This kind of flavor might make acceptance easier in the long run too. We're out to make things better. How can you object to that?

I'll endorse feeder of civilization.
>>
No. 59079 ID: b6edd6

>power of friendship
My Little Yozi, Friendship Is Titanic?
>>
No. 59081 ID: a3b384

>>59052
>>59053
That's what I meant about understanding how it being a feeding soul effects its other aspects. Does it have to eat according to its element, or can it influence its output, or is it merely incidental?

My guess is that if the element is related with what it eats, then that would boost efficiency. If it were opposed to it it would be less effective. But it wouldn't be dependent on it either way, and could offer other advantages even when opposed. That's the logic I was using when I suggested Humanity as an element for the feeder. I'm still not sure if it would be a good element or not for a feeder, but being attuned to humanity itself as an element could have very positive long term implications. Much the same ones as the Civilization idea. I stick by Empowerment as a good purpose for any kind of feeder, though.
>>
No. 59082 ID: 34d817

>>59065
>She may try the friendly approach, but being helpful and cooperative haven't really been her intentions behind that as much as keeping her ass out of the fire.
That's why Goodwill is the element, rather than the purpose. Saulanna's purpose is diplomacy, the manipulation and control of others through peaceful means; Goodwill is her chosen tool to that end.

>>59076
>We're out to make things better. How can you object to that?
Well, a lot of things in Exalted are out to make things better in their own point of view; I'm sure someone will object. It's certainly a decent basis for some very nice PR, though!

The support from both of you is much appreciated. Hopefully this will work out well.

>>59079
Titanic friendship is a terrifying thing.
>>
No. 59084 ID: 7472ad

>>Well, a lot of things in Exalted are out to make things better in their own point of view

First thing I thought of; http://tinyurl.com/8hblhxv
>>
No. 59150 ID: bf54a8

http://wiki.white-wolf.com/exalted/index.php?title=Autochthon

full set of devas and what they do. notice how they appear to be several things at once.
>>
No. 59151 ID: bf54a8

>>59084
and i just read that. if the yozis have not gone insane from the years in prison then yeah....
>>
No. 59162 ID: 5f525b

>>59150
I'm not sure what you mean by "how they appear to be several things at once"?

>>59151
If the Yozis hadn't gone insane what?
>>
No. 59164 ID: b85f8c

I read about how Infernals can increase their lifespan... by turning into a Primordial. Isn't that basically what Saulanna is doing? It's like she's a noncorrupted Infernal with a headstart on immortality.
>>
No. 59172 ID: 5f525b

>>59164
>>59164
Skipping past the odd use of "noncorrupted" (Infernals are Titanic Exaltations powered by Solar Exaltations; the Exaltations haven't been corrupted), that is a terrible comparison. For one thing, Saulanna is just a baby Titan-to-be, born from the merging of a mortal soul with a deva. Titanics are Exalted by the Primordials.

From my understanding, Saulanna gains immortality as she matures into a Titan. Titanics, on the other hand, gain immortality when they turn into a Primordial.
>>
No. 59175 ID: b85f8c

>>59172
Err?

>These new Celestial Exalted have been created from the Solar Exaltations captured by the Deathlords after breaking the Jade Prison. They have been given to the Yozis by their dead siblings, the Neverborn. Twisted thoroughly, they are used to Exalt those mortals who failed at a critical point in their lives.

Sounds like a corrupted exalt to me.
>>
No. 59199 ID: bf54a8

primordials ARE titans. it's just different names for the same thing.
>>
No. 59208 ID: b85f8c

I suppose the main difference is that Saulanna has her Lunar Exalt powers in addition to her Titanic powers.
>>
No. 59253 ID: 8e921b

While Saulanna definitely has a resemblance to Infernal Exalted, she's developing in a very different way, and is also a Lunar in addition.

It won't be a good idea to rely on OOC knowledge about canon Infernals OR Lunars to judge how she could develop.
>>
No. 59335 ID: af25e0

It's fitting that the ED's emissary is themed after a creature that's vulnerable to gold.
>>
No. 59880 ID: 125053

There seems a little confusion, albeit not unreasonably so.

When Akatrina said "charming magic", she meant "social magic". The majority of magical powers in Exalted are grouped under a category which is called "Charms" in the original material, but Lunar Quest doesn't use that terminology.
>>
No. 59887 ID: d6c330

So we'd be agreeing to turn off scent of victory, and whatever Garm's using.

Does that also mean we're agreeing not to moon boost our stats? I was never clear if the stat boosts was something everyone could do, or if it was a protagonist only mechanic.
>>
No. 59919 ID: 125053

>>59887

All Heroes have their own form of Boost, and it would be part of the agreement, yes.
>>
No. 60282 ID: 075d9c

Heads up, no updates for the next two days at least due to temporary work. Also sorry for not updating before now.
>>
No. 60319 ID: cee89f

>>60282
Thanks for letting us know. =)
>>
No. 60427 ID: f03e5a

I look forward to checking back each day :). I'll keep reading so long as you keep writing Jukashi.
>>
No. 60431 ID: 521a34

Delay extended another two days due to extra work! More money, less updates. Sorry.
>>
No. 60432 ID: f2c20c

>>60431
DOSH.
>>
No. 60452 ID: f03e5a

>>60431
Make dat monay.
>>
No. 60489 ID: cee89f

>>60452
LIKE A BOSS
>>
No. 60669 ID: b6edd6

It just occurred to me... Can EXCEPTIONALLY STYLISH (but not actually magical) CLOTHES add to beauty?
>>
No. 60684 ID: 960513

I said we should include Beauty, but noo no one listens to me.</TimTheEnchanter>

Word blood, if we increase Beauty right now in social combat, will it be an Obvious transformation? So everyone will know we are using magic? Or would it be more subtle?
>>
No. 60685 ID: 960513

I said we should include Beauty, but noo no one listens to me.</TimTheEnchanter>

Word blood, if we increase Beauty right now in social combat, will it be an Obvious transformation? So everyone will know we are using magic? Or would it be more subtle?
>>
No. 60686 ID: d6c330

>>60684
Considering beauty is the one stat that isn't hidden from us on other combatants, they'd notice.

Besides, alteration of our base stats more than likely violates the no social magic agreement we made.
>>
No. 60688 ID: bf54a8

>>60686
except the link itself would say we aren't breaking the rules. dula would be freaked out yes, as whatever the fuck we just did DIDN'T set off the alarm. meaning she would know whatever we did WASN'T magic.
>>
No. 60689 ID: d6c330

Maybe it wouldn't break the letter of the rules we agreed to, but it certainly violates the intent. (Not sure how her powers work, and if that distinction matters).

And even if we do do it, we've given something away in front of an audience. Who can than ask us "wait, what did you just do" when we're bound to either tell the truth or make a weak evasion. Doesn't seem ideal.

I mean, we want to shoot her down, earn the lunar's respect, and diffuse the situation. Not to pique everyone's interest in finding out what kind of super-powered freak we are.
>>
No. 60706 ID: e148db

In the current debate with Akatrina, I don't think an outright victory with her conceding to us is likely, but we can likely improve our standing with her and make her more likely to be an ally in the future. We should also probably avoid the current topic of conversation (Dragon's Shadow is totally a "nice" guy), as that seems to be her objective. We probably shouldn't act TOO much on info we have about the Ebon Dragon that Wordblood knew, as that could raise suspicions that we are something more than a Lunar.
>>
No. 60715 ID: f2c20c

I think we need a new questdis.
>>
No. 60725 ID: 4a328b

GUYS after staring at it for a while, I think I've figured it out.

Askalaff isn't an owl or anything like that

His animal is obviously a bunny.
>>
No. 60748 ID: cee1fb

We definitely don't want to use Titanic magic in front of Akatrina. In her withdrawal from the "What are you here for" topic, she pretty much gave away that she's here for us, it's just that she doesn't know it yet.

We won't win outright, but that's okay, we don't need to. We just need to get the Lunars and her out of our house without things escalating into a bloodbath and without revealing ourselves.

And let's see if we can't turn that star of hers blue while we're at it. :D
>>
No. 60770 ID: b08105

Wow, social combat updates take a long time to write.
>>
No. 60851 ID: 3bad4c

So for everyone out there not used to debating (myself included), here are some basic lists to help you with noticing fallacy etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases
>>
No. 60855 ID: b6edd6

Some social combat mechanics questions relevant to our next move:
- Can we imply we are convinced of something without actually yielding the subject?
- Can other characters tell if they have won a topic? In particular, if we can make an implication like the previous question without it being yielding, will our unconvinced state be obvious through our not having lost the topic?

The particular statement I had in mind is: "If what you say is true, it sounds like Moon Heroes might be the ones I should be suspicious of here."


(...It is a very interesting game where talk is not in fact free and can be a direct danger in itself.)
>>
No. 60856 ID: 4d68b8

>>60855

Good thinking! That would basically be another method of Topic Shifting, but using Dickery and Deception instead of Inspiration and Leadership, and matched against relevant detection numbers. A slightly higher-risk strategy given the consequences if you fail (your opponent will know you were trying to be tricky), but could be just what one needs.
>>
No. 60862 ID: bf54a8

oh oh, and it should get the truth oath bonus. if we imply we agree, but never actually say it.
>>
No. 60863 ID: 34d817

Here's a question: We have Titan's Will available, and it's been previously implied that we can alter our non-physical attributes instantly. Could we use our Titan's Will to alter our own mind, by say applying a temporary strong belief, Heart's Desire, emotional state, or even reinforcing our Virtues?

And just as importantly, would we be able to do so without sending up a detectable flare of power?
>>
No. 60865 ID: f2c20c

>>60862
We don't get that bonus. We didn't make a truth oath.
>>
No. 60867 ID: 34d817

>>60863
Actually, been thinking on what we could use Titan's Will for here a little more, and it occurred to me that Wordblood is literally made of helpfulness and communication. Titanic Abilities which reflect that should be right up his alley, so if we're going to spend Titan's Will, we might as well invest them in something permanent. Perhaps something like one of the following:

Vizier's Veto: Wordblood becomes better at refuting arguments targeted at his friends or allies.

Trusted Advice: Wordblood gains bonuses when making arguments which are directed toward someone who holds Affection for him when his argument is intended to benefit them.

Either of those could save our ass- and since we only swore not to use Hero magic to influence Akatrina, even if we're openly burning Moon Power when we use them we can honestly say that the only one being affected is ourself.

Jukashi, your review of the feasibility of this would be appreciated.
>>
No. 60868 ID: 4d68b8

>>60867

Theoretically, Wordblood should have a TITAN BOOST, which would allow him to enhance his ability to do things that are suited to his particular nature. However, he doesn't, yet. Perhaps it is because he has no power pool of his own and must borrow from Saulanna, who uses incompatible Moon Power. Or perhaps she and he simply do not have strong enough titanic mojo in general yet?
>>
No. 60872 ID: 34d817

>>60868
That is... an interesting point worthy of investigation when we have time, but I don't see any direct method of applying it to solve our situation here. And the question of if we could invent and then implement a new base-level Titan's Working for Wordblood essentially instantly remains on the table.
>>
No. 60874 ID: 88e3f8

ha, this is why I love social combat - so twisty!

Jukashi do you have a writeup anywhere of the social combat rules you are using?
>>
No. 60876 ID: 740f31

>>57596
>>454394

And so Askalaffs midriff is exposed for us to see.
>>
No. 60879 ID: 4a328b

>>60876
Oh yeah, I wonder if we could read any thing else from those tattoos, or if we'd have to get him MORE nekkid to read it.
>>
No. 60880 ID: 61d996

>>60879
>MORE nekkid
Well he is a lunar, it can't be too hard.
>>
No. 60881 ID: cee89f

>>60880
He's also married =P
>>
No. 60882 ID: 61d996

>>60881
That's fine, we can invite her too.
>>
No. 60886 ID: cee89f

>>60882
That would require weeks of searching for her and getting him to her without arousing suspicion.
>>
No. 60888 ID: 61d996

>>60886
It'll be an open invitation. Whenever she gets to it. Maybe we can send her an nakedness IOU later or something.

...You shouldn't be taking this seriously, you know.
>>
No. 60889 ID: cee89f

>>60888
If I were, I'd point out how utterly tacky/trashy/terrible it is to do that =P

How do you even SEND a nekkidness IOU anyway?
>>
No. 60890 ID: 1987d1

>>60889
Via sexygram, of course.
>>
No. 60891 ID: cee89f

>>60890
That's not an IOU, though. That's just nekkid.
>>
No. 60895 ID: 612b01

Update will likely be delayed as I am moving back into college over the next couple of days.
>>
No. 60908 ID: cee89f

>>60895
I cannot properly express how glad I am that you actually TELL US this stuff.
>>
No. 60923 ID: 2eac65

We can form new Titanic abilities at will, right? If so, then here's one that should be immediately useful.

Refuge of the Unspoken
Every statement made is first formed in the speaker's mind, but not every statement formed is given the chance to be said. People are often forced to hold their tongues for a variety of reasons, such as contracts, threats of force, or the belief that their word would be poorly received. Though these words are not set free to roam, they still linger in their imprisonment, and can be heard if one knows the right way to listen.

While this ability is active, Saulanna can hear statements which others want to say, but feel they cannot. or should not In addition to the obvious uses in discovering information, this gives an advantage in social combat. For every well-crafted statement, the speaker goes through several versions which they usually discard for being less than eloquent, or including doubts which would undermine their credibility; awareness of these half-formed arguments will serve to disillusion Saulanna to her opponent's stated argument, granting a defensive bonus against persuasion.
>>
No. 60925 ID: 886a4d

I have no idea if that will work but it sounds really cool.
>>
No. 60933 ID: 2eac65

>>60925
Indeed! And it has an advantage I forgot to mention: it will allow Peregrin Kaan to support us without his statements being noticed by the others. And since he's also sworn not to deceive us, his words will be that much more effective.

Of course, it'll cost Titan's Will to form a new ability, but it shouldn't be too hard to reimburse the cost, so it's only a short-term loss.

And it'll also cost magic to activate, which will be suspicious, but I've thought of a way around that: if we activate it right after Askalaff says something, Akatrina will assume we're using social magics against/to resist him.

The trickiest part about this plan will be communicating it to Peregrin without tipping off the others, so he'll be able to help us. I haven't figured out a very good way to do that, and there's a good chance he's been oath-bound or otherwise forced not to interfere with the Dragon's recruiters. Hopefully, our perfect Language skill will help.
>>
No. 60934 ID: b6edd6

>>60923
It sounds useful if it works, but it also sounds like a specialized form of surface-thought-reading, which tricky diplomatic types probably have ways to avoid or sense.
>>
No. 60935 ID: 4a328b

I think it's worth worrying about how visible using Titan's Will is. We know Peregrin was observing our titanly shenanigans earlier, but I think he used a power for that. But I wonder if Akatrina, for one, might have something similar passively active since she was sent to investigate weirdness.

On the other hand, no one seems to notice WordBlood, so maybe it'd be fine as long as we didn't make any physical changes or light up with moon power.
>>
No. 60938 ID: 612b01

>>60923

You can spend TW to give Wordblood new Titanic Abilities, which Saulanna can use to her advantage, yes. But there are limits. Foremost is Wordblood's Soul Force, which is still only 2 - by the standards of his kind, he is only slightly less weak then the weakest he could be. Telepathy, while within his purview, is as yet beyond the scope of his power.

For another, there are prerequisite abilities. Wordblood's telepathic abilities, such as you suggest, involve him "reading" people, and are a few levels up of his World Reading Ability, which he does not yet have.

Perhaps you could think about abilities for sending rather than receiving?
>>
No. 60939 ID: 34d817

>>60938
Well, there are the basic social assistance sort of abilities in >>60867 which remain as possibilities, yes? Or are those for some reason infeasible/outside the range of Wordblood's current Soul Force?

As far as abilities for sending go, we don't even need to get a Titanic ability if the only one we want to talk to is Peregrin; we have infinite Linguistics through Wordblood and should therefore be able to phrase a sentence in such a way that he'll interpret it to contain a hidden message which only he can catch. I suppose we could get a Titanic Ability to make the message explicitly obvious to him, in case he might otherwise be too oblivious to pick up on hidden meanings, or to conceal our message particularly well from everyone else in case they might notice that there's something there.
>>
No. 60944 ID: 4a328b

The Whispered Word

Wordblood passes a message directly to the mind of a specified target nearby. This message is received as though Saulanna is whispering in the recipient's ear, but no actual sound is involved, so there is no risk of the message being intercepted by others.

am I doing this properly
>>
No. 61113 ID: cee89f

...This is kinda late, but do we the (players/suggesters/quest participants/whatever-you-wanna-call-us) represent the past lives function of the Lunar Exaltation? (VOICES FROM THE PAST from the first few posts in thread one?)
>>
No. 61119 ID: 740f31

>>60895

What are you studying? If you don't mind me asking.
>>
No. 61164 ID: 368bd2

I am actually expecting him to say "No", it leads nicely into a nice retreat from the conversation. On the off chance he says "Yes", then that has to give us a bonus to resist and reject outright, as it's clearly walking into harm's way.

Either way, it should force our Lunar friends to up the ante on their social attack, or encourage them to open fighting, either of which would help get us out of this losing conversation.

At this point, I don't see a way to win that doesn't involve a tactical retreat - or spending TW to force his hand.

Can WordBlood give us a magically enforced motivation or similar - ie, a perfect social defence?
>>
No. 61261 ID: 33f08d

Question posted from phone.

How much would a hero be able to tell about a power word just from hearing it? For instance, if we used STOP during Akatrina's next argument, would she/the moon heroes be able to tell it was titanic? Were power words unique to He who bleeds, rare enough that nobody but a fellow Titan would recognize one, or something the Dragon does as a matter of course?

I ask because we swore not to use our Lunar powers, but if Akatrina thinks its a form of sorcery (unlikely, I know) we could use it to make her skip her next turn and give us an opening.
>>
No. 61264 ID: bf54a8

>>61261
the exalted were specifically built to fight titans. as such they have innate senses when it comes to titan powers.
>>
No. 61288 ID: 888f37

>>61264
Is this something Jukashi said is true in Lunar Quest?
Because otherwise, no, they don't have any such innate senses.
>>
No. 61289 ID: cee89f

>>61264
>>61288
It makes some sense that Heroes would have resistance to titan powers too, but Peregrin had jack. Just want to make sure using titan powers and keeping their origins a secret isn't an option here.
>>
No. 61290 ID: 62bab4

If nothing else, it will be blatantly obvious to all three of them that we just did something pretty powerful that no newbie Lunar can normally do. Even if they can't directly tell it was titanic, that's still bad. It's a small short term gain for a much bigger disadvantage and exposure.

Akatrina might be the most likely to recognize titanic magic for what it is, since she's working directly for a titan. Ask is the next most likely, since he seems to know a thing or two about them.
>>
No. 61297 ID: cee89f

>>61290
We're trying to convince the moon heroes we AREN'T just the average overconfident newbie, aren't we? =P
>>
No. 61299 ID: 62bab4

We want to show them we're competent enough to leave alone, to be trusted.

We don't want them to think we're special or unique in a way that needs to be secured and/or protected before we can be allowed to go crazy or fall under the shadow's sway. Neither do we want them to think we're dangerous and need to be destroyed.
>>
No. 61300 ID: 2b7692

>>61297
No, we're trying to convince them to not push tattoos on us and let us stay without either jeopardising future relations with other Lunars and more importantly not raise suspicions about us that could reveal our titanic nature.

Unless we find out that in this setting there are Infernals who've gone Devil-Tiger and not been murdered(Which I think is somewhat unlikely because Jukashi hadn't read BWC before Lunar Quest started) then keeping our Titanic nature hidden is one of, if not the most important goal we have until' we get significantly higher soulforce or earn major points with the Incarnae .
>>
No. 61345 ID: cee89f

>>61300
*shrug* it'd still be nice to know. Just to be sure.
>>
No. 61419 ID: cee89f

>>61345
Looking back, Wordblood earlier said that Heroes probably have a way to tell when a spell or effect is titanic. It's not a sure thing, but it's likely, and if he knew for sure he would've said so. Dang =(
>>
No. 61434 ID: f5588d

It just occurred to me that Death Hero McHorse might have an ability that lets her lie by first convincing herself that her lie is the truth.

"Hey! Me! The Ebon Dragon isn't a douche!"

"That's a very good point, me. I guess it must me true!"

"Hey! You! The Ebon Dragon isn't a douche."

"My magic senses tell me she isn't lying."
>>
No. 61438 ID: 2babec

>>61434
theoretically possible but not really necessary.
>>
No. 61487 ID: cee89f

>>61434
What >>61438 said. Especially since it's very, VERY dangerous to have an ability that gives you a belief you can't question.
>>
No. 61488 ID: 997ce7

>>61434
I'd like to add that there's probably an ability that tells you if something is objectively true.
>>
No. 61494 ID: 2babec

>>61488
well that would require an objective value of "douche"
>>
No. 61501 ID: cee89f

>>61494
"Feminine cleaning product"

...

Well you asked =P
>>
No. 61572 ID: f5588d

>>61487

How so? Somebody willing to rewrite their own personality to win an argument will not have difficulty (emotionally) putting it back where it began after the new personality ceases to be useful.

Unless the new belief is something like, "I am not a giant prat who rewrites their own personality".

But at that point their head would explode.
>>
No. 61589 ID: b6edd6

>>61572
Believing that something is true involves believing that something is true, so she would only know to change her mind back if she was using some sort of convoluted 1984 doublethink system in which she simultaneously believes and does not believe a statement.
>>
No. 61594 ID: f54e12

>>61589
and in that case she doesn't need to brainwash herself anyway
>>
No. 61602 ID: bdb3f8

>>61434
I am not sure why you think self-delusion is a super power anyway.
>>
No. 61612 ID: f5588d

>>61589

Except for, you know, memories.
>>
No. 61624 ID: cee89f

>>61612
Beliefs change over time, and if she uses such a spell and tells herself she believes something, she has no real need or desire to switch it back, because she believes the new belief as strongly as she did the old, maybe even stronger.
>>
No. 61642 ID: 9f4ba5

You know, I don't think Askalaff or Peregrin have the type of scores to change this subject away from this obvious victory, or save our own will, but Akatrina is both sparing us some damage and giving a viable topic to change to with her last comment. I think she might have heard that we're defending our Lunar independence and decided to prove our own strength with this argument so she could keep us around Dragon's Shadow.

Frankly I also think she somehow realized we were a titan with that contact we shared, and is now preparing us for Shadow; but I also don't think vassalizing us as Akuma would do much for Shadow at this point too, so I don't know how I feel about this.
>>
No. 61650 ID: cee89f

>>61642
That's an awful lot of conjecture with very little evidence. If any.
>>
No. 61658 ID: b23677

>>61642
Why on earth would you think they didn't have the score? Askalaff is there to recruit us, of course he's going to be at least PARTIALLY a charisma type, and don't we already basically KNOW peregrin is? And they'd both be taking actions, so its peregrin+askalaff+the bonus to being able to trust peregrin.
>>
No. 61662 ID: 2b7692

>>61642
Peregrin can use magic during this and he's managed to maintain a great deal of independence and not fall head over heels for the Dragon even with Akatrina stopping by regularly. He might not be stronger then her, but he's competitive, would likely have a bonus(to defense at least) fom his oath, and we'd out number Akatrina.
>>
No. 61690 ID: eab5ff

Even if the subject hasn't shifted officially, it seems to me that that second attack has shifted us almost entirely to a new topic.

Perhaps that would give a large bonus to the topic change, who-ever does it, as long as it is within that theme.

Also, if the topic -is- shifted, wordlbood could continue to bolster our resolve on the other topic.

I've gotten some ideas from the conversation, and have a suggestion for what to say, but I know that it will need work before the actual response, so I'm posting it here before the main thread.

Please pardon the lack of formatting, I'm not sure how to do that here yet.

"Now wait a minute, I'm a Lunar. I don't remember being in any war, or having to protect anyone, but you're making me out to be the bad-guy here. It'd be the same with your Lunar mate... and even you, and Peregrin, if you're blaming all of us for the failures of past lives. You're even making us sound like we're worse than the Ebon Dragon was when he was still the Ebon Dragon. I don't see how that can be."

"Even if that's your perspective, that just doesn't seem right. Peregrin, Askalaff? Are we really all that bad?"

As I see it, this is a refutation of her point, and an invitation to two others to either refute, or change topics, possibly giving them bonuses due to the invitation, and the closely linked topic.

There might also the possibility of focusing on a very specific portion of the existing topic.

"Mmmm. You're bringing up a lot of good inteesting points, but I'd like to know more about how you said he could help me avoid that chimera problem Askalaff was talking about. Can he really do that? How? How well would it work? Peregrin? Have you ever heard of this before? Which do you think would work better, the tatoos, or the titan thingy?"

Can we burn Titans will to get conversation will back? Would it make us glow in any way?

Also, we said we wouldn't use our lunar hero magic to influence her, but we didn't say that we would not use it to keep ourselves from being influenced.

Can't we use some mana to boost our own defences against being convinced by her arguments, while leaving Wormblood, and Peregrin able to convince us not to trust the Dragon's Shadow at this time? I know that using it to convince her is out, but this seems different.
>>
No. 61691 ID: eab5ff

We might also be able to spend TW to increase our non-visible social stats.
>>
No. 61693 ID: cee89f

>>61690
That oath prevents us from using our magic to boost our social stats, so no, no moon power, and probably no titan's will, since it relies on whether or not SAULANNA thinks she broke her oath.
>>
No. 61694 ID: 9718f3

>>61693
Saulanna used tricky wording to agree to not use her moon abilities. She deliberately left herself open to using Titan powers.
>>
No. 61695 ID: bf54a8

also we agreed to moon powers that would effect talking. can do other things.
>>
No. 61700 ID: cee89f

>>61694
WE think of it that way. Does she?
>>
No. 61701 ID: cee89f

>>61694
WE think of it that way. Does Saulanna?
>>
No. 61737 ID: eab5ff

No, we didn't agree to not moon power to boost social stats. We agreed to use moon power to influence her.

"But I'll swear not to use any of my Hero magic to influence you,"

I'm not saying we use our magic to influence her, but rather, to defend ourselves, or to make it easier to convince ourselves of something by counter-arguing to ourselves.
>>
No. 61738 ID: eab5ff

That is, if we have that amount of control / granularity over our own powers.
>>
No. 61739 ID: 86c3a7

>No, we didn't agree to not moon power to boost social stats.
I'm afraid that's incorrect. See:

>>59887
>Does that also mean we're agreeing not to moon boost our stats?
>>59919
>it would be part of the agreement, yes.
>>
No. 61740 ID: eab5ff

Okay, here's a list of the options/resources that seem open to us that I, personally, think would be acceptable ones, and might yield results, as well as seeming to be available, based on the discussion so far, and Jukashi's summary.

1. We use moon power -not on Akatrina-, to boost our social stats. This would be if we use it on Askalaff or ourselves.

2. We boost our Inspiration, Sass (if possible), or some other social stat. We might even be able to boost our own dickishness, and use that. We can't boost appearance, but that's okay, for now.

3. We get Wormblood to boost his ability to send thoughts to people, and use this to contact Preregrin to get him to change the topic.

4. We ceede territory by agreeing that it seems like the Dragon's Shadow isn't worth opposing outright, unless more information comes to light later, thus allowing us to shift the topic. He's powerful enough we probably don't want to outright oppose him for a long anyway.

5. Outright retreat, in order to regroup. We say we need to head to the bathroom, or something. I'd like to avoid arguments based on "I can't handle this" due to the long term implications. "I am angry, and excusing myself to calm down", on the other hand, would be entirely appropriate, and even fit the arguments Akatrina made earlier.

My favorite option thus far if we can pull it off is #5, followed by #3, followed by combining 1 and 2, followed by #4.
>>
No. 61741 ID: eab5ff

>>61739
>>No, we didn't agree to not moon power to boost social stats.
>I'm afraid that's incorrect. See:

>>460339
>She can also try to use trickery to get Akatrina or Askalaff to shift Topic, including Boosting herself in the latter case;

It is a conditional agreement. We agreed not to use moon power to influence her, we made no other agreement to limit our use of it. I left the word 'not' out of my previous post in error. Apologies there.

Bottom line, Jukashi himself has said we can use moon power on people other than Akatrina, and I think this includes using it to influence ourselves - such as when we are rebutting to convince ourselves of something, rather than someone else.

This is because we never agreed -not- to. Context is important.
>>
No. 61746 ID: eab5ff
File 134941223438.png - (52.74KB , 560x323 , Ranma_vs_Picolet_-_Manga.png )
61746

Well, hello everyone. I came in too late to contribute to Chapter 1, and am very glad to see Chapter 2 up and running. I hope to be a helpful contributer, and (especially since I'm new), don't intend to jump into the main thread too often without discussing here first.

Also, since I'm replying to quite a lot that's happened, I've made several posts. It'll drop off soon, and I really don't mean to dominate the discussion, that said, there's still something I'd like to weigh in on.

That was quite a lot of reading to get caught up on the discussion of the Feeder Deva. I wanted to see what kind of consensus, if any, had been reached.

So far, it seems to me that while there is not a firm consensus, people would like a somewhat restrained feeding grace, who's element reflects the fact that Miss Rockblossom is an intelligent young woman, who cares about doing the right thing and restraining herself. As well as people wanting a theme that is in concert with, but does not stomp on, or dominate Wordblood's theme of communication. (Please pardon when I called him wormblood before).

Others want something tied in some way to civilization, or growth, and spreading.

I, personally, would like to suggest the theme of "culture". A Feeding Deva with an element of culture would eat politely, and with restraint (good table manners), get along well with those that communicate well, and yet is it's own concept. We could eat customs we don't like to remove them, and also feed well upon spreading customs and idioms we do like.

And to touch on the earlier conversation of eating elements, she could use any number of eating implements.

A cultured deva would also serve us well in the current social arena in which we find ourselves.

And while some might find Miss Rockblossom becoming cultured, or emphasizing what part of her current nature is cultured to be a bit stuffy, I don't think it would be a particularly negative trait, especially as it is already balanced by her Lunar nature.

Besides, some cultures have some particularly harsh, or fun cultures or traditions.

If this Feeding Deva gets some area of Miss Rockblossom's head-space to call her own, I imagine it would grow into a large mansion, with not only a library, but also an elegant dining hall, and possibly a hunting-grounds outside (eventually). It might start as something as simple as a well kept single-room flat, with many books, and a nice large dining table and dining set.

I realize that we can't pick everything. Appearance, personality, and exact starting abilities being off the list, I'd like Jukashi to at least consider some influence from the image included.

I think that having her look like a combination of Miss Rockblossom, and Miss "Ranko Tendo" (on the right) would be nice. I think it would behoove the feeding deva to develop abilities similar to Mr. Chardin's ability to eat things very very quickly, without appearing unsightly, except under duress.

Perhaps we might even find a use for something along the lines of "Gourmet du Foie Gras", though that's just something silly, and I doubt we'd develop in that direction.

In any case, I've probably rambled on a bit too much, so now that I've presented my idea, and how I think it combines elements already discussed, I will end this post.
>>
No. 61747 ID: eab5ff

Pardon, part of the above should read:
"Even still, I'd like Jukashi to consider"

I apologize for the edit-error that made the above unclear.

I realize we have limited control over said Deva, but I'm still hoping Jukashi will consider some aspect of the above as a possibility if we go with the 'culture' rout.
>>
No. 61769 ID: eab5ff

Regarding the "squeamishness" argument.

My main reason for wanting to get us some privacy is not to devour. My main reason is that our best strength at the moment seems to be Wordblood countering everyone else's arguments internally.

I think that having another deva doing the exact same thing would be one of the best possible boosts we could have.

And, if we have enough left over to boost one of our social stats, or we can get another boost to TW -without much glowing- in order to boost our social stats, so much the better.

As pleased as I am to be able to contribute to the discussion on how the feeding deva would work, I don't think we'd be in quite the same mess if we already had one when all of this occured.
>>
No. 61770 ID: 86c3a7

>>61769
That kind of assumes the new feeding deva would be up and ready for action. It's quite possible it would start out in some kind of infant or child stage and be unable to participate fully. (Worst case, it's basically a glowing battery slowly producing titan's will until we upgrade it).

Also, Wordblood's thing is communication/words. I'm not sure how effectively a deva of anything else might be able to rebut for us (unless the subject overlaps with their specialty, I suppose?).
>>
No. 61771 ID: 34d817

>>61746
There's not much consensus in this game... ever, really. It doesn't help that updates are generally far enough apart that we have plenty of time to bicker. I'm sticking with >>59034 as our growth path for Lord souls unless new information is presented which makes it obviously nonviable, personally.
>>
No. 61774 ID: eab5ff

While I don't find it particularly likely, I will admit that the possibility of a new-born or uncommunicative deva is a weakness of my plan. Then again, no plan is perfect.

Also, that's one of the reasons why I prefer a shift in element from civilization to culture. It's a difference in the over-all flavor, really. It's that aspect of civilization that you bring with you, wherever you go. However, it carries connotations of polite communication, and manners. It also carries connotations of not leaving a mess everywhere when you're done eating.

In other words, I think a feeding deva of culture is more likely to be useful in the social arena, as well as being one of the best elements we could pick for our desire to not send shreds of energy flying everywhere when we feed. It's not <em>stealth</em> exactly, just eating in a clean and polite way that doesn't disturb the senses of others.

That said, a Deva of culture is less likely to have any combat abilities, aside from being good in a duel, when we eventually get the ability to bring our devas outside. War is a hallmark of civilization, and so a feeding deva of civilization would probably be really good when it comes to coordinating supply lines .

As for why I don't find it plausible that our new deva will just be a battery, or a newborn with no mind at all, is due to my experience with the exalted setting. I've read up on the various component souls of Titans, and from my understanding, they come into existence formed with a mind, and a personality ready to go.

I find it more likely that such a deva would be at some level of disadvantage due to not knowing a lot about the world with which we are interacting... but I still think that we would get some use out of such a soul.

If people would prefer to go right to boosting social stats, I'm up for that too. I am just firmly convinced that it would be advantageous to regroup, and use our resources in a way that doesn't harm us, but will advantage us.


>>59034
As far as the other devas go, I can get behind the idea of one of our first two devas being one with a purpose of diplomacy, and an element of good will. It's definitely in theme, would be very helpful, and given how heavy we're going on the social-concept side of our elements, it would very strongly distinguish us from Cyclene.

We might even consider making this one first, given the situation we are in. However, that might reduce our long-term growth, so I'd prefer to go with the feeding deva first.

As to the third Deva proposed,
>>
No. 61775 ID: eab5ff

Please pardon the cut off line.

As to the third Deva proposed, I would prefer to wait and see before taking a stance on something that would happen that far out.
>>
No. 61801 ID: 34d817

>>61775
You might strongly consider using the board's delete function and combining otherwise-consecutive posts into one when you feel the need to post again before any other person has done so. Particularly in situations where you might otherwise have, say, five posts in a row. Post length is near-unlimited here (it's tens of thousands of words), so there's not much excuse for splitting posts up when you don't have to.
>>
No. 61815 ID: eab5ff

I attempted to do so, and the delete function did not work for me. I've tried checking the box to the left, and I've tried clicking on the "no" link. I presumed that it was just broken.

After some more experimentation, it appears that the reason in some cases was a problem with the passwords.

I'd go back and combine previous posts that I can now that I understand how it's working, but I'd only be able to delete some, there have been replies, and in the end it'd probably just make a mess of things.

I'll be more careful with that feature in the future.

I apologize for any inconvenience this has caused in the mean time.
>>
No. 61849 ID: 2eac65

I think the answer is to to use a new Titan ability, since our nature is optimized to the current situation and no one else would recognize the loophole. Thus, I propose this:

Rhyme of Reason
While many people can come up with well-developed reasoning behind their beliefs, fewer will notice when their reasons apply to positions they're already opposed to. These similarities, if brought to light, can be the vital crack in a stubborn mental defense.

This ability allows Saulanna to, by accepting one of a target's beliefs, redirect their own skill at them to convince them of another, similar belief. By relying on already accepted premises, the target will be predisposed to agreeing with the new position.
>>
No. 61860 ID: cee89f

>>61849
... Or we could make that mind-speak ability Wordblood offered, talk to Peregrin through it and NOT try and trick the system in a way that utterly breaks it?
>>
No. 61861 ID: 34d817

>>61860
In Exalted you'd better break the system, because your enemies certainly are.

May or may not apply here, admittedly.
>>
No. 61864 ID: eab5ff

>>61860

... Wordblood did say he could create the ability to talk to Perigrin, possibly, though I thought it was an unreliable possibility.

... Maybe it'd be best to get him to create that ability and contact Peregrin to get him to help us get out of the conversation temporarily, so that we can have a bit of momentary privacy to power up.

It'd depend on whether we would wind up with enough TW left to create that feeding deva, or, alternatively, to boost our social stats enough.

We might also be able to cooedinate better with him in order to get those slavers he mentioned, so that we can get the feeding deva and some social stat boosts... though there would be some extra risk there.
>>
No. 61891 ID: cee89f

>>61861
Not like this.

>>61864
Changing the tattoos was unreliable - Wordblood left the impression that he could DEFINITELY recreate the ability to speak into the minds of others. Looking back, the issue is that we wouldn't be able to hear responses... and... huh. Okay, so this plan IS inoperable. Never mind.
>>
No. 61915 ID: 404f8a

>>61891
So what if we can't get a response back, as long as the person we're communicating to actually gets the message? Dragon-blooded have a charm that does this too, more or less; it's called Wind-Carried Words Technique.
>>
No. 61923 ID: cee89f

>>61915
Telling Peregrin we're going to go eat the souls he told us about isn't gonna help if we can't find out where those souls are =p
>>
No. 62114 ID: d0bebe

Due to the fact that there are parallel discussions going on along the same ends, I'm just going to post my response in the discussion thread, and link to it in the main thread. I'm doing it that way due to Jukashi requesting that discussions/arguments occur in the discussion thread.

-----

Okay, first of all, the use of Titan's Will. I've reviewed the gaining and use of Moon Power, and it seems to me that gaining titan's will causes an increase in soul fire, while expending the titan's will does not.

Titan's Will Gained
>>194720 to >>194725
>>213360 to >>213361
>>405260 to >>405263


Titan's Will Spent
>>195051 to >>195053
>>208242 to >>209202
>>214068 to >>214385
>>405261
>>409522 to >>410751, special note >>410751

The second, and last examples of spending TW seem to be the most illustrative, as the others were done either as a part of gaining TW, or while our Soul Fire was at full. In these two example no increase occurs in the soulfire when we expend TW.

As such, if there is any risk of being discovered due to use of soulfire, it would be due to gaining TW, not expending it. Further, Wordblood said in >>409526
>"Beyond that, though, a Feeding Soul would also assist with the recovery and management of magical Power, and may even be able to do something about this troublesome Soul Fire of yours."

So there might not be a problem with the Soul Fire, even if Saulanna does consume a spirit (though if we decide to risk it, I'd recommend going with one of the lower-powered spirits available).

Also, recall that Jukashi said in >>18322 that "Efficiency of Consumption would reduce the light show that comes with it, and provide an additional measure of Titan's Will each time a soul is absorbed".

If we create this Feeding Deva, then we will have both Wordblood, and the feeder, both with Efficiency of Consumption 2. The "Light show" should be decreased in power, particularly for less potent spirits.

As such, using Titan's Will mid-conversation should be safe, in general. Creating the Feeding Deva, on the other hand, is an involved and possibly painful process, and so should only be done when we have a few minutes to recover, at least.

-----

As to the question of contacting Perigrin surreptitiously, keep in mind that if Saulanna is sending instructions to her vassal, he need not communicate back in order to follow those instructions, unless communicating back is a part of them. If she tells him to get her out of the conversation, and take her to a secure location, and bring her the least secure ghost, he would attempt to do so, unless doing so would be disastrous for a reason he can't communicate back. In that case, lack of compliance is it's own communication.

At the very least, we can tell him to aid our own clumsy attempts to make a temporary withdrawal, in order to regroup. Besides, I think that it would be nice to let Wordblood communicate (which seems a part of his purpose) with others besides us, directly, though only if they already know, or we want to show his existence. It might also help to smooth some future situations over.

The only downside that I see to this is that if we want to do this and make the Feeder Deva, we couldn't raise Saulanna's Soul Force back to 3 without her consuming a spirit.

-----

Regarding the attempt to get Saulanna out of the conversation with the others, and my reference to accusations being used against us: Each Moon Hero soul empowers a human multiple times, and while some may have memories of past lives, these are new beings. Given the age ranges given, it's certain that neither of these Moon Heroes personally fought in the Usurpation, yet Akatrina is treating the failures of the Usurpation, and what lead up to it as belonging to them. To be logically consistent, she must be similarly blaming her own Moon Hero partner, and Saulanna for the part their previous incarnations played, even if she has "nothing personal against Moon Heroes". These are all conclusions we can reach from the information that has been portrayed in character.

While this hasn't been revealed in character yet, the Silver Pact was formed after the usurpation, and many of it's factions recognized the previous failures, and based new philosophies on avoiding them. Further, they did NOT expend all of their resources fighting the Deathlords, nor did they spend all of that time building up power and nothing else. They were battered by the Baloran Crusade more than perhaps any other group of Exalts, and were an intrinsic part of turning back that tide. They also were the first line of defense against fair folk incursions before and after that, and were also fighting escaped demons, realm and sidereal forces seeking to kill them, AND the Death Lords all at once, while attempting to build up their power bases.

The fact that there are still Moon Heroes at all, or a creation to Defend is testament to their prowess, especially when opperating out of the paradigm they were created with in mind, where they were supporting and supported by the other exalt types. I hope to see some of this come up in Askalaff's rebuttals, as this information severely undercuts the validity of Akatrina's arguments, and Askalaff seems studious enough to know all of that.

-----

Finally, as to the Dragon's Shadow. The wyld is a dangerous and chaotic place, wherein Unshaped monstrosities dwell. The Titans created Creation as a sanctuary from these very same creatures. As such, saying that the Ebon Dragon did not flee one well-known set of dangers he could plan around, in order to exist among unknown dangers is not a statement of new-found courage. Further, it is in his nature to betray, and it is difficult to betray chaos, for most of the creatures in deep chaos are not going to be around, or remember long enough to be betrayed. Those that are likely see stories of betrayal as a kind of game, and a favor. It would be difficult for him to slake his thirst for true betrayal in the deep chaos.

He has set up a new sun, which he may be able to use to give himself more flexibility in defining what he opposes. He has also taken the shadowy underworld, full of strife, and decay as his domain, which is in line with the worst of his nature both before and after he was locked away in Malfeas. He knew he could not take Yu Shan, and creation was more of a gamble. Taking the underworld better fit his nature, and made it more likely that he would not be opposed on additional fronts, as he would have been had he tried to take creation.

And his relationship with the titans? The main reason that the other Titans put up with him was that despite being a dickish betrayer, he was useful. Also, if you were the one he betrayed most recently, you were not in a position to oppose him, while if you were not, he just did you a service by bringing one of the other titans lower than your own status. He used these aspects to play the other Titans against each-other and keep his own position secure.

There is an ancient adage. "To fool your enemies, you must first fool your allies." This could easily apply to the relationship that The Ebon Dragon has with Akatrina. It is in his nature to betray, and fooling her into trusting him in a way he should not be trusted may well be the way he is betraying her personally.
>>
No. 62123 ID: d1d807

I love our infinite language ability.

In the previous chapter wordblood said that
> Knowing his True Name, you will be able to use your magic on him wherever he goes.
Does this mean we can use Voice in the Dark to send Peregrin a message over any distance? Or does the "Saulanna must be able to see them" requirement override that? How does magic on one's true name work?
>>
No. 62124 ID: df5417

>>62123

She can send him a message from anywhere.
>>
No. 62133 ID: bf54a8

we can send a message to ANYONE we can SE. but for people we know the true name of we can send one from ANYWHERE. basically the name knowing is THAT big of an upgrade.
>>
No. 62173 ID: dd287a

There seems to be this whole morality discussion in teh quest for some reason, perhaps it should be over here instead?
My take on it is this, We are a Lunar, our primary objective at all times is to survive, screw everybody else if it comes to it, besides, judging by how the last ghost made our intrepid hero sick with the mere knowledge of their skills, these people arn't exactly saints.
>>
No. 62211 ID: cee89f

>>62173
At any rate, it's a discussion for another time. Right now, we are basically screwed if we don't get at least enough TW to do that multi-part plan to create a feeder soul. One should be enough, since the only reason we don't have enough now is because we spent the 1 to make the Voice in the Dark ability.
>>
No. 62231 ID: e297bb

>>62173
Indeed, this would be the place to have that discussion, but unless the one person who keeps riling that discussion up comes here to discuss it, any answer we settle on here will not be lasting.

That said, if anyone wants some more info about how the various souls work in the Exalted setting, I'd be happy to provide the mechanics.

>>62211
To clarify, we actually have enough Titan's Will at the moment to create the Feeder Deva. We simply don't have enough to increase Saaulanna's Soul Force back to 3 afterward. But the plan it's self, includes that, and yes, it would take only 1 very minor member of the slavers to restore us to that point in the plan. In fact, Wordblood's Efficiency of Consumption ability gives an extra dot of Titan's Will for each consumed ghost. If we persue this after we already have the Feeder Deva, who will also have this ability, and it's own feeding purpose, then we may well get even more.

As a result, we can afford to spend one more point of TW on the creation of the Feeding Deva than the minimum Wordblood explained.

Copying Wordblood's feeding abilities to the new Feeding Deva costs a single TW, we copy his (or, possibly, Saulanna's) abilities relating to civilization, culture, and ettiquite. This would help to cement the element of the Feeder Deva that the group seems to be leaning toward. We might even be able to copy over our ability to be stealthy, when it comes to how the Feeding Deva eats, since one of the ways that Wordblood has said this Deva might help us is by fixing the "Soul Fire" problem... at least when it comes to the feeding.
>>
No. 62234 ID: cee89f

>>62231
I didn't say we couldn't make the deva - I said we didn't have enough to do the PLAN to create a feeder soul, which includes raising it back to 3. The fact Wordblood brought it up at all tells me that raising it again will help in some way - otherwise it makes more sense to conserve our TW until we have both the feeder deva AND more will to throw around. Given we have no real way to quickly gain TW at the moment, raising it to 3 isn't a small investment - judging from the Voice in the Dark ability, we could've gotten another ability or two in addition to the voice.

This is mostly speculation, but i assumed raising it back to 3 was a significant part of that plan since we were so low on TW and we had no way of knowing how we would get our next batch or what the most useful expenditures of said will would turn out to be in the near future.
>>
No. 62241 ID: e297bb

>>62234
I did not mean to imply that you did not know that. I simply thought that some readers in general might not be aware of the difference between the plan as a whole, and simply creating the Feeder Deva.

It seems like having a higher Essence than any of the other Devas, while not the totality of what determines Saulana as the main Deva, helps to cement that fact. That is, indeed, an important consideration. It also improves out over-all potency as far as resisting some effects are concerned.

However, it is also my stance that having the Feeder Deva is one of the best options open to us at the moment, for the following reasons.

1. It most likely serves short term needs by giving us yet another resource to help us resist mental influence.

While it is possible that the Deva will come into being with less ability to help us than we'd like, I don't find it at all likely that it will not be of any use at all.

Making our skills with culture and ettiquite explicitly a part of the Deva to start with will maximize it's possibility of being useful to us in the short term, I think.

2. It will maximize Saulanna's gains of power through feeding, and also allow her to gain power without feeding.

If we want to continue to gain in power without feeding on ghosts, we're basically in a "Rats of Nihm" situation. Short term we're grabbing more, in order to establish our ability to do without grabbing any.
There is also the possiblity of consuming written works, but given that the largest source of written works is currently unaviailable, that's not really a possibility right now.

However if we have a choice between having ghosts copy down the library for us to consume the copy, and consuming those ghosts, long term, I'll argue for the former over the latter.

3. If we do continue to eat ghosts, it would be a good idea to get as much out of them as possible, and to minimize the flare of Soul Fire from doing so. Wordblood said that the Feeder Deva might help with that. I think that choosing it's nature well, and giving it further abilities at the start related to that element/purpose would maximize that chance.

So, in my analysis, the 3 reasons for creating the Feeding Deva in the first place are to remove a vulnerability, improve our long-term gain of power, and to improve our ability / remove a disability in social combat, which is important in the short term.

If we do decide to go with the Feeder Deva, then we should maximize it's utility toward these 3 reasons for picking it. It is my opinion that choosing the element of "culture", and granting it copies of our (or Wordblood's) social abilities would maximize the Feeding Deva's utility toward these objectives.

I think it would also help to minimize what downsides, if any, we do experience from creating one.

If I am over-looking something, or there is another objective to persue in creating this Feeding Deva, I would like to hear this information.
>>
No. 62250 ID: 2eac65

>Lack of Titan's Will
Since we only lack one point, we could just delay copying Ease of Consumption onto the new soul until after we get more.

On that note, suggesting we design our Feeding Soul specifically to solve our immediate problem is unwise. It's going to be a fundamental part of our personality, and we need to approach it from that perspective, creating one that reflects what Saulanna wants to become and what "consuming" means to her. We've already got a soul that's specialized in social interaction, so if we need help with that, we can expand on Wordblood's abilities; we don't need to make a whole new soul just for it.
>>
No. 62256 ID: e297bb

>>62250
Hmm. An interesting proposition, however the point that goes to that would also copy over Efficiency of Consumption. Coppying those two over was described as a part of the things Wordblood described as being bound together.

>>409526
>"a single measure to safely divide off part of your soul, another for me to copy my own feeding enhancements over, and finally 2 more to bring it all together and breathe life into the new spirit."

If we don't copy those over, I'm not sure if it would be a Feeding Deva at all, let alone a very good one.

As for your other point, I am not suggesting that we make it merely for our short-term gain. That is merely one of 3 objectives we are seeking to persue, and it is my opinion that we can satisfy all 3 quite well with a single action. Observing and considering one objective does not preclude fulfilling the other two.

I am, rather, arguing that we should not reduce our long term capability to take an action that would only serve our short term needs, but cut off longer term growth.

I have yet to hear any reasons why choosing an element of "Culture" would be a bad choice, long term.
>>
No. 62263 ID: 44f93b

>I have yet to hear any reasons why choosing an element of "Culture" would be a bad choice, long term.
Really, to me, it seems like a more narrow choice than civilization, with possible weakness in that in encompasses things that aren't actually useful (see Saulanna's problem when we brought up table manners- too much information, and not enough of it applicable).
>>
No. 62264 ID: 2eac65

>>62256
That linked to /questdis/. Here's how you link cross-board:
>>/quest/409526
>"a single measure to safely divide off part of your soul, another for me to copy my own feeding enhancements over, and finally 2 more to bring it all together and breathe life into the new spirit."
Ah, right. I remembered it as being one point each.

>I have yet to hear any reasons why choosing an element of "Culture" would be a bad choice, long term.
Because it doesn't fit the concept of a feeding soul at all. It's an attempt to accomplish two unrelated goals with the same action, and the result is awkward and doesn't reflect Saulanna's personality.
>>
No. 62301 ID: 3bad4c

My suggestion:
Jukashi, make a new quest thread every time people go discussing things that should be in here.

Eventually, even the stupidest fucks will get it. Plus, their stupid discussions get hidden away in the archives.

You should understand; you are dealing with trolls and you need to be heavy handed!
>>
No. 62310 ID: cee89f

>>62301
*sigh*
'Troll' and 'moron', despite common belief, are two different things
>>
No. 62319 ID: 3bad4c

That doesn't change anything.
>>
No. 62329 ID: cee89f

>>62319
Yes it does. Trolling is done on purpose - moronic behavior will continue even if Jukashi makes a new thread.
>>
No. 62369 ID: 34d817

>>62256
>I have yet to hear any reasons why choosing an element of "Culture" would be a bad choice, long term.
It more closely overlaps with Wordblood's "Communication" and lacks many of the large-scale utility purposes of "Civilization", in my opinion. The latter should let us construct and control cities, realign ley lines, warp terrain to become more controlled and hospitable- all sorts of things which don't directly involve people at all. It's also more narrow in what it would let us harvest energy from, in my opinion.

Not saying it's a bad choice, I just don't think it's as good.
>>
No. 62370 ID: f3bd64

Just so that people know; Saulanna's personality traits, including her Heart's Desire, Mal/Affections and Virtues, are not decided by direct suggestion. Such things develop based on the cumulative effect of her actions and the motivations she had for those actions.

The players are still responsible for them, but they aren't as controllable. A few other things are influenced this way as well.
>>
No. 62371 ID: 4a328b

>>62370
Oh, so we can't increase Dis or Det using TW? Good to know!
>>
No. 62372 ID: 34d817

>>62370
Is this a statement that we can only wait for them to naturally appear, and can't prompt their appearance in any fashion? I would have expected that some time spent talking with someone with heavy social magics could help someone decide on or even change their Heart's Desire and build or destroy Mal/Affections, though Virtues might be a little trickier. Could help with building resolve to follow the precepts of a specific Virtue, at least.
>>
No. 62376 ID: 8383d5

I'm partial to just eating Noise.
>>
No. 62379 ID: b6edd6

I was thinking about how we should probably diversify with our new deva, and it occurred to me... If devas can have themes like Fear, what if we make our feeding soul a deva of Will?

On a somewhat unrelated note, are we unable to make a deva with a theme if that theme is already taken by someone else? For example, does the existence of a Darkness deva in the Ebon Dragon prevent us from making our own Darkness deva?
>>
No. 62380 ID: 44f93b

Huh. Feeds off the will of others, feeds by strengthen our will, feeds through acts of will... a creature of will.

The possibility are interesting. Honestly, I like that more than any suggestion I've heard since civilization. Possibly even more so.

>>62376
You're forgetting that the element is more than just what the feeder "eats". It's what they make, work with, are. Noise has all kinds of problematic implications (it's more than just sound- it's non-useful sound, bad data, etc) and might overlap too much with Wordblood (words- speech) or worse, conflict with him (communication and empty noise are kind of polar opposites!).
>>
No. 62383 ID: cee89f

>>62380
Okay. So far we have:
Civilization
Will

Any other suggestions? I'll add it to a list for when we make the soul if it gets suggested and backed up by at least two different posters, and then we can choose from those.

Sound like a plan? =3 Hope i don't sound pretentious.
>>
No. 62390 ID: 2eac65

I've done quite a bit of thinking on it, and the most suitable element for a Feeding Soul would be:

Desire.

First, let us define "consumption". To Saulanna, it means not to destroy, but to make a part of herself, subject to her will. With this in mind, Desire fits nearly every feeding-related action she has taken:

She consumes to protect Desire. Her first victim was the mobster who invaded her mind and tried to mentally dominate her. Saulanna devoured him to protect her own will.

She consumes her own desire. When her urges threatened to consume her, she restrained them and made them subject to her rational mind.

She consumes others through their Desire. Or rather, she offered such a choice to Peregrin, but he refused. While Saulanna hasn't yet convinced anyone to willingly be absorbed by her, such an act would be perfectly suited to her character.

And if you're willing to get abstract about it, She consumes others' Desires to see them fulfilled. In other words, accepts the personal quests of others. Like when she decided to help Gevin reconnect with his love.
>>
No. 62391 ID: 44f93b

A deva of NPC sidequests? Seems kind of meta, and it puts us at the disadvantage of being subject to the desires of others, doesn't it?

...also, if we go feeder of desire, I think we end up veering dangerous close to taking the succubus route. I mean, c'mon, we're already a lunar here. Put those together and...
>>
No. 62392 ID: 997ce7

>>62391
Please, this is tgchan, I'm sure we can explore the more abstract aspects of desire and handle the cruder parts with delicacy, good taste, maturity, and tact.



Holy fuck I can't believe I managed to type that with a straight face


Seriously though, pretty sure we can keep from becoming a total slutbag, especially if Saulanna decides she doesn't want to. Look how long Overlord managed to hold out against the hug menace.
>>
No. 62394 ID: 44f93b

>especially if Saulanna decides she doesn't want to
The thing is, the devas become part of our personality gestalt. If we make desire a core part of our personality, she's gonna want it. I mean, "wanting" is pretty much the definition of desire.

Honestly, it just seems like it has the potential to be difficult to manage, with lots of potential complications and downsides. There are useful applications for manipulating/feeding off/creating/etc desire, especially in a social way, but I'm kind of not sure they're worth it, or that's really the way we want to steer Saulanna.
>>
No. 62396 ID: f2c20c

I think a feeder of Moonlight or Light or Shadow or something like that would fit us best.

Hmm. Perhaps we can be a titan attuned to the phase of the moon? Closely tied to Luna but separate from her? And our souls would be configured to give us advantages depending on the moon's phase? A Feeder of Moonlight would give us faster TW generation while the moon is full, and presumably while our aura is flaring up.

Oh, and if we're voting about whether eating souls is a bad thing... I've already said that it's not and continue to stand by that. However, we should at least limit it to people who are in our way, or deserve to have their undead existence ended. Those who are contributing positively to the ghost civilization should be under our protection, not our prey. Regardless of who it is, however, if the choice is between eating the soul and letting it 'reincarnate', eating it is ALWAYS the better thing to do. We would merely be reclaiming raw materials, in that case, and eventually we can start producing those raw materials ourselves to give back to the world what we took. It's like farming. It's like eating an apple instead of leaving it on the ground to sprout a tree, then later magically creating apples or appleseeds or whatever to grow the trees that we prevented from growing. Don't think of it as destroying potential lives, but borrowing them to earn interest on.
>>
No. 62398 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will

>>62390
I'd like to point out real quick that we don't actually know that's Gevin's love - the impression I got when i read through the archive was 'close friend'.

And no, I'm not going to repost the list every time something new makes it onto said list - just when i make a post so I can easily find it again.
>>
No. 62403 ID: 8383d5

>>62380
bad choice of words, i didn't intend for those connotations of noise. I meant sound, but was basing this off a half remembered and evidently wrong idea that there was a choice between "feeding on ___" and "feeding by spreading ___"

rather than the sexual connotations of "desire" we could go with "want" but it would KINDA risk completely eliminating her self-control.

What about "stories"? It's like a much more LUNARY version of "knowledge"
>>
No. 62406 ID: b6edd6

...Nobody seems to have gotten the main point of what I was getting at with the Will suggestion (though Will is also useful for a lot of other things like social combat and not going insane).
Consider that it would be a titanic deva of will, and then remember what it is we want this soul to generate. Titan's Will

>>62396
Moonlight has the problem of limited growth potential, as unless we do some crazy stuff to the cosmos the amount of moonlight in the world will be more or less in a fixed range.

>>62403
Stories would have a much higher risk of overlap with communication that knowledge, as stories are as much about the telling as what is told.
>>
No. 62407 ID: f2c20c

>>62406
There's a fixed amount of practically everything, dude. The feeder soul gets better at generating TW when we give it TW. Having it attuned to moonlight would just give a bonus depending on how much moonlight is around. It's a modifier, and that's all you can ever hope for in an element.
>>
No. 62415 ID: 44f93b

My complaint about tying a deva to the moon in any way is that we're already dependent on the moon. It's a doubling down- yes, it will make certain strengths stronger, but it will make any weaknesses or dependencies on / related to the lunar cycles all the more pronounced.

I'd rather diversify than double down.
>>
No. 62418 ID: b3952d

As far as the feeding soul's element goes, count me in for Knowledge, Stories, Books, Libraries, or anything in that vein.
>>
No. 62419 ID: b24894

I dunno if it necessarily matters whether Saulanna eating a soul is "evil" or not.

If Evil is an arbitrary matter of perspective in Exalted, then why are we even worrying about it in the first place, or allowing it to inform our decisions?

If Evil is an objective thing in Exalted, then when we get powerful enough, we can use our Primordialhood to tweak the calibration of the Shinma here or there, to make eating souls objectively Good instead of Evil, and then we'll be a retroactive saint.

No way we can lose!
>>
No. 62421 ID: b6edd6

>>62419
That isn't how systems of morality work. Being moral is an end in itself rather than a a set of rules to be rules-lwayered.

As an example of a similar concept, suppose we were to say that blowing stuff up is cool*. Coolness is not an objective standard, the lack thereof will not send us to lame-hell, and we could theoretically alter the universe to make not-exploding cool, but all of that is aside from the point. We want to do cool things like exploding stuff simply because it is cool, not for some reason that depends on it being cool.**

* extra points for walking away slowly afterward
** You might ask why we should care about coolness or morality, but you could ask that question about any motivation, including survival.
>>
No. 62422 ID: b24894

So you're saying that, first, we have to alter the universe so that *is* how systems of morality work? And then change what Goodness is? That seems like it'll be a little bit more troublesome, but doable.
>>
No. 62423 ID: b6edd6

>>62422
What I meant is that altering the universe would be aside from the point, because if you want to do something than you have no reason to alter the universe to get out of doing it.
>>
No. 62424 ID: b24894

Unless you want to be able to do two mutually exclusive things. If you want to be Good and Eat Souls, and Eating Souls is Bad, then you can't do both. Solution? Change them so they aren't mutually exclusive.

Like, if you wanted to eat bacon all the time, but you also wanted to be skinny/healthy. Genetically engineer some bacon that's good for you! Now you get both things you want.

In this case, you're dealing with morality, so you have to alter the nature of morality. If Eating Souls equals Good, then you can Eat Souls and Be Good simultaneously. It's double the satisfaction.
>>
No. 62426 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will

>>62424
MORALITY IS NOT A DIET! It doesn't work like that!!
>>
No. 62427 ID: 4a328b

>>62426
Eater of Light has two votes as well
>>
No. 62428 ID: 4c6822

Knowledge and Time were two earlier suggested possibilities, as well. There may have been more.

But it is not quite soul decision time yet!
>>
No. 62429 ID: b24894

>>62426
Have a little optimism! If it doesn't already work like that, we just have to become powerful enough to force it to work like that. No biggie.

Choosing a Heart's Desire akin to "I must gain titanic power at all costs, regardless of the consequences." would go a long way to getting us there.
>>
No. 62430 ID: 44f93b

>Time
Yeah, but for some weird reason absolutely no one seemed to like the idea back when I made that suggestion. :p

Kinda cool you remembered, though.
>>
No. 62433 ID: b6edd6

>>62429
Trying to solve every problem by restructuring the universe's logic seems most likely to end in reducing the universe to incoherence. (And safely changing the universe so that you can safely change the universe is a circular causality situation that you need to already be in to get into. It would be like saying that we can get a time machine whenever we want by simply going back in time and giving it to ourself.)
>>
No. 62435 ID: b24894

>>62433

We won't know if we never try! Don't you want to see what the story will be like if we climb in power far too quickly to learn anything resembling restraint and just start mucking about with forces that aren't beyond our control, but are beyond our full understanding?

You can already live by a modern age 1st world moral code, think through your decisions, and make all the safe choices. Let Saulanna be a power hungry monster! It'll be entertaining.
>>
No. 62436 ID: f2c20c

>>62415
I kinda wanted to do it that way to show Luna that we are on her side as part of our intrinsic nature. As a pledge of loyalty a step beyond being Lunar Exalted.
>>
No. 62437 ID: 4a328b

>>62436
I can get behind this, as well as it being a possible way to control our hero flaring stuff.
>>
No. 62439 ID: fa9f7e

>>62436
Yeah, and then it turns out that tells her and everyone else that we're a Titan and gives her even more of a hold over us and we're ultrafucked. Even if that doesn't happen, it makes us even more dependent on a single variable.

Time is good. Moonlight is terribad.
>>
No. 62440 ID: b6edd6

>>62435
Eh, 'causality falls everyone unexists' isn't really my thing.*
Besides, being careless will get us killed off before we can get anywhere near enough power to mess around with that stuff.

*(Ok, Evangelion was entertaining, but one of those was enough.)


>>62436
Personally I am worried it would look like we were trying to steal her shtick. As we just saw with Wordsblood, divine beings can be kind of touchy about that.
>>
No. 62441 ID: 1e9865

>>62406
well in that case we should maybe ASK wordblood if he'd be likely to feud with a stories soul
>>
No. 62443 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will
Moonlight

>>62427
>>62428
I was only adding things to the list suggested AFTER i started making the list and Civilization*, and Light (as far as i can tell) has had ONE supporter since then... not counting you =p

But i'll add it anyway, for now, and I'll go back through again and see if I missed anything else.

*Civ made it to the list in part because I agreed with it, someone else agreed with it and it was brought up again, and partly because I have a vague memory that it won the last debate.

EDIT-through-deletion: Actually, looking back, Light's never really defined as an element. The original suggestion was 'light or shadow or moonlight or something' and it never really gets reinforced. Moonlight gets critiqued a bit but i think only one poster actually supported it =/
>>
No. 62444 ID: f2c20c

>>62440
Oh, the schtick-stealing point is a good one. Making it more neutral, like just Light, would work to avoid that. That would also align ourselves with both Luna AND the Sun!

Unfortunately I feel like that might hurt our TW generation while we're in the shadowlands.
>>
No. 62457 ID: 34d817

>>62444
I don't actually want to align ourselves with the beings that slaughtered and/or enslaved their creators and then took their opium den as their own while leaving the world to rot. We'll have to deal with them at some point and killing them is impractical, but that doesn't mean shaping our very being (which is what making more souls is) into a form of flattery is a good idea.
>>
No. 62458 ID: 44f93b

>>62457
This fella raises a good point. Just because we don't actively want to be hostile with Luna and the Sun doesn't mean we should bend over backwards or tailor our very being to suit them.

Honestly, our best hope of dealing with them is a strong bartering position, and a track record they'll respect.

>Time is good. Moonlight is terribad.
Woot! Time finally got some support.

Right now I'm leaning will over civilization, but I'd switch back to voting time in a heartbeat if I thought for a moment it had a chance of winning. Time based powers are all kinds of abusable.

Desire or (moon)light just come with way too many potential downsides or complications.
>>
No. 62459 ID: 42ace1

>>62457
The creators are dicks. True Fact.

(The Incarna are also dicks.)

(The Exalted Host are also dicks.)

And, in any case, what I am seeing from the Moonlight/Light Element is that Saulanna gains power from herself. That is, the Feeder Soul is most powerful, all things being equal, when Saulanna flares her Totemic Anima Banner. Which is not quite ideal; we do, after all, prefer to remain hidden, if I do not misjudge our actions. If we are to create a Feeder of Moonlight/Light, that would nudge Saulanna toward an overwhelming/unrestrained/unsubtle aspect as her Soul incentives acting while flaring her Totemic Anima Banner (or, spending lots and lots of MP).

The Incarna have nothing to do with that (barring Luna, who made the Exaltation Saulanna holds and from which derives power).
>>
No. 62460 ID: 925aa6

>>465195
Nope. I use 2 wi-fi networks, but I never dupe suggestions.
>>
No. 62461 ID: 925aa6

>>62460
I also post infrequently enough that I think I messed up quoting the main quest thread.
>>/quest/465195
>>
No. 62462 ID: 5bf190
File 135092981477.gif - (70.57KB , 649x446 , facepalmcombo.gif )
62462

>>62458
>I'd switch back to voting time in a heartbeat if I thought for a moment it had a chance of winning
>I'd switch [...] voting [...] if I thought [...] it had a chance of winning
>tactical voting

Methinks I might try an Instant-runoff system.
>>
No. 62464 ID: 44f93b

...there's non-tactical voting?

Forgive me, but a lifetime under time American political system has somewhat skewed my perspective. (You don't vote for what you want, you look at the only two people who have a prayer of winning and vote for the one you hate less!).

...not that I've reached anywhere near that level of cynicism here. There's a difference between "picking the better of two evils" and "respecting it when other suggesters aren't interested in your ideas" (even snarkily :p).

Some kind of formalized run off might be a good idea though. We've been bouncing ideas for elements around for weeks without really getting anywhere.
>>
No. 62465 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will
Light
Time

I'm not a fan of time - ignoring how abusable it is, how would a FEEDING deva feed off or spread time? Would it just be really efficient? Would it cause time to slow down/speed up around it?

>>62462
What's an instant-runoff system?
>>
No. 62466 ID: 4a328b

>>62464
OR we can keep coming up with new elements until we hit on one people really like
>>
No. 62467 ID: 34d817

>>62458
Time is cool, but when choosing an element for a feeder soul it doesn't seem right to me. The question here is "What do we want to make Saulanna stronger, and which she will thus want to make stronger in turn?" Time... isn't really something we can establish positive feedback with, at least not in any simple way that I can see unless we start tearing up the rules of reality. I would be willing to support it for the element of a lord deva with a different purpose- we certainly have enough things that we could use souls for!- but not as our feeder soul.

Likewise, it's for this reason that I consider civilization such an excellent choice for the feeder soul- Saulanna can easily and actively either seek out or build up large centers of civilization, and by doing so build her own power and gain public relations points.

Will isn't a terrible choice by this metric, but it's not great either; as it's a quality that people possess Saulanna will have to work to shape the personalities and decisions of those around her into certain patterns in order to cultivate a supportive environment for herself. Maintaining them in a high-will state, particularly on a large scale, seems like a huge job because will isn't a characteristic that people naturally possess in large amounts. We'd have to basically change how people think and act in order to really cultivate a proper feeding ground.
>>
No. 62469 ID: 44f93b

>moonlight
You know what? If we want better control over our moon-powers, we shouldn't even be using the feeder-Deva for this. We should take our hero's soul, dump it full of titan's will, grant it sentience, and promote it from passive spirit-symbiote to a full on Deva. Bam.

>Time
The initial idea for this was that is would maximize any passive feeding / energy generation if we wanted to minimize getting titan's will from non-ing souls. So long as time passes, we have an energy source. In addition active consumption of time could be used offensively- say, consuming parts of the past the alter the present (like Balefire, say). Manipulation of time could be especially potent in the shadowlands (with the broken calender and all) or when used in conjunction with moon-based powers (if we can hack the time of day or lunar phase). Then of course there's normal time-based shenanigans, of course.

>>62466
I have no problem with us coming to a consensus. I just don't see it happening smoothy or easily- the field is too wide open, and we've got too many ideas.
>>
No. 62472 ID: 5bf190

>>62467

Feeding on/through the Element is a significant part of the choice, but it's not the only important aspect to it. You could come up with some interesting tricks with the right combinations. For example, a Feeding deva based on Time might (eventually) have the power to undo TW purchases and reclaim what was spent on them, which would otherwise be impossible. Things like that.

>>62465

Instant runoff voting is where you vote by listing your preferences. For example you could list "Desire 1, Will 2, Civilization 3"; then I count up all the first-preference and, whoops, Desire came in last place. So then I eliminate Desire, and your Desire-first vote will "run off" and be given to Will. I check who's in last place again, take them out, reassign the votes, and so on until there's only two contenders and we have a winner.
>>
No. 62477 ID: 4a328b

How about the element of Secrets?
Finding them, keeping them, detecting them--everyone has secrets, and many locations have them as well.
>>
No. 62478 ID: 34d817

>>62472
That ability is really nice... being able to suddenly retroactively reallocate our resources would be an exceedingly potent tool. Although I remember reading somewhere that Luna has a trick very like that where she becomes/channels the abilities of one of the other moon gods that might have been but she devoured. If that's so, then with a Titanically-reinforced Moon Hero soul we might be able to do something of the kind already, though as we haven't devoured any other possible Saulannas perhaps not. Maybe if we ate another Titan...

The ability to use civilizations as nation-sized power generators calls to me, though. As does being able to spread and sculpt them as we choose, and being able to devour them should the situation call for it.

In addition, the concern that an Element which is alien to Saulanna's current mortal perspective will begin to alienate her from that perspective exists; the farther our Lord souls' elements are from the human condition the more alien Saulanna's overall mindset will inevitably become, at least as I understand it. Whatever element we choose will become a core part of who she is- I'd rather not go with anything too abstract and fundamental to reality until we've got another soul or two in place to help counterbalance how much alien perspectives influence our thinking. There must be a dozen things that we could key Time to if we want ridiculous hax out of it; it doesn't have to be this, even if stripping the Titan's Will out of our past uses of it (a dozen or so Soul Force down the line) would be crazy good.

>>62477
I'd still like to pair stealth/secrets/deception/etc. with a protector-purposed deva.
>>
No. 62479 ID: 44f93b

>time feeder
>Allow Ashenzari style TW reskilling
Yes please! Who doesn't want Red Mage and time powers at the same time? Ultimate versatility and flexibility.

>secrets
Another idea that got debated a while back (one of the first few suggested elements, I think). If I remember right, the consensus-ish was to wait for our next deva to craft one specifically to deal with divinations, concealment, and stuff like that.
>>
No. 62482 ID: b6edd6

Another argument I would like to put forwards in favor of Will is that IIRC Creation contains heaps of beings with self-control abilities that are damaged, subverted, or otherwise manipulated by various curses. A notable example of this would be the lunars and solars, who have a tendency to go out of control.
Gaining abilities to effect or eventually negate that sort of thing would go a long way towards both our ability to effect Creation and give groups like the solars and lunars a major reason to be interested in our survival.

>>62478
We already do have (potential for) the ability to gain power from the existence and size of nations, from the fact that nations need (and are in many ways built on) communication.
>>
No. 62485 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will
Light
Time

>>62482
True but Wordblood isn't a Feeding Deva, so it doesn't really matter.
>>
No. 62487 ID: f2c20c

>>62472
Are we voting yet?
>>
No. 62488 ID: cee89f

>>62487
Pretty sure we're gonna wait until Wordblood asks about things like the purpose and element.
>>
No. 62489 ID: 44f93b

>>62487
I assume we'll wait till the quest actually gets to the deva creation. For now we're just brainstorming ideas and trying to win each other over.
>>
No. 62495 ID: b24894

Element: Raccoons.

Now, hear me out. Surely, Lunars have some kind of raccoon-manipulating charms. But what would happen if we doubled up on that? The ability to put a titanic tint on the power to create, disseminate, devour, and control raccoons, combined with our own natural raccoon talents, could allow us to reach Squirrel-Girlian plateaus of eminence.

It won't warp us all that much, since we're already so heavily tied to raccoons. And raccoon-based powers won't look all that out of the ordinary for a Lunar to sling around, which might be important when we're just getting started in making our way in the world.
>>
No. 62504 ID: bf54a8

oh my god, raccoon girl, that is freakishly brilliant.
>>
No. 62505 ID: cee89f

Civilization
Desire
Will
Light
Time

>>62495
I don't wanna eat raccoons =( Couldn't we just stipulate that the feeder soul LOOKS like a raccoon? Wordblood did mention we'd be picking things besides the element, and i do remember bringing up a raccoon with horn-rimmed glasses... as a librarian, admittedly, but still!
>>
No. 62506 ID: 9718f3

What about a Feeder soul of Preservation? The act of protecting something from forces that would erode or damage it. Be it knowledge, wealth, peace, health, civilization, or delicious delicious jams. It's an activity basically every major player takes part in; preserving the status quo, if nothing else. Specifically in Saulanna's case, she has an interest in preserving her autonomy.

It's a soul that focuses on defense and is disposed towards resource management, which is ideal for us.

Plus, you know, jam. Everyone likes jam.
>>
No. 62508 ID: a69257

>>62507
Oh! How about a Feeder soul of Change? =D We already shapeshift, we intend to change the god's minds about titans, we could respec ourselves (for lack of a better phrase) more easily to make our various tasks easier (remember the clifface from thread 1? We could, for instance, up our agility if we came to a similar situation again) We could change how our TW gets spent (a la the Time deva) etc etc...

...Or we could save that one for a combat deva or something =/
>>
No. 62509 ID: 44f93b

>Raccoon (eating) Diva
Seems an absurd waste of potential, to me. And really, we could accomplish the same thing by uplifting our hero's soul.

Really, consider, what happens if we promote the passive exaltation Luna attached to us to a full on Deva? (Pretty much anything we could consider falling under the domain of the moon, combat, change, etc. could theoretically fall under this Deva's jurisdiction).

>preservation
Doesn't that go against our very nature? We're a new Titan, born in a way nothing else has been before- a strange hybrid of Exalt, Titan, and Human. By our very existence we change the world order. And the world is hardly in the best state of things as it is- our goal should not be to preserve the old ways, but to better the new. To say nothing of the fact that to be Lunar is to embrace change on a pretty fundamental level.

Making preservation core to our identity... almost sounds like castrating ourself to survive. I think it would bite us in the ass, long run.
>>
No. 62510 ID: 9718f3

>>62508
Whoops, I deleted that post.

For anyone wondering what we're rambling about, it was basically saying that just because many preserve the status quo, doesn't mean we would have to or that it would stifle our growth or adaptability. We could even enact drastic world-spanning changes without betraying the concept, so long as we preserved the world of old in history. Like Indiana Jones! Or Brainiac!
>>
No. 62511 ID: 9718f3

>>62509
There's nothing saying that we have to choose any one time, place, or thing over any other in what we preserve, or that we can't do so if we wish. Tossing away all that has come before to create anew is foolish anyway. There's some pretty cool stuff that exists, or has existed. Having an interest in keeping it around doesn't mean opposing the creation of anything new. And there's also nothing saying that we can't preserve the past in the form of histories and memories, rather than literally maintaining its unchanging existence forever.

Yes it does dispose ourselves away from change a bit, but that isn't too far off from the path we're taking anyway. The consensus seems to be against stirring things up, at least at this point.

But I see "Preservation" as more of a defense of specific things than a blanket rejection of change anyway.
>>
No. 62512 ID: bf54a8

>>62511
>brainiac, learns everything there is about a planet then BLOWS IT THE FUCK UP

yeah no..

the idea of somehow turning the exalt shard into a deva is interesting.
>>
No. 62513 ID: 9718f3

>>62512
Oh come one, I was obviously joking about the Brainiac thing. Jeeze.
>>
No. 62516 ID: b24894

>>62505
Eating raccoons to gain their power is just a natural part of the cycle. Raccoon Girl giveth and Raccoon Girl taketh away.

Besides, imagine titanic raccoon manipulation. Like, Raccoonbending. Riding on cresting waves of raccoons. Ascending on squeaking pillars of furry death, lashing our foes with long-range raccoon whips. Raising raccoon walls to stop the deadly flow of magma from an erupting volcano, saving the townspeople caught nearby. Breathing burning clouds of raccoons when our anger is aroused. So on.
>>
No. 62523 ID: 34d817

>>62516
You. You're having too much fun. Stop that. This discussion is for ultra-serious, miserable squabbling only.
>>
No. 62527 ID: 997ce7

Raccoons are too ordinary.

I suggest one of the following in no particular order:

Water bears
Wolverines
Honey badgers
Ferrets
Axolotls
>>
No. 62530 ID: cee89f

>>62516
>>62523

...Ya know what?

I still don't think it should be our Feeding Deva.

But that mental image is just too awesome+funny to NOT try for. So yeah, I'll put it on the list. (the guy who suggested it, one other guy and me - that's three)

Civilization
Desire
Light
Time
Raccoon
Will

... I still think that for this one we should go either Desire or Civilization.
>>
No. 62533 ID: cee89f

>>62527
Water bears?

... Those microscopic things that can survive the vacuum of space?

...

Do we even know if those EXIST in exalted? Do we even know if Saulanna or Wordblood have any way of KNOWING what they are?!
>>
No. 62534 ID: bf54a8

wait, is there even SPACE in exaclted? could we be the titan to MAKE space?
>>
No. 62538 ID: b24894

>>62534
Shards of the Exalted Dream somewhat implies that Creation was an entire universe, with space, and galaxies, and planets, and stuff, prior to the Primordial War. However, all of the fucking doomsday weapons, and reality-warping clusterfucks, and various conceptually-destructive fuckeries, utilized by both the Primordials and the Chosen of the Gods, ended up eventually reducing all of reality to a single sad little world for the Exalted to crown themselves king of in the aftermath.

It's not canon, certainly. But it's implied, and I kinda like it.
>>
No. 62570 ID: f2c20c

>>62538
I DON'T LIKE IT.
>>
No. 62598 ID: 554191

Civilization
Desire
Light
Raccoon
Time
Will

Is it even POSSIBLE to uplift our hero's soul? =/ the impression I've gotten from what little I know of exalted suggests that the exaltation:

A) Is more like a computer than a person - ie, separating it from us would do nothing of consequence
B) Is a symbiote, and therefore MUST be attached to the soul of the exalted in order to both remain in the body and give the user power.
>>
No. 62599 ID: 44f93b

>Is it even POSSIBLE to uplift our hero's soul? =/
No idea! I think it's certainly interesting enough to consider, until Wordblood stops by to tell us we're being crazy again.

>Is more like a computer than a person - ie, separating it from us would do nothing of consequence
>Is a symbiote, and therefore MUST be attached to the soul of the exalted in order to both remain in the body and give the user power.
I don't see it as separating the hero's soul from us- I see it as more closely integrating it. And a self-aware superbeing attacked to our soul, powering us up, sounds more powerful and versatile than the seemily passive one we have now.

Of course, there are all kinds of risks. We could break our exaltation (no more moon powers!). Messing with it could alert Luna (although the sun didn't notice when solar souls were being hacked to make death heros). Or... our new lunar soul might be upset with the situation it finds itself in. (You made me part of a Titan?! I live to hunt you/us! WhathaveyoudoneWhathaveyoudoneWhathaveyoudone...).
>>
No. 62600 ID: cee89f

>>62599
>(although the sun didn't notice when solar souls were being hacked to make death heros).

As far as we know. =p

I still think it's a bad idea. The Hero's soul is already a part of us - uplifting it would do little besides put us at even more risk than before, and possibly make it harder for us to use MP.
>>
No. 62601 ID: 44f93b

Really, we're too ignorant right now to make an accurate risk/reward assessment. And I would like to hear what Wordblood thought of the idea before trying it.

It's not an immediate concern though- we definitely want to create the feeder deva before anything else. Energy management and production is a big concern.
>>
No. 62603 ID: 34d817

>>62598
>Is it even POSSIBLE to
Whenever you want to ask something like this, see Jukashi's comment at >>18218:
>But if Saulanna has enough Titan's Will, she can pretty much do... anything.
>If she has enough.

Things can be "impossible right now", "inefficient", "extremely difficult", or "incredibly stupid", but nothing is impossible for Saulanna in the absolute sense.

Mucking about with our hero soul in particular strikes me as something to worry about much, much later, though. Perhaps after we're no longer dependent upon it as the primary source of our power.
>>
No. 62613 ID: cee89f

>>62603
I would like to point out that, when we asked Wordblood about the tattoos, his reply was "It... might be possible?" implying that it also might NOT be. Hence, there are some things BEYOND a titan's (or at least OUR) ability and since the Hero's soul was created by a titan specifically to FIGHT titans, then I'd say the idea that we CAN'T manipulate this thing at all is certainly possible.

Civilization
Desire
Light
Raccoon
Time
Will
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [Last 100 posts]

Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason